What makes the anime worse than the manga?

Dec 22, 2023 3:56 PM

Offline

Jun 2009

1077

I've only read the manga up to chapter 10 back in the day, forgot about until I realize there's an anime airing.

Opinions seem very divided on this show but manga readers still like the manga.

So what makes the manga better than the anime? What is the anime doing wrong?

Dec 22, 2023 4:06 PM

FutoiOtaku

Offline

Nov 2023

933

To be fair, it’s a pretty decent anime overall, the hate is all coming from a user called Johan starting repeated threads trashing the show as well as hijacking any positive threads to insult anyone who likes it. It’s a one man(?) campaign. Ignore him and it’s gone down fairly well.

Dec 22, 2023 4:08 PM

Pablo_Neruda1

Offline

Dec 2022

751

to be very honest, i liked the anime. What made the anime to decline is how the plot deviated and the unnecessary elements. The hate on the MC Adonis and how Doroka was always a pacifist is a factor too. We got a peek at how the world despised witches and therefore it should strictly be fantasy in medieval times but we started seeing technology on a whole new level. It felt odd because that made no sense. Even more than that, we started seeing different countries with different cultures like the country with samurais. We got introduced to the dystopian element and we started seeing cyborgs and advanced machineries and weapons. Bruh, what's the idea? how do all this correlate with what the anime was meant to be.

and then there's Adonis. personally, I like him but others despise him because he supposedly acts like a child and is hellbent on wiping out the humans because of what happened to Chloe. He finally got the chance to revive Chloe but turns out his resolve was half-assed and he decided to revive Doroka. What was the point of all the humans you killed if you didn't even revive Chloe? he still insists that the humans are evil but anytime Doroka opens his heart to the feeling of happiness, he shuts it away because he is convinced that his revenge is his sole reason for living.

well, that's that

Dec 22, 2023 4:11 PM

Aragane

Offline

Oct 2019

I'm not a manga reader, but after finishing the adaptation I don't think I will read it.

While it's true that the animation studio doesn't have the best track record, it stems more from the source material that they were given is not the best in the field. I would assume the same to be true for the manga of this show.

Note that I'm blaming the source material more doesn't mean that the animation was good.

Dec 22, 2023 4:41 PM

InNeedOfAName

Offline

Jan 2023

257

I've heard that this is actually a sequel to another manga called "The Kingdom of Culibrun" aka "Tsurugi no Oukoku" so that might factor into the plot.

Dec 22, 2023 4:44 PM

Flacion

Offline

Jan 2023

haven't read the manga, but I am thinking about doing it. So can only answer what they did wrong.

For me what they did wrong, was the arc on the moon. It didn't have time or power enough to build op to that blood bath that happened at the end of the arc. Just some more dialogue, a flashback, some exploration of the place, just something, since it seemed kinda rushed storywise.

I really liked the start and after the moon arc. Because the start had a very powerful beginning, really setting the scene and after the moon arc, were there time to build the characters and understand the world. These things just made the fights seem more important and more justified.

Dec 22, 2023 4:46 PM

Bear_from_cave

Offline

Dec 2019

Manga "just" have horrible character writing and awful plot, anime has all that and shitty animation, making it worse than manga which at least has a good art.
Also LOL at people who think this isn't widely disliked, everywhere I've seen where people discuss anime it's either almost unanimously criticized, or there are like five people still remaining to discuss it in its threads.

Dec 22, 2023 5:15 PM

FutoiOtaku

Offline

Nov 2023

933

Bear_from_cave said:
Manga "just" have horrible character writing and awful plot, anime has all that and shitty animation, making it worse than manga which at least has a good art.
Also LOL at people who think this isn't widely disliked, everywhere I've seen where people discuss anime it's either almost unanimously criticized, or there are like five people still remaining to discuss it in its threads.

All this expert judgement from someone who watched 1 episode. You’re just passing on second hand trash talk, why bother?

Dec 22, 2023 7:12 PM

Bear_from_cave

Offline

Dec 2019

Reply to FutoiOtaku

All this expert judgement from someone who watched 1 episode. You’re just passing on second hand trash talk, why bother?

