Let me preface this by saying that I've never never submitted a review before, because if I find something enjoyable enough to consider writing a review for it, I feel that I will be biased - and there's usually plenty of reviews that can cover that. To be fair, I am biased about this one too although in the opposite direction. However, I need to warn those who are more of the same mind as myself before they watch this.
Before moving onto the actual review, I also need to elaborate on what I meant with my previous statements. I☆Can is Netorare (NTR for short). Most
...
people watching hentai are already familiar with what that means, and if you aren't you should look it up as you'll be seeing a lot of it in all forms of hentai.
People have very different opinions about NTR - Personally I don't enjoy it and for the most part something containing NTR will make it worse. That said, I've always been able to stomach it. I have never been outright turned off or disturbed by NTR.. until now. This is important and a big factor that you should keep in mind as you decide if I☆Can is for you or not. On to the actual review;
Before anything else, I'll mention that episode 3 is seperate from episode 1-2 - The first two cover one story while the third covers a different story arc (or route, if you're familiar with VNs). This review focuses on the first two episodes.
I☆Can was essentially similar to any other NTR up until near the end of episode 2, up until then there wasn't anything that stood out much. The aesthetics were solid, while the story was similar to the more stereotypical NTRs out there - nothing that would've made an impression on me. However, that all changed as I watched the culmination of the story for the second episode. In just a few minutes I☆Can managed to change my mood from a mellow calm to utter anger and disgust. I can't remember the last time something managed to make my stomach turn from sheer disgust.
Then what was so different compared to any other NTR I have seen? Simply put - the execution. While I do not enjoy NTR by itself, I can find logical/psychological arguments that are acceptable or they present it in a way that allows me to accept them. This is key for someone that does not enjoy NTR but can deal with it.
I☆Can failed on both ends. This is far from the first time I've been unable to justify what happens, but in all previous cases it has been presented in a way that I can swallow. In this case it almost felt like they went out of their way to make sure it was as indigestible as possible for anyone but the key audience. I'll elaborate on my thoughts for those interested after wrapping up the body of this review.
The bottom line of all of this and the point of the entire review is to warn anyone that does not enjoy NTR. I cannot imagine anyone being able to stomach the conclusion of this story unless they're specifically into this kind of thing. I imagine that much like myself, you'll find yourself utterly disgusted. Those that truly enjoy NTR will likely find I☆Can very appealing for reasons similar to why I couldn't even stomach it.
*Closing Statement*
In short; If you are into NTR then look no further, as this may be your next favorite. For anyone else - stay as far away as possible.
**Arguments and reasoning behind my review**
For this part, I'll try to shortly go over my reasoning as I try to digest just why I ended up feeling so disgusted. This will contain no direct spoilers, but will hint at what kind of story development there is. I'll also warn you that this is a lot less compact and concise and borders more on a rant, but will let you see most of the reasoning as to why I disliked it as much as I did.
The main point focuses on the main character. This point is especially important - this one, aswell as a lot of other NTR will have the MC lose his beloved to whatever alpha male is represented in it because he is both beta as fuck aswell as ignoring one of her needs (or ignoring her altogether). The most common combination I've seen is that the girl is sexually frustrated due to the MC refusing to (completely) satisfy her sexually after what she has experienced with Mr Alpha, aswell as either being insensitive or neglective to her. There are cases where the only factor is sexual frustration, but those are generally the cases where the girl has been thoroughly trained for an extended period of time specifically for that purpose. In that case her feelings for the MC tends to remain but she acknowledges that she cannot live without Mr Alpha anymore, while in the former she has simply lost interest in the MC in favor of Mr Alpha due to the neglect of her sexual needs in combination with the neglect of one of her other important needs. There are more examples I could make - the point is that I can find acceptable arguments for things turning out the way it did in both cases.
For I☆Can I simply cannot find any way to justify the turn of events. While the girl IS sexually frustrated and that is a contributing factor, the problem is her reasoning and explanation of why she made her choice. She tries to make it a point that MC acts as if he doesn't care about what happened to her on top of seeming unable to satisfy her sexually - which would be fine, I've seen plenty of NTR that developed that way. The problem is that it simply isn't true. I have a decent amount of both knowledge and experience as to how the human mind and reasoning works - both from first-hand knowledge of interacting and discussing with people of both genders aswell as second-hand knowledge found in literature and on the internet.
There is just no way that ANYONE would not realize that another person is worried and care about you when they're repeatedly asking you if you're fine in a situation where you're hiding something but trying your hardest for it to not show. On top of that due to how MC is going about asking her about it, most (but not all, unlike the previous point) people would also realize that he also knows about whatever you're trying to hide from him, but is not bringing it up because he's being considerate of you. The only way I could justify her train of thought would be if she had a serious mental derangement or some form of mental retardation - the problem is that she is presented as a (mostly) normal person. Because of that, the next logical step would be to assume that she's "a bad girl" - basically that her argument doesn't hold water because she's an asshole just trying to make excuses. Again, the problem is that she's not presented as such - I'd even argue for the opposite. Until the climax of the story she's essentially portrayed as more of a "good girl".
Essentially any logic and reasoning to explain why she did what she did is thrown out the window. As I already touched on, even in cases where her argument doesn't hold up it can normally be explained in some other way, most commonly by portraying her as an asshole. There are other examples too, but I won't cover them. The point is that it is acceptable, because you're given a reason or explanation (that holds) for what happens.
As if that wasn't bad enough already, I☆Can basically slaps it all in your face by having the climax of this whole NTR mess *actual spoiler warning* end with her blowing Mr Alpha under his desk while the MC convinces Mr Alpha to leave his girl alone, and her explanation as to why she continues doing so follows shortly after. It is worth noting that MC does convince Mr Alpha of this in a beta way that can be somewhat questionable (though surprisingly reasonable for a hentai), but it should be clear even to an idiot listening to the conversation that he deeply cares about the girl. As I already mentioned, he has already shown clear concern about her on multiple occassions on top of this, yet she's still making the argument that the MC doesn't care about her. Just after she went out of her way of saying this, she continues by talking about how MC can't satisfy her sexually. This by itself wouldn't have been strange, but the way she talks about it is as if the previous part of the conversation had never happened, and the sexual frustration is the biggest reason. The irony is that if they had excluded the first part of her argument it would've made a far more acceptable - even if still not satisfying - end to the story. While clearly not the case, it's almost as if the producers themselves realized the fallacies of the whole scene and wanted to change her argument.
They could've handled the finish in so many different ways, and most of them would've been far better. I've already mentioned it, but.. Sexual frustration the big reason? A-ok. Her being an asshole? Also fine. The problem is that's not what they're actually presenting. They're giving you the combo I mentioned far earlier in the review - sexual frustration+neglect, except the neglect they're talking about is just not true.
In the end, these are the reasons why it left such a bad taste in my mouth - not the ending by itself but rather the presentation and the way they tried to explain/justify it. Unless I run into something that handles their story just as bad or worse, this will likely be my lowest rated entry in not only my hentai entries, but the entirity of my MAL library despite being solid on other fronts.
Sep 21, 2018
Let me preface this by saying that I've never never submitted a review before, because if I find something enjoyable enough to consider writing a review for it, I feel that I will be biased - and there's usually plenty of reviews that can cover that. To be fair, I am biased about this one too although in the opposite direction. However, I need to warn those who are more of the same mind as myself before they watch this.
Before moving onto the actual review, I also need to elaborate on what I meant with my previous statements. I☆Can is Netorare (NTR for short). Most ... |
