Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
Jul 28, 5:44 AM
#1
Offline
Dec 2017
2037
I find it disgusting how they sexualize a character like Bonney so much, even though she turns out to be just a 12-year-old girl. What's wrong with these guys? Because there's no logical reason to show so much fanservice on this character, and the fact that she's depicted as a child makes me find it quite disturbing.
This topic has been locked and is no longer available for discussion.
Pages (2) [1] 2 »
Jul 28, 5:54 AM
#2
Offline
Jan 2025
63
Because everything gets sexualized in this show.

Yes you could consider it weird but they are not actually sexualizing her 0-12 year old form. If anything I think this is one of the better depictions of someone her age in anime (in the flashbacks at least, outside being a pirate captain at age 10). No panty shots, no weird semi thirsty/blush for no reason looks, has an actual varied voice, no loli tropes. Just a child having fun.

Does her adult form in the bodysuit look absurd? Yep it's pretty weird. But it's also a retcon/her actual adult form.

I honestly don't give a crap. I think her design is completely overkill and the anime has being goin full gungho since dress rosa with the chest sizes. But actually worrying about it is some typical 2025 nonsense. People find it disturbing because everyone wants to find everything disturbing. Let's not act like anime hasnt been doing this since day 1. I am more worried about shows like fireforce where the girls sole purpose is getting stripped.
MoimoiWaJul 28, 6:23 AM
Jul 28, 7:00 AM
#3
Offline
Oct 2022
4
that's a physical grown ass women u people complain about anything "um she's 4 years old' meanwhile it's a strong busty fighter
Jul 28, 7:32 AM
#4
Offline
Jul 2025
1
Yea I would have to agree with this even though one piece is one of my favorites.
Jul 28, 7:46 AM
#5
Offline
Sep 2021
819
MoimoiWa said:
Because everything gets sexualized in this show.

Yes you could consider it weird but they are not actually sexualizing her 0-12 year old form. If anything I think this is one of the better depictions of someone her age in anime (in the flashbacks at least, outside being a pirate captain at age 10). No panty shots, no weird semi thirsty/blush for no reason looks, has an actual varied voice, no loli tropes. Just a child having fun.

Does her adult form in the bodysuit look absurd? Yep it's pretty weird. But it's also a retcon/her actual adult form.

I honestly don't give a crap. I think her design is completely overkill and the anime has being goin full gungho since dress rosa with the chest sizes. But actually worrying about it is some typical 2025 nonsense. People find it disturbing because everyone wants to find everything disturbing. Let's not act like anime hasnt been doing this since day 1. I am more worried about shows like fireforce where the girls sole purpose is getting stripped.

It's not a retcon, lol.

Her official age was never confirmed before Egghead. 🤷‍♀️
Jul 28, 7:59 AM
#6
Offline
Sep 2021
819
It's actually/technically, only Toei being weird. ((it's not the first time for Toei exaggerating the body shape of female characters, e.g., Viola in Dressrosa (just look at comparison photos of Viola between the anime and the manga (and like I've said, she's only/just an example of this))


And other than that, her adult form is how she imagines herself as an adult.
Jul 28, 8:01 AM
#7
Offline
Dec 2023
64
bruh did you just watch this anime or something
Jul 28, 8:04 AM
#8
Offline
May 2022
876
Because it was only revealed last year in the manga that she was 12 so any sexualization or fanservice that happened before its reveal in the anime is fair game.
Jul 28, 8:17 AM
#9
Offline
Sep 2022
794
damn bro thats crazy
Jul 28, 8:21 AM
Offline
Jan 2025
63
Reply to Loaf_dontcare
MoimoiWa said:
Because everything gets sexualized in this show.

Yes you could consider it weird but they are not actually sexualizing her 0-12 year old form. If anything I think this is one of the better depictions of someone her age in anime (in the flashbacks at least, outside being a pirate captain at age 10). No panty shots, no weird semi thirsty/blush for no reason looks, has an actual varied voice, no loli tropes. Just a child having fun.

Does her adult form in the bodysuit look absurd? Yep it's pretty weird. But it's also a retcon/her actual adult form.

I honestly don't give a crap. I think her design is completely overkill and the anime has being goin full gungho since dress rosa with the chest sizes. But actually worrying about it is some typical 2025 nonsense. People find it disturbing because everyone wants to find everything disturbing. Let's not act like anime hasnt been doing this since day 1. I am more worried about shows like fireforce where the girls sole purpose is getting stripped.

It's not a retcon, lol.