I've read the source manga, and episode threads make it clear that anime was a faithful adaptation.

Dec 23, 2023 6:14 AM

#10

SonoAltoComeLevi

Offline

Nov 2022

FutoiOtaku said:
To be fair, it’s a pretty decent anime overall, the hate is all coming from a user called Johan starting repeated threads trashing the show as well as hijacking any positive threads to insult anyone who likes it. It’s a one man(?) campaign. Ignore him and it’s gone down fairly well.

Omg, are you saying that the hate came from a guy called Johan? Shit, this could be the biggest reference to Monster that I ever seen. He just acted like in the show creating hate from something just for watching the declind of the community from the top.

Dec 23, 2023 7:39 AM

#11

anikun2k10

Offline

Mar 2017

Reply to InNeedOfAName

I've heard that this is actually a sequel to another manga called "The Kingdom of Culibrun" aka "Tsurugi no Oukoku" so that might factor into the plot.

@InNeedOfAName from what i have seen of the caliburn story, its not needed unless you wanna know the backstory of the queen

Dec 25, 2023 6:33 AM

#12

koneroko

Offline

Sep 2019

119

The majority of people don't like this anime at all. Just look at the metrics and it shows.

C6R5 Raiden

Jan 31, 12:45 PM

#13

ScrewFiction

Offline

Jun 2009

302

Reply to InNeedOfAName

I've heard that this is actually a sequel to another manga called "The Kingdom of Culibrun" aka "Tsurugi no Oukoku" so that might factor into the plot.

@InNeedOfAName Where did you get this info from? I can't even find it on MAL

Jan 31, 1:01 PM

#14

mechian

Offline

Jun 2009

1077

Reply to ScrewFiction

@InNeedOfAName Where did you get this info from? I can't even find it on MAL

@ScrewFiction Yea cause it's some kind of low grade webtoon. Don't think MAL lists webtoons.

https://mangakakalot.com/read-ugvdy18982v1695926405

Jan 31, 1:15 PM

#15

ScrewFiction

Offline

Jun 2009

302

Reply to mechian

@ScrewFiction Yea cause it's some kind of low grade webtoon. Don't think MAL lists webtoons.

https://mangakakalot.com/read-ugvdy18982v1695926405

@mechian They do list a lot of webtoons so I don't see why not

but well that explains the ensembleverse and why the queen and Doroka are looking identical and why there's a red-haired Adonis

edit there are 175 chapters to Calibrun, and all but 8 are lost?! wtf...

ScrewFictionJan 31, 2:16 PM

See All Discussions

Poll: » Hametsu no Oukoku Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 ) Stark700 - Dec 22, 2023	100	by RyuuJiuS »» Nov 17, 5:44 AM
Poll: » Hametsu no Oukoku Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 ) Stark700 - Oct 27, 2023	114	by dboodagh »» Nov 3, 3:17 PM
Poll: » Hametsu no Oukoku Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 ) Stark700 - Dec 15, 2023	76	by Vandesdelca »» Oct 26, 2:52 AM
» So the "love spell" SPOILERS Dustin1280 - Jul 12	20	by Dustin1280 »» Sep 24, 6:34 AM
Poll: » Hametsu no Oukoku Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 ) Stark700 - Oct 20, 2023	105	by ShadowRonin47 »» Aug 14, 3:57 PM

What makes the anime worse than the manga?

More topics from this board

Poll: » Hametsu no Oukoku Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

Poll: » Hametsu no Oukoku Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

Poll: » Hametsu no Oukoku Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 )

» So the "love spell" SPOILERS

Poll: » Hametsu no Oukoku Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters

What makes the anime worse than the manga?

More topics from this board

Poll: » Hametsu no Oukoku Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

Poll: » Hametsu no Oukoku Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

Poll: » Hametsu no Oukoku Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 )

» So the "love spell" **SPOILERS**

Poll: » Hametsu no Oukoku Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters

» So the "love spell" SPOILERS