| Wow, I didn't expect a veteran. And about yesterday's random lynch, good job getting the executioner. Honestly. Karote said: I'm not sure if you care who dies but I will say my role since you leave me no choice ; I am Investigator. Let me check Crowlage if you let me live. Of course now I'm mafia/sk target so doc/jailor , save me please? (If I get off from lynching of course.) Investigator Karote, report please. |
| "Good-o morning-u ebberi-wan, haba nice day!" - Kud |
| I did say i would put in some surprises vet is one of my fav roles. Also MAL is far too busy tonight just turned into a big mess |
 |
| phantom doesnt even get to post lol - sorry just gotta butt in :p |
“They stood together in a false intimacy, a nervous contact. And he was in love with her.” ― D.H. Lawrence, Women in Love |
Haine15 said: PTYamin said: Investigator Karote, report please. ^Yes please T_T I checked Hagarn last night , I won't say his role but he is for town. (or should I say his role?) |
 |
| So, if I'm not mistaken, the roleblocker was mafia aligned? In some versions it could be town aligned. |
| "If you look for a ghost, you'll find one." |
| right i will clear this up my bad the rb was town |
|
| Damn! That's two of us in one night! I never liked the veteran role; it was always more of hinderance rather than a benefit. It's a role more dangerous for the town rather than Mafia. But, If it is town aligned, then there's nothing we can do about it other than avoid him/ her. Town power roles be wary. |
| "If you look for a ghost, you'll find one." |
| I survived the night! Im a survivor, Im gonna make it. Im a survivor, keep on surviving! :3 Some of you guys are bad. How could you kill someone you meanies >:3 |
 |
| What's the survivor? Im just happy I survived :/ |
|
| Nevermind, the survivor is a third party role in which the goal is to literally survive for X amount of time, or until X amount of people cease to live. |
| "If you look for a ghost, you'll find one." |
| Is MAL lagging for anyone else? PTYamin said: What makes you say it was random? Mafia wouldn't know he was third party, assumed he was town and jumped on the wagon right away.And about yesterday's random lynch, good job getting the executioner. Honestly. |
Karote said: I checked Hagarn last night , I won't say his role but he is for town. (or should I say his role?) You mean Hagarn had no crimes? He still may or may not be town-sided. |
| "Good-o morning-u ebberi-wan, haba nice day!" - Kud |
Fo-Fai said: What makes you say it was random? Mafia wouldn't know he was third party, assumed he was town and jumped on the wagon right away. It looked pretty random.. |
| "Good-o morning-u ebberi-wan, haba nice day!" - Kud |
PTYamin said: It might have looked random at a glance but going back now you can plainly tell Crowlage was fishy as heck. Thus why I voted for him. Fo-Fai said: What makes you say it was random? Mafia wouldn't know he was third party, assumed he was town and jumped on the wagon right away. It looked pretty random.. You need to think hard about what goes on behind the scenes. Anyway, pointless talk is pointless. I wanna see karotes informant report. I don't fully trust him though, that's an easy role to fake claim. |
PTYamin said: Karote said: I checked Hagarn last night , I won't say his role but he is for town. (or should I say his role?) You mean Hagarn had no crimes? He still may or may not be town-sided. No , I Investigated* him. Sorry. xD I know his role , so trust me on that. |
|
| Anyone has any suspicious on certain person? I can find out his/her role. If not , Then I will just choose someone who doesn't speak much. |
|
| Anyway, I'm gonna vote PTYamin again. His.. "Let's never lynch anyone and lose on purpose" strategy still erks the shit outta me. If he happens to be town, so be it. I know what that will look like but town has a much higher chance of winning without him regardless. I await his strawman defense. Also, Karote, why the hell did you just out somebodies alignment unprovoked? :/ |
Fo-Fai said: Also, Karote, why the hell did you just out somebodies alignment unprovoked? :/ What do you mean? My English skills can't keep up. xD edit: Oh , I know what you mean. |
|
