grrr said: logic340 said: My thinking is if he's scum his buddies would have filled him in and he would have just claimed Miller right away instead of fiddling around with it, but I'm sorry if I ruined your plans. Thank you for clearing this out. You might fluff a lot but when you are right you are right. @logic |
 |
im not dodging ur question tho i just want an aswer to my question before i go get my proof of my read. |
  |
Karote said: Nice try.aa-dono said: I don't think I get the same townvibe on logic, but I can't think of him as scum too. Everyone's welcome to lynch Shin-chan even if I'm not around :D You can't think Shinichi as scum but we are welcome to lynch him either way? |
 |
Shinichi-Kun said: im not dodging ur question tho i just want an aswer to my question before i go get my proof of my read. I've already given my stance on aa-dono, she's in my lynch pool on third place. You're not reading again. Now I want the read. |
 |
Shinichi-Kun said: You conveniently left out the part about grrr.aa-dono said: I don't think I get the same townvibe on logic, but I can't think of him as scum too. Moving on, @Shinichi-Kun, when you're fine and awake, could you tell us your current scumreads? You seem to put town tags more than scum. Also, in one of your previous post that I'm too lazy to dig, you said 90% of grrr's posts shows a town mindset. Could you break down those posts. and what of the 10% ? So well, until then I'll park my vote here: Vote: Shinichi-Kun I am going off now in hopes that I can wake up in time for phase change. Everyone's welcome to lynch Shin-chan even if I'm not around :D Smh haha Well my biggest scum read is still ruu the problem is ever since that jester post i think its possible shes just jester. 2nd would be chione after the end of day 1 the town read i had on her never came back and it feels like she doesnt have that same atmosphere if i get a chance once im done back reading ill find a post that shows what i mean. I dont really have a 3rd scum read alot of people are giving me those i am scum vibes like those 2, i rather see one of them flip before i decide the game out some more. What's the problem about Ruu being jester though? I thought you're pro lynch all third party regardless of what they are. |
|
aa-dono said: Shinichi-Kun said: You conveniently left out the part about grrr.Smh haha Well my biggest scum read is still ruu the problem is ever since that jester post i think its possible shes just jester. 2nd would be chione after the end of day 1 the town read i had on her never came back and it feels like she doesnt have that same atmosphere if i get a chance once im done back reading ill find a post that shows what i mean. I dont really have a 3rd scum read alot of people are giving me those i am scum vibes like those 2, i rather see one of them flip before i decide the game out some more. What's the problem about Ruu being jester though? I thought you're pro lynch all third party regardless of what they are. I am pro tpr lynch but that doesnt mean i would rather lynch them over someone that can actually flip scum. I didnt ignore it ive explained over and over my stand on grrr lol |
|
Jackrito said: I'm almost always not able to join phase change time. With exceptions of games hosted by shad. It's not rare that I left my vote and then gone.aa-dono said: I don't think I get the same townvibe on logic, but I can't think of him as scum too. Moving on, @Shinichi-Kun, when you're fine and awake, could you tell us your current scumreads? You seem to put town tags more than scum. Also, in one of your previous post that I'm too lazy to dig, you said 90% of grrr's posts shows a town mindset. Could you break down those posts. and what of the 10% ? So well, until then I'll park my vote here: Vote: Shinichi-Kun I am going off now in hopes that I can wake up in time for phase change. Everyone's welcome to lynch Shin-chan even if I'm not around :D I'm semi townreading you after outr eariler talk, but it annoys me how you leave a vote on someone you don't really sucm read I know timezones are a issue but it can create issues late on and give scum easy way to frame you and get a lynch they want. Why is that an issue here? It's not like the vote was random. |
|
Especially choine. (PS: it's a joke.) |
|
| @grapefruit, give me anything so i can change my vote to shinichi. At least a tiny mini soft claim. Even a fake one will do. |
| |
It is okey. I thing you will be dead soon, so enjoy your life while you can. |
| |
