Forum Settings
Forums

Key's Mixed Media Project 'Prima Doll' Gets TV Anime for 2022

New
Pages (2) « 1 [2]
Jan 28, 2022 9:43 AM
Offline
Jan 2021
28
Summer pockets now this, hopefully it’s good
Jan 28, 2022 9:48 AM

Offline
Oct 2016
21
Totoshinoz said:
Manpig said:


Kai did not write the Rewrite anime, the rewrite anime was written by Romeo Tanaka, the original writer of the Rewrite VN, and the reason that had to change was because the Rewrite VN in itself is difficult to adapt.

I think Kud Wafter's anime isn't that bad, it's just a completely different project from the original game. I do agree the liberties were strange though, I attribute it to maybe Kud Wafter's less-than-positive reputation for not having any real drama in the original story.


Kai wrote the anime alongside Tanaka. It's listed on the Rewrite anime production staff articles and he's credited for it. He also did interviews with Tanaka, Hinoue and I think Tensho about the anime production and what to expect from it, so he was very much involved.

I know the anime went a separate path because of how the visual novel routes clash with each other, but the anime still ended up being very messy to the point where they would've been better off adapting a heroine route instead of that original route which was just a collage of all the routes. I get that episode-count was a problem because Aniplex is always stingy with Key, but Tensho and the writers didn't plan accordingly to what they had to work with and it's upsetting because we at the very least could've had 1 proper heroine route adaption if nothing else. Even if they wanted to go with the "original 6th route" as they called it, it should've been written as an actual route rather than a collage.

And yeah, it's not like I was expecting the Kud Wafter anime to be a masterpiece since I heard that the original visual novel barely had a story and I personally don't think Kud's original route from Little Busters was all that strong to begin with compared to the other Little Busters heroine routes, so I wasn't expecting her spin-off to be ideal either, but the anime was still rushed. How do you rush a story when there's not really any story to begin with?

I just don't feel like the Prima Doll staff have anything backing them up for any anime projects they're on. But if Kai did an original anime for Key? That'd be worth checking out.


That's actually quite interesting about Kai since they had nothing to do with Rewrite otherwise, but fair enough.

I don't really agree with the original route being a collage, I felt outside of Kotori, all characters evolved in very different ways compared to the original VN, I do think its its own thing, whether or not people like it.

Kud Wafter is a weird case, I think the main issue is that they were planning on making an accurate adaptation (the original PV even had Ui who got cut out entirely), but halfway through the production they might've decided it wouldn't be right since anime onlies would be confused as to where the rest of the busters are, and because it didn't link with the original story at all.

Either way the concerns are valid, no way on checking how it'd happen other than seeing the anime itself once it airs.


Soul: Blue
Status: Inactive
Jan 28, 2022 10:31 AM
Offline
Jan 2022
11
Manpig said:
[and are planning to announce their next full-length visual novel this Spring.

Did they confirm that?
Jan 28, 2022 12:47 PM

Offline
Oct 2016
21
Just4FunAcc said:
Manpig said:
[and are planning to announce their next full-length visual novel this Spring.

Did they confirm that?


Not officially, but they said they were going to announce a new work "at the usual time"
Key often announces things in Spring for April Fools, if not a few days afterwards


Soul: Blue
Status: Inactive
Jan 28, 2022 1:18 PM

Offline
Jun 2014
1202
RobertBobert said:
Thai777 said:
Script -> no Jun Maeda

Good.

Hopefully the anime will have a decent pacing for once. I'm cautiously optimistic.


People rejoicing at the absence of Jun in Key is like rejoicing that they didn’t put sausage in your hot dog


I'd rather just have the bread if the sausage is sure to be rotten. It avoid me the trouble of taking it out myself.
Jan 28, 2022 3:05 PM

Offline
Apr 2012
21435
Thai777 said:
RobertBobert said:


People rejoicing at the absence of Jun in Key is like rejoicing that they didn’t put sausage in your hot dog


I'd rather just have the bread if the sausage is sure to be rotten. It avoid me the trouble of taking it out myself.


In that case, Key just isn't for you. It's like calling yourself a Children of Bodom fan and constantly whining that Laiho is a shitty composer.

Manpig said:
Just4FunAcc said:

Did they confirm that?


Not officially, but they said they were going to announce a new work "at the usual time"
Key often announces things in Spring for April Fools, if not a few days afterwards


Hope it will be better than Rewrite. The SoL part was a masterpiece, but then everything turned into some kind of lazy version of Higurashi.
Jan 28, 2022 11:02 PM

Offline
Jun 2014
1202
RobertBobert said:
Thai777 said:


I'd rather just have the bread if the sausage is sure to be rotten. It avoid me the trouble of taking it out myself.


In that case, Key just isn't for you. It's like calling yourself a Children of Bodom fan and constantly whining that Laiho is a shitty composer.


Key doesn't have to be defined by Jun Maeda writing. We can still have him composing music and have new fresh writer take over. Why shackle yourself with him when he himself said he was done with writing? I often feel he continues to write only because of the fan's pressure.

Summer pockets and Rewrite did fine without his writing. I'd rather have new stuff and fail than have another Charlotte or The day I became god.
Jan 29, 2022 12:51 PM

Offline
Apr 2012
21435
Thai777 said:
RobertBobert said:


In that case, Key just isn't for you. It's like calling yourself a Children of Bodom fan and constantly whining that Laiho is a shitty composer.


