SoulEaterQUEEN said: indipindy16 said: But what mafia would risk being seen as town in such a stunt? It doesn't make sense. Plus. you both have it wrong, he never mentioned my role, he just wanted a character name claim - that seems innocent imo in a closed set up. He never gave hints to what my role could be, and could have followed up with my claim with a question hinting to my role, but he has not. To me, this is why I don't seem him particularly scummy, Opps, sorry. ᕮ>人<ᕭ |
  **********Smile! ^^********* |
SoulEaterQUEEN said: magicalofmagic said: Well, I suppose a bit like you. You contribute a lot and are pretty active. I mean, I know this is kinda hypocritical, but I know that I am town so why should I prove it to myself? Well, no, you should prove it to others, otherwise if you sit there passively then you are sitting a big fat null read like a lot of players choose to do, and imo the ones who have the ability (free time, I guess?) to contribute but choose not to are being anti-town. Really? (Ȍ෴Ȍ) I hope I don't seem anti town. Oh, and I forgot to vote yesterday, didn't I? Sorry about that too, I totally forgot and I was asleep around the phase change due to by timezone ᕦ(@﹏@)ᕥ |
**********Smile! ^^********* |
SoulEaterQUEEN said: indipindy16 said: Pfft, not really anyone, 'cept myself, you and lamb, after that stunt lamb pulled by getting you to claim and whatnot. Everyone else is in a kinda neuteral zone. Meh So what kinds of things do you suppose give you scum tells, and town tells then? you seem to be a hard 1 to convince. what are your thoughts on coro? why do you think Lamb trying to get me to claim makes him town? this post. |
 |
magicalofmagic said: SoulEaterQUEEN said: Well, no, you should prove it to others, otherwise if you sit there passively then you are sitting a big fat null read like a lot of players choose to do, and imo the ones who have the ability (free time, I guess?) to contribute but choose not to are being anti-town. Really? (Ȍ෴Ȍ) I hope I don't seem anti town. Oh, and I forgot to vote yesterday, didn't I? Sorry about that too, I totally forgot and I was asleep around the phase change due to by timezone ᕦ(@﹏@)ᕥ Well you've been more on the lurker end, so yes you certainly didn't appear town to me. Now that you are here now, do you have any thoughts game related? any particular reads to make note of I suppose? any observations? |
|
| @talonbone Once you have done some backreading, can we hear your thoughts? do you still suspect Lamby? town read indi? have any other suspects you are interested in pursuing? |
|
can you like be focus, and be serious. You really aren't helping your case at the moment >.> |
|
plus for someone who complains about how everyone seems neutral, why don't you press on them yourself to get a better read on them? |
|
SoulEaterQUEEN said: magicalofmagic said: Really? (Ȍ෴Ȍ) I hope I don't seem anti town. Oh, and I forgot to vote yesterday, didn't I? Sorry about that too, I totally forgot and I was asleep around the phase change due to by timezone ᕦ(@﹏@)ᕥ Well you've been more on the lurker end, so yes you certainly didn't appear town to me. Now that you are here now, do you have any thoughts game related? any particular reads to make note of I suppose? any observations? Well, I'm kinda in the process of backreading, so I'll have some more stuff for you when I'm done. |
**********Smile! ^^********* |
(⍤ロ⍤) |
**********Smile! ^^********* |
magicalofmagic said: SoulEaterQUEEN said: Well you've been more on the lurker end, so yes you certainly didn't appear town to me. Now that you are here now, do you have any thoughts game related? any particular reads to make note of I suppose? any observations? Well, I'm kinda in the process of backreading, so I'll have some more stuff for you when I'm done. magicalofmagic said: SoulEaterQUEEN said: Well you've been more on the lurker end, so yes you certainly didn't appear town to me. Now that you are here now, do you have any thoughts game related? any particular reads to make note of I suppose? any observations? Well, I'm kinda in the process of backreading, so I'll have some more stuff for you when I'm done. I guess I have no choice but to wait. I'm keeping my vote on you for the time being though until you start making contributions. |
|
indipindy16 said: oh yay questions to answer First off, a scum tell is doing something anti-town. For example, trying to lynch an inactive. looking at you, ghost of zurel and a town tell is, like, nothing. I can never tell townies unless I'm mafia, when I already know and there's only either town or 3rd party ^^; Second,I'm pretty sure coro's contributing more than usual, but he might just really like this game... Last, I think a scum wouldn't risk getting the attention being put on them, because peopel would find them suspicious for character-fishing, since a lot of the time a character's personality can tell you what role they might have in a game. Wow, I don't think I've written so much since, like, my very first game lol the way coro is contributing, do you have further comment on this? you don't have any town tells based on the voting pattern? Well for character-fishing can give good fake claims for scum to use, but the way Lamby approached it was different as I've already noted. |
|