Her official age was never confirmed before Egghead. 🤷‍♀️
@Loaf_dontcare I like the coping mechanism you got going.

Yes, its not an official retcon. But anyone with half a brain can see its a retcon. Yes the flashbacks were great but the whole idea behind it is extremely forced (like a lot of things since wano)

Oh wait, i forgot ''oda cant do wrong''
Jul 28, 8:23 AM

Offline
Mar 2007
147
Pixels on your screen don't have an age.
Jul 28, 8:26 AM
Offline
Jan 2025
63
Reply to iweebz
Pixels on your screen don't have an age.
@iweebz Yeah people seem to forget this. Authors can literally change ages on the spot (they even did this in some games lol) so people worrying about the ages in anime is actually pretty cringe. But well, American twitter culture caused this

With that being said. Ive said this before but if you're sexualizing her actual child-child form its a bit silly.
Jul 28, 8:58 AM
Offline
Dec 2024
25
fr bro like bonnie is just 12 😭
Jul 28, 9:07 AM

Online
Sep 2016
22006
Because they are trolling the prudes.
*kappa*
Jul 28, 9:12 AM
Offline
Apr 2023
13
I hope you did the same reaction when Momonosuke turned 28 physically, but not mentally. If not, well this is self-explenatory 😃
Jul 28, 9:34 AM
Offline
Sep 2021
819
MoimoiWa said:
@Loaf_dontcare I like the coping mechanism you got going.

Yes, its not an official retcon. But anyone with half a brain can see its a retcon. Yes the flashbacks were great but the whole idea behind it is extremely forced (like a lot of things since wano)

Oh wait, i forgot ''oda cant do wrong''

It's not coping.

Luffy's df is a retcon. (from Gomu gomu no mi to a model of Hito Hito no mi)

This isn't one. 🤷‍♀️
Jul 28, 9:53 AM
Offline
Feb 2022
119
iweebz said:
Pixels on your screen don't have an age.

But you're a real person, so your opinion and reaction about it says more about you than the pixel.
Jul 28, 9:55 AM
Offline
Feb 2022
119
Leon888 said:
I find it disgusting how they sexualize a character like Bonney so much, even though she turns out to be just a 12-year-old girl. What's wrong with these guys? Because there's no logical reason to show so much fanservice on this character, and the fact that she's depicted as a child makes me find it quite disturbing.

Oda supported Nobuhiro Watsuki on Rurouni Kenshin's 30th anniversary, you shouldn't be surprised atp.
Jul 28, 10:09 AM
lagom
Online
Jan 2009
107500
its culture wars again its just a japan culture thing they are obsess with youth like lolis and shotas
Jul 28, 10:45 AM
Offline
Nov 2024
2
are you being willfully obtuse? she's depicted as how she would look if she's grown (20+), not a child.
there are few weird angles here and there but there's nothing crazy, and certainly not when she's actually depicted as a kid.

she literally looks like how a typical female would look in the show.
Jul 28, 10:52 AM

Offline
Apr 2021
200
it's not oda who sexualize it...he draws normally...toei gives it steroids and make it unbelievably gross
Jul 28, 10:58 AM
Offline
Nov 2020
50
Who fucking cares? It’s not a real person.
Jul 28, 11:30 AM
Offline
Jan 2025
63
Reply to Sverkell
Leon888 said:
I find it disgusting how they sexualize a character like Bonney so much, even though she turns out to be just a 12-year-old girl. What's wrong with these guys? Because there's no logical reason to show so much fanservice on this character, and the fact that she's depicted as a child makes me find it quite disturbing.

Oda supported Nobuhiro Watsuki on Rurouni Kenshin's 30th anniversary, you shouldn't be surprised atp.
@Sverkell this is such a stupid argument
Jul 28, 12:20 PM
Offline
Sep 2021
819
ratfakar said:
it's not oda who sexualize it...he draws normally...toei gives it steroids and make it unbelievably gross

Yup. This here. ☝️
Jul 28, 12:21 PM
Offline
Jul 2018
561867
because it's japanese, sexualizing minors is in all their media.
Jul 28, 12:45 PM
Offline
Jul 2021
97
stfu (text,text)
Jul 28, 12:49 PM
Offline
Sep 2021
819
Sverkell said:
Leon888 said:
I find it disgusting how they sexualize a character like Bonney so much, even though she turns out to be just a 12-year-old girl. What's wrong with these guys? Because there's no logical reason to show so much fanservice on this character, and the fact that she's depicted as a child makes me find it quite disturbing.

