SADDEST ENDING ? ( SPOILER )

Oct 19, 2021 2:39 AM

Offline

Apr 2020

3231

this anime is not sad imo, even though the main girl died but that didn't make me sad at all, because the main girl was killed by someone, maybe this anime will be sad if the main girl dies of her illness.

Oct 19, 2021 2:39 AM

#3

Ni8htwing

Offline

Jul 2020

279

It was kind of obvious that she is going to die. But it was not too sad for me. The main character had a great development though.

Toxic fans:- using the anime list of the user to criticize his opinions on a different anime.

If you cannot tolerate others taste delete your mal account☮️.

Oct 19, 2021 2:40 AM

#4

mashy_xd

Offline

Jul 2021

39

I personally like sad endings.
But I think nothing could've been done to save Sakura 😔

Oct 19, 2021 2:41 AM

#5

animeforlife808

Offline

Sep 2021

156

Kaiseki said:
this anime is not sad imo, even though the main girl died but that didn't make me sad at all, because the main girl was killed by someone, maybe this anime will be sad if the main girl dies of her illness.

wait was this comment supposed to be an irony ? I felt like if she died due to her illness it would have been better , and it would also be expected

Oct 19, 2021 2:46 AM

#6

OtakuHead69

Offline

Jun 2021

24

Bro but this movie wasn't even sad.. I've seen many movies but this ain't me feel sad.. Instead I felt,it was full of Happy vibes.Even the moral of the movie itself was that even if you have a few days to live..Then live your life to the Fullest.

Oct 19, 2021 2:48 AM

#7

removed-user

Offline

Jul 2018

561871

I was laughing at how stupid it was.

Oct 19, 2021 3:07 AM

#8

removed-user

Offline

Jul 2018

561871

I feel like it could have been much better without the beginning of the movie. The beginning itself tells you everything about how it ends.

You know that Sakura died after MC sent her a particular message. When in the end he literally types the name of the film to send her, it becomes obvious that she is about to die. That shock value of him returning and finding out is taken away because of that.

They do a lot to allow us to be in the MC's shoes by not focusing on him and leaving him undeveloped. So, it would have been better if we also felt the same sudden shock he must have felt.

Other than that, the movie is fine. Just the beginning is something I would personally change/cut out.

Oct 19, 2021 3:21 AM

#9

Sawan_28

Offline

Jul 2021

31

animeforlife808 said:

Kaiseki said:
this anime is not sad imo, even though the main girl died but that didn't make me sad at all, because the main girl was killed by someone, maybe this anime will be sad if the main girl dies of her illness.

wait was this comment supposed to be an irony ? I felt like if she died due to her illness it would have been better , and it would also be expected

if she would have died because of her illness that would be too generic ... i think the ending is better this way...

Oct 19, 2021 3:38 AM

#10

animeforlife808

Offline

Sep 2021

156

VarunBalodi330 said:
I feel like it could have been much better without the beginning of the movie. The beginning itself tells you everything about how it ends.

You know that Sakura died after MC sent her a particular message. When in the end he literally types the name of the film to send her, it becomes obvious that she is about to die. That shock value of him returning and finding out is taken away because of that.

They do a lot to allow us to be in the MC's shoes by not focusing on him and leaving him undeveloped. So, it would have been better if we also felt the same sudden shock he must have felt.

Other than that, the movie is fine. Just the beginning is something I would personally change/cut out.

well she was the one who texted him

Oct 19, 2021 3:39 AM

#11

removed-user

Offline

Jul 2018

561871

animeforlife808 said:

VarunBalodi330 said:
I feel like it could have been much better without the beginning of the movie. The beginning itself tells you everything about how it ends.

You know that Sakura died after MC sent her a particular message. When in the end he literally types the name of the film to send her, it becomes obvious that she is about to die. That shock value of him returning and finding out is taken away because of that.

They do a lot to allow us to be in the MC's shoes by not focusing on him and leaving him undeveloped. So, it would have been better if we also felt the same sudden shock he must have felt.

