Back to Single_fighter's Profile Single_fighter's Profile

My review for this anime is good in a certain sense, good for the yuri part, good for the ecchi part, good for the unusual story concept about Mahou Shoujo so it seems like a unique story.

For animation, it can't be said to be very good or bad, which is standard for a similar action genre anime where it doesn't show much martial art choreography, just showing the fight between witches.

For the voice acting part, I think it suits the main character and some supporting characters so I give a plus point for this part. I have read the manga of ... this anime and didn't expect it to be made into an anime, according to expectations, this story is well done because it is rare for an ecchi genre anime to get good reviews from fans.

So in conclusion, I recommend this anime for those who like the ecchi and yuri genres in particular because this anime is full of fanservice of course.

I will give my impression of the action ecchi anime disguised as a fantasy comedy, Here the ecchi is the yuri relationship between the characters. Honestly I'm confused about where this anime genre is going to be taken, it's unclear or ambiguous, because from the early episodes the action elements are already felt and at the end of the last episode there are more and more action elements, yes comedy only feels like it's at the beginning of the episode in the end of the episode comedy is forced by making the main character look even more stupid with his behavior, which should be in ... the final battle situation the main character is better off looking serious and cool but it doesn't happen, as a viewer of this anime I'm quite disgusted with this kind of plot. So there are many where the comedy elements are wrong in their placement. Yes I admit it's not easy to combine action and comedy genre anime, only a few great works have succeeded but not this anime. There are many mistakes that occur in this story but the most crucial ones are in the genre and concept of this anime story. And a common mistake in action genre works is that the main character is innocent and naive, made worse to look funny, and his intelligence is reduced, believe me this will not work in a 12-episode action genre work unless you have a lot of episodes to develop the character. It is true that in this story from the beginning of the episode to the end the development of the main character (Komari) does not go at all, it looks monotonous.

There is not much I can review from this anime, I only like the shojo ai relationship between the female characters, while for the action storyline in my opinion it is very lacking in cliche. The problem lies in the role of the antagonist in this story is no more than an NPC with minimal background information, so it looks like the protagonist characters are fighting aliens who accidentally stopped by on earth which even these aliens do not have intelligence and a clear purpose for their invasion. I admit that the storyline of this anime is full of gaps if what is being sold ... is the action story. This anime is more suitable for the shojo ai, yuri, drama, slice of life genres. The animation is standard and not bad. The soundtrack is also standard.

Browsing anime genre music and I was fooled by the cover photo of this anime which is not interesting but the rating is quite good but after finishing watching this anime my expectations are in accordance with the rating. My impression of the main story for the main character is unique, Carole with a tomboyish nature while Tuesday with her innocent and careless nature, this is a balanced and complementary combination. The setting of the story is also the planet Mars so it reminds me of the Aria series. The concept of the story is also unique for anime genre music different from most anime ... of the same type, a duo singer who tries to be famous and makes his debut through various ways that I think are realistic according to reality in the real world, even in the story of this anime the conflict is very complex not only in the scope of family and friends but also involves the politics of a country, racism immigrants and the dark side of the entertainment world. From this anime I remember the saying "music can unite the world" and that happened in this anime with a good ending execution. For the storyline I give a score of: 8.

And for the soundtrack the song is very good and the impression really feels in accordance with the situation that occurs during a certain scene, this part I give a score of: 8

for the graphic art I think it's just standard and ordinary maybe because of the style of the illustration like that from the author, so I give a score of 6.

So my conclusion is to recommend this anime for those who like the music anime genre with a different touch.

Since this is season 3, I will only discuss the storyline. So for season 3 my conclusion is boring, there are no new elements or new arcs and 13 episodes ended in vain just to catch one wizard who is not even ranked among the greatest wizards in the anime world. I suggest that each season should discuss different arcs and each arc should have at least 1 major problem resolved. I give an example, season 3 of this anime should discuss the problems of the Yotsuba family with Tatsuya to the end, and if there is a season 4 this anime can focus on ... the arc of the competition for the strongest wizards in the world, this needs to be done so that each season there is something achieved and the storyline feels solid not boring. This season 3 is really a decline in the quality of the storyline. I can't imagine a wizard as strong as the MC who can eliminate a military base can have difficulty facing weak enemies even requiring 13 episodes, suddenly the impression of epic battles in seasons 1, 2, & movies just disappeared because of season 3. I hope this can be an evaluation material for the author and director staff