Key doesn't have to be defined by Jun Maeda writing. We can still have him composing music and have new fresh writer take over. Why shackle yourself with him when he himself said he was done with writing? I often feel he continues to write only because of the fan's pressure.

Summer pockets and Rewrite did fine without his writing. I'd rather have new stuff and fail than have another Charlotte or The day I became god.


Why don't you mention the same Angel Beats, which were a masterpiece and were written by him, for example? Also, Charlotte was also pretty good, aside from the idiotic ending. Yes, Jun was not the only author of Kei. But he is more or less the heart of the whole brand. And compared to the old games, Rewrite didn't leave me with any special memories.
Jan 29, 2022 1:55 PM

Offline
Jun 2014
1202
RobertBobert said:
Thai777 said:


Key doesn't have to be defined by Jun Maeda writing. We can still have him composing music and have new fresh writer take over. Why shackle yourself with him when he himself said he was done with writing? I often feel he continues to write only because of the fan's pressure.

Summer pockets and Rewrite did fine without his writing. I'd rather have new stuff and fail than have another Charlotte or The day I became god.


Why don't you mention the same Angel Beats, which were a masterpiece and were written by him, for example? Also, Charlotte was also pretty good, aside from the idiotic ending. Yes, Jun was not the only author of Kei. But he is more or less the heart of the whole brand. And compared to the old games, Rewrite didn't leave me with any special memories.


Because Angel Beats was decent. Not so much for the rest, but angel beat was 11-12 years ago, not that relevant.

You can have your opinion on Charlotte just like with Rewrite, it still won't change my opinion that Maeda has not written anything impressive for over a decade and so I'm more happy with someone else taking the writing mantle in this new Key project.
Jan 29, 2022 1:56 PM

Offline
Apr 2012
21435
Thai777 said:
RobertBobert said:


Why don't you mention the same Angel Beats, which were a masterpiece and were written by him, for example? Also, Charlotte was also pretty good, aside from the idiotic ending. Yes, Jun was not the only author of Kei. But he is more or less the heart of the whole brand. And compared to the old games, Rewrite didn't leave me with any special memories.


Because Angel Beats was decent. Not so much for the rest, but angel beat was 11-12 years ago, not that relevant.

You can have your opinion on Charlotte just like with Rewrite, it still won't change my opinion that Maeda has not written anything impressive for over a decade and so I'm more happy with someone else taking the writing mantle in this new Key project.


Well if nothing will change your mind then why do you keep arguing lol?
Jan 29, 2022 2:03 PM

Offline
Jun 2014
1202
RobertBobert said:
Thai777 said:


Because Angel Beats was decent. Not so much for the rest, but angel beat was 11-12 years ago, not that relevant.

You can have your opinion on Charlotte just like with Rewrite, it still won't change my opinion that Maeda has not written anything impressive for over a decade and so I'm more happy with someone else taking the writing mantle in this new Key project.


Well if nothing will change your mind then why do you keep arguing lol?


Because you are the one who is trying to say that Key is Jun Maeda and without him they are nothing which is not how I view it. I'm not trying to change your view either, I'm just offering you my perspective. Maeda can have enough impact with just his music, there's no need to have him on the script.
Jan 29, 2022 2:17 PM

Offline
Apr 2012
21435
Thai777 said:
RobertBobert said:


Well if nothing will change your mind then why do you keep arguing lol?


Because you are the one who is trying to say that Key is Jun Maeda and without him they are nothing which is not how I view it. I'm not trying to change your view either, I'm just offering you my perspective. Maeda can have enough impact with just his music, there's no need to have him on the script.


Really? I never said anywhere that Kei is nothing without him. It's you who decided for some reason that defending the importance of Maeda means ignoring the contributions of anyone other than him. Anyway, this is starting to turn into a typical "bandleader leaving" thread, so the best solution is to end it right here and now.
Jan 29, 2022 11:25 PM
Offline
Oct 2013
99
I wouldn't get my hopes up. How many times have we been disappointed with Key's anime? The last decent anime from them was Planetarian.
Feb 13, 2022 7:16 PM
Offline
Mar 2019
101
Would you believe my favorite Key-related anime from the past 10 years was Kaginado?
Pages (2) « 1 [2]

More topics from this board

» 'Hikaru ga Shinda Natsu' Reveals Main Cast, Staff, Teaser for Summer 2025

Vindstot - 8 hours ago

8 by Temperanced »»
18 minutes ago

» 'Akuyaku Reijou Tensei Ojisan' Unveils Additional Cast

Nioxys - Nov 14

1 by StephenJParnell »»
52 minutes ago

» 'Kono Light Novel ga Sugoi!' 2025 Rankings Revealed

Snow - Yesterday

14 by Temperanced »»
9 hours ago

» 'Babanbabanban Vampire' Announces Additional Cast Pair

Vindstot - Nov 25

11 by KietaTeenRomance »»
10 hours ago

» Novel 'Shabake' Receives TV Anime in 2025

Nioxys - Nov 25

3 by Memore »»
Yesterday, 3:42 AM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login