I rate with genre, intent, age of the piece, and format in mind
I don't like to compare apples and oranges
things that go into a rating (in order of personal importance) are
For Anime:
Personal enjoyment, Writing, Pacing, Sound Effects, Voice acting,
Facial expressions, Characters, Art, Shot framing,
How well it did in regards to its intended purpose
Music, Animation, Art style
For Manga:
Personal enjoyment, Writing, Pacing,
Panel Structure, Flow, Characters, Facial Expressions,
How well it did in regards to its intended purpose,
Line Quality
Explanations:
Personal enjoyment
Positive: if it's fun, if it made me emotional, if it's Intriguing
Negative: If it caused me pain (flashing lights, motion sickness),
if it made me uncomfortable/angry
(pedo shit, incest, abuser/rapist apologia),
if it's boring
All Comments (0) Comments