Karote said: Obviously not. I looked back and I guess PTY asked for your "informant report" probably just another bad play on his part not understanding what your role even does. Crap. Fo-Fai said: Also, Karote, why the hell did you just out somebodies alignment unprovoked? :/ What do you mean? My English skills can't keep up. xD edit: Oh , I know what you mean. It's too late now but next time wait. That doesn't make you look too good to be honest. You weren't under any serious suspicion yesterday. The way you claimed seemed kinda forced as well. Who asked you to claim in the first place? Hagarn, give me reasons for those players you suspect if you don't mind please.. |
| Wasn't it enough that I told Hagarn was for town? I don't want to reveal roles but if it's because you suspect me because I didn't tell Hagarn role then I don't know what to say. I will only tell roles when I find mafia/sk. |
|
| I will explain this as host a vet can go alert a certain amount of times in the game. who ever visits the vet at night when they are alert dies no matter if they are town or mafia so it can either make or break the town |
|
Fo-Fai said: Obviously not. I looked back and I guess PTY asked for your "informant report" probably just another bad play on his part not understanding what your role even does. Crap. It's too late now but next time wait. That doesn't make you look too good to be honest. You weren't under any serious suspicion yesterday. The way you claimed seemed kinda forced as well. Who asked you to claim in the first place? Hagarn, give me reasons for those players you suspect if you don't mind please.. I was under pressure yesterday , Last few minutes you said you would kill anyone who ties votes so I can be lynched and then I wanted to tell my role , Hoping that would convince you and I'm sure few people did suspect me. Crowlage happened to look more suspicious than me. Fair enough. I know you are still suspicious of me and I don't mind that. ----------- Vote lynch : PTYamin |
|
| Well i am going to bed so have fun guys |
|
Hagarn said: Maybe PTYamin still new to this game and want to play careful.. But so far he hasn't helped or shared his opinions. Only comments on random things , Could also be trying to fit there but you never know. I want to hear what he says. |
|
Hagarn said: Haine15 said: I also suspect PTYamin for always protecting and keeping tie that doesn't make sense sense . Mm, if he were in mafia, he won't do something like that, he obviously want someone to lynch.. beside we know now that Crowlage or Karote is not mafia, he should have jump to banwagon to vote.. That's why he votes with town to avoid suspections on him but that's what I would do if I were mafia. |
|
Karote said: Pressure=/=Suspicion I was under pressure yesterday , Last few minutes you said you would kill anyone who ties votes so I can be lynched and then I wanted to tell my role , Hoping that would convince you and I'm sure few people did suspect me. Crowlage happened to look more suspicious than me. Fair enough. I know you are still suspicious of me and I don't mind that. ----------- Vote lynch : PTYamin It's never really a good idea to claim unless somebody asks you. Truth be told I was never gonna let you get lynched yesterday. Lynching inactive players gives us literally no information. I'm really happy you showed up to defend yourself yesterday and considering we had like an hour left and pretty much nailed crowlage on his slips and eventually ended up lynching him should attest to that. You can call it luck, I just call it instinct. On the other hand though, that was a pretty shallow defense, I suppose there's not much to defend against but given the high amount of attention you've garnered and the lack of proper claiming eticate you've shown, I'll chalk that up to a miss play and not a scum slip, for now. Would you like to add anything on why you voted Yamin, or is it basically a sheep vote? |
Hagarn said: I suspect this player: Smurphinator Shadowsnake777 Ranoom In my own defense, it's not as though my participation has been lacking because I want it to; I'm moving houses. By the time I was on yesterday, it was already night. At any rate, while I should probably be skeptical of your list (for accusing me and whatnot) I actually agree that Ranoom has been setting off my suspicion sensors. |
| Hey guys. I would like to offer in my defense is tat this is my first game and im still learning how to play this game. So im really not sure how i can help. or have any other convosation with you guys except for a normal one. and the two posts i posted was that. I was also offline when you guys started lynching[Last few hours of day phase] in day 1 and thats when [i think] most of you started tallking so.... Do not when i could've helpd. |