aa-dono said: I don't trust his tone. It's that weak of a reason that's why I don't pursue it compared to Lucian. I did scumread Lucian. I tried to understand their thought process, but what I get from the subsequent replies were neutral. It doesn't mean my view of him turned neutral. It meant that none of his replies to me changed my opinion of him. This is pretty much the reason ive been curious of dono its a weak reason though thats why im not ok with voting her like the rest. I get that she scum read lucian but seems more like she was afraid to unvote because people would question her. Normally when u continue to see someone posting neutral stuff after u scum read them u would question if ur right,because if someone stops posting scummy stuff u dont continue to scum read them. Like people see me as scummy because im constantly posting stuff that gives off a bell ring, but when people think im starting to show neutral or town like aspects they say it or back off. She just left her vote there regardless if her read was wrong or if lucian would have defended himself because she was under the assumption nothinng he posted made him less scummy but was just neutral. it took me so long to find this post lol i should have quoted it before hand |
|
grrr said: @grapefruit, give me anything so i can change my vote to shinichi. At least a tiny mini soft claim. Even a fake one will do. :( |
|
aa-dono said: Jackrito said: I'm almost always not able to join phase change time. With exceptions of games hosted by shad. It's not rare that I left my vote and then gone.I'm semi townreading you after outr eariler talk, but it annoys me how you leave a vote on someone you don't really sucm read I know timezones are a issue but it can create issues late on and give scum easy way to frame you and get a lynch they want. Why is that an issue here? It's not like the vote was random. Not a issue more just a pet hate. Out of your control I know though |
 |
logic340 said: It was referring to nothing in this game. Something about the way Grape posted gives me townvibes. However, I've seen CP doing the same appeal as scum and it works because it's not easy to fake frustrations. Which is why I noted it down, in case Grape was doing that as well. But yeah, just because one player does it well, doesn't mean I'll hold everyone the same way. It was just a note for myself to not give Grape free passes since I tend to do that when I townread people.@aa-dono #194 in your catch up post you talk about CP being emotional but that was a post where Grape was talking to Shinichi about grrr can you Clairify which CP post you were referring to? |
|
Shinichi-Kun said: I don't really see what's so wrong about that :/aa-dono said: I don't trust his tone. It's that weak of a reason that's why I don't pursue it compared to Lucian. I did scumread Lucian. I tried to understand their thought process, but what I get from the subsequent replies were neutral. It doesn't mean my view of him turned neutral. It meant that none of his replies to me changed my opinion of him. This is pretty much the reason ive been curious of dono its a weak reason though thats why im not ok with voting her like the rest. I get that she scum read lucian but seems more like she was afraid to unvote because people would question her. Normally when u continue to see someone posting neutral stuff after u scum read them u would question if ur right,because if someone stops posting scummy stuff u dont continue to scum read them. Like people see me as scummy because im constantly posting stuff that gives off a bell ring, but when people think im starting to show neutral or town like aspects they say it or back off. She just left her vote there regardless if her read was wrong or if lucian would have defended himself because she was under the assumption nothinng he posted made him less scummy but was just neutral. it took me so long to find this post lol i should have quoted it before hand |
|
Grapefruit21 said: ?? About what?@logic340 @aa-dono I asked about that and never followed up because I got distracted by the inheritor/nurse thing. I don't think Rosie is scum, but if there is no movement I will vote her to tie it with 20 minutes left. |
|
aa-dono said: Shinichi-Kun said: I don't really see what's so wrong about that :/This is pretty much the reason ive been curious of dono its a weak reason though thats why im not ok with voting her like the rest. I get that she scum read lucian but seems more like she was afraid to unvote because people would question her. Normally when u continue to see someone posting neutral stuff after u scum read them u would question if ur right,because if someone stops posting scummy stuff u dont continue to scum read them. Like people see me as scummy because im constantly posting stuff that gives off a bell ring, but when people think im starting to show neutral or town like aspects they say it or back off. She just left her vote there regardless if her read was wrong or if lucian would have defended himself because she was under the assumption nothinng he posted made him less scummy but was just neutral. it took me so long to find this post lol i should have quoted it before hand cause normally when someone continues to post neutral alignment stuff u should back off and rethink your vote. Since it gives a small chance he could be either alignment. Atleast thats how i see it |
