I am no critic and my opinion is my own, just as you are also not and yours is yours. All I ask is that you accept my review as is, not place judgment or become biased. A review may hold emotion to it, but also remember the logic behind your words. Should you wish to discuss about opposing viewpoints, I would happily accept. I hope my input may help in any way that it can.
Should you wish to read my bio, here are some notes as to what and how I rate:
Anime: I will rate each show I have seen based of of its story (interest of the plot, pacing, climax, conclusion), characters (realism, behavior, depth), animation (blends with the story, characters, and environment), music (placement, remembrance, emotional and personal attachment), and true to the genre (relation to the genre tags as a whole and how well it kept to that narrative story telling throughout). Each topic will be rated out of 5, tallied in total, then finalized as my resulting opinion.
Manga: I am not an avid manga reader, so don't expect much.
Hentai: I will rate each show I have seen by the story (plot, climax, conclusion, characters), music (how well it adds to each scene), animation (fluctuates with each scene on eroticism for characters, environment, and story), true to the genre (relation to the genre tags placed for the story), and story's eroticism (erotic interest towards the show). Each topic will be rated out of 5, tallied in total, then finalized as my resulting opinion. I understand that this brand of anime is primarily focused on eroticism, but not every hentai is a good one (i.e. Tsui no Sora, look up The Anime Man). Quick note: there are certain genre tags I will avoid due to my personal disinterest against them, such as NTR and Rape, but should I find an interest in the story behind it, you may see a review with such tags.
Doujin: I will rate each doujin I have read by the characters (interest, attraction), story elements to eroticism (how well it blends together), art (details added to each scene and adds to the emotion/erotic interest), and true to genre (relation to the genre tags placed on the doujin). Each topic will be rated out of 5, tallied in total, then finalized as my resulting opinion. Same notes as my hentai review: I will tend to avoid certain tags unless the story interests me.