Let's leave the character and story aside, the beautiful artwork and epic/emotional soundtracks are enough to place it at least a 7. People who score it less than that are missing a crucial point.
I admit that people who write on the front page and score this anime low made some valid points and I do agree with some of their points. Contradictory, people who write that well usually are over the age of the intended audience this anime is aiming at. People who hate this anime should realize that this anime is aiming at a specific audience group and it's not for everyone. They should use a different point of view when evaluating this anime.
Popular anime are popular for good reasons, because it successfully captures the interests of its intended audience!
The story and characters are not that bad as well. It's really enjoyable for me and introduce me into the world of anime. I would also say that this anime is a great starter anime.
Lastly, I want to say that this anime does a good job at capturing audience's interests and put them into the world of the SAO with its wonderful artwork and music.
This anime really shouldn't be getting 2-4s...
