Attack on Titan
Available on Manga Store
New
Mar 24, 2021 9:25 AM
#101
yaegerist-15 said: Sad7727 said: do that, make a thread when they announce part 2 this fall. I’m so hyped for the shitfest. I agree with all of them but jjk isn’t just the effort of parks freelancers. Freelancers like watanabe are always working for jjk and most animators are freelancers. But yeah All in all they are right@yaegerist-15 these are few pictures of them,but anyway most of them are disappointed and think the same as us (JJK is better). there are few people who don't care and say mappa is good enough though. there's also a lot in 5chan.but i didn't post any from there some guy said this is mappa level of animation because JJK was made by freelancers due to Park's connections lol. its google translate,but you can get the gist. original = manga i think            maybe i should make a separate thread when the season ends,who knows. here's an extra one i forgot to add  5ch is too hard to browse with translate,and i don't know if they have archive like 4chan. but they were complaining hard about Ep 14. they had the same complaints as us (CGI,rap) and shat on mappa there's two people saying JJK is made by help of extrenal staff,as i said id on't know if its true or not since i don't care that much anymore to search about it (but i will when CSM staff/pv hits) Yeah me too,if they put CSM as entirely 3DCG ..... |
Sad7727Mar 24, 2021 1:27 PM
Mar 24, 2021 10:47 AM
#102
| Wit studio animation is obviously superior to Mappa's in every way as far as aot is conserned, but the final season is still great cause it's still aot and the story is still great. That doesn't mean that the animation this season is only bad compared to Wit's, cause it's just not great in general. Let's hope they get more time for part 2. |
 |
Mar 24, 2021 1:17 PM
#103
Bhaskar_Singh said: Kharan said: When even SAO better animation in an iconic fight than AoT fucking FINAL season you know that something, somewhere went veeeeery wrong. https://youtu.be/M_YJvhJKr1g Even Boruto got an entire sakuga episode in a hyped fight amidst pandemic. Boruto of all things. And it's weekly. And I hate this trash show with a burning passion but even I can't deny that this level was amazing. Damn it bro. I can't believe that was SAO, that show was downright garbage and they is what it gets? Which season is it? I don't remember this from the 1st 2 seasons. Believe it or not this is what SAO now gets. It was from Alicization: War of Underworld Part 2. And there's more where that one came from: https://youtu.be/31rXI4n5Y7o A franchise as big as AoT doesn't even have one such fight in it's FINAL season. Where they should've thrown everything they had on board because it's, you know, FINAL. What I should take from that? People don't want to work on AoT but they want on SAO? Or is it that they don't want to work on AoT under MAPPA. Somehow they worked with WIT. They had three fights this season. Slava raid. Eren vs Warhammer. Levi vs Zeke. The Levi fight was perfect for that. It was no more demanding than his fights from previous seasons. There was only one Big Titan - Beast. Couldn't have hand drawn him for two minutes? WIT could. Instead I got copy-pasted trees and bloated Levi who moved as if he had arthritis. Perfect. 10/10 /s To be clear. I'm not typing this to slight animators. The regular workers are in no way to blame for the clusterfuck that is this season compared to the past ones. Their efforts are appreciated. The final product is not, considering how big of a name it is and the standards set up. |
Mar 24, 2021 1:20 PM
#104
Kharan said: people have to say it isnt that bad, sad that this is our standard now. if its not THAT BAD, then its fine. While 90% of the anime this season have better animation. Bhaskar_Singh said: Kharan said: When even SAO better animation in an iconic fight than AoT fucking FINAL season you know that something, somewhere went veeeeery wrong. https://youtu.be/M_YJvhJKr1g Even Boruto got an entire sakuga episode in a hyped fight amidst pandemic. Boruto of all things. And it's weekly. And I hate this trash show with a burning passion but even I can't deny that this level was amazing. Damn it bro. I can't believe that was SAO, that show was downright garbage and they is what it gets? Which season is it? I don't remember this from the 1st 2 seasons. Believe it or not this is what SAO now gets. It was from Alicization: War of Underworld Part 2. And there's more where that one came from: https://youtu.be/31rXI4n5Y7o A franchise as big as AoT doesn't even have one such fight in it's FINAL season. Where they should've thrown everything they had on board because it's, you know, FINAL. What I should take from that? People don't want to work on AoT but they want on SAO? Or is it that they don't want to work on AoT under MAPPA. Somehow they worked with WIT. They had three fights this season. Slava raid. Eren vs Warhammer. Levi vs Zeke. The Levi fight was perfect for that. It was no more demanding than his fights from previous seasons. There was only one Big Titan - Beast. Couldn't have hand drawn him for two minutes? WIT could. Instead I got copy-pasted trees and bloated Levi who moved as if he had arthritis. Perfect. 10/10 /s To be clear. I'm not typing this to slight animators. The regular workers are in no way to blame for the clusterfuck that is this season compared to the past ones. Their efforts are appreciated. The final product is not, considering how big of a name it is and the standards set up. |
| Attack on Titan ended with chapter 123 and 130/131 is the epilogue |
Mar 24, 2021 1:24 PM
#105
yaegerist-15 said: Sad7727 said: what are the Japanese saying?MironBiron said: A little more respect to WIT Studio guys. MAPPA might’ve given us a fully hand-drawn CT for a few seconds, but let’s not act as if S3P2‘s hand-drawn Colossal doesn’t have more screen-time than MAPPA’s. The cut in which he’s taken down by Eren is actually one of the most impressive in the entire series.               I’m not here to discuss the quality of MAPPA’s CGI btw. I’m just reminding you guys that the instances in which S3P2’s Colossal Titan was hand-drawn, arguably outnumber the amount of individual (not combined) shots in which we’ve seen MAPPA’s hand-drawn Beast, Attack, Armoured, Jaw and Cart Titans. Stop bashing WIT Studio’s adaptation of Attack on Titan when the current schedule doesn’t even allow for on-model close-ups during key moments in the story. You guys are literally KODANSHA’s wet dream. Also stop hyping this season’s direction as if it’s the second coming of Christ for fuck’s sake. They literally rushed the living shit through Eren’s transformation in E05 and played K21 during Levi versus Zeke Round 3. They turned AoT into a total post-2010-Hollywood-blockbuster shit show and only time can tell how the retrospective reception of this season will develop itself. Mironbiron with the hard hitting facts! people nitpicking WIT for literally minor faults while S4 is riddled with them is so disingenuous.cock sucking Crappa dick all day will do nothing but bring you even shitter quality for Part 2. and since they saw the huge amount of cock sucking they'll even put a shitter sequel. because why improve when everyone sucking your dick for the garbage you put? im glad i don't care about the anime anymore. when they put a shitty quality Part 2. i hope they enjoy it. the good thing is that the japanese are ripping on them on yaaron. Season 1 has the score of 90.8 on anikore Season 2 - 89.6 Season 3 Part 1 - 80.7 Season 3 Part 2 - 84.6 Season 4 - 69.4 |
Mar 24, 2021 1:26 PM
#106
Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. |
 |
Mar 24, 2021 1:29 PM
#107
I_Am_Freeballing said: if at least s2 and s3 would have the same quality as season 4, do you think it would be the same?Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. |
| Attack on Titan ended with chapter 123 and 130/131 is the epilogue |