|
Shinichi-Kun said: My phone died. Wait one year before I even consider buying new one haha. I'll use it until it's ready for burial.aa-dono said: Here. Just woke up. I don't think I'm going to backread a lot, just gonna skim and digest what I could. But here anyway. u would have had like 4 hours lol my calls woke u up tbf |
|
Shinichi-Kun said: aa-dono said: I don't trust his tone. It's that weak of a reason that's why I don't pursue it compared to Lucian. I did scumread Lucian. I tried to understand their thought process, but what I get from the subsequent replies were neutral. It doesn't mean my view of him turned neutral. It meant that none of his replies to me changed my opinion of him. This is pretty much the reason ive been curious of dono its a weak reason though thats why im not ok with voting her like the rest. I get that she scum read lucian but seems more like she was afraid to unvote because people would question her. Normally when u continue to see someone posting neutral stuff after u scum read them u would question if ur right,because if someone stops posting scummy stuff u dont continue to scum read them. Like people see me as scummy because im constantly posting stuff that gives off a bell ring, but when people think im starting to show neutral or town like aspects they say it or back off. She just left her vote there regardless if her read was wrong or if lucian would have defended himself because she was under the assumption nothinng he posted made him less scummy but was just neutral. it took me so long to find this post lol i should have quoted it before hand How is this weaker than your scum read on grape? (Actually... what is even your scum read on grape?) |
|
AbuHumaid said: damn you guys really talk a lot, i'll continue backreading tomorrow just focus on the thread now and back read during the night phase. |
|
Shinichi-Kun said: It's not like I didn't re-think it.aa-dono said: I don't really see what's so wrong about that :/ cause normally when someone continues to post neutral alignment stuff u should back off and rethink your vote. Since it gives a small chance he could be either alignment. Atleast thats how i see it But if someone was scummy, and later just constantly reply in neutral manner, I see that as being careful. Anything could happen with a vote. If my vote wasn't there, Coel would probably have to work harder to get Lucy's lynched. Or maybe Ruu would be lynched. So I'm not at phase change. I think having my stance known is a lot better than unvoting since that would give you that safe place that people can't hold you accountable for any lynches at all >,> |
|
aa-dono said: This feels a little over explain. I think I get what you are saying. You get a town vibe from his #194 due to the emotional appeal but since CP is good at it you don't want to full commit to a town lean? logic340 said: It was referring to nothing in this game. Something about the way Grape posted gives me townvibes. However, I've seen CP doing the same appeal as scum and it works because it's not easy to fake frustrations. Which is why I noted it down, in case Grape was doing that as well. But yeah, just because one player does it well, doesn't mean I'll hold everyone the same way. It was just a note for myself to not give Grape free passes since I tend to do that when I townread people.@aa-dono #194 in your catch up post you talk about CP being emotional but that was a post where Grape was talking to Shinichi about grrr can you Clairify which CP post you were referring to? |
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC  |
| @AbuHumaid @Lam-B @Oyasumi_Rosie @Jackrito @Grapefruit21 @Shinichi-Kun Why aren't you voting? |
|
| Unvote Be back later, unexpectedly busy |
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal. ~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~ |
grrr said: @grapefruit, give me anything so i can change my vote to shinichi. At least a tiny mini soft claim. Even a fake one will do. If you feel that way you can do it without a claim. I'm not claiming. Anyway I'm kind of over this right now. Verifying a claim with a replacement is standard practice from what I've seen. And given when I asked there was 30 minutes till deadline I don't see a problem with it. You don't have to respect me, but I don't know why you feel the need to publicly announce that. |
