Mini Game v1: Attack on Titan Mafia S2 | Game Thread | Serial Killer (Suzune-chan) has won!

coromandel said:


It's not even like I'm keeping all my reads to myself anyway, so what is your problem?? I've said what I thought about suzune, you, RE, yurkin, Ruu, roz.
I've stated my thoughts on those players, but you're talking about me as if I don't share anything at all. That's wrong, and you know it. Yurkin is keeping her reads much more to herself than me, and yet you're not going after her, you're just tunneling on me. Care to explain why?
This tells me you're just using this argument to justify your read on me. But it's fallacious.

coromandel said:


It's not even like I'm keeping all my reads to myself anyway, so what is your problem?? I've said what I thought about suzune, you, RE, yurkin, Ruu, roz.
I've stated my thoughts on those players, but you're talking about me as if I don't share anything at all. That's wrong, and you know it. Yurkin is keeping her reads much more to herself than me, and yet you're not going after her, you're just tunneling on me. Care to explain why?
This tells me you're just using this argument to justify your read on me. But it's fallacious.

RE1031 said:

No (there are other things that do...), but I have complaining rights.

@coromandel
I think you've been asked this already, but why didn't you vote in self defense? I don't think a vote on Suzune because you think she is scum is adequate enough of an answer. Were there nobody else with 2 vote trains that you didn't have an inkling of a suspicion of? And you said that you believed Ruu to be town. I'm not blaming you for this part, but did you consider building a countertrain to save her?

logic340 said:
Now yurking is behind you but earlier....EoD1 instead of giving me read you gave me weak self defense and refused to talk about the players. Now you still haven't discussed half the player base and I am just supposed to be ok with that? What if scum is in the half you have you to talk about? This makes me feel like you have something to hide. Like information on those players. Be a little more open and I will try to back off you a little bit deal?

coromandel said:


Partly because I wanted to be lynched. I didn't want to continue playing this game tbh.
I even considered voting for myself, but that's not allowed. ("play to your win condition")

I didn't have a good case against anyone at that time. I didn't even fully scum-read logic, part of me was thinking he was stubborn town - which I've changed my mind about this phase. The only people who had more than 1 vote were ruu, yurkin and roz and I didn't scum-read any of them. Aa-dono had 1 vote but she said she didn't have a good internet connection. I had no read on her and she wasn't there to defend herself.

coromandel said:

No.
How many other people haven't given her opinion on half the playerbase? Many, but you're not suspecting them for it.

yurkin said:
Btw...

(logic to coro, iso) #619 "basically you thought they were scum too but didn't vote for them? Which is weird in itself when you stop and think about it?"

(logic to coro regarding suzune's not voting ruu) #727 "also there are ways to find scum without pressure voting you know that right?

- um then why is coro not voting roz any different that suzune not voting ruu?; ofc this is about certain point in time of the game not about the whole d1.

yurkin said:
logic #1110
Looked from another standpoint they are.

Suzune scum read ruu based on her reaction to roz and abus posts, but do not vote there.

Coro initial reaction is believing rozs post is slip, but do not vote there.

I see them as one of the same thing.

yurkin said:

Hmm actually no.
You all were convinced im scum from quite a little, so i dont see why i should do the exact opposite of you all and "do a lot of convincing."

Convince me that i myself am scum instead.

coromandel said:

It's too early to tell.
Her read on you seems pretty in-depth and it made me think she's town for a wihle. But you could still be scum together. She's only accused you during twilight phase, without backing up her thoughts with a vote. So that doesn't make me suddenly think "they can't possibly be scum together."

yurkin said:
#1114 --> #1113

Suzune-chan said:
I don't understand? Are you saying a post is missing?

Suzune-chan said:
I don't understand? Are you saying a post is missing?

Rinto-kun said:
Uh... hello everyone?

Rinto-kun said:
Uh... hello everyone?

yurkin said:
logic #1110
Looked from another standpoint they are.
Suzune scum read ruu based on her reaction to roz and abus posts, but do not vote there.
Coro initial reaction is believing rozs post is slip, but do not vote there.
I see them as one of the same thing.

logic340 said:
How is this the same when Suzune moved her vote right back to Ruu? While in the post where Coro makes her suspicions known she RVS votes Suzune? These are nowhere near the same thing you need to find a better example or move on to something else.

lastwhisper31 said:
Actually it almost feels like you and RE just attack everything thats against ur agenda. I mean ya thats part of mafia, but you guys do it in a way that just seems so aggressive like in the sense "How dare you make such a stupid comment", and my scum lean on RE wont be changing anytime soon and I might need to look into you. @Logic340, not gunna let you control the game like your usual self.
Edit: words

roz1roz said:
More questions why I did it?
1. I said earlier I prefer Yurkin here over Coro
2. My top scum read tries to snipe my top town read up, when lowering Yurking wagon

It was my natural reaction for countersniping in multi-lynch game.

If I really wanted to have a town-read for that, I wouldn't point that it actualy didn't save the twilight phase, just changed the candidates.

Oh and probably one more reason - I was in other game in the same time and scum actualy sniped the lynch there... around 2 hours earlier before Abu's one.

If you really expected me to allow someone to snipe without quick reaction, you was wrong.

Also, I'm still not buying Yurkins defense. I would prefer Abu, Suzuke or even logic there, but I don't see a point in no-lynching.

Lynches are the thing wich gives us most information, cause it allows to confirm the aligment of lynched person. I will vote Yurkin to be executed as of now.

yurkin said:
logic #1125
i did saw my mistake now after rereading that part. The time stamps were too close to one another for that comparison to be true :< ...

Though i got pretty annoyed at how you said i have no right to comment of someone else vote... at this certain thing about suzu's vote i was wrong.

roz1roz said:
Also, I'm still not buying Yurkins defense. I would prefer Abu, Suzuke or even logic there, but I don't see a point in no-lynching.

Lynches are the thing wich gives us most information, cause it allows to confirm the aligment of lynched person. I will vote Yurkin to be executed as of now.

Rinto-kun said:
Vote: No lynch
I'd rather not lynch until I sort out my thoughts about the players.

logic340 said:
@RE1031 you read on AbuHumaid feels weird considering we just got out of a town game with him were I went through hell and high water to keep that mislynch from happening. Though I am liking you more of town now than yesterday I would like you to go into more detail on what he was missing here?

logic340 said:
I say that because of your refusal to use your own vote. What right do you have to comment on a vote when you wont give us the ability to do the same?

RE1031 said:

Do you remember the post I townread him for? I didn't see anything of the like here.

yurkin said:

Ah so.
Thats not better than #1113, you simply double down on it. Why quoting me again to just tell the same stuff anyway.

Suzune-chan said:
I am also going to vote like this
Vote: No Lynch
As I do not have a scum read on Yurkin just not much. Not that they were very helpful in making a read on them.

logic340 said:

2. I really wish you would try to get the opinions of others in regards to your top scum read who only you were voting. Also many of us wanted Ruu there. This is a town vs. mafia game not roz vs. mafia think about that before you make another selfish move like that please

logic340 said:
@roz1roz if we are lost at the end of day tomorrow will you battle me in twilight? Let's make our own rules no no lynch or double lynch you or me one must go?
I kind of feel like coro was right you made this play but haven't done much but go after Abu which most of ust told you was lynch fodder and actually looks more town to me for his late vote that you call a snipe. Use a more neutral word as i see it differently than you do and snipe has such a negative connotation like you are trying to make him look bad. He does that well enough himself you don't need to try so hard it makes your read look forced and bad.