Mar 24, 2021 1:32 PM
#108
yaegerist-15 said: I don't think S3 necessarily looks better than S4 so yes. I_Am_Freeballing said: if at least s2 and s3 would have the same quality as season 4, do you think it would be the same?Peeti said: I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. |
|
Mar 24, 2021 1:40 PM
#109
I_Am_Freeballing said: s3 p1 looks way better and s3 p2 looks better in the key moments, look at mironbirons commentyaegerist-15 said: I don't think S3 necessarily looks better than S4 so yes. I_Am_Freeballing said: Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. |
yaegerist-15Mar 24, 2021 1:43 PM
| Attack on Titan ended with chapter 123 and 130/131 is the epilogue |
Mar 24, 2021 1:43 PM
#110
yaegerist-15 said: Ok, I still think S3 would be loved the same even if we didn't have moments like Levi vs Zeke round 1.I_Am_Freeballing said: s3 p1 looks way better and s3 p2 looks better in the key momentsyaegerist-15 said: I_Am_Freeballing said: if at least s2 and s3 would have the same quality as season 4, do you think it would be the same?Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. |
|
Mar 24, 2021 1:45 PM
#111
I_Am_Freeballing said: as I said several times, that wasn't the only moment. Im sure with this quality, the beach scene wouldnt be so goodyaegerist-15 said: Ok, I still think S3 would be loved the same even if we didn't have moments like Levi vs Zeke round 1.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: I don't think S3 necessarily looks better than S4 so yes. I_Am_Freeballing said: if at least s2 and s3 would have the same quality as season 4, do you think it would be the same?Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. |
| Attack on Titan ended with chapter 123 and 130/131 is the epilogue |
Mar 24, 2021 1:50 PM
#112
yaegerist-15 said: A scene can always be better. That doesn't mean anything. Even Levi and Zeke and the beach scene can be improved. So what's your point? I don't like those moments any more than important moments in S4.I_Am_Freeballing said: as I said several times, that wasn't the only moment. Im sure with this quality, the beach scene wouldnt be so goodyaegerist-15 said: I_Am_Freeballing said: s3 p1 looks way better and s3 p2 looks better in the key momentsyaegerist-15 said: I don't think S3 necessarily looks better than S4 so yes. I_Am_Freeballing said: if at least s2 and s3 would have the same quality as season 4, do you think it would be the same?Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. |
|
Mar 24, 2021 1:53 PM
#113
I_Am_Freeballing said: now you're contradicting yourself, I was talking about the audience who wouldnt like this if it weren't for the good quality. You said season 4 won't effect anything but now you're saying you dont like those moments any more than important moments in s4. But im pretty confident that aot wouldnt be that popular if those moments weren't delivered. At the end of the day its a mediumyaegerist-15 said: A scene can always be better. That doesn't mean anything. Even Levi and Zeke and the beach scene can be improved. So what's your point? I don't like those moments any more than important moments in S4.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: Ok, I still think S3 would be loved the same even if we didn't have moments like Levi vs Zeke round 1.I_Am_Freeballing said: s3 p1 looks way better and s3 p2 looks better in the key momentsyaegerist-15 said: I don't think S3 necessarily looks better than S4 so yes. I_Am_Freeballing said: if at least s2 and s3 would have the same quality as season 4, do you think it would be the same?Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. |
| Attack on Titan ended with chapter 123 and 130/131 is the epilogue |
Mar 24, 2021 1:58 PM
#114
I_Am_Freeballing said: Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. Isn't it? Truly? Are Japanese less biased? Or are they all haters? Season 1 has the score of 90.8 on anikore Season 2 - 89.6 Season 3 Part 1 - 80.7 Season 3 Part 2 - 84.6 Season 4 - 69.4 |
Mar 24, 2021 2:04 PM
#115
yaegerist-15 said: How am I contradicting myself? I always said this is my favorite season and never said I loved Levi vs Zeke more than lets say Kaya and Gabi moments. Cause I don't. I also don't see the point in saying things would be more popular if done better. That's true for everything. That's why some think S1 looks the best. They make a good first impression to take in the viewers and then after don't try as hard, cause they have built an audience already. I doubt visuals were getting S3 any meaningful popularity, as it was the weakest season visually at the point but it was still regarded as the best one. And that's because of the story.I_Am_Freeballing said: now you're contradicting yourself, I was talking about the audience who wouldnt like this if it weren't for the good quality. You said season 4 won't effect anything but now you're saying you dont like those moments any more than important moments in s4. But im pretty confident that aot wouldnt be that popular if those moments weren't delivered. At the end of the day its a mediumyaegerist-15 said: I_Am_Freeballing said: as I said several times, that wasn't the only moment. Im sure with this quality, the beach scene wouldnt be so goodyaegerist-15 said: Ok, I still think S3 would be loved the same even if we didn't have moments like Levi vs Zeke round 1.I_Am_Freeballing said: s3 p1 looks way better and s3 p2 looks better in the key momentsyaegerist-15 said: I don't think S3 necessarily looks better than S4 so yes. I_Am_Freeballing said: if at least s2 and s3 would have the same quality as season 4, do you think it would be the same?Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. Kharan said: The Japanese dislike the manga post-time skip anyway because it's not pandering to it's shonen demographic anymore. The Japanese fans are more supportive of this season than the westerners too. Those who watch it anyway.I_Am_Freeballing said: Peeti said: I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. Isn't it? Truly? Are Japanese less biased? Or are they all haters? Season 1 has the score of 90.8 on anikore Season 2 - 89.6 Season 3 Part 1 - 80.7 Season 3 Part 2 - 84.6 Season 4 - 69.4 |
I_Am_FreeballingMar 24, 2021 2:08 PM
|
Mar 24, 2021 2:11 PM
#116
| The colossal titan has never looked worse than in S3P2, but it was still a masterful anime. All 4 seasons are Chimera Ant Arc-level of awesomeness or beyond...even reaching HxH 1999's original dedication with a hint of classic Berserk. tl;dr: it's worthy of being the best anime out there. |
| End Zionazism |
Mar 24, 2021 2:13 PM
#117
I_Am_Freeballing said: you know there is a limit for a quality drop? You're saying this like season 4 quality could be even worse and the people would watch it. So it can be like berserk 2016? Because the story is good enough, ffs what am I even doing all this energy for nothing. You know god damn well that the story in the ANIME ADAPTION isnt the only thing that carries it. If season 2 looked like this shit season, then many people would've dropped aot back then. now most of them dont care anymore because we are in the endgame. the visuals in s3 weren't important? I could cry and laugh at the same time.yaegerist-15 said: How am I contradicting myself? I always said this is my favorite season and never said I loved Levi vs Zeke more than lets say Kaya and Gabi moments. Cause I don't. I also don't see the point in saying things would be more popular if done better. That's true for everything. That's why some think S1 looks the best. They make a good first impression to take in the viewers and then after don't try as hard, cause they have built an audience already. I doubt visuals were getting S3 any meaningful popularity, as it was the weakest season visually at the point but it was still regarded as the best one. And that's because of the story.