All my scores are entirely subjective. I do try not to overhype my points if I absolutely know that its not as good as I think it is, but if I enjoyed something, I will definitely give it at least 7 points, even if it has a lot of flaws.
Except Sword Art Online. It's not as bad as I rated it, but it is just really offensive to me. It could have been good, but it was content to be an offensive mediocre thing, so I can't even give it pity points for trying.
I'm not a critic, so take everything from me with a grain of salt. But sometimes it is nice to hear the opinion of people who are not critics, so I still yell into the internet a lot. :D