Oda supported Nobuhiro Watsuki on Rurouni Kenshin's 30th anniversary, you shouldn't be surprised atp.

It's so stupid when people bring this up as an argument. 🤦‍♀️🙄

Oda never supported him in the way you and others mean.

And yes, ofc he "supported him" as in e.g. drawing a character from the manga Rurouni Kenshin as a "celebration" for the anniversary.

And because the author of Rurouni Kenshin (Watsuki) was once his sensei before One Piece officially came to be/got published. (sensei as in -> Oda the assistant for Watsuki)

The work/life culture in japan is just completely/totally different than overseas.

Shueisha themselves (the publisher) practically overlooked Watsuki's case.


Edited.

((and no, I don't support someone like that; people like Watsuki should NORMALLY get what they deserve (morally and logically speaking), but it is what it with japanese work + anime/manga/light etcetera culture))
Loaf_dontcareJul 28, 12:56 PM
Jul 28, 12:51 PM
Offline
Mar 2024
14
I can’t believe Mfs are defending this , it’s so weird sexualising a 12 year old but the one piece glazers are defending it
Jul 28, 1:28 PM
Offline
Aug 2024
83
Because age is completely arbitrary for fictional characters
Jul 28, 3:21 PM
Offline
May 2021
1
Crazy how yall say “your weird so what if she’s 30 she looks so short ” to “you’re weird so why if she looks like a grown woman she’s a kid” please stfu and stop interacting
Jul 28, 3:39 PM
Offline
Aug 2022
274
Weebthedweeb said:
I can’t believe Mfs are defending this , it’s so weird sexualising a 12 year old but the one piece glazers are defending it

shes aged herself to be an adult woman and therefore... (wait for it!) she looks like every other adult one piece women!

its one piece youre either going to have women that all look like nami but with a different hair colour or goblin big mom looking people that look like their family tree is a circle.
Jul 28, 3:49 PM
Offline
Sep 2021
819
Sifer878 said:
Crazy how yall say “your weird so what if she’s 30 she looks so short ” to “you’re weird so why if she looks like a grown woman she’s a kid” please stfu and stop interacting

What's with that photo/"fanart" 💀🫣😭😭
Jul 28, 3:53 PM

Online
Feb 2020
1627
Interesting talk because if we say It is not what is inside, it is what is outside, we are automatically hitting the onibaba lovers. If we say the opposite, we are superficial pigs. So I will take the third option: It your glaze @Leon888 that is sexualizing what you see, she is just there living her pirate live. You should be disturbed by yourself and its impure thoughts.

Jul 28, 7:51 PM
Offline
Jul 2021
856
mentallycoded said:
that's a physical grown ass women u people complain about anything "um she's 4 years old' meanwhile it's a strong busty fighter

Stop defending bro, accept that this is just one of the worst aspects of One piece.
Jul 28, 8:10 PM
Offline
Jul 2021
856
AwokenStroken said:
because it's japanese, sexualizing minors is in all their media.

No it's not. Have you not seen or read AOT, 86, Dr. stone or any other Ghibli movies and most of the Seinen manga (Vinland Saga/ Vagabond) ?!
Jul 28, 8:17 PM
Offline
Jan 2025
24
keep crying buddy
Jul 28, 8:17 PM
Offline
Oct 2021
667
Bro Lord @Leon888 just Dropped One Piece and Give the score 3. He still watching OP and Ragebait anything for his life..
Jul 28, 8:23 PM
Offline
Jan 2025
24
Sverkell said:
Leon888 said:
I find it disgusting how they sexualize a character like Bonney so much, even though she turns out to be just a 12-year-old girl. What's wrong with these guys? Because there's no logical reason to show so much fanservice on this character, and the fact that she's depicted as a child makes me find it quite disturbing.

Oda supported Nobuhiro Watsuki on Rurouni Kenshin's 30th anniversary, you shouldn't be surprised atp.

it's mandatory u fkn loser
Jul 28, 10:59 PM

Offline
Apr 2023
101
cry about it, it's just a character. Fanservice happens in a lot of shows, but no one is forcing u to watch something you're so clearly uncomfortable with.
Jul 29, 5:47 AM
Offline
Feb 2021
10
The Japanese unfortunately are very weird people at times
Jul 29, 7:13 AM
Offline
Aug 2022
31
Deviiilchan said:
cry about it, it's just a character. Fanservice happens in a lot of shows, but no one is forcing u to watch something you're so clearly uncomfortable with.