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: A scene can always be better. That doesn't mean anything. Even Levi and Zeke and the beach scene can be improved. So what's your point? I don't like those moments any more than important moments in S4.I_Am_Freeballing said: as I said several times, that wasn't the only moment. Im sure with this quality, the beach scene wouldnt be so goodyaegerist-15 said: Ok, I still think S3 would be loved the same even if we didn't have moments like Levi vs Zeke round 1.I_Am_Freeballing said: s3 p1 looks way better and s3 p2 looks better in the key momentsyaegerist-15 said: I don't think S3 necessarily looks better than S4 so yes. I_Am_Freeballing said: if at least s2 and s3 would have the same quality as season 4, do you think it would be the same?Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. Kharan said: The Japanese dislike the manga post-time skip anyway because it's not pandering to it's shonen demographic anymore. The Japanese fans are more supportive of this season than the westerners too. Those who watch it anyway.I_Am_Freeballing said: Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. Isn't it? Truly? Are Japanese less biased? Or are they all haters? Season 1 has the score of 90.8 on anikore Season 2 - 89.6 Season 3 Part 1 - 80.7 Season 3 Part 2 - 84.6 Season 4 - 69.4 |
| Attack on Titan ended with chapter 123 and 130/131 is the epilogue |
Mar 24, 2021 2:14 PM
#118
Mikasa said: the colossal titan still had 2d cuts in season 3 part 2, and they looked better than the colossal titan in season 4The colossal titan has never looked worse than in S3P2, but it was still a masterful anime. All 4 seasons are Chimera Ant Arc-level of awesomeness or beyond...even reaching HxH 1999's original dedication with a hint of classic Berserk. tl;dr: it's worthy of being the best anime out there. |
| Attack on Titan ended with chapter 123 and 130/131 is the epilogue |
Mar 24, 2021 2:20 PM
#119
yaegerist-15 said: But this season isn't as bad as Berserk 2016 so what are you talking about? The story is the most important thing in anime like AOT. That is the truth. No one is saying the visuals aren't important. I'm saying it's not why S3 is loved. Stop twisting my words. Obviously it would be bad if the quality was like Berserk 2016. But it's nowhere close.I_Am_Freeballing said: you know there is a limit for a quality drop? You're saying this like season 4 quality could be even worse and the people would watch it. So it can be like berserk 2016? Because the story is good enough, ffs what am I even doing all this energy for nothing. You know god damn well that the story in the ANIME ADAPTION isnt the only thing that carries it. If season 2 looked like this shit season, then many people would've dropped aot back then. now most of them dont care anymore because we are in the endgame. the visuals in s3 weren't important? I could cry and laugh at the same time.yaegerist-15 said: I_Am_Freeballing said: now you're contradicting yourself, I was talking about the audience who wouldnt like this if it weren't for the good quality. You said season 4 won't effect anything but now you're saying you dont like those moments any more than important moments in s4. But im pretty confident that aot wouldnt be that popular if those moments weren't delivered. At the end of the day its a mediumyaegerist-15 said: A scene can always be better. That doesn't mean anything. Even Levi and Zeke and the beach scene can be improved. So what's your point? I don't like those moments any more than important moments in S4.I_Am_Freeballing said: as I said several times, that wasn't the only moment. Im sure with this quality, the beach scene wouldnt be so goodyaegerist-15 said: Ok, I still think S3 would be loved the same even if we didn't have moments like Levi vs Zeke round 1.I_Am_Freeballing said: s3 p1 looks way better and s3 p2 looks better in the key momentsyaegerist-15 said: I don't think S3 necessarily looks better than S4 so yes. I_Am_Freeballing said: if at least s2 and s3 would have the same quality as season 4, do you think it would be the same?Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. Kharan said: I_Am_Freeballing said: Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. Isn't it? Truly? Are Japanese less biased? Or are they all haters? Season 1 has the score of 90.8 on anikore Season 2 - 89.6 Season 3 Part 1 - 80.7 Season 3 Part 2 - 84.6 Season 4 - 69.4 |
|
Mar 24, 2021 2:24 PM
#120
I_Am_Freeballing said: then why has Levi vs Kenny squad the most views on YouTube? You said the hype wouldnt decrease but im pretty sure the hype wouldnt be that big for season 4 if there wouldn't be a good adaptation in the previous. The story didn't carried season 3 as you said. iT was the best part yes but the quality in the key moments were important tooyaegerist-15 said: But this season isn't as bad as Berserk 2016 so what are you talking about? The story is the most important thing in anime like AOT. That is the truth. No one is saying the visuals aren't important. I'm saying it's not why S3 is loved. Stop twisting my words. Obviously it would be bad if the quality was like Berserk 2016. But it's nowhere close.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: How am I contradicting myself? I always said this is my favorite season and never said I loved Levi vs Zeke more than lets say Kaya and Gabi moments. Cause I don't. I also don't see the point in saying things would be more popular if done better. That's true for everything. That's why some think S1 looks the best. They make a good first impression to take in the viewers and then after don't try as hard, cause they have built an audience already. I doubt visuals were getting S3 any meaningful popularity, as it was the weakest season visually at the point but it was still regarded as the best one. And that's because of the story.I_Am_Freeballing said: now you're contradicting yourself, I was talking about the audience who wouldnt like this if it weren't for the good quality. You said season 4 won't effect anything but now you're saying you dont like those moments any more than important moments in s4. But im pretty confident that aot wouldnt be that popular if those moments weren't delivered. At the end of the day its a mediumyaegerist-15 said: A scene can always be better. That doesn't mean anything. Even Levi and Zeke and the beach scene can be improved. So what's your point? I don't like those moments any more than important moments in S4.I_Am_Freeballing said: as I said several times, that wasn't the only moment. Im sure with this quality, the beach scene wouldnt be so goodyaegerist-15 said: Ok, I still think S3 would be loved the same even if we didn't have moments like Levi vs Zeke round 1.I_Am_Freeballing said: s3 p1 looks way better and s3 p2 looks better in the key momentsyaegerist-15 said: I don't think S3 necessarily looks better than S4 so yes. I_Am_Freeballing said: if at least s2 and s3 would have the same quality as season 4, do you think it would be the same?Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. Kharan said: The Japanese dislike the manga post-time skip anyway because it's not pandering to it's shonen demographic anymore. The Japanese fans are more supportive of this season than the westerners too. Those who watch it anyway.I_Am_Freeballing said: Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. Isn't it? Truly? Are Japanese less biased? Or are they all haters? Season 1 has the score of 90.8 on anikore Season 2 - 89.6 Season 3 Part 1 - 80.7 Season 3 Part 2 - 84.6 Season 4 - 69.4 |
| Attack on Titan ended with chapter 123 and 130/131 is the epilogue |
Mar 24, 2021 2:32 PM
#121
Kharan said: I_Am_Freeballing said: Peeti said: I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. Isn't it? Truly? Are Japanese less biased? Or are they all haters? Season 1 has the score of 90.8 on anikore Season 2 - 89.6 Season 3 Part 1 - 80.7 Season 3 Part 2 - 84.6 Season 4 - 69.4 I wouldn't take the opinion of people who put S3P2 below S1 seriously |