Other than that, the movie is fine. Just the beginning is something I would personally change/cut out.

well she was the one who texted him

Wait, I thought he is the one who texts her, "I want to eat your pancreas." To tell her that he wants to try and become like her.

Oct 19, 2021 3:40 AM

#12

Akitokamisen

Offline

Jul 2017

819

Well for me it was a bit sad and it left an impression on me
Showing her funeral at the start, I was like oh she dies in the end huh (basically no opinion)
Then we are shown what kind of character she is/was and how she interacted with the mc
Basically getting you attached to the character
Ryan her condition improved and was about meet the mc at a cafe she gets killed from killer not from illness which is the original assumption you get to while watching the movie
Than the funeral scene is shown again and this time feels hit me (the impression it left me is you won't feel anything for a person you don't know anything about or got attached to or had some opinion of them but if you know than or had an opinion on than or got attached to them then there death will make you feel something

Oct 19, 2021 3:49 AM

#13

_syedmuhammad__

Offline

Jan 2021

554

animeforlife808 said:
NGL I watched this movie around 5 times , and everytime I watched it I cried . The ending wass like soooo depressing , many times I wished it had an alternative ending . But if it did , it wouldnt have been that famous as now . How did u guys want the anime to end ? were u happy with the ending ? or did u prefer an alternative one ? and how ?

Don't ever watch 5 centimetres per second , it is much sadder .

Oct 19, 2021 3:50 AM

#14

Riddhiman10

Offline

Aug 2021

22

Obviously yes.... She was anyway running out of time due to that illness but being murdered was so tragic nd sad... I cried nd sobbed for 2 weeks

Oct 19, 2021 3:50 AM

#15

nimokeN

Offline

May 2021

149

It's not even that sad but I think its the best ending

Oct 19, 2021 3:51 AM

#16

Imagine_Breakr

Offline

Jan 2021

114

animeforlife808 said:
NGL I watched this movie around 5 times , and everytime I watched it I cried . The ending wass like soooo depressing , many times I wished it had an alternative ending . But if it did , it wouldnt have been that famous as now . How did u guys want the anime to end ? were u happy with the ending ? or did u prefer an alternative one ? and how ?

i stayed numb for her death 😐
But yeah i broke up in movies like Kimetsu no Yaiba mugen and NGNL/0 .....saddest n most heartbreaking was Silent Voice

Oct 19, 2021 3:51 AM

#17

Imagine_Breakr

Offline

Jan 2021

114

animeforlife808 said:
NGL I watched this movie around 5 times , and everytime I watched it I cried . The ending wass like soooo depressing , many times I wished it had an alternative ending . But if it did , it wouldnt have been that famous as now . How did u guys want the anime to end ? were u happy with the ending ? or did u prefer an alternative one ? and how ?

i stayed numb for her death 😐
But yeah i broke up in movies like Kimetsu no Yaiba mugen and NGNL/0 .....saddest n most heartbreaking was Silent Voice

Oct 19, 2021 3:51 AM

#18

Imagine_Breakr

Offline

Jan 2021

114

animeforlife808 said:
NGL I watched this movie around 5 times , and everytime I watched it I cried . The ending wass like soooo depressing , many times I wished it had an alternative ending . But if it did , it wouldnt have been that famous as now . How did u guys want the anime to end ? were u happy with the ending ? or did u prefer an alternative one ? and how ?

i stayed numb for her death 😐
But yeah i broke up in movies like Kimetsu no Yaiba mugen and NGNL/0 .....saddest n most heartbreaking was Silent Voice

Oct 19, 2021 4:20 AM

#19

RobeChelseaBoots

Offline

Jul 2021

27

I loved the ending; what really made it sad for me was the fact she died very unexpectedly from something you wouldn’t ordinarily expect to happen. I thought she was going to die of her illness or something but then my expectations were subverted in an instant and that honestly made it more real for me. Since a main theme of the movie is about living every second like it’s your last, when this shit happened it proved how real the possibility of anyone dying at any given time is even if their death is determined by something like an illness.

