Report MoonstruckMinun's Profile

Rating Scale:

10 - Succeeds fantastically in at least 3 of the following categories: intellectually engaging, psychologically thrilling, emotionally moving, humor, and musically/aesthetically pretty.
9 - Succeeds fantastically in at least 2 of those categories.
8 - Succeeds in at least 2 of those categories, but falls noticeably short in others.
7 - Succeeds to some degree in 2 of those categories, but not as well as 8-10, and falls noticeably short in others. Alternatively, succeeds fantastically in at least one of those categories while not failing in others.
6 - Succeeds in at least one of those categories, but falls noticeably short in others.
5 - Succeeds to some degree in one of those categories, but not well enough to redeem other aspects which fall short.
4 - Does not succeed in any of those categories to a noticeable extent.
3 - Does not succeed in any of those categories and has also at least 2 of: poor writing, poor pace, unlikeable characters, poor attempts at imitation, poor music/visual.
2 - Does not succeed in any of the first category, and fails in at least 3 of the second category.
1 - Fails to succeed in anything it attempts.