Mar 24, 2021 2:34 PM
#122
yaegerist-15 said: And I'm agreeing with you for that first part. The story definitely carried S3 tho. You are talking as if the quality is gone in S4. It's still there. Just because it's not as good as before in key scenes doesn't mean it's bad. It's not bad at all.I_Am_Freeballing said: then why has Levi vs Kenny squad the most views on YouTube? You said the hype wouldnt decrease but im pretty sure the hype wouldnt be that big for season 4 if there wouldn't be a good adaptation in the previous. The story didn't carried season 3 as you said. iT was the best part yes but the quality in the key moments were important tooyaegerist-15 said: I_Am_Freeballing said: you know there is a limit for a quality drop? You're saying this like season 4 quality could be even worse and the people would watch it. So it can be like berserk 2016? Because the story is good enough, ffs what am I even doing all this energy for nothing. You know god damn well that the story in the ANIME ADAPTION isnt the only thing that carries it. If season 2 looked like this shit season, then many people would've dropped aot back then. now most of them dont care anymore because we are in the endgame. the visuals in s3 weren't important? I could cry and laugh at the same time.yaegerist-15 said: How am I contradicting myself? I always said this is my favorite season and never said I loved Levi vs Zeke more than lets say Kaya and Gabi moments. Cause I don't. I also don't see the point in saying things would be more popular if done better. That's true for everything. That's why some think S1 looks the best. They make a good first impression to take in the viewers and then after don't try as hard, cause they have built an audience already. I doubt visuals were getting S3 any meaningful popularity, as it was the weakest season visually at the point but it was still regarded as the best one. And that's because of the story.I_Am_Freeballing said: now you're contradicting yourself, I was talking about the audience who wouldnt like this if it weren't for the good quality. You said season 4 won't effect anything but now you're saying you dont like those moments any more than important moments in s4. But im pretty confident that aot wouldnt be that popular if those moments weren't delivered. At the end of the day its a mediumyaegerist-15 said: A scene can always be better. That doesn't mean anything. Even Levi and Zeke and the beach scene can be improved. So what's your point? I don't like those moments any more than important moments in S4.I_Am_Freeballing said: as I said several times, that wasn't the only moment. Im sure with this quality, the beach scene wouldnt be so goodyaegerist-15 said: Ok, I still think S3 would be loved the same even if we didn't have moments like Levi vs Zeke round 1.I_Am_Freeballing said: s3 p1 looks way better and s3 p2 looks better in the key momentsyaegerist-15 said: I don't think S3 necessarily looks better than S4 so yes. I_Am_Freeballing said: if at least s2 and s3 would have the same quality as season 4, do you think it would be the same?Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. Kharan said: The Japanese dislike the manga post-time skip anyway because it's not pandering to it's shonen demographic anymore. The Japanese fans are more supportive of this season than the westerners too. Those who watch it anyway.I_Am_Freeballing said: Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. Isn't it? Truly? Are Japanese less biased? Or are they all haters? Season 1 has the score of 90.8 on anikore Season 2 - 89.6 Season 3 Part 1 - 80.7 Season 3 Part 2 - 84.6 Season 4 - 69.4 |
|
Mar 24, 2021 2:35 PM
#123
yaegerist-15 said: Mikasa said: the colossal titan still had 2d cuts in season 3 part 2, and they looked better than the colossal titan in season 4The colossal titan has never looked worse than in S3P2, but it was still a masterful anime. All 4 seasons are Chimera Ant Arc-level of awesomeness or beyond...even reaching HxH 1999's original dedication with a hint of classic Berserk. tl;dr: it's worthy of being the best anime out there. I don't care if it's 2d or 5d it looked god-awful. Armored titan in S4 looked even better than he did in S1. |
| End Zionazism |
Mar 24, 2021 2:36 PM
#124
Mikasa said: I agree on the armored titan, while the attack titan looks like a rat and the odm gear this season looks like smacking flies yaegerist-15 said: Mikasa said: The colossal titan has never looked worse than in S3P2, but it was still a masterful anime. All 4 seasons are Chimera Ant Arc-level of awesomeness or beyond...even reaching HxH 1999's original dedication with a hint of classic Berserk. tl;dr: it's worthy of being the best anime out there. I don't care if it's 2d or 5d it looked god-awful. Armored titan in S4 looked even better than he did in S1. |
| Attack on Titan ended with chapter 123 and 130/131 is the epilogue |
Mar 24, 2021 2:40 PM
#125
YouNeedMemes said: Kharan said: I_Am_Freeballing said: Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. Isn't it? Truly? Are Japanese less biased? Or are they all haters? Season 1 has the score of 90.8 on anikore Season 2 - 89.6 Season 3 Part 1 - 80.7 Season 3 Part 2 - 84.6 Season 4 - 69.4 I wouldn't take the opinion of people who put S3P2 below S1 seriously Personally I think season 3 (both part one and two) were the best. But that's not the point. He said that this season isn't less loved outside of MAL than s3p2. Now he's saying it IS less loved because it doesn't pander to shonen simps. Hilarious. |
Mar 24, 2021 2:42 PM
#126
| There are other visual issues with this seasons that aren't due to 3d |
 _______I like rocks__  |
Mar 24, 2021 2:47 PM
#127
Atlos said: yeah like that atrocious blur filter There are other visual issues with this seasons that aren't due to 3d |
| Attack on Titan ended with chapter 123 and 130/131 is the epilogue |
Mar 24, 2021 2:48 PM
#128
yaegerist-15 said: And the new character designs Atlos said: yeah like that atrocious blur filter There are other visual issues with this seasons that aren't due to 3d |
| _______I like rocks__ |
Mar 24, 2021 2:49 PM
#129
Atlos said: well I prefer reiner, zeke and Armin with this design but that's just meyaegerist-15 said: And the new character designs Atlos said: There are other visual issues with this seasons that aren't due to 3d |
| Attack on Titan ended with chapter 123 and 130/131 is the epilogue |
Mar 24, 2021 2:58 PM
#130
Atlos said: yaegerist-15 said: And the new character designs Atlos said: There are other visual issues with this seasons that aren't due to 3d Depends. Imho they made Hanji perfectly. They look much more detailed/mature. The expressions and visuals - beautiful. And Armin. The best he's ever looked. Those two are the suns of this season. Shame can't say the same for Levi. |
Mar 24, 2021 4:38 PM
#131
Kharan said: I was talking about Japan specifically. They don't like the story of the season. Not merely the visuals.YouNeedMemes said: Kharan said: I_Am_Freeballing said: Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. Isn't it? Truly? Are Japanese less biased? Or are they all haters? Season 1 has the score of 90.8 on anikore Season 2 - 89.6 Season 3 Part 1 - 80.7 Season 3 Part 2 - 84.6 Season 4 - 69.4 I wouldn't take the opinion of people who put S3P2 below S1 seriously Personally I think season 3 (both part one and two) were the best. But that's not the point. He said that this season isn't less loved outside of MAL than s3p2. Now he's saying it IS less loved because it doesn't pander to shonen simps. Hilarious. |
|
Mar 24, 2021 4:38 PM
#132
