Story: 9
Its a great harem/ecchi/romance story. The Main Character picks the right girl in the end despite some really twisted circumstances that could turn him away. Again, manga does explore some forbidden areas of society, and this one does it well. It is paced well (for the most part) and it is also concise. Im Dall Young's writing style is extremely intense in this manga, but is also satisfying at the end... for the most part.
If i was judging this by potential, it would be a 10. This manhwa had so much potential to comtinue and introduce more plot, complication, and relationship strengthening. However, Young chose to cut it short, which has its merits, but I still felt as if it were missing something. Cutting it short meant rushing the ending, inserting a catalyst and closure within the span of 2 chapters, which is fast in comparison to the rest of the manhwa.
Therefore a solid 9/10 for story, with a deduction due to the ending/ minor plot holes.
Art: 10
Im dall Young seems to always pair up with Lee Soo Hyun, and needless to say, I am in love with his drawing style. You see it in Freezing, both manga and anime, and it is just so well proportioned (Well except for the chest, but that doesn't matter to me) and the style just seems to lend itself toward beautiful women. However it is not just character design, there are also alot of action scenes that were framed well, and damn, everything is just beautiful.
Character: 10
Originally thought it was a 9, but then after looking back at it from the standpoint of judging character away from the Plot, its definitely a 10. All the main Characters are faceted, and none are really flat characters. Each has a personality that is kept throughout the Manhwa, although by the end there is a change in affection. MinHo's steadfast determination is also commendable, and really drives this piece.
Enjoyment:10
Although it does not feature some of my more favorited categories (such as fantasy, mecha, magic, supernatural, etc.) it still does well within the boundaries of the real world. It's a refreshing take that is set in reality, and thats were the appeal really is. Male readers can identify with MinHo liking his super hot teacher, and the success of that relationship only increases the enjoyment of male readers. I'm not a Female so I can't claim the same for them, but Personally I feel like this manhwa was very enjoyable.
Overall:
Wavered between a 9 and a 10, but decided to give it a 10. It isn't perfect, but it is definitely close. It's an outstanding Manhwa that I would recommend reading to anyone who enjoys the genre, but it isn't a masterpiece. I would definitely give it a try if you enjoy romance, ecchi, etc. So, breaking it down, 3 for Art + 2 for characters + 2 for Story +3 for enjoyment = 10 overall