Oct 19, 2021 4:28 AM

#20

Landon_08

Offline

Aug 2020

235

Perfect movie 10/10

Oct 19, 2021 4:56 AM

#21

lizzziziz

Offline

Dec 2020

3855

it was something out of my prediction and it did give a "shock" kind of feeling but it wasn't so much "sad" to me, i do like the ending tho. much prefer it rather than if they didnt reveal that she died at the beginning and gave her an "ordinary death" where she dies because of her illness. the murder was out of what we expected so it was a good twist

Oct 19, 2021 5:05 AM

#22

SethXoXkun

Offline

Jan 2021

438

Grave of the fireflies: let me introduce myself

Oct 19, 2021 7:10 AM

#23

removed-user

Offline

Jul 2018

561871

they actually pulled something so obvious from the start to be sooo emotional , but I don't think its the saddest ending there are others shows , not gonna name them coz its highly subjective

Oct 19, 2021 8:10 AM

#24

Jayanthlovesanim

Offline

Nov 2020

75

Man I don't know if it's a cause it's sad or something else but every time I rewatch this anime I don't watch it till end cause don't know why...but I feel too scared to watch it till end. But for me the movie in itself was 10/10

Oct 19, 2021 9:26 AM

#25

WoughtFighter

Offline

Jan 2021

263

Landon_08 said:
Perfect movie 10/10

Couldn’t agree more

MALoween✟Mansion 2023 Candies:

Oct 19, 2021 11:10 AM

#26

HentaiLandlord

Offline

Jan 2021

62

Aayushkr_singh said:
It was kind of obvious that she is going to die. But it was not too sad for me. The main character had a great development though.

i mean it literally shows her dead at the start lol

Oct 19, 2021 11:29 AM

#27

Gogetac

Offline

May 2021

219

Bruuuh why the F you watched 5 times!!!!
I literally downloaded it, watched and never Opened that folder again after watching it.
My heart is not strong to watch it again😭💔

Oct 19, 2021 3:24 PM

#28

steph-_-

Offline

Jun 2021

8

I'm currently on the hunt for a show/movie that would make me cry; this movie almost did. The fact that he asked for permission to cry was cute and sad at the same time

Oct 19, 2021 6:38 PM

#29

SPlKE_SPIEGEL

Offline

Oct 2021

34

DamonElix said:
I was laughing at how stupid it was.

Exactly. It’s like surviving cancer and dying from holding in a shit.

Oct 19, 2021 6:39 PM

#30

SPlKE_SPIEGEL

Offline

Oct 2021

34

steph-_- said:
I'm currently on the hunt for a show/movie that would make me cry; this movie almost did. The fact that he asked for permission to cry was cute and sad at the same time

Explain your childhood and personality and I’ll find one that devastates you

Oct 19, 2021 7:11 PM

#31

removed-user

Offline

Jul 2018

561871

Sad ending but I don't consider it as saddest.

Oct 20, 2021 6:10 AM

#32

driftah

Offline

Feb 2021

21

I see a lot of people saying “she was obviously gonna die” and shit like that. But that’s literally the fucking point lmao. The reason it’s so sad is because they were aware of their inevitable fate, so they were making the most out of the time she had left, but she died before they could finish what they started.

Oct 20, 2021 7:11 AM

#33

uwuligator

Offline

Aug 2021

2

DamonElix said:
I was laughing at how stupid it was.

thanks for providing so much value through your amazingly meaningful and elaborate comment

Oct 20, 2021 7:23 AM

#34

uwuligator

Offline

Aug 2021

2

for some it might have been not so sad and i can see that. i personally thought it was emotional and meaningful. but nevertheless it was a good ending. it was able to prove it's point in a way that would have had an impact even if someone didn't find it sad.

and if you think about it we are all like Sakura. we don't have to be terminally ill to be cosidered short lived. cuz that was the point. you never know how long anything will last. so idk maybe value our time and make sth out of it i guess

it was a good anime

Oct 20, 2021 10:11 AM

#35

KarnaKua

Offline

Mar 2021

199

The whole point of the plot is that she's going to die, and there's nothing anyone can do about it. Its moral is basically "life moves on, even without the people you love most. That's the way life is. Its too short for you to wait for your opportunity because it can end at any moment"

And this moral is stressed in Sakura's Premature death. Even though Haruki knew she was going to die, he kept waiting for his opportunity to confess his true feelings, but that day neer came because "life is too short".

