I'm super new to anime, this is my, like, 5th show, and I loved every minute of it. I came here with high hopes for story (I was intrigued because Hiromi/u Arakawa, the author of FMA, wrote it), and it did not disappoint. The animation is nothing to write home about, but every character is lovable in their own ways, and once again, the story is on-point!
I especially enjoyed the Pizza and Porkbowl arcs, as well as the story's (albeit unfinished in the anime) developing love interest.
If you're like me, you'll also enjoy all of the plots with the horses, especially Maron. He's super ugly, but he's awesome!
I liked all the openings and endings as well (although many despise the first OP), and if you can recognize the voices of Sukima Switch, you'll find a treat in the first ED ;)