Kit said: clearly not what i said. I would just consider you less "pretty much confirmed" "I think the way logic claimed makes him almost confirmed anyway, unless scum team has someone that makes very convincing convoluted fake claims.. (just IMO)" Maybe one day I will join the ranks of Penta and Lam-B but the one time i came up with a fake claim (spent a lot of time on it) I chickened out. This is what I am just a lone poet with a bunch of one shot tricks up my sleeve. Though similarly to a claim you made (in a game I can't speak of right now) since there are only a few people good enough to make that type of fake claim imo. |
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC  |
DenjaX said: If you were a gladiator who would you choose to duel today?Also, I am on mobile so I will be at a disadvantage for ninjas during EoD Step outside now you cowards. |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
logic340 said: me and grrr. Id obviously lose but i be able to prove my point with a flip and it will compensate with my terrible argument.DenjaX said: If you were a gladiator who would you choose to duel today?Also, I am on mobile so I will be at a disadvantage for ninjas during EoD Step outside now you cowards. |
Coelestin said: There's nothing better than being alive. The Private Detective Agency showed me that. It is my home, my save heaven. And when it's under attack, I will fight. For this, I ask for your help. Beast Beneath the Moonlight, reveal yourself! Reveal: Innocent Child @Suzune-chan @SoulEaterQUEEN @Shinichi-kun Thank you for revealing my role for absolutely NO reason -_____________________- @logic340 Sorry that you had to make that ISO read despite me claiming now anyways. Will be back in a few hours. WHy hide it lool theres people that literally suspected you so why waste our times and resources when u can make our lives so much easier. Idk why i had to ask u to do it myself. |
  |
logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: @Shinichi you know I am good for that XDoh by any chance do u know the post number of pentas claims? i need to check something This is going to seem weird, but I'm trying something new. One of the following claims are true. You could spend some time trying to decipher this if you want, but I'm mostly just trying to mess with the mafia's heads. 1. I'm town vengeful. If you lynch me I've got my brutal aimed at Karote. 2. I'm virgin. Lynch me and there is no night kill. 3. I'm a 1-Shot Vigilante who can not shoot day 1 and was roleblocked last night. 4. I'm a tracker who has been tracking grrr every phase to see whether the nurse claim is justified and have not seen them perform an action. 5. I'm a mason with a top secret mason buddy. 6. I'm a mayor that hasn't revealed because I haven't been under significant pressure. Once I reveal I will be unable to be protected from death, implying there is a doctor but no strongman. 7. I am a town roleblocker who has blocked grrr every phase to see what will happen. 8. I'm a spy and have gotten snippets of the mafia conversation about who they think they can mislynch, which clears grrr, but was roleblocked night 2 and heard nothing. 9. I'm a 1-Shot lie detector and verified grrr's Nurse claim. 10. I'm a type of vanilla cop that can determine whether someone attempted to perform an action last night and have determined that neither grrr nor Ruu attempted actions. 11. I'm the real transporter, but it is a 2-shot ability I haven't used yet. 12. I'm an odd day doublevoter. 13. I'm a special type of doctor that can only stop attempted suicides instead of night kills but do not know what kind of ability would cause that. 14. I'm a martyr that will die in place of my target and has a 50% chance of revealing the killer. 15. I'm a vanilla town. Ok well if penta hasnt claimed yet i can confirm his role is here lol |
|
Jackrito said: Suzune-chan said: The Moon Rises The full moon was beginning to rise as night was upon the ability users. Everyone was fighting. It was becoming apparent that the darkness they were looking for was lurking in those closest to them. Friends turning on friends.  "Stop fighting. We need to think this through. We need to relax a little. I am not your enemy." Atsushi announces. Coelestin has been revealed as Atsushi Nakajima (Beast Beneath the Moonlight) the innocent child. b] @Logic340, @Sleipnirr, @Shinichi-Kun, @Kit, @Aa-dono, @DenjaX, @Jackrito, @Grrr,, @Pentaflare, @LucianRoy, @Coelestin, @Qoco Well that is that cleared would rather that be revealed later tbh to catch a bad scum push on her. This could have just led to a town being lynched too tho lol |
|