I don't really understand Vtuber culture so I can't judge accurately because this is a really new show in anime. But I will judge logically according to my perspective. So from the storyline telling about a Vtuber who became very famous because of his unintentional negligence but was liked by his fans and colleagues, basically it only tells about his daily life along with his professional activities which are spiced up with sexual humor that tends more towards shojo ai. It takes patience to be able to enjoy this anime because you will be faced with a lot of chat interactions between characters and NPCs ... aka audiences which are sometimes just like a chat panel on social media which is quite difficult to follow because it passes so quickly, especially if we have to translate it into a language that we understand. It will be very troublesome and boring because you have to pause this anime video often in order to understand the storyline. And this should be an anime that tells the real Vtuber culture but I can't see it or distinguish it because there is no difference between the Vtuber character and the real character, the only difference is the presence of 2.5D animated characters, and it doesn't explain the reference for making Vtuber characters whether from the original appearance of the real character or just the imagination of the character creator in the story, and the lack of the appearance of NPCs that are not related to the story are only depicted with markers that are not similar to human appearance, maybe this is just my prejudice that considers it as the uniqueness of this anime's background.

So my conclusion for this anime, it is unique in some senses but not impressive enough to make me interested in Vtuber culture, maybe the advantages of this anime are only a place for voice actors to improve their skills by imitating some unique characters in this anime.

My assessment, we start from the main story which I think is very problematic which makes this anime get a bad score on MAL. more precisely the main character in the story has a personality that is too innocent and stupid enough to understand the surrounding environment, and too stupid to understand the comparison of power and social status in society in the story. I am ironic that a story like this can be made into an anime, because the trend of manga, manhua, and mahwa that are popular when it comes to the action genre is a smart and manipulative main character, or a ... main character who becomes a clever Villain. Or alternative stories such as multi-level (like solo leveling anime) but with a touch of parallel worlds, multi dungeons, or stories with an apocalypse setting due to an alien attack with its zombie virus. From the alternative stories like the ones I explained above, these are stories that are currently popular in comics outside Japan. I think let's innovate with different stories, not just about the outdated Rainkarnator and isekai stories. Come on, authors, producers, and animation studios, innovate and be more selective in choosing story material for your comics and anime, don't just chase the demands of having to release seasonal anime without paying attention to the quality of the work created..! I'm really sad.. That's all for the assessment of the main story, score: 4...

For the animation, it's quite good in the fighting duel section, score: 6.5

for the standard soundtrack only, score: 5, nothing impressive

Even until season 3 I still don't understand about caruta sports? Quite entertained by the drama, but I don't fit the competitive sports genre anime with added elements of romance that look disgusting and eliminate the passion of sports genre anime lovers. Maybe this is what makes me choose to watch sports anime that are tainted with elements of romance. But according to my guess the main character is a woman and surrounded by men there must be romance, even though the description does not have a romance genre, but in season 3 the romance seems real.. Hhaaaaaa.. Very disappointing to be fooled.. So the ... point is I don't really like the competitive sports genre tainted with elements of romance that is a consideration in my assessment.

I won't comment much, I will only discuss the storyline. In my opinion, the first few episodes made me entertained and interesting with the story concept which was quite unique than usual. For conflicts in the story that become a problem because the resolution is not executed well, it just seems flat, especially in the final few episodes of this anime. Even though I expected there to be retribution or proof for the various characters in solving their problems and it turned out to be normal so it seemed like there was something missing in the story. Because it's not very impressive ... in my opinion, I'll give it a normal score, namely: 6

The main character is from another world but doesn't seem smart about things in the home world. The main character is an adult office worker who is supposed to be quite smart. It's ridiculous that the knowledge of the modern world is not used in another world, in fact the main character is too dependent on his followers and their interpretation skills. If modern knowledge is applied in another world by the main character, it will be easier to win the battle in this comic story. Knowledge of making bombs, gunpowder, firearms. I think this is basic knowledge if a sane person ... from the modern world is going to war and wants victory in fiction or real life, especially since this concept is Reincarnated from the modern world. And why are details like this not thought of by the author of this manga? ? And also I am quite disturbed by the child mentality with the main character's innocent face even though it was clear that in his previous life the main character was an adult man? The author must explain whether becoming Reincarnated will reset the personality and intelligence of the main character too? I hope the author of this manga series will pay more attention to small details and initial concepts according to the title and prologue in this story so that it makes more sense and attracts readers' interest. Because in my opinion, readers' current interest prefers main characters who are smart or overpowered rather than main characters who are innocent and naive.