Sep 14, 2020
So this is my first time writing a review, but since this manga is fairly unpopular, I think it's worth taking a shot.
Let's start with what's good.
Art: 9/10
Honestly, not much to say about it. Character design is very good, backgrounds are too, action scenes are engaging, it clearly is one of the strong points of the manga.
Story 6/10
Don't let the note fool you, it's not that bad. This manga is very short (only 4 volumes), and it clearly suffers from it. The first 2 volumes are, in my opinion, really great. They are really intriguing, the pace is good most of the time (albeit
...
it sometimes feels fast, it really depends on the scenes) and that's why I originally bought them. You really get a sense of tension, almost supernatural, and you really want to know more. The art also helps a lot at conveying the feelings of the characters. The 3rd book is still good, but it doesn't do much to advance the plot despite the lack of chapters. The 4th and final volume is the "revelation" volume, and without spoiling anything... what.the.hell. In the beginning, you feel like "yeah, ok, it's a logical conclusion" but it's very... unengaging. It's probably a spoil, but they just... explain it. Full-on exposition. Then there's more plot, and it's cool and interesting with somewhat acceptable twists, but the last chapter is clearly rushed, and the epilogue is just frustrating. The twists are there, but they just don't land. And in my opinion, in a mystery/intrigue-driven manga, if the ending is not good, then it ruins the whole thing.
TLDR: good start, rushed ending. Needed more time to develop its plot, and more importantly, the ending is unsatisfying/frustrating.
Character: 7/10
So once again, not the best score but far from the worst. And, once again, it's because the story is too short. The characters are interesting, especially the MC and a few side characters, but they lack the time to shine. Some are flat-out forgotten by the end of the story.
Enjoyment: 8/10
Despite the ending, I still kinda enjoyed it. Sure, the plot has problems. Sure, the "high school students uncover a massive conspiracy" trope is overused, but... it's kind of what I like and kind of the reason why I picked it up in the first place.
--------------------------------------------------------------
Overall: 7/10
In a nutshell: an interesting if somewhat overused concept, with a very good setup and some good supporting characters and good art to support the whole, but an unsatisfying and rushed ending kinda ruins it and some characters lack the time they need to shine. Had it been at least twice longer, it would have been very good.
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
