Story:9 (call me crazy, but I liked more the way the promised neverand ended in the anime rather than in the manga...)
Art:8
Sound:9
Character:10
Enjoyement:9
Overall: 9
Story:9 -- as I said, call me crazy, but I liked more the way the promised neverand ended in the anime rather than in the manga... they did their best to achieve the best ending without leaving it open, they gave us a similar ending but changing how the last manga's arc developed, giving a more heroic development to main characters and the ones that needed redemption for their past; it was rushed and skipped like 70% of arcs past 1st season, but they gave us a complete story instead of ending at goldy pond arc, if it were an original anime, people would end up praising this season
Art:8 -- pretty good, nice backgrounds and animation, no complaints here
Sound:9 -- good OST, good job making it work with the scenes
Character:10 -- excellent characters considering is a shonen anime, with weaknesses, moral dilemmas, and as said in story part, they managed to give them even more heroism in the end
Enjoyement:9 - rushed, skipped 70% or more arcs... doesn't matter for me, they worked hard to give the best possible way of ending the entire story within just 11 episodes, don't blame production team, blame the ones who decided this is the last season, otherwise we could have ended with something like hoshiai no sora, which I also liked, but having an end is better than having 1 or 2 more arcs to fulfil nothing in the end
Overall: 9 -- it's all said before, but let me repeat this: "call me crazy, but I liked more the way the promised neverand ended in the anime rather than in the manga..."