indipindy16 said: SoulEaterQUEEN said: plus for someone who complains about how everyone seems neutral, why don't you press on them yourself to get a better read on them? man i've been so utterly roasted maaan you vote for DenjaX, why did you find him "weird"? What do you think of the read Jack had on him versus your read in comparison? 1130 edit: including the post link. |
|
indipindy16 said: oh yay questions to answer First off, a scum tell is doing something anti-town. For example, trying to lynch an inactive. looking at you, ghost of zurel and a town tell is, like, nothing. I can never tell townies unless I'm mafia, when I already know and there's only either town or 3rd party ^^; Second,I'm pretty sure coro's contributing more than usual, but he might just really like this game... Last, I think a scum wouldn't risk getting the attention being put on them, because peopel would find them suspicious for character-fishing, since a lot of the time a character's personality can tell you what role they might have in a game. Wow, I don't think I've written so much since, like, my very first game lol Strange how you say that on Coro I was questioning thier level of activity a bit before this phase. On your last point a good scum player will want the attention on them, if it is postive that is how you get the town reads that will save you. |
|
| Alright minna-san~ I have some deductions about the set-up of this game~ I believe each idol roles are 1 from each series. I do not think there will be 2 roles that come from the same series. This info will help reduce the baddies to safe claim. They have to get some obscure idol role to reduce the risk of counterclaim~ I think indi is scum but I am starting to think that she is a third party than mafia. So I dont mind having her lynched today. I am still hoping for SK to keep killing mafias~ I want to examine more about magical and talonbone. I have suspicions that they are smelly oji-sans xDD shad and Claire should be good. I like this refreshing feeling of Claire trusting me <3 Vote: magical ojisan |
indipindy16 said: SoulEaterQUEEN said: plus for someone who complains about how everyone seems neutral, why don't you press on them yourself to get a better read on them? man i've been so utterly roasted maaan utterly roasted, what do you mean? |
|
DenjaX said: Alright minna-san~ I have some deductions about the set-up of this game~ I believe each idol roles are 1 from each series. I do not think there will be 2 roles that come from the same series. This info will help reduce the baddies to safe claim. They have to get some obscure idol role to reduce the risk of counterclaim~ I think indi is scum but I am starting to think that she is a third party than mafia. So I dont mind having her lynched today. I am still hoping for SK to keep killing mafias~ I want to examine more about magical and talonbone. I have suspicions that they are smelly oji-sans xDD shad and Claire should be good. I like this refreshing feeling of Claire trusting me <3 Vote: magical ojisan This is the kind of play I wanted to see from you >.> better late than never I suppose lol |
|
Jackrito said: indipindy16 said: oh yay questions to answer First off, a scum tell is doing something anti-town. For example, trying to lynch an inactive. looking at you, ghost of zurel and a town tell is, like, nothing. I can never tell townies unless I'm mafia, when I already know and there's only either town or 3rd party ^^; Second,I'm pretty sure coro's contributing more than usual, but he might just really like this game... Last, I think a scum wouldn't risk getting the attention being put on them, because peopel would find them suspicious for character-fishing, since a lot of the time a character's personality can tell you what role they might have in a game. Wow, I don't think I've written so much since, like, my very first game lol Strange how you say that on Coro I was questioning thier level of activity a bit before this phase. On your last point a good scum player will want the attention on them, if it is postive that is how you get the town reads that will save you. I think a balance of attention is good especially in a bigger game when it takes longer to reach the killing wincon. If you make a mistake, paranoia town at end game will eat you alive somehow. |
|
Jackrito said: indipindy16 said: oh yay questions to answer First off, a scum tell is doing something anti-town. For example, trying to lynch an inactive. looking at you, ghost of zurel and a town tell is, like, nothing. I can never tell townies unless I'm mafia, when I already know and there's only either town or 3rd party ^^; Second,I'm pretty sure coro's contributing more than usual, but he might just really like this game... Last, I think a scum wouldn't risk getting the attention being put on them, because peopel would find them suspicious for character-fishing, since a lot of the time a character's personality can tell you what role they might have in a game. Wow, I don't think I've written so much since, like, my very first game lol Strange how you say that on Coro I was questioning thier level of activity a bit before this phase. On your last point a good scum player will want the attention on them, if it is postive that is how you get the town reads that will save you. Do you think a level of activity on a player is a scum-tell/town-read, Jack? |