Jackrito said: aa-dono said: If they're both town, isn't it fine? Not really he should not know that off his role, it bothers me the disintrest in that. it bothers me too tbh DenjaX said: Jackrito said: I cant even find the post about him talking her role.Why is no one asking how Shinichi knew Chione's role? Really lol? did everyone in the game miss that post but chione |
|
DenjaX said: aa-dono said: thats not how it works.This happens Day 4 or during the night? Could it be someone checks Coel and Shinichi got the result? But that's not how it works, right? Everything redirect to him means whatever result people get is all based off Shinichi.. But lets say lightning rod also takes night results. Even if we have another cop, he would learn his own alignment only. But it would have been greatly utilised if there was a watcher and he learned who visited him. But I dont think lightning rod works that way. Would have been cool tho. @Shinichi-Kun Ill tell u this i did get the information due to my lighting rod ability but im still backreading so idk if more already got revealed. |
|
DenjaX said: aa-dono said: Segregation duties is my way of doing to sort out alignments from players.Good. I've been meaning to ask: What's segregation duties? Other than that, I'm assuming it means you think I'm town. Why? Seems like general consensus is "I don't know where to place you" and "scum" when it comes to me. So what post or posts made you think I'm town? Off topic: Astros urged me to. He's the only fan of my bookclub. And oof, unfortunately, I cannot provide you the posts you made because I am on mobile atm and I will be on mobile for the rest of the phase. But your posts helped me when I was catching up. Your posts were easy to read and I was able to see the current state of the game much faster. Why give it a weird name thats pretty much what everyones been trying to do, giving it some sort of forced flavor just seems weird. |
|
aa-dono said: I've only skimmed through things. Anyway, I hate that lighting rod thing and I have no idea why you guys suggested that. Probably explained, but I can't remember it. 1. All it does is confirm Shin's ability. If he wasn't up for a lynch why does he need to do it? 2. It doesn't help check Qoco who was also a lynch candidate. 3. Unless I get the ability wrong, then everything gets redirected to Shinichi which means that it's a wasted night for informative roles to get info. If you there's a manipulation role like Carrot, I don't think only informative role is Cop. Also, to town. Do you really believe all those claims? Look at your role pm, and look at the flips and tell me that you think all of them are right. @PentaFlare What did you achieve from the Shin's ability? @Coelestin I thought Innocent Child is revealed at the start of game? Are you ignoring the biggest 1 up of the entire night? No one died which helps us greatly, anything else that happened would have just been a bonus. If was better to use it now than to wait for the doctor to die then i just become a martyr. |
|
Shinichi-Kun said: Nobody does it the Denja way. Like putting myself on the spot to get reactions to discern their alignment. You can ask logic for some instances.DenjaX said: Segregation duties is my way of doing to sort out alignments from players. And oof, unfortunately, I cannot provide you the posts you made because I am on mobile atm and I will be on mobile for the rest of the phase. But your posts helped me when I was catching up. Your posts were easy to read and I was able to see the current state of the game much faster. Why give it a weird name thats pretty much what everyones been trying to do, giving it some sort of forced flavor just seems weird. |
DenjaX said: Also Sleip is bad for not taking the modkill. This statement is just unfair |
|
aa-dono said: Jackrito said: Actually now that I thought of it...To this I think it was a good night it confimed Shinichi and that we do have a healer, not sure the issue. No one died either On claims no I don\t believe them town has too much imo to stop kills. Also with no death on Shinichi likely no strongman to balance that as well. grrr is moved back to town for me. The roles are flavoured according to anime. So a healer with a condition makes sense. Question. Hypothetically, if a roleblocker exist, what alignment do you think they'll be in? If a roleblocker did exist it have to be scum aligned because if we had a town aligned roleblocker holy crap would we be way too pwerful, generally speaking tho i doubt their is a roleblocker unless its the kind that doesnt tell people they have been roleblocked. Also roles arent flavored cause if thats true idk why i would be a lightning rod lmfao |
|
DenjaX said: Jackrito said: If you let mistrust/doubts get over you all the time, you wont able to find progress. I proceeded with caution because that is the best thing to do. Well that is the only thing I can do. It is true that there are scum in the midst but it is also true that there are town among us as well.That last bit makes no sense if they are a doubt dont trust them that much or you get led to mislynches. We are way beyond the doubting part its day 4, gut feelings are our greatest allies at this point, our first couple lynches were us being careful thats exactly how a tie happened. |
|
aa-dono said: Jackrito said: Oh, I missed this. (I would ask if you could link me to it, but it's alright.... when my energy comes back, I'll re-read everything properly.)On the ascetic claim Lamb and Denjax both lied on that and now claims he has a OP 1 shot ablity. I sort of see that as a don't lynch me I can save you and win game claim though. OP 1 shot ability is too much. That would render Shin's ability useless. Since that was pretty OP. I don't distrust he have an OP role though. If town have Shin's role, then mafia should have one too. Vote: DenjaX Sorry Shishou. Thank you for trusting me. I can't return you the favour ;-; I agree its possible scum do have a strng ability like mine. Either way its really not looking good for denja im hoping he claims before phase ends. Change Vote:denjax |
|
Shinichi-Kun said: tell that to Jack. I am not stuck on doubting people.DenjaX said: If you let mistrust/doubts get over you all the time, you wont able to find progress. I proceeded with caution because that is the best thing to do. Well that is the only thing I can do. It is true that there are scum in the midst but it is also true that there are town among us as well. We are way beyond the doubting part its day 4, gut feelings are our greatest allies at this point, our first couple lynches were us being careful thats exactly how a tie happened. |
I demand a visual novel right now |
|
DenjaX said: Shinichi-Kun said: tell that to Jack. I am not stuck on doubting people.We are way beyond the doubting part its day 4, gut feelings are our greatest allies at this point, our first couple lynches were us being careful thats exactly how a tie happened. Oh well i town read jack, i honestly thought u were saying ur still being doubtful i read this wrong then lol |
|
Vote Count 4.4 PentaFlare: Kit, aa-dono Jackrito: Coelestin, DenjaX DenjaX: Jackrito, Shinichi-Kun Sleipnirr: Grrr Not Voting:, Pentaflare, Qoco, Sleipnirr, Logic340, What has already transpired Phase Day one! || Vote count 1.1 || 1.2 || 1.3 || 1.4 || 1.5 || 1.6 || 1.7 || 1.8 || 1.9 || 1.10 || 1.11 || 1.12 || 1.13 || 1.14 || 1.15 Night one Day 2 || Vote Count 2.0 || 2.1 || 2.2 || 2.3 || 2.4 || 2.5 || 2.6 || 2.7 || 2.8 || 2.9 || 2.10 || 2.11 Night 2 Day 3 || Vote Count 3.0 || 3.1 || 3.2 || 3.3 || 3.4 || 3.5 || 3.6 || 3.7 || 3.8 || 3.9 || 3.10 || 3.11 Night 3 Day 4 || 4.1 || 4.2 || 4.3 || 4.4 Timer |
SoulEaterQUEENApr 28, 2017 11:33 AM
 |
| @Shinichi-kun you say gut feeling is out best ally at this time so what is your gut telling you about aa-dono? Mine is not saying town at t his time. |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
| No he hasn't claimed yet. I think I have an idea based on my own role and things he has said throughout the game. |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
DenjaX said: Are you going to be able to make it to a computer? Do you want to claim before you phone dies if not? I haven't seen enough "Best Town" from you to offer my unyielding protection like I normally would. How do you feel about aa-dono? I haven't been able to make a definitive read either way. I can't even say she is scummy of meta because I think I would have found it hard to read her until she claimed in the sailor moon game that just ended. Rip 6% battery |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
logic340 said: DenjaX said: If you were a gladiator who would you choose to duel today?Also, I am on mobile so I will be at a disadvantage for ninjas during EoD Step outside now you cowards. Damn you guessed what I think his super powerful role is |
|
| Annoying how 2 of the big scum reads are inactive right now |
|
logic340 said: @Shinichi-kun you say gut feeling is out best ally at this time so what is your gut telling you about aa-dono? Mine is not saying town at t his time. mine isnt saying town either |
|
i meant me and grrr obviously |
|
Shinichi-Kun said: logic340 said: @Shinichi-kun you say gut feeling is out best ally at this time so what is your gut telling you about aa-dono? Mine is not saying town at t his time. mine isnt saying town either I must be the only person that does then lol. Possible I'm just been insane but as said