Someone who was meant to die died prematurely and that's what hit the hardest.

And I wouldn't have had it end any other way.

Oct 20, 2021 5:16 PM

#36

bree_janice

Offline

Jul 2021

17

This movie has a really sad ending but try watching Maquia. You’ll dry for days.

Oct 21, 2021 12:17 PM

#37

steph-_-

Offline

Jun 2021

8

SPlKE_SPIEGEL said:

steph-_- said:
I'm currently on the hunt for a show/movie that would make me cry; this movie almost did. The fact that he asked for permission to cry was cute and sad at the same time

Explain your childhood and personality and I’ll find one that devastates you

well i lived in the country away from my parents for 5 years. I got the life bullied out of me for 3 years and now I live a normal life; very extroverted and I get along with everyone.

Oct 21, 2021 12:20 PM

#38

KryzakamiHrybami

Offline

Sep 2014

9575

I didn't even know it was supposed to be a sad anime.

Oct 21, 2021 7:49 PM

#39

animeforlife808

Offline

Sep 2021

156

bree_janice said:
This movie has a really sad ending but try watching Maquia. You’ll dry for days.

already did XD , it did hit hard , especially at the end

Oct 21, 2021 7:52 PM

#40

animeforlife808

Offline

Sep 2021

156

DamonElix said:
I was laughing at how stupid it was.

well try buying/ getting a heart , cuz u may need one in the near future , u stupid emotionless , peanut-for-brains guy

Oct 21, 2021 7:54 PM

#41

animeforlife808

Offline

Sep 2021

156

n

VarunBalodi330 said:

animeforlife808 said:

well she was the one who texted him

Wait, I thought he is the one who texts her, "I want to eat your pancreas." To tell her that he wants to try and become like her.

nope , he was sad that she couldnt send him any message , after getting her phone back he reads the text which she was supposed to send , but couldnt :')

Oct 21, 2021 7:57 PM

#42

animeforlife808

Offline

Sep 2021

156

_syedmuhammad__ said:

animeforlife808 said:
NGL I watched this movie around 5 times , and everytime I watched it I cried . The ending wass like soooo depressing , many times I wished it had an alternative ending . But if it did , it wouldnt have been that famous as now . How did u guys want the anime to end ? were u happy with the ending ? or did u prefer an alternative one ? and how ?

Don't ever watch 5 centimetres per second , it is much sadder .

dude seriously ? its soo boring , that i slept halfway through . No offense bro , but the way the movie was picturised and animated was not that good

Oct 21, 2021 8:02 PM

#43

removed-user

Offline

Jul 2018

561871

driftah said:
I see a lot of people saying “she was obviously gonna die” and shit like that. But that’s literally the fucking point lmao. The reason it’s so sad is because they were aware of their inevitable fate, so they were making the most out of the time she had left, but she died before they could finish what they started.

That's not the point. I am one of those stupid people.
The fact that they told us about the message was the part I thought should not have happened. Telling us she died is a good idea, and it makes the movie much much better, but if we know *when* she is going to die, the suddenness of the death is taken away. Death is certain, but if we didn't know when it would happen, then it would be much more powerful.
But the movie gives you the entire "twist" right in your hands from the beginning and a scene which could have been really sudden and powerful lost all its charm.

