Reviews

Mar 27, 2015
I don't write reviews for a lot of recent anime but I felt like Tokyo ghoul need it. Because of the big success that the first season had it was inevitable not to take a second one. What made this anime look even more interesting was the announcement that the creator of the manga Sui Ishida made about the second anime season to take a different rout from the manga. Hence the name Root A. The story tells the happenings of the manga from a different point of view with Kaneki joining the Aogiri side than the Anteiku's. With that really interesting plot twist things were looking really bright for the non-manga readers like me but also for the manga readers too because they would see a different story with the touch of Ishida in it. But unfortunately things didn't go as good as everybody was expecting it to be.Things started really interesting with two awesome first UNCENSORED episodes and then... the downfall started. First of all unlike what Sui Ishida said things are not different from the manga. Apart from the happening with Kaneki and maybe the last episode everything else is exactly the same as the manga. I didn't have a problem with it because as I said I don't read Tokyo Ghoul's manga but I can understand the frustration that the manga readers felt. The problems don't end here though. This season has a really serious problem because it has to adapt at least 80 remaining chapters into 12 episodes. The first season managed it well enough I have to say but this one was a real failure. A lot of things are opening up right from the first episode but they never close or nobody deals with them. The results are to end without having any real meaning or having answered a lot of our questions. But if I have to give them something that would be the last episode which from an artistic side was a masterpiece and it gave a good ending to an overall unsatisfying anime.
Another huge minus that ''Tokyo Ghou Root Al'' had was the animation. Even though ''Studio Pierrot'' is not the best anime studio in Japan it can do some pretty decent animation sometimes. And while the first and the second along with the last episode had really good animation and aesthetics the rest of the episodes were really average. Also after episode 5 we have another one of the anime plagues. Censorship. Yeah it returns and while is less annoying than the first season it still hurts your eyes and makes you loose all of the interesting parts and fights.
Before moving to the character section I will say first of all about the sound because especially for this anime it deserves at least one paragraph. I put a 9 mainly because I want to piss off all those fan boys/girls who were bitching about the new opening. They were all saying that it was shit compared to ''Unravel'' and while a big fun of the first opening myself, I have to say that this opening was better than ''Unravel''. With it's really simple (and not stolen from another anime...yeah I'm looking at you ''Unravel'') visuals, it brings us Kaneki's character development and with it's somehow twisted lyrics it unravels (get it? XD) the fucked up world that we are seeing. Even better was the ending. Man that song was a masterpiece. In terms of voice acting every single one of the voice actors did their job really good but the one who stood out was the new in the voice acting business Natsuki Hanae as the tragic protagonist Ken Kaneki. He captures Kaneki's character so amazing that you are forgetting you are seeing a character made from pixels. This voice actor i going to be the next big thing I'm sure.
And now we move to the character section. The results were really disappointing. Tokyo Ghoul is a character-driven anime so you expect some amazing character development. And here is the surprise. Almost none of the characters are developed to the degree you are expecting. With the only exception of Amon and Akira all the others are staying exactly the same from the start till the end. Kaneki who is the supposedly main character disappears suddenly without any meaning from the story with sudden appearances in every single episodes and then near the end he remembers that he is the main character and he returns more undeveloped and from Kirito's sword from SAO. And when you finally reach a point when you say that something good is going to be with his character the anime just ends.
So overall Tokyo Ghoul Root A was surely a disappointment as an anime series especially with the awesomeness that the previews season delivered to us. It starts off really promising but then throws the plot out off the window and just do whatever it wants trying to built all this dramatic atmosphere and forgetting to make a good story. I couldn't say that I enjoyed it as much as the first season and I can't say that is a true continuation of it's successor. It wasn't bad but it wasn't really good either. Watch it only if you are not feeling like reading the manga like I do and you want an ending of this anime.
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice Nice0
Love it Love it0
Funny Funny0
Show all
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login