Total Recommendations: 3
If you liked
Soul Eater
|
...then you might like
Ao no Exorcist
|
Both deal with a group of students in training to become great fighters in the war against demons/the supernatural. They have intense plot lines but are injected with enough humor to keep it from being too serious. However, the drawing style for Ao No Exorcist is a bit more wispy and edgy than for Soul Eater which uses a more cartoony style.
If you liked
Higurashi no Naku Koro ni
|
...then you might like
Another
|
Both of these anime lean towards a dark aspect with many creepy undertones. However from what I've seen of Another it has much less gore an insanity than Higurashi, so if you want something with more of a creep-out factor than gore, watch Another.
If you liked
Azumanga Daiou The Animation
|
...then you might like
Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei
|
Both have a rather random plot line with humor catered towards those that enjoy insanity.