Durarara!!, Re:Creators Recommendations
If you like Izaya you will like this show. Megane is very similar to Izaya, but eviler and with magic that involves manipulating people with her words. AKA so much worse for those against her. Like Izaya she loves all humans though. In this character comparison Alicetaria is Shizou, which fits but minus shipping.
Great huge cast all bouncing off of each other trying to not destroy or destroy the city!
-Similar setting with dark theme.
-Both have characters who have supernatural powers (Celty in Durarara!!, The "Creations" in Re:Creators).
-Main Protagonist are kind of similar: they looked like a normal high school boy, but they actually hiding something that will make a change to the story.
-Both have a lot of dialogues. If you like dialogues in anime, then you'll probably like both anime.
-IMO, Magane is like the female version of Izaya lol.