I_Am_Freeballing said: well its ruined in the retrospective way. The drop in the quality is to significant to do a re watch. While s1 and 2 was a 10/10 and s3 was a 8.5, this is maybe a 6/10 and such inconsistencies ruins an anime adaptation in the long wayyaegerist-15 said: And I'm agreeing with you for that first part. The story definitely carried S3 tho. You are talking as if the quality is gone in S4. It's still there. Just because it's not as good as before in key scenes doesn't mean it's bad. It's not bad at all.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: But this season isn't as bad as Berserk 2016 so what are you talking about? The story is the most important thing in anime like AOT. That is the truth. No one is saying the visuals aren't important. I'm saying it's not why S3 is loved. Stop twisting my words. Obviously it would be bad if the quality was like Berserk 2016. But it's nowhere close.I_Am_Freeballing said: you know there is a limit for a quality drop? You're saying this like season 4 quality could be even worse and the people would watch it. So it can be like berserk 2016? Because the story is good enough, ffs what am I even doing all this energy for nothing. You know god damn well that the story in the ANIME ADAPTION isnt the only thing that carries it. If season 2 looked like this shit season, then many people would've dropped aot back then. now most of them dont care anymore because we are in the endgame. the visuals in s3 weren't important? I could cry and laugh at the same time.yaegerist-15 said: How am I contradicting myself? I always said this is my favorite season and never said I loved Levi vs Zeke more than lets say Kaya and Gabi moments. Cause I don't. I also don't see the point in saying things would be more popular if done better. That's true for everything. That's why some think S1 looks the best. They make a good first impression to take in the viewers and then after don't try as hard, cause they have built an audience already. I doubt visuals were getting S3 any meaningful popularity, as it was the weakest season visually at the point but it was still regarded as the best one. And that's because of the story.I_Am_Freeballing said: now you're contradicting yourself, I was talking about the audience who wouldnt like this if it weren't for the good quality. You said season 4 won't effect anything but now you're saying you dont like those moments any more than important moments in s4. But im pretty confident that aot wouldnt be that popular if those moments weren't delivered. At the end of the day its a mediumyaegerist-15 said: A scene can always be better. That doesn't mean anything. Even Levi and Zeke and the beach scene can be improved. So what's your point? I don't like those moments any more than important moments in S4.I_Am_Freeballing said: as I said several times, that wasn't the only moment. Im sure with this quality, the beach scene wouldnt be so goodyaegerist-15 said: Ok, I still think S3 would be loved the same even if we didn't have moments like Levi vs Zeke round 1.I_Am_Freeballing said: s3 p1 looks way better and s3 p2 looks better in the key momentsyaegerist-15 said: I don't think S3 necessarily looks better than S4 so yes. I_Am_Freeballing said: if at least s2 and s3 would have the same quality as season 4, do you think it would be the same?Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. Kharan said: The Japanese dislike the manga post-time skip anyway because it's not pandering to it's shonen demographic anymore. The Japanese fans are more supportive of this season than the westerners too. Those who watch it anyway.I_Am_Freeballing said: Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. Isn't it? Truly? Are Japanese less biased? Or are they all haters? Season 1 has the score of 90.8 on anikore Season 2 - 89.6 Season 3 Part 1 - 80.7 Season 3 Part 2 - 84.6 Season 4 - 69.4 |
| Attack on Titan ended with chapter 123 and 130/131 is the epilogue |
Mar 24, 2021 4:40 PM
#133
yaegerist-15 said: That's true, but every season was inconsistent with one another. S1, S2 and S3 all look different. People just bitch about this season because it's a new studio.I_Am_Freeballing said: well its ruined in the retrospective way. The drop in the quality is to significant to do a re watch. While s1 and 2 was a 10/10 and s3 was a 8.5, this is maybe a 6/10 and such inconsistencies ruins an anime adaptation in the long wayyaegerist-15 said: I_Am_Freeballing said: then why has Levi vs Kenny squad the most views on YouTube? You said the hype wouldnt decrease but im pretty sure the hype wouldnt be that big for season 4 if there wouldn't be a good adaptation in the previous. The story didn't carried season 3 as you said. iT was the best part yes but the quality in the key moments were important tooyaegerist-15 said: But this season isn't as bad as Berserk 2016 so what are you talking about? The story is the most important thing in anime like AOT. That is the truth. No one is saying the visuals aren't important. I'm saying it's not why S3 is loved. Stop twisting my words. Obviously it would be bad if the quality was like Berserk 2016. But it's nowhere close.I_Am_Freeballing said: you know there is a limit for a quality drop? You're saying this like season 4 quality could be even worse and the people would watch it. So it can be like berserk 2016? Because the story is good enough, ffs what am I even doing all this energy for nothing. You know god damn well that the story in the ANIME ADAPTION isnt the only thing that carries it. If season 2 looked like this shit season, then many people would've dropped aot back then. now most of them dont care anymore because we are in the endgame. the visuals in s3 weren't important? I could cry and laugh at the same time.yaegerist-15 said: How am I contradicting myself? I always said this is my favorite season and never said I loved Levi vs Zeke more than lets say Kaya and Gabi moments. Cause I don't. I also don't see the point in saying things would be more popular if done better. That's true for everything. That's why some think S1 looks the best. They make a good first impression to take in the viewers and then after don't try as hard, cause they have built an audience already. I doubt visuals were getting S3 any meaningful popularity, as it was the weakest season visually at the point but it was still regarded as the best one. And that's because of the story.I_Am_Freeballing said: now you're contradicting yourself, I was talking about the audience who wouldnt like this if it weren't for the good quality. You said season 4 won't effect anything but now you're saying you dont like those moments any more than important moments in s4. But im pretty confident that aot wouldnt be that popular if those moments weren't delivered. At the end of the day its a mediumyaegerist-15 said: A scene can always be better. That doesn't mean anything. Even Levi and Zeke and the beach scene can be improved. So what's your point? I don't like those moments any more than important moments in S4.I_Am_Freeballing said: as I said several times, that wasn't the only moment. Im sure with this quality, the beach scene wouldnt be so goodyaegerist-15 said: Ok, I still think S3 would be loved the same even if we didn't have moments like Levi vs Zeke round 1.I_Am_Freeballing said: s3 p1 looks way better and s3 p2 looks better in the key momentsyaegerist-15 said: I don't think S3 necessarily looks better than S4 so yes. I_Am_Freeballing said: if at least s2 and s3 would have the same quality as season 4, do you think it would be the same?Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. Kharan said: The Japanese dislike the manga post-time skip anyway because it's not pandering to it's shonen demographic anymore. The Japanese fans are more supportive of this season than the westerners too. Those who watch it anyway.I_Am_Freeballing said: Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. Isn't it? Truly? Are Japanese less biased? Or are they all haters? Season 1 has the score of 90.8 on anikore Season 2 - 89.6 Season 3 Part 1 - 80.7 Season 3 Part 2 - 84.6 Season 4 - 69.4 |
