I had zero expectations going into this show. I have never seen a magical girl show before, but had heard much about what they're like. I never in a million years would have thought that this show would become one of my favorites.
While the main character of Madoka is a pretty basic character, its not her that you watch the show for. Actually the only character that is worth anything is that of Homura. Most of the characters are either initially unlikable or make bad decisions that lead them astray throughout the shows short 12 episode season.
I will say, please don't quit on this show before episode 3. I know a lot of people talk about the 3 episode rule, but it actually applies perfectly to this show! Episode 3 is where it really picks up steam and you realize that this is no ordinary show about magical girls. Madoka Magica was written by the same guy who wrote Fate/Zero. If you have ever seen that show you know that it doesn't end happy, and don't expect this show to end with a happy ending either. This show is dark!
Finally the art and animation are all very good! The characters lack a little something, but that is to be expected with only 12 episodes to explore them. I think I would have given this show a 8.5, but since MAL doesn't have that I gave it an 8. I feel like after a rewatch or finally getting around to watching the sequel movie, rebellion, that I might finally change it to a 9. But overall I was extremely surprised with this show, it going from something I never thought I would love to a show where I'm now considering buying the blu rays.
Check it out!