based comment right there
Jul 29, 7:30 AM

Offline
Apr 2023
101
Reply to giingfreaks
The Japanese unfortunately are very weird people at times
@giingfreaks racist ass thing to say btw
Jul 29, 7:32 AM

Offline
Sep 2018
14393
Because fictional girls are peak, and One Piece is made for straight males.
Jul 29, 8:39 AM
Offline
Jan 2025
63
Reply to Ridzaxster
Bro Lord @Leon888 just Dropped One Piece and Give the score 3. He still watching OP and Ragebait anything for his life..
@Ridzaxster Average woke babyrager probably
Jul 29, 9:18 AM
Offline
Feb 2021
10
Reply to Deviiilchan
@giingfreaks racist ass thing to say btw
@Deviiilchan You're right, the wording was too extreme. But it's undeniable that historically the country has it's problem regarding lolis and sexualization of minors. Which unfortunately reflects itself alot of times in animes and manga, not only in One Piece. Ofcourse that doesn't go for every person that lives there.
Jul 29, 11:30 AM
Offline
Jan 2025
63
Reply to giingfreaks
@Deviiilchan You're right, the wording was too extreme. But it's undeniable that historically the country has it's problem regarding lolis and sexualization of minors. Which unfortunately reflects itself alot of times in animes and manga, not only in One Piece. Ofcourse that doesn't go for every person that lives there.
@giingfreaks meantime they keep it to fiction while girls in the US are sexualizing themselves 24/7 irl. Like don't get me wrong there is stuff like underage idols but if we really compare the amount of sexualization then the west is way worse

" But but have you seen the female school outfits they all have skirts. "

Yeah that's clearly much worse than all the semi nudity going on in the West. Japan certainly has some issues but it's funny how Western woke folks always overreact to fiction while ignoring all the real life problems in their own country. Not to mention all the skin tight outfits in western fiction
Jul 29, 12:04 PM
Offline
Feb 2021
10
MoimoiWa said:
@giingfreaks meantime they keep it to fiction while girls in the US are sexualizing themselves 24/7 irl. Like don't get me wrong there is stuff like underage idols but if we really compare the amount of sexualization then the west is way worse

" But but have you seen the female school outfits they all have skirts. "

Yeah that's clearly much worse than all the semi nudity going on in the West. Japan certainly has some issues but it's funny how Western woke folks always overreact to fiction while ignoring all the real life problems in their own country. Not to mention all the skin tight outfits in western fiction

The west definetly also has it's problem but I don't understand what this whataboutism should lead to. This is a thread regarding the problems within the anime industry. Not one about Japan and the West. No need to point fingers in a different direction when there is clearly a problem at hand that needs to be adressed.
Jul 29, 1:19 PM
Offline
Jan 2025
63
Reply to giingfreaks
MoimoiWa said:
@giingfreaks meantime they keep it to fiction while girls in the US are sexualizing themselves 24/7 irl. Like don't get me wrong there is stuff like underage idols but if we really compare the amount of sexualization then the west is way worse

" But but have you seen the female school outfits they all have skirts. "

Yeah that's clearly much worse than all the semi nudity going on in the West. Japan certainly has some issues but it's funny how Western woke folks always overreact to fiction while ignoring all the real life problems in their own country. Not to mention all the skin tight outfits in western fiction

The west definetly also has it's problem but I don't understand what this whataboutism should lead to. This is a thread regarding the problems within the anime industry. Not one about Japan and the West. No need to point fingers in a different direction when there is clearly a problem at hand that needs to be adressed.
@giingfreaks So we went from JP being weird, to their weirdness reflecting in manga/anime, to it only being an anime/manga problem. Got it

Also it's a bit hard to call it a problem just because some people in the west decided to babyrage about everything.

That's not to say that there's never any weirdness (looking at you pure loli shows) but honestly calling it a problem is kind of laughable. Everyone has this obsession with protecting minors nowadays to the point that they lost sight of reality.

Is the ridiculous fan service a bit cringe, even more if it brings down the quality of the show? Yes ( i mean, what are those k cup boobs on everyone, bonney looks stupid). Is it annoying when female characters are introduced simply for the sake of ripping of their clothing in mainstream shounen? Yes, 100%. Is it gonna affect you or anyone in real life by any means? (unlike the irl nonsense in the west) No, its not. And if you think it is then you yourself might be the problem.

Again don't get me wrong, I pretty much avoid most fanservice shows because I'm not really a fan of them. But we're still talking about a medium that's mostly meant for a younger audience (regardless of how old the fanbase is now). Its not about making ''hot minors''. It's about making the FICTIONAL characters in their manga, meant for younger people hot.

