I have mixed feelings about this.
On one hand I'm a manga reader that has kept up to date with this series, and just as the other reviews of the manga say, the first episode really gets you excited but then after that the story can get a little samey fast. There is little substantial character development that doesn't get... uuuh... to avoid any spoilers lets say cut off, and even then 'most' characters are not very like able and though that may be what the the writer was going for, there weren't many characters that could be empathized or sympathized with (in my case anyway) so it's hard to feel anything for them when they inevitably... go fishing.
Therefore if you didn't like it's big gimmick, the theme or you aren't a massive sucker for these kinds of stories then there wasn't much reason to continue reading after the first handful of chapters because after that you could kinda see how things were gonna go from there, and you'd be right, because despite hints of things possibly changing for the characters or story, it didn't.
But then something DID begin to change, down the road when you thought it was going to be the same shtick over and over, as if the writer did a double take and when you were least expecting it, kicked you in the nuts. Suddenly it felt like the story was moving, there was character development that had me interested and actually FEELING something for said characters. It felt like everything that preceded it was to place the main character in this moral dilemma, where they show their changes for the better but are struggling to cope with their past actions and doubt towards whether or how to deal with things from there.
However of course this doesn't automatically eliminate much of the problems, despite the change things seem to still follow the same "so and so of the week" formula. The issues people will experience before getting to this point are still very much there. And at this point in time I still don't know if it will be able to keep this up, if most others will appreciate this change or if it will return to it's roots and go back to being its old self, that for the most part, only people who are into this genre would be able to enjoy.
That's why I'm afraid an anime adaptation would probably fall into a similar pattern the manga did. People would be enticed by the first episode and continue watching from there but then get bored and leave before things get a chance to pick up. And even then that's a mystery in of itself because a single chapter of this book is L O N G dude, not anything crazy amounts but enough that there's actually more material than you'd think just by looking at the chapter count. Anyway there's a lot of material to cover before things to get to this point and unless the anime is willing to omit a lot of things (which they could probably do, there isn't much things you could skip over and have it negatively effect the story) or, trim the fat as they say, then I doubt it would get the chance to shine as an anime.
But all in all, these are just my thoughts, maybe the anime would be totally different and surpass all my expectations and I'll end up looking like a bumbling dumb ass and I hope that's true, because personally I can see this becoming pretty damn good given the correct circumstances and changes and would want it to be. But right now there's too much I don't know so I'll just be waiting too see how it is I suppose.
