Kino Queen

The art and character design are great. The story and plot are incredibly bland and uninspired.

Trash

Tenmaku cinema if the writer knows how to execute and present the theme in an interesting way.

It's a series that I read just to see what happens in the next chapter, but don't care or sympathize with any of the characters.

Overrated as shit lmao

Very funny and the characters are endearing.

Nice art and fanservice, Dogwater story and plot

Potential that never arrived.

Not as good as the movie version but still serviceable.

Garbage

An incredibly stylish and unique one. I really enjoyed it even though I wasn't interested in solving the puzzles.

mediocre and disorganized.

Wacky premise with strong execution

Mid

Aimless and all over of the place, well-deserved axed if you ask me.

The characters aren't exactly likeable, but they're relatable.

Cooking kino

How not to make a sport manga

This is probably the best-written fiction I've ever read.

I don't know how to feel about this.

I just don't like it in general.

I'm pretty sure the author smoked weed while cooking this.

Atrociously awful

The author's inexperience

Huh, a power system based on color in a black and white manga? The art style and character designs are also repulsive.

Generic and basic but well-executed

I'm probably in the very small minority who find this funny.

The art is quite rough, but that doesn't stop it from conveying a powerful and deeply moving message.

Stylish Trainwreck

See a therapist if you enjoy this.

It started off intriguing but seems like they can't offer on anything more than that.

An actually filler series

This is without a doubt the worst thing I have ever witnessed.

It's good proof that art alone isn't enough to make a good manga.

I quickly lost interest after chapter 2.

It's not actually good, but i like this energy.

For better or worse, this is pure madness.

Extremely uncomfortable. I guess the author has mental issues.

It's very generic but I don't mind reading it.

It's boring and pointless. It's worth it if you have too much free time to waste.

Gone too soon

A great example of how to make manga with an unpopular topic good and enjoyable.

It should have ended after they escaped from the school. Anything after that was a real mistake.

Better than Chainsaw Man, I'm not kidding.

Should be better

Yes, that's right.

Hmmmmmmmmmm

A gag manga about fandom wars. Pretty funny.

Messy and poorly pacing & executed

Timeless classics comedy

Super sweet and wholesome

I forgot about it.

Improved too late plus golf

Harmless and goofy

Not that much

It quickly lost its plot until the end.

The art is great but the rest is average.

Existence is suffering

Superb meta jokes

A terrifying trainwreck. It's not even funny.

An interesting idea that needs better execution, however it's not something that should have been in this magazine in the first place.

Godawful

It's funny but I can understand why it was axed.

Starts off very strong, gets less and less interesting as it goes on.

Extremely generic and forgettable

It exists.

Competent enough

I think it's good series and worth it despite its many flaws.

I didn't really get into the nihilistic message this series wanted to convey, but this is the kind of romance story I really like

Overhated

The ending was garbage enough that I downgraded it from 4/10 to 2/10 for a series that wasn't anything outstanding as such.

Weird and awesome

Super bad

Meh

Just mid

It starts off a bit rough and finds its footing after that, but overall it's a strangely enjoyable read, although Kumagawa doesn't really do much for me as the character who "carries" the series

A pseudo-psychological slop with bad writing, bad characters, bad art, and the most ridiculous asspull as much as possible at the end

I have no idea why so many people like this btw.

A realistically written story about work life, relationships and dreams. The space technilogy trivia is interesting enough even though I didn't understand it at times. It loses momentum a bit midway through but still manages to conclude the story without missing anything.

Not as deep and complex as expected, the story and plot is quite basic but the characters are well-written and have enough depth, especially Gesicht, whom I find to be an excellent protagonist of this series, and Tenma is also a good secondary character. Overall, I like the message that robots or artificial intelligence have dignity equal to humans, even though in the real world this issue is still debated. However, something that bothers me a lot is the excessive emphasis on words of "hatred" and "sorrow," which doesn't add much meaning or impact to the overall story, and the ending is rather weak overall. 

PPPPPP is an abstract series due to its piano-related theme, which readers cannot hear through the manga format. However, the art style and writing give this work a charm that is hard to find elsewhere. I found the characters and their dramas interesting, but overall, it became less engaging in the second half.

Considering the treatment it received, I think the author had every right to make such an outrageous ending.

The initial premise was interesting, but once (poorly executed and confusing) power system and (shallow and uninteresting) villain organization or whatever were introduced, it went downhill from there. the overall story was an absolute mess too, especially second half. I'm surprised it's lasted this long and liked by many people.

It wasn't even a good series to begin with and the way the author ended it really pissed me off. I'm glad this garbage got axed.

Boring, pretentious and no impact. One of the most overrated shit I've ever witnessed.

what the fuck is this

I guess the author wasn't smart enough to write something like this, and the ending was just unbearable garbage with nothing being resolved due to the rushed cancellation. other than the art, I have nothing positive to say about it.

Although I think how good this is when it comes to depicting the depressing and dark side of society. It's definitely not a series I want to re-read for that reason.

I wasn't expecting top-tier writing from this genre, but this is incredibly dumb, and there's way too much unnecessary text and dialogue that even someone who can stand text-heavy manga like me finds annoying. Other than the art and some badass characters, this series is disappointing and not really worth it.

The Japanese are right, this series is so fucking boring and nothing, only stupid gaijin who lack reading comprehension skills or read manga by just staring at the pictures think it's good.

The ending was as lazy as I expected, but I don't mind. Aside from that, I think it's a solid series with a lot of strong emotional moments and notable casts, and Takemichi is a decent MC in my opinion, but I kinda understand why a lot of readers hate him so much.

This series is a thin line between charm and emptiness. While I liked the character interaction and its poetic storytelling nature, the rest was nothing and meh, and I was quite disappointed that the worldbuilding and a lot of things was totally left unexplained/unexplored