(theres limits tho, shows like Astarotte no Omocha/komodo no jikan go a bit 2 fur)

ps: uzaki chan has already proven that people just don't like boobs/the only real problem is forsaking story for fanservice
pss: i don't wanna defend oda, i think he's overrated, but he's not ''sexualizing the child''.


Hell, i dont even like defending this topic cause the FS in OP is goin overboard but im soooooooooo tired of people babyraging w/o logic.

MoimoiWaJul 29, 1:55 PM
Jul 29, 2:14 PM
Offline
Feb 2022
119
strikeee said:
Sverkell said:

Oda supported Nobuhiro Watsuki on Rurouni Kenshin's 30th anniversary, you shouldn't be surprised atp.

it's mandatory u fkn loser

I know, but Araki still managed to show no support despite that fact.
Jul 29, 2:35 PM
Offline
Feb 2021
10
MoimoiWa said:
@giingfreaks So we went from JP being weird, to their weirdness reflecting in manga/anime, to it only being an anime/manga problem. Got it

Also it's a bit hard to call it a problem just because some people in the west decided to babyrage about everything.

That's not to say that there's never any weirdness (looking at you pure loli shows) but honestly calling it a problem is kind of laughable. Everyone has this obsession with protecting minors nowadays to the point that they lost sight of reality.

Is the ridiculous fan service a bit cringe, even more if it brings down the quality of the show? Yes ( i mean, what are those k cup boobs on everyone, bonney looks stupid). Is it annoying when female characters are introduced simply for the sake of ripping of their clothing in mainstream shounen? Yes, 100%. Is it gonna affect you or anyone in real life by any means? (unlike the irl nonsense in the west) No, its not. And if you think it is then you yourself might be the problem.

Again don't get me wrong, I pretty much avoid most fanservice shows because I'm not really a fan of them. But we're still talking about a medium that's mostly meant for a younger audience (regardless of how old the fanbase is now). Its not about making ''hot minors''. It's about making the FICTIONAL characters in their manga, meant for younger people hot.

(theres limits tho, shows like Astarotte no Omocha/komodo no jikan go a bit 2 fur)

ps: uzaki chan has already proven that people just don't like boobs/the only real problem is forsaking story for fanservice
pss: i don't wanna defend oda, i think he's overrated, but he's not ''sexualizing the child''.


Hell, i dont even like defending this topic cause the FS in OP is goin overboard but im soooooooooo tired of people babyraging w/o logic.


I've already mentioned that me calling Japanese people weird was to much. I honestly didn't put much thought into that and just wanted to quickly comment something without going into the depths of the topic. But yeah it was my mistake for putting up such a comment without thinking that people would (rightfully) be upset about it. So I'll take that part back.

Now regarding the part if it is problematic or not. I honestly think that it is to some degree. Sexualization of minors within anime is so much ingrained within it's culture that even an anime as big as One Piece feels the need to depict it. There are countless of animes that make profit purely trough the depiction of Lolis. What does it say about an society that produces and consumes content like that in such high numbers? Why does the industry feel the need to constantly depict it? Who are the people that seek such content? You're right that a female character being stripped of their clothes in One Piece for example is not the end of the world. But that is only the tip of the iceberg. For me the problematic part is moreso how it came to the point where this is regarded as normal. We as anime fans got numb to it but ask someone who has never watched one what they think about it.

Regarding the last part, I just don't believe that they do it in order to make hot people for their respective demographic. You are saying regardless of how old the fanbase is, but thats not what the Anime comittee is thinking. They are very well aware of who consumes their product (not only children) and give them what they want to see.
This topic has been locked and is no longer available for discussion.
Pages (2) [1] 2 »

More topics from this board

Poll: » One Piece Episode 709 Discussion ( 1 2 )

G_Spark233 - Sep 12, 2015

60 by grimjaw1513 »»
6 hours ago

Poll: » One Piece Episode 130 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

TechDragon - Oct 23, 2009

106 by PraneshChow »»
Yesterday, 11:51 PM

» Most underrated part/arc of OP in your opinion?

DarkFirefly72 - Oct 7

26 by DavidCosmico »»
Yesterday, 10:13 PM

Poll: » One Piece Episode 578 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Fiji - Dec 22, 2012

71 by Yiuumii »»
Yesterday, 2:40 PM

Poll: » One Piece Episode 206 Discussion ( 1 2 )

HaiAlwaysHungry - Nov 9, 2008

65 by ExoTrillionic »»
Yesterday, 2:21 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login