Fo-Fai said: Anyway, I'm gonna vote PTYamin again. His.. "Let's never lynch anyone and lose on purpose" strategy still erks the shit outta me. If he happens to be town, so be it. I know what that will look like but town has a much higher chance of winning without him regardless. I await his strawman defense. Also, Karote, why the hell did you just out somebodies alignment unprovoked? :/ Random lynching is usually just going to help the mafia a lot more than it helps town. I simply thought the risk was too high on day 1. That said, I don't think no-lynching is a good idea anymore because of the biggest reason that keeps this game from getting any less random: We don't know how many mafia there are. 2? 3? 4? This makes determining lynch-or-lose days impossible, and so we must lynch every day. |
| "Good-o morning-u ebberi-wan, haba nice day!" - Kud |
PTYamin said: It wasn't a random lynch though. -_-Fo-Fai said: Anyway, I'm gonna vote PTYamin again. His.. "Let's never lynch anyone and lose on purpose" strategy still erks the shit outta me. If he happens to be town, so be it. I know what that will look like but town has a much higher chance of winning without him regardless. I await his strawman defense. Also, Karote, why the hell did you just out somebodies alignment unprovoked? :/ Random lynching is usually just going to help the mafia a lot more than it helps town. I simply thought the risk was too high on day 1. That said, I don't think no-lynching is a good idea anymore because of the biggest reason that keeps this game from getting any less random: We don't know how many mafia there are. 2? 3? 4? This makes determining lynch-or-lose days impossible, and so we must lynch every day. A random lynch would have been if we went after karote, an inactive. We got Crowlage, who was an anti-town role. Thanks to some quick thinking on my part. Be happy and stop worrying about how many mafians there are because that number is far from necessary information at the moment. We're not anywhere close to Mylo and wont be for at least a couple more phases. |
Hagarn said: You can help by giving some actual speculations or peculiarities that you believe might have went unnoticed. Throwing out a bunch of names and calling it gut just looks fishy. Just guts mainly... three of them either only do one post or try to participate but not really try to help.. i guess. Drive by posters so far have explained they're new to the game. Which is no excuse to not post, if you're new the best way to learn is by actually playing and trying to help town. If you're new and trying to help mafia the best thing you could do is remain unnoticed completely. The best way to do that is lurk..Which is what pretty much half the roster has been doing. EVERYONE IS SUSPICIOUS RIGHT NOW!! POST POST POST POST COME ON OUT SCUM I KNOW YOU'RE READING THIS!! |
| Sorry I'm joining this kind of late, but today we actually have evidence to go on, so we don't need to do random lynchs anymore. The evidence appears slim, but despite that, we can still work with it. In order to look back on what we know so far, I propose we make a quick list of all players, both dead and alive, in order to label their roles/ suspected roles. I can probably make this myself; it doesn't have to be anything fancy. In the end, the least we can use this list for is process of elimination, (if it comes down to that). |
| "If you look for a ghost, you'll find one." |
| 1.Crowlage- mafia executioner 2.Gatomon -so far the most inactive player; quite possibly Mafia 3.Haine15 4.LucianRoy 5.Madhattrr -also fairly inactive 6.trebmeg- town Roleblocker 7.Fo-Fai 8.Smurphinator 9.shadowsnake777 -yet another inactive person 10.Karote - possible Investigator; inquiries might need to made further to confirm this 11.Phantomgoat townie 12.Jakeisanime 13.Ranoom 14.PTYamin- currently most suspicious for his intriguing defensive strategy on the previous day 15.Hagarn -possible town if Karote is to be trusted There are 11 people left. If we assume that there are two, (maybe three), third party roles, then that means the town to mafia ratio might be equal currently, (considering we lost two town members). To go out on a leg, I'm assuming there are only two third party roles, and if that's the case, then we're probably only one member above the mafia; thus meaning we aren't winning by much. Considering the fact that the serial killer is also loose, we could lose the game tomorrow if we don't lynch one of the mafia (or serial killer more preferably) today. |