|
| [quote=SoulEaterQUEEN message=45791573] Jackrito said: indipindy16 said: oh yay questions to answer First off, a scum tell is doing something anti-town. For example, trying to lynch an inactive. looking at you, ghost of zurel and a town tell is, like, nothing. I can never tell townies unless I'm mafia, when I already know and there's only either town or 3rd party ^^; Second,I'm pretty sure coro's contributing more than usual, but he might just really like this game... Last, I think a scum wouldn't risk getting the attention being put on them, because peopel would find them suspicious for character-fishing, since a lot of the time a character's personality can tell you what role they might have in a game. Wow, I don't think I've written so much since, like, my very first game lol Strange how you say that on Coro I was questioning thier level of activity a bit before this phase. On your last point a good scum player will want the attention on them, if it is postive that is how you get the town reads that will save you. Do you think a level of activity on a player is a scum-tell/town-read, Jack?[/quot SoulEaterQUEEN said: Jackrito said: Strange how you say that on Coro I was questioning thier level of activity a bit before this phase. On your last point a good scum player will want the attention on them, if it is postive that is how you get the town reads that will save you. Do you think a level of activity on a player is a scum-tell/town-read, Jack? It depends on the player, but I would say what they do and say when they are active is a bigger tell. as I said in old games a mafia will be more careful about thier posts and not commit to things. This is because they know who is not mafia so need to be careful not to let this info show so are more careful.That is why a mafia read list is easy to see because they will support people with little reason or bad reasons. A town does not have these worries so can post more freely,As long as you have confidence in yourself to prove your role when asked. |
|
| [quote=Jackrito message=45791676] SoulEaterQUEEN said: Jackrito said: Strange how you say that on Coro I was questioning thier level of activity a bit before this phase. On your last point a good scum player will want the attention on them, if it is postive that is how you get the town reads that will save you. Do you think a level of activity on a player is a scum-tell/town-read, Jack?[/quot It depends on the player, but I would say what they do and say when they are active is a bigger tell. as I said in old games a mafia will be more careful about thier posts and not commit to things. This is because they know who is not mafia so need to be careful not to let this info show so are more careful.That is why a mafia read list is easy to see because they will support people with little reason or bad reasons. A town does not have these worries so can post more freely,As long as you have confidence in yourself to prove your role when asked. Read lists are manipulative to town because some players who are read as town, will usually have a good backing on it, and this gives a false sense of confidence to the player. The player may want to trust that person since it means they are not prepared to backstab you in the game - the ones who really look into a night kill analysis approach, I suppose. Also read lists from mafia, can be a good way to frame another player since some people assume they will work hard at giving town credit to their fellow scumbuddies which I disagree with completely. I agree with your first statement though, and I think because of that ones who prepare quite big contribution to when they are called out, or questioned about it feels pretty forced at times. Though at other times, it can be coincidental based on when they are active as well. |
|
DenjaX said: SoulEaterQUEEN said: Hmmm another idolm@ster role? Suspicious~Yes I claim her. What of it then? There is already a town flip idolm@ster role. I'll keep an eye of you~ Teehee Sure. |
|
| anyway need to get ready to go into the lab. I'll do my best to be back on here like 1.5 hour before phase change but I will be in the lab during it. |
|
SoulEaterQUEEN said: If my suspicion is true then you could be a smelly ojisan and that makes Lamby one as well. Sure. I need all the idols out there to confirm with me that my set-up deduction is correct because I have yet to see an idol flip that are from the same series~ Myself included xDD Them oji-sans can cosplay real idols as much as they want but their hairy legs and their beer bellies will still be apparent~ They can't be as adorable as we do~ ☆ I suggest we should not focus on this for now and focus more on scum hunting. It is just an info that may be useful when someone attempts to fake claim~ ☆ |
DenjaX said: SoulEaterQUEEN said: If my suspicion is true then you could be a smelly ojisan and that makes Lamby one as well. Sure. I need all the idols out there to confirm with me that my set-up deduction is correct because I have yet to see an idol flip that are from the same series~ Myself included xDD Them oji-sans can cosplay real idols as much as they want but their hairy legs and their beer bellies will still be apparent~ They can't be as adorable as we do~ ☆ I suggest we should not focus on this for now and focus more on scum hunting. It is just an info that may be useful when someone attempts to fake claim~ ☆ I'm fairly sure that they will be some repeat shows in this they are not that many idol shows to begin with anyway. Idolmaster is one of the more popular ones, so it makes sense that it would have multiple characters. |