logic340 said: Yeah (though now I'm wondering if appeal is the right word to use). aa-dono said: This feels a little over explain. I think I get what you are saying. You get a town vibe from his #194 due to the emotional appeal but since CP is good at it you don't want to full commit to a town lean? It was referring to nothing in this game. Something about the way Grape posted gives me townvibes. However, I've seen CP doing the same appeal as scum and it works because it's not easy to fake frustrations. Which is why I noted it down, in case Grape was doing that as well. But yeah, just because one player does it well, doesn't mean I'll hold everyone the same way. It was just a note for myself to not give Grape free passes since I tend to do that when I townread people. I still remember games when I trusted scum fully because they were so town. |
|
| Will you be back before phase change? |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Vote Count 2.9 Grapefruit21: Grrr, logic340 Karote: Coelestin Shinichi-Kun: aa-dono Oyasumi_Rosie: Karote, Qoco Those not voting AbuHumaid , Lam-B, Oyasumi_Rosie, Jackrito, Grapefruit21, Shinichi-Kun, Pentaflare @AbuHumaid replaces in for Ruu! What has already transpired Phase Day one! || Vote count 1.1 || 1.2 || 1.3 || 1.4 || 1.5 || 1.6 || 1.7 || 1.8 || 1.9 || 1.10 || 1.11 || 1.12 || 1.13 || 1.14 || 1.15 Night one Day 2 || Vote Count 2.0 || 2.1 || 2.2 || 2.3 || 2.4 || 2.5 || 2.6 || 2.7 || 2.8 || 2.9 Phase is two hours longer to account for replacements! Time until phase end |
 Where there is no imagination there is no horror. || Arthur Conan Doyle || Happy Halloween! |
Coelestin said: @AbuHumaid @Lam-B @Oyasumi_Rosie @Jackrito @Grapefruit21 @Shinichi-Kun Why aren't you voting? My main reason is I'm really at a loss if I was still nowhere on my reads I was going back to Ruu but the replacement is throwing me Ruu been replaced as scum has happened before though, but feel bad about lynching a new person. I'm leaning most towards a lynch on Shinichi, Quco and Karote atm. Grape is been scumread by some people but just not seeing it, they are signs but not enough for me to risk lynching a good player. Rosie has soft claimed a power role so not touching that, Dono changed my mind eariler today and rest are town to me or claimed roles like Grr and Lamb. If I was lynching anyone atm it would still be Ruu's slot and the 3 said before. I feel like I'm forgetting someone though. |
|
Jackrito said: The lynch on Qoco and Carrot. Is it due to inactivity?Coelestin said: @AbuHumaid @Lam-B @Oyasumi_Rosie @Jackrito @Grapefruit21 @Shinichi-Kun Why aren't you voting? My main reason is I'm really at a loss if I was still nowhere on my reads I was going back to Ruu but the replacement is throwing me Ruu been replaced as scum has happened before though, but feel bad about lynching a new person. I'm leaning most towards a lynch on Shinichi, Quco and Karote atm. Grape is been scumread by some people but just not seeing it, they are signs but not enough for me to risk lynching a good player. Rosie has soft claimed a power role so not touching that, Dono changed my mind eariler today and rest are town to me or claimed roles like Grr and Lamb. If I was lynching anyone atm it would still be Ruu's slot and the 3 said before. I feel like I'm forgetting someone though. |
|
| Vote: Karote I think he's less likely to be scum than Ruu/abu but I feel bad immediately killing the guy who replaced in. Karote has done pretty much nothing to convince me they are town and that is pretty telling on it's. |
Shinichi-Kun said: You did say over and over that grrr's town. I don't remember you giving reasons to it though.I didnt ignore it ive explained over and over my stand on grrr lol But ok. I'll see if I can find it. |
|
grrr said: Chione is the most likely to be traitor. Ok. |
 |
aa-dono said: Jackrito said: The lynch on Qoco and Carrot. Is it due to inactivity?My main reason is I'm really at a loss if I was still nowhere on my reads I was going back to Ruu but the replacement is throwing me Ruu been replaced as scum has happened before though, but feel bad about lynching a new person. I'm leaning most towards a lynch on Shinichi, Quco and Karote atm. Grape is been scumread by some people but just not seeing it, they are signs but not enough for me to risk lynching a good player. Rosie has soft claimed a power role so not touching that, Dono changed my mind eariler today and rest are town to me or claimed roles like Grr and Lamb. If I was lynching anyone atm it would still be Ruu's slot and the 3 said before. I feel like I'm forgetting someone though. Partly and when active a lack of scumhunting this can come easily from town and I know both have history there, which is making me wary of not voting them but the longer I leave them type slots the higher chance it will cost town at EOG. Both took a bit of defense to my questions as well which has threw me Karote espically I scumread though because some of his actions feel forced and he is going with flow a lot. |
|
aa-dono said: Is it due to inactivity? He's biased. |
|