|
Mar 24, 2021 4:43 PM
#134
I_Am_Freeballing said: I agree with you but I think the drop in the quality now is too much, season 3 had the important key moments and still the art sytle. The new artsytle this season, which is very good, can be overlooked if the animation would be at least s3 quality. shame it isnt yaegerist-15 said: That's true, but every season was inconsistent with one another. S1, S2 and S3 all look different. People just bitch about this season because it's a new studio.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: And I'm agreeing with you for that first part. The story definitely carried S3 tho. You are talking as if the quality is gone in S4. It's still there. Just because it's not as good as before in key scenes doesn't mean it's bad. It's not bad at all.I_Am_Freeballing said: then why has Levi vs Kenny squad the most views on YouTube? You said the hype wouldnt decrease but im pretty sure the hype wouldnt be that big for season 4 if there wouldn't be a good adaptation in the previous. The story didn't carried season 3 as you said. iT was the best part yes but the quality in the key moments were important tooyaegerist-15 said: But this season isn't as bad as Berserk 2016 so what are you talking about? The story is the most important thing in anime like AOT. That is the truth. No one is saying the visuals aren't important. I'm saying it's not why S3 is loved. Stop twisting my words. Obviously it would be bad if the quality was like Berserk 2016. But it's nowhere close.I_Am_Freeballing said: you know there is a limit for a quality drop? You're saying this like season 4 quality could be even worse and the people would watch it. So it can be like berserk 2016? Because the story is good enough, ffs what am I even doing all this energy for nothing. You know god damn well that the story in the ANIME ADAPTION isnt the only thing that carries it. If season 2 looked like this shit season, then many people would've dropped aot back then. now most of them dont care anymore because we are in the endgame. the visuals in s3 weren't important? I could cry and laugh at the same time.yaegerist-15 said: How am I contradicting myself? I always said this is my favorite season and never said I loved Levi vs Zeke more than lets say Kaya and Gabi moments. Cause I don't. I also don't see the point in saying things would be more popular if done better. That's true for everything. That's why some think S1 looks the best. They make a good first impression to take in the viewers and then after don't try as hard, cause they have built an audience already. I doubt visuals were getting S3 any meaningful popularity, as it was the weakest season visually at the point but it was still regarded as the best one. And that's because of the story.I_Am_Freeballing said: now you're contradicting yourself, I was talking about the audience who wouldnt like this if it weren't for the good quality. You said season 4 won't effect anything but now you're saying you dont like those moments any more than important moments in s4. But im pretty confident that aot wouldnt be that popular if those moments weren't delivered. At the end of the day its a mediumyaegerist-15 said: A scene can always be better. That doesn't mean anything. Even Levi and Zeke and the beach scene can be improved. So what's your point? I don't like those moments any more than important moments in S4.I_Am_Freeballing said: as I said several times, that wasn't the only moment. Im sure with this quality, the beach scene wouldnt be so goodyaegerist-15 said: Ok, I still think S3 would be loved the same even if we didn't have moments like Levi vs Zeke round 1.I_Am_Freeballing said: s3 p1 looks way better and s3 p2 looks better in the key momentsyaegerist-15 said: I don't think S3 necessarily looks better than S4 so yes. I_Am_Freeballing said: if at least s2 and s3 would have the same quality as season 4, do you think it would be the same?Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. Kharan said: The Japanese dislike the manga post-time skip anyway because it's not pandering to it's shonen demographic anymore. The Japanese fans are more supportive of this season than the westerners too. Those who watch it anyway.I_Am_Freeballing said: Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. Isn't it? Truly? Are Japanese less biased? Or are they all haters? Season 1 has the score of 90.8 on anikore Season 2 - 89.6 Season 3 Part 1 - 80.7 Season 3 Part 2 - 84.6 Season 4 - 69.4 |
| Attack on Titan ended with chapter 123 and 130/131 is the epilogue |
Mar 24, 2021 4:50 PM
#135
yaegerist-15 said: Well it's a shame you can't enjoy it. I don't think the drop in quality is relevant at all since it doesn't bother me in the slightest. I am having the time of my life watching this season and if people think I have low standards because of it then that's fine. I'd rather be a blind fool and enjoy something than be overly critical and nitpick everything. I believe I am very aware of the downsides of this season, I just don't deem them serious enough.I_Am_Freeballing said: I agree with you but I think the drop in the quality now is too much, season 3 had the important key moments and still the art sytle. The new artsytle this season, which is very good, can be overlooked if the animation would be at least s3 quality. shame it isnt yaegerist-15 said: I_Am_Freeballing said: well its ruined in the retrospective way. The drop in the quality is to significant to do a re watch. While s1 and 2 was a 10/10 and s3 was a 8.5, this is maybe a 6/10 and such inconsistencies ruins an anime adaptation in the long wayyaegerist-15 said: And I'm agreeing with you for that first part. The story definitely carried S3 tho. You are talking as if the quality is gone in S4. It's still there. Just because it's not as good as before in key scenes doesn't mean it's bad. It's not bad at all.I_Am_Freeballing said: then why has Levi vs Kenny squad the most views on YouTube? You said the hype wouldnt decrease but im pretty sure the hype wouldnt be that big for season 4 if there wouldn't be a good adaptation in the previous. The story didn't carried season 3 as you said. iT was the best part yes but the quality in the key moments were important tooyaegerist-15 said: But this season isn't as bad as Berserk 2016 so what are you talking about? The story is the most important thing in anime like AOT. That is the truth. No one is saying the visuals aren't important. I'm saying it's not why S3 is loved. Stop twisting my words. Obviously it would be bad if the quality was like Berserk 2016. But it's nowhere close.I_Am_Freeballing said: you know there is a limit for a quality drop? You're saying this like season 4 quality could be even worse and the people would watch it. So it can be like berserk 2016? Because the story is good enough, ffs what am I even doing all this energy for nothing. You know god damn well that the story in the ANIME ADAPTION isnt the only thing that carries it. If season 2 looked like this shit season, then many people would've dropped aot back then. now most of them dont care anymore because we are in the endgame. the visuals in s3 weren't important? I could cry and laugh at the same time.yaegerist-15 said: How am I contradicting myself? I always said this is my favorite season and never said I loved Levi vs Zeke more than lets say Kaya and Gabi moments. Cause I don't. I also don't see the point in saying things would be more popular if done better. That's true for everything. That's why some think S1 looks the best. They make a good first impression to take in the viewers and then after don't try as hard, cause they have built an audience already. I doubt visuals were getting S3 any meaningful popularity, as it was the weakest season visually at the point but it was still regarded as the best one. And that's because of the story.I_Am_Freeballing said: now you're contradicting yourself, I was talking about the audience who wouldnt like this if it weren't for the good quality. You said season 4 won't effect anything but now you're saying you dont like those moments any more than important moments in s4. But im pretty confident that aot wouldnt be that popular if those moments weren't delivered. At the end of the day its a mediumyaegerist-15 said: A scene can always be better. That doesn't mean anything. Even Levi and Zeke and the beach scene can be improved. So what's your point? I don't like those moments any more than important moments in S4.I_Am_Freeballing said: as I said several times, that wasn't the only moment. Im sure with this quality, the beach scene wouldnt be so goodyaegerist-15 said: Ok, I still think S3 would be loved the same even if we didn't have moments like Levi vs Zeke round 1.I_Am_Freeballing said: s3 p1 looks way better and s3 p2 looks better in the key momentsyaegerist-15 said: I don't think S3 necessarily looks better than S4 so yes. I_Am_Freeballing said: if at least s2 and s3 would have the same quality as season 4, do you think it would be the same?Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. Kharan said: The Japanese dislike the manga post-time skip anyway because it's not pandering to it's shonen demographic anymore. The Japanese fans are more supportive of this season than the westerners too. Those who watch it anyway.I_Am_Freeballing said: Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. Isn't it? Truly? Are Japanese less biased? Or are they all haters? Season 1 has the score of 90.8 on anikore Season 2 - 89.6 Season 3 Part 1 - 80.7 Season 3 Part 2 - 84.6 Season 4 - 69.4 |
|
Mar 24, 2021 4:54 PM
#136
I_Am_Freeballing said: no you're not a blind fool for that, you even accepted my criticism. Im happy you can enjoy the season to its fullestyaegerist-15 said: Well it's a shame you can't enjoy it. I don't think the drop in quality is relevant at all since it doesn't bother me in the slightest. I am having the time of my life watching this season and if people think I have low standards because of it then that's fine. I'd rather be a blind fool and enjoy something than be overly critical and nitpick everything. I believe I am very aware of the downsides of this season, I just don't deem them serious enough.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: That's true, but every season was inconsistent with one another. S1, S2 and S3 all look different. People just bitch about this season because it's a new studio.I_Am_Freeballing said: well its ruined in the retrospective way. The drop in the quality is to significant to do a re watch. While s1 and 2 was a 10/10 and s3 was a 8.5, this is maybe a 6/10 and such inconsistencies ruins an anime adaptation in the long wayyaegerist-15 said: And I'm agreeing with you for that first part. The story definitely carried S3 tho. You are talking as if the quality is gone in S4. It's still there. Just because it's not as good as before in key scenes doesn't mean it's bad. It's not bad at all.I_Am_Freeballing said: then why has Levi vs Kenny squad the most views on YouTube? You said the hype wouldnt decrease but im pretty sure the hype wouldnt be that big for season 4 if there wouldn't be a good adaptation in the previous. The story didn't carried season 3 as you said. iT was the best part yes but the quality in the key moments were important tooyaegerist-15 said: But this season isn't as bad as Berserk 2016 so what are you talking about? The story is the most important thing in anime like AOT. That is the truth. No one is saying the visuals aren't important. I'm saying it's not why S3 is loved. Stop twisting my words. Obviously it would be bad if the quality was like Berserk 2016. But it's nowhere close.I_Am_Freeballing said: you know there is a limit for a quality drop? You're saying this like season 4 quality could be even worse and the people would watch it. So it can be like berserk 2016? Because the story is good enough, ffs what am I even doing all this energy for nothing. You know god damn well that the story in the ANIME ADAPTION isnt the only thing that carries it. If season 2 looked like this shit season, then many people would've dropped aot back then. now most of them dont care anymore because we are in the endgame. the visuals in s3 weren't important? I could cry and laugh at the same time.yaegerist-15 said: How am I contradicting myself? I always said this is my favorite season and never said I loved Levi vs Zeke more than lets say Kaya and Gabi moments. Cause I don't. I also don't see the point in saying things would be more popular if done better. That's true for everything. That's why some think S1 looks the best. They make a good first impression to take in the viewers and then after don't try as hard, cause they have built an audience already. I doubt visuals were getting S3 any meaningful popularity, as it was the weakest season visually at the point but it was still regarded as the best one. And that's because of the story.I_Am_Freeballing said: now you're contradicting yourself, I was talking about the audience who wouldnt like this if it weren't for the good quality. You said season 4 won't effect anything but now you're saying you dont like those moments any more than important moments in s4. But im pretty confident that aot wouldnt be that popular if those moments weren't delivered. At the end of the day its a mediumyaegerist-15 said: A scene can always be better. That doesn't mean anything. Even Levi and Zeke and the beach scene can be improved. So what's your point? I don't like those moments any more than important moments in S4.I_Am_Freeballing said: as I said several times, that wasn't the only moment. Im sure with this quality, the beach scene wouldnt be so goodyaegerist-15 said: Ok, I still think S3 would be loved the same even if we didn't have moments like Levi vs Zeke round 1.I_Am_Freeballing said: s3 p1 looks way better and s3 p2 looks better in the key momentsyaegerist-15 said: I don't think S3 necessarily looks better than S4 so yes. I_Am_Freeballing said: if at least s2 and s3 would have the same quality as season 4, do you think it would be the same?Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. Kharan said: The Japanese dislike the manga post-time skip anyway because it's not pandering to it's shonen demographic anymore. The Japanese fans are more supportive of this season than the westerners too. Those who watch it anyway.I_Am_Freeballing said: Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. Isn't it? Truly? Are Japanese less biased? Or are they all haters? Season 1 has the score of 90.8 on anikore Season 2 - 89.6 Season 3 Part 1 - 80.7 Season 3 Part 2 - 84.6 Season 4 - 69.4 |
| Attack on Titan ended with chapter 123 and 130/131 is the epilogue |
Mar 24, 2021 7:19 PM
#137
I_Am_Freeballing said: outside where? The popularity has come back due to s3p2. The hype was only due to s3p2.Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. |
| "I think I wanted to attack something. Like betraying people or hurting people. And, well, it's not exactly nice, but hurting the readers too... In all honestly, I feel that's what I really wanted to do. For me, as a reader, when I think, "this manga will remain in my heart," it means, for example, it phenomenally hurt me: It's those kinds of experiences I'm after." - Pajime Hisayama (My favourite hurting author). |
Mar 25, 2021 9:12 AM
#138
Peeti said: No one is denying the popularity came back because S3P2. I'm telling you it's staying. More people love this season than S3P2.I_Am_Freeballing said: outside where? The popularity has come back due to s3p2. The hype was only due to s3p2.Peeti said: I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. |
|
Mar 25, 2021 9:16 AM
#139