|
Jackrito said: Yes there are not a lot of idol shows but there are other shows that has an idol character such as Yusa and 5pb. They come from a different genre but their role there were idols that is why my deduction can still hold true.I'm fairly sure that they will be some repeat shows in this they are not that many idol shows to begin with anyway. Idolmaster is one of the more popilar ones, so it makes sense that it would have multiple characters. I suspect that the mafias are filled with smelly oji-sans and the TPR might be filled with idols too as evidenced by grrrr flip role. Again Date a Live isnt an idol anime xD I am thinking which idol would fit the SK role. might be some yandere idol I suppose xDD I dont want them to dominate the idol industry~ Nyoron~ |
indipindy16 said: Pfft, not really anyone, 'cept myself, you and lamb, after that stunt lamb pulled by getting you to claim and whatnot. Everyone else is in a kinda neuteral zone. Meh And who are you scum-reading? (don't just say Denja, give me more names, pls. And reasons. >.>) SoulEaterQUEEN said: SalazarSlytherin said: Did you not notice how strange these two have been acting lately? And I'm not even being pushy so they are lynched, I just want them to act more seriously. I'm now getting Jester vibes from Indy especially. Just re-read the last few pages and you'll see what I mean - her behavior has changed. She has been extremely uncooperative lately, it's unlike her. I don't remember very many times she has been cooperative unless it was forced, if you want my opinion. edit: bbcode error. I have - in the Digimon game, for example. Even in this game, she was more cooperative at the beginning. But it has changed. |
indipindy16 said: Being an idol is a serious business. My cutesy act is the persona that I have used. After all, as idols, we have to deliver the best performance to our fans who supported us~ We have to cater on the ideal views they imposed on us and use our songs and dances to reach their hearts~ ♡♡♡I'll ask you now. Why are you putting all the hearts and stars and fluffiness in your posts? Iyaa~ that speech was embarassing~ >\\\\< |
DenjaX said: Alright minna-san~ I have some deductions about the set-up of this game~ I believe each idol roles are 1 from each series. I do not think there will be 2 roles that come from the same series. This info will help reduce the baddies to safe claim. They have to get some obscure idol role to reduce the risk of counterclaim~ I think indi is scum but I am starting to think that she is a third party than mafia. So I dont mind having her lynched today. I am still hoping for SK to keep killing mafias~ I want to examine more about magical and talonbone. I have suspicions that they are smelly oji-sans xDD shad and Claire should be good. I like this refreshing feeling of Claire trusting me <3 Vote: magical ojisan I agree about Talonbone, mainly because of his vote for Lamby. The way he voted seemed kind of opportunistic, like he just joined the train because Lamby had the most votes. Magic is also fishy because from what she's said so far I can't read her properly. She seems to post just enough to be considered active, but doesn't share her opinion on other players. And plays the newbie "I don't know what's going on" card. Add to that how she flinched and unvoted after someone called her out. Let's say your theory about 2 characters per series being in the game is correct, how will that help us figure out who's bad? |
| Vote Change: Magicalofmagic I want to see what she does when she's under pressure. @Magicalofmagic: Tell me who you think is bad, and why. I'm also curious why you haven't voted for anyone today. |
indipindy16 said: SalazarSlytherin said: And who are you scum-reading? (don't just say Denja, give me more names, pls. And reasons. >.>) Asking for reasons too? Man, this is hard. I simply can't do it. I know you can. ^^ I'm really wondering why you're so indecisive today, mind telling me that too? |
SalazarSlytherin said: Vote Change: Magicalofmagic I want to see what she does when she's under pressure. @Magicalofmagic: Tell me who you think is bad, and why. I'm also curious why you haven't voted for anyone today. Oh I forgot to vote today too... uh, I'm not sure, but Vote: Lamby since I've already given why I think their scummy... |
**********Smile! ^^********* |
Vote Count 3.3 Lambtron [ Ascius, talonbone, magicalofmagic ] DenjaX [ indipindy16 ] indipindy16 [ Jackrito, _Claire_, Lambtron ] SalazarSlytherin [ Shinichi-kun ] magicalofmagic [ SoulEaterQUEEN, DenjaX, SalazarSlytherin ] Not Voting [ aa-dono, shadroxx2810 ] Mod Notes: nya nya i am a neko desu |
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal. ~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~ |
