My personal ranking system:
10 (Masterpiece)- Favorite show; practically perfect. An excellent, innovative work that has made a profound impact on me and that I thoroughly enjoyed the entire time.
9 (Great)- Favorite show. An excellent, innovative work that I thoroughly enjoyed and that separates itself in quality from most other shows, even if it has some flaws.
8 (Very Good)- A quality show that I thoroughly enjoyed and looked forward to watching. May not have the same emotional attachment of a 9. A show that I would definitely recommend to others.
7 (Good)- A quality show that I liked and looked forward to. May have flaws that prevent it from being an 8, but I would most likely recommend it.
6 (Fine)- My baseline for something I like. An average show that is mainly enjoyable but has definite flaws. An anime that I would most likely not recommend compared to others. May have unique concepts that fall apart or are left unexplained, have too much filler, some prominent issue, etc. May be fun to watch but not as great as a 7.
5 (Average)- "Eh." A show that has significant flaws and/or average enjoyment. Shows rated a 5 may be a struggle to finish due to lack of enjoyment or a feeling of neutrality. May have good moments, but not worth watching in the long run. I am not excited to watch the next episode (or I don't care much either way). Could also describe a 6 with too many issues but not enough to completely dislike it.
4 (Bad)- A show that has major flaws and average to poor enjoyment. There is a distinct negative impression of the show. May be a struggle to finish due to some core aspect of the show that I disliked and/or upsetting content. Would not recommend it, but it might still have some sort of merit. I frown at the thought of the next episode.
3 (Very Bad)- Distinct from other categories and reserved for shows where "it's so bad it's good." Show itself is awful and has severe flaws, but watching it was fun and/or perplexing. Quality varies.
2 (Horrible)- A show with severe flaws that I largely did not enjoy and would not recommend. Nothing really good to say about the show. "It's so bad it's... bad." Could also be a "slightly better 1."
1 (Appalling)- A show with severe flaws that I hated because of offensive content. No redeeming qualities that would make it fun to watch. Severely distressed/upset me.
|
All Comments (1) Comments