The main character has little to no actual "character" and that is probably because the movie wanted to focus more on Sakura. This makes it so that we feel closer to her story because we can fill the empty character of the MC ourselves. But then the movie contradicts this by making sure we know when she dies. The stabbing news is no big deal at that point. You know she died, it's just, "oh, she died from a stabbing instead of her disease", and nothing more. On the other hand, it is supposed to be a very big deal for MC. If we are filling his shoes with our own emotions, then why aren't we allowed the same gut punch of hearing of her sudden death?

Oct 21, 2021 8:05 PM

#44

removed-user

Offline

Jul 2018

561871

animeforlife808 said:
n

VarunBalodi330 said:

Wait, I thought he is the one who texts her, "I want to eat your pancreas." To tell her that he wants to try and become like her.

nope , he was sad that she couldnt send him any message , after getting her phone back he reads the text which she was supposed to send , but couldnt :')

He is sitting in the restaurant waiting for her and he sends her the message, "I want to eat your pancreas.". Her reply to this message is what you are talking about. I am not talking about that.
The movie begins with MC saying that, "I sent her a message before her death, and I have no idea if she ever read it.". That's what I'm talking about. We know that he sent the message already. Her reply is part of the end and not at all connected to my argument.

Feb 2, 2022 12:01 PM

#45

CarbonMD

Offline

Aug 2017

2592

Nope Your Lie in April was better and more sad.

Or a bunch of other anime. This one is a stinker.

Feb 8, 2022 3:12 AM

#46

random55555

Offline

Feb 2022

1

Kaiseki said:
this anime is not sad imo, even though the main girl died but that didn't make me sad at all, because the main girl was killed by someone, maybe this anime will be sad if the main girl dies of her illness.

That's the sad part. That she had a little more time left that she could have spent with him but she was killed. If not for that maybe we could have accepted it a bit because we were prepared for that but not for the sudden murder

Feb 11, 2022 8:32 AM

#47

bullseye99o

Offline

Nov 2019

1

It is sad but not saddest. But it is very much touching.

Mar 12, 2022 8:17 AM

#48

Rogersss

Offline

Nov 2017

119

It’s definitely up there Imo, but for me Your Lie In April will almost certainly Always be the saddest thing I ever watch, in general and ending wise. But pancreas is probably the second most emotional I’ve been watching anime, either that or plastic memories or maybe clannad. Your lie in April is not only the saddest but probably the best for me when it comes to sad shows tho

Poll: » Kimi no Suizou wo Tabetai Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page ) Kisaragi - Sep 1, 2018	411	by bakakisima »» Oct 2, 2:22 PM
» Am I the only one not feeling any attachment to Sakura, making the whole movie less sad? griddyweeb - May 21, 2024	27	by CapBuster »» Sep 15, 6:24 AM
» SPOILER did anyone cry in this movie? ( 1 2 ) ichigo23sterling - Apr 11, 2021	98	by WindyCakePow »» Jul 22, 10:37 AM
» I feel like the Chekhov's Gun detracted from the experience TheCornerBro - Feb 18	16	by Melvin_15 »» Feb 20, 3:10 AM
» I cried so hard to this, I wish I could hug someone kaenkoi - Jan 2	37	by Im_Geek_Rin »» Jan 5, 6:45 PM

SADDEST ENDING ? ( SPOILER )

More topics from this board

Poll: » Kimi no Suizou wo Tabetai Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

» Am I the only one not feeling any attachment to Sakura, making the whole movie less sad?

» SPOILER did anyone cry in this movie? ( 1 2 )

» I feel like the Chekhov's Gun detracted from the experience

» I cried so hard to this, I wish I could hug someone

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters

SADDEST ENDING ? ( SPOILER )

More topics from this board

Poll: » Kimi no Suizou wo Tabetai Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

» Am I the only one not feeling any attachment to Sakura, making the whole movie less sad?

» *SPOILER* did anyone cry in this movie? ( 1 2 )

» I feel like the Chekhov's Gun detracted from the experience

» I cried so hard to this, I wish I could hug someone

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters

» SPOILER did anyone cry in this movie? ( 1 2 )