| A triple tie really we are doing this again. I'm still confident on my vote but I will have to change later on if things stay this way. These current votes will tell us a lot at a later date though because it is clear that some people are voting for no real good reason and just because they see it as a easy lynch or to save a scum buddy . I also like the way that indi is not commiting to any of these trains keeping her vote on Denja it appears they don't want to change because it may give some info in my view. If I was going to take a guess, I would say that the lamb train is where the mafia are currently lying since that is the one with the innoconet child so they think following that is the best way to get a town read. I also disagree with the reasosn been used on lamb so far. I would also say that dono is likely a scum of some sort based off thier voting so far and general contribution. |
|
| change vote:magical not allowing a tie and I don't supect the other 2 |
  |
Jackrito said: A triple tie really we are doing this again. I'm still confident on my vote but I will have to change later on if things stay this way. These current votes will tell us a lot at a later date though because it is clear that some people are voting for no real good reason and just because they see it as a easy lynch or to save a scum buddy . I also like the way that indi is not commiting to any of these trains keeping her vote on Denja it appears they don't want to change because it may give some info in my view. If I was going to take a guess, I would say that the lamb train is where the mafia are currently lying since that is the one with the innoconet child so they think following that is the best way to get a town read. I also disagree with the reasosn been used on lamb so far. I would also say that dono is likely a scum of some sort based off thier voting so far and general contribution. Totally forgot there was an innocent Child lol |
|
| Vote Change: Indipindy Hmm.. I suspect both Indi and magical. But I don't trust Shinichi one bit, so I'm going back to Indi. :> |
SalazarSlytherin said: Vote Change: Indipindy Hmm.. I suspect both Indi and magical. But I don't trust Shinichi one bit, so I'm going back to Indi. :> </3 |
|
Jackrito said: A triple tie really we are doing this again. I'm still confident on my vote but I will have to change later on if things stay this way. These current votes will tell us a lot at a later date though because it is clear that some people are voting for no real good reason and just because they see it as a easy lynch or to save a scum buddy . I also like the way that indi is not commiting to any of these trains keeping her vote on Denja it appears they don't want to change because it may give some info in my view. If I was going to take a guess, I would say that the lamb train is where the mafia are currently lying since that is the one with the innoconet child so they think following that is the best way to get a town read. I also disagree with the reasosn been used on lamb so far. I would also say that dono is likely a scum of some sort based off thier voting so far and general contribution. If you are very certain, Jack, I will change my vote to lynch indi. But, I want to see how magic responds to pressure, like coro has already mentioned, plus his vote on Lamby really urks me - almost like he was pressured into voting when coro asked, and put no thought into it. |
|
SalazarSlytherin said: Vote Change: Indipindy Hmm.. I suspect both Indi and magical. But I don't trust Shinichi one bit, so I'm going back to Indi. :> Any reason you want to share? |
|
Shinichi-Kun said: change vote:magical not allowing a tie and I don't supect the other 2 can you retell me the reason why you don't suspect indi/Lamb again? p.s. why am I playing this game at work >_< my prof is going to fry me alive he catches me lol |
|
magicalofmagic said: SalazarSlytherin said: Vote Change: Magicalofmagic I want to see what she does when she's under pressure. @Magicalofmagic: Tell me who you think is bad, and why. I'm also curious why you haven't voted for anyone today. Oh I forgot to vote today too... uh, I'm not sure, but Vote: Lamby since I've already given why I think their scummy... you know this contributed into a tie, right? is indi in the clear for you? |
|
magicalofmagic said: SalazarSlytherin said: Vote Change: Magicalofmagic I want to see what she does when she's under pressure. @Magicalofmagic: Tell me who you think is bad, and why. I'm also curious why you haven't voted for anyone today. Oh I forgot to vote today too... uh, I'm not sure, but Vote: Lamby since I've already given why I think their scummy... how's that backreading going for you? I have yet to see more thoughts from you yet. |
|
More topics from this board
» Chat Thread ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Fo - Jul 10, 2014 |
3745 |
by Mishukax
»»
Oct 21, 11:34 AM |
|
» Count To 7777 V3 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Lambtron - May 15, 2018 |
1163 |
by Kit
»»
Oct 17, 6:57 AM |
|
» [GAME] Last Letter Game ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )grave_robber - Sep 9, 2014 |
8752 |
by Aswin_Ash
»»
Jan 23, 11:52 AM |
|
» [GAME] (*￣･￣)ﾉ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated Staff Member Posts! v4 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Togs - Jul 2, 2017 |
2870 |
by Jackrito
»»
Jan 8, 11:22 AM |
|
» [GAME] (*￣･￣)ﾉ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated MEMBER Posts! v1 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )SoulEaterQUEEN - Mar 26, 2016 |
1990 |
by Serafos
»»
Aug 17, 2024 9:42 PM |