It just ruins everything there is to love in the original, undoing the whole sacrifice of Madoka as well as ruining Homura's character beyond repair.
As one guy on this forum put it: 'it spits on everything Puella Magi Madoka Magica is. This is a good example of how you do not make a sequel.
i gave it 4 instead of 1 because plot is still somewhat reasonable. Unique art style and feel of Madoka Magica is as present here as well.
As to people who can watch it without hatred, then perhaps if you do not feel much about these poor girls in the original, you will not find this one too bad.
Overall this is another disappointing sequel of a show that deserves way better than that.