aa-dono said: I don't think I would call Qoco inactive. More so Karote but that is actually just his general play style imo. Jackrito said: The lynch on Qoco and Carrot. Is it due to inactivity?My main reason is I'm really at a loss if I was still nowhere on my reads I was going back to Ruu but the replacement is throwing me Ruu been replaced as scum has happened before though, but feel bad about lynching a new person. I'm leaning most towards a lynch on Shinichi, Quco and Karote atm. Grape is been scumread by some people but just not seeing it, they are signs but not enough for me to risk lynching a good player. Rosie has soft claimed a power role so not touching that, Dono changed my mind eariler today and rest are town to me or claimed roles like Grr and Lamb. If I was lynching anyone atm it would still be Ruu's slot and the 3 said before. I feel like I'm forgetting someone though. |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
logic340 said: I don't think I would call Qoco inactive. Host poked me for inactivity. I would call myself inactive. |
|
Qoco said: logic340 said: I don't think I would call Qoco inactive. Host poked me for inactivity. I would call myself inactive. Though I already explained why that was the case, it's neither here nor there. |
|
Shinichi-Kun said: aa-dono said: I don't really see what's so wrong about that :/ cause normally when someone continues to post neutral alignment stuff u should back off and rethink your vote. Since it gives a small chance he could be either alignment. Atleast thats how i see it Just wondering why you have not called me out for trying to build a lynch on you yet, I would expect you to take offense to it a bit but every time I have mentioned I scum read you, they has been no reaction. You are just coming off as so passive right now you have not voted all day and your first vote is on the easy option. But now nothing I would expect you to move to one of your other ones. |
|
Qoco said: Ruu/Lam/Karote are what I would term true inactives. You boarder but you had work from 10-7 right?logic340 said: I don't think I would call Qoco inactive. Host poked me for inactivity. I would call myself inactive. |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Jackrito said: Coelestin said: @AbuHumaid @Lam-B @Oyasumi_Rosie @Jackrito @Grapefruit21 @Shinichi-Kun Why aren't you voting? My main reason is I'm really at a loss if I was still nowhere on my reads I was going back to Ruu but the replacement is throwing me Ruu been replaced as scum has happened before though, but feel bad about lynching a new person. I'm leaning most towards a lynch on Shinichi, Quco and Karote atm. Grape is been scumread by some people but just not seeing it, they are signs but not enough for me to risk lynching a good player. Rosie has soft claimed a power role so not touching that, Dono changed my mind eariler today and rest are town to me or claimed roles like Grr and Lamb. If I was lynching anyone atm it would still be Ruu's slot and the 3 said before. I feel like I'm forgetting someone though. Ok, I very much see why you are at this point. It's just very annoying to see so many people not voting... If you are leaning towards a lynch between these three, then go after one of them and try to pressure them, ask them questions etc. Or try to pressure someone who's maybe not quite in the lynch range there but should be questioned anyways. Pls :/ |
|
Jackrito said: you have not voted all day  |
|
logic340 said: Ruu/Lam/Karote are what I would term true inactives. You boarder but you had work from 10-7 right? I started a new job the day before yesterday, and worked 10 hours. Then yesterday I worked my regular job, from 10-7. Today I'm off. |
|
Qoco said: Congratulations I hope things go well for you. logic340 said: Ruu/Lam/Karote are what I would term true inactives. You boarder but you had work from 10-7 right? I started a new job the day before yesterday, and worked 10 hours. Then yesterday I worked my regular job, from 10-7. Today I'm off. So are you feeling scum rosie or was that a pressure vote? |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Just because I'm not voting now does not mean I have not voted at all, you don't need to vote to apply pressure as well. This is the second time you have said I did not vote today. |
|
More topics from this board
Sticky: » [Club] Member Introductions ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Bombolz - Jul 6, 2014 |
574 |
by Serafos
»»
Jan 4, 12:49 AM |
|
» [GAME] Solve the Riddle ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Zymf - Aug 6, 2015 |
975 |
by Serafos
»»
Jan 2, 9:46 PM |
|
» [GAME] Make a Mafia Alias for the User Above YouMaiTai - Dec 9, 2014 |
42 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 27, 2025 11:32 PM |
|
» [GAME] Banana Gameosieorb18 - Jan 10, 2019 |
15 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 27, 2025 11:32 PM |
|
» [GAME] Potato Game ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Shinichi-Kun - Sep 23, 2015 |
2928 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 27, 2025 11:31 PM |