I_Am_Freeballing said: but the thing is, will it keep it up?Peeti said: No one is denying the popularity came back because S3P2. I'm telling you it's staying. More people love this season than S3P2.I_Am_Freeballing said: Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. |
| "I think I wanted to attack something. Like betraying people or hurting people. And, well, it's not exactly nice, but hurting the readers too... In all honestly, I feel that's what I really wanted to do. For me, as a reader, when I think, "this manga will remain in my heart," it means, for example, it phenomenally hurt me: It's those kinds of experiences I'm after." - Pajime Hisayama (My favourite hurting author). |
Mar 25, 2021 9:22 AM
#140
Peeti said: It will be even more with Part 2.I_Am_Freeballing said: but the thing is, will it keep it up?Peeti said: I_Am_Freeballing said: outside where? The popularity has come back due to s3p2. The hype was only due to s3p2.Peeti said: I already said that it doesn't matter what the scores are on one fansite. This season isn't less loved than S3P2 outside MAL.I_Am_Freeballing said: that's because season two has only one or two also. Tell me an episode whose rating is below 80% for s3p2.Peeti said: Ratings on one site mean nothing. This season is as loved as S3P2 if not more in general. And I'm not talking per episode but the story overall. That's like saying S2 is the best season because of the 6th episode.I_Am_Freeballing said: there are two episodes in 90% this season only. One of them is barely staying there.Kharan said: People will remember top-notch moments, which this season has plenty of. It has nothing to do with sakuga. You're wrong if you think people only remember scenes that are animated well. That makes no sense. I would rewatch both scenes you mentioned and no, this season has the most ''holy shit this is insane'' moments. They just have nothing to do with animation. You are delusional if you think this season is going to ''fall into oblivion'' or whatever. Quite on the contrary, this will be the one remembered the most. That is until Part 2 comes out. AOT has reached heights even worse animation than we're getting wouldn't put a dent in it's reputation. AOT is doing nothing but rising in the eyes of the people. Animation complaints don't hold any power against it. That is the reality.I_Am_Freeballing said: yaegerist-15 said: The whole point is that it doesn't need to be amazingly animated to be amazing. Sure, everyone would like it even more if it was better animated but the fact remains it doesn't need to be. This season also has very greatly animated moments. The ending of episode 15, while simple, is probably the prettiest and crispiest SNK has ever looked.I_Am_Freeballing said: storywise yes but unlike previous seasons, this season doesent have impact on several important moments thanks to the bad production. I would call it the best season but the previous seasons made the iconic scenes look better. I can’t really say this season is better. I wonder how season 3 p2 would look if they put more effort in floch talking to eren instead of the beach episode or in hange shooting a thunder spear in reiners mouth instead of Levi vs beast titan. Nobody would say back then s3 is the best season if it weren’t for the effort in important momentsyaegerist-15 said: This season > previous 3 seasons even with generally worse visuals. Stay mad about it.I_Am_Freeballing said: beach scene in season 3>>> every aesthetic shot/scene this seasonGabi and Kaya moments > Levi vs Zeke round 2 It's just tiring seeing the same few people complain about stuff that holds no weight when all is said and done. 99% of the people watching this haven't even thought about Levi vs Zeke round 2 looking bad. The reason S3P2 is loved is the basement reveal, not the 1st round of Levi vs Zeke. It looks amazing, but it would be false to claim it's the reason people liked that season. It's still because of the story. Every season has been. What will people remember, tho? Few top-notch sakuga moments or an overall average season? What would you rather rewatch: Eren carrying the boulder scene or Gabi reloading her gun? This season has nothing that makes one go "holy shit this is insane". I guess you can say as Carla did in previous season: "You don't need to be special, it's enough that you are average." Except when you are average, you are doomed to fall into oblivion the moment you die/end. And that's what will happen with this season. Sadly. |
|
Mar 25, 2021 9:30 AM
#141
If it's anything like Dorohedoro then i'm pleased. |
Mar 25, 2021 11:07 AM
#142
| That's the thing for me. I feel like Attack on Titan's art and animation, while having ~dem sakuga moments~ from time-to-time, was never the absolute best, especially when you have stuff like Demon Slayer and practically anything Masaaki Yuasa does in the game. That's not to say I think AOT has bad art/animation, not at all, but EVERYTHING else is what made the anime work so good. I mean, even looking at the manga, to this day I wouldn't say Isayama is a very good artist, especially when you have other manga like Berserk or Land of the Lustrous out there. Everything else about AOT just makes up for the art not being top tier stuff. That's not to say I would excuse anything if I was genuinely bothered by AOT's art/animation in the anime, but I don't see it as a massive downgrade at all, because it was just never the absolute highlight for me. Everything else is what's made AOT one of my favorite stories ever told. |
Mar 25, 2021 11:15 AM
#143
| Seeing the dscussions in hindsight is also quite entertaining. "MAPPA will have better sakuga than WIT!" ... "Guys. There's still Levi vs Zeke." ... "AoT WaS NeVeR AbOuT AnImAtIoN!" "WIT's animation was even worse!" |
Mar 25, 2021 11:53 AM
#144
Kharan said: it’s actually astonishing how low my expectations were and I still got that disappointedSeeing the dscussions in hindsight is also quite entertaining. "MAPPA will have better sakuga than WIT!" ... "Guys. There's still Levi vs Zeke." ... "AoT WaS NeVeR AbOuT AnImAtIoN!" "WIT's animation was even worse!" |
| Attack on Titan ended with chapter 123 and 130/131 is the epilogue |
Mar 25, 2021 12:11 PM
#145
yaegerist-15 said: Kharan said: it’s actually astonishing how low my expectations were and I still got that disappointedSeeing the dscussions in hindsight is also quite entertaining. "MAPPA will have better sakuga than WIT!" ... "Guys. There's still Levi vs Zeke." ... "AoT WaS NeVeR AbOuT AnImAtIoN!" "WIT's animation was even worse!" Funny thing is the same people that say AoT is not about animation cry about WIT's Collosal cgi. Like... If it wasn't about animation, shouldn't you be grateful that they even animated it at all? |
Mar 25, 2021 12:29 PM
#146
Kharan said: most of them wouldn’t be that fascinated by AoT if it weren’t for the gorgeous animation that was essential for the adaption.yaegerist-15 said: Kharan said: Seeing the dscussions in hindsight is also quite entertaining. "MAPPA will have better sakuga than WIT!" ... "Guys. There's still Levi vs Zeke." ... "AoT WaS NeVeR AbOuT AnImAtIoN!" "WIT's animation was even worse!" Funny thing is the same people that say AoT is not about animation cry about WIT's Collosal cgi. Like... If it wasn't about animation, shouldn't you be grateful that they even animated it at all? |
| Attack on Titan ended with chapter 123 and 130/131 is the epilogue |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Jan 24, 2021 |
997 |
by znjsensej
»»
Oct 10, 5:33 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Mar 7, 2021 |
521 |
by graciana
»»
Oct 9, 1:26 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Jan 31, 2021 |
830 |
by graciana
»»
Oct 8, 11:40 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Dec 20, 2020 |
604 |
by graciana
»»
Oct 6, 3:39 AM |
|
» Dont make those flame wars threads distract you from thisrach1m4n - Mar 14, 2021 |
16 |
by PeterOliver1
»»
Sep 27, 5:39 PM |