LucianRoyJul 15, 2014 8:04 PM
| "If you look for a ghost, you'll find one." |
| You think it was a coincidence we hit an executioner day 1? Nah. There's probs a butt ton of third party in this game. So mafia probably doesn't have that strong of a number. If I had to guess, I'd say 4. Just a guess though. I'm thinking Jakeisanime might be a good lynch today. What do you think Lucian? |
| I propose these options for possible suspects/ targets for lynching. Please speak up if any one of you disagree. 1. PTYamin is option number one because, from a large, general standpoint, he appears to be anti-town for his work trying to have nobody lynched on day one. His defense is that he doesn't like random lynching so-on and so-on. It appears pretty weak to me. 2. JakeIsAnime is appearing to not know much about the game, and I can understand that if he's a noob, but if he's defending himself with that, and nothing but that, then it will get old after a while, and appear suspicious. 3. Gatoman is currently the least active player, and for numerous reasons, that could quite also mean he is mafia, but at the end of the day he is still a random lynch; thus making him a fall-back option. |
| "If you look for a ghost, you'll find one." |
| I'm pretty sure Yamin is town at this point. His defense is weak, yea. Looks like he means well though. I still stand by my point of him getting in our way though. Might be better left to a night kill. Jake is just posting to post and that doesn't get us anywhere if we lynch him. That's too easy of a target but if we have nothing else it wouldn't be a bad lynch imo. Not sure where Gatoman stands for me atm. Haven't even noticed him post tbh. Then we have Karote, who I'll assume is town at this point, who outed Hagard as town. So those guys can be trusted pretty much for the time being. Unless of course they're scum buddies trying to clear each other, which is a possibility, but that's wine and I digress. Our best plan of attack would be to lynch Yamin, now that I think about it. I'll get a for sure read on Karote, while simultaneously confirming most of his investigations. Save for some amnesiac or paranoid stuff but I doubt we'll see anything too bastard in this game. |
| My thoughts exactly. Vote Lynch: PTYamin For now, it will remain that until decided otherwise. I suggest all three suspects speak up though, for without posts, you guys appear more and more suspicious. In any event, my decision might just change after I sleep on it, (hypothetically). |
LucianRoyJul 15, 2014 8:13 PM
| "If you look for a ghost, you'll find one." |
Hagarn said: Ugh. This rubs me the wrong way. It might be the effortless post style or it might be the echoing of already said opinions but something smells fishy here.Haine15 said: I also suspect PTYamin for always protecting and keeping tie that doesn't make sense sense . Mm, if he were in mafia, he won't do something like that, he obviously want someone to lynch.. beside we know now that Crowlage or Karote is not mafia, he should have jump to banwagon to vote.. Maybe we should lynch Hagarn, that way we'll know if we can trust Karote or not. 100% |
| Actually, now that I read that again. Why not. vote hagarn Now if only people would start playing. |
More topics from this board
» [GAME] (*￣･￣)ﾉ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated Staff Member Posts! v4 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Togs - Jul 2, 2017 |
2866 |
by fausifahrial
»»
Nov 7, 2023 9:07 AM |
|
» [GAME] Last Letter Game ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )grave_robber - Sep 9, 2014 |
8750 |
by fausifahrial
»»
Nov 7, 2023 9:06 AM |
|
» Count To 7777 V3 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Lambtron - May 15, 2018 |
1159 |
by fausifahrial
»»
Nov 7, 2023 9:06 AM |
|
» [GAME] Say something about the person above you ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Haine - Jul 19, 2014 |
3810 |
by Zymf
»»
Jun 19, 2023 2:43 PM |
|
» [GAME] Truth or dare (ToD) 2.0 [Round 5] ( 1 2 )Lambtron - Mar 12, 2019 |
92 |
by Zymf
»»
Jun 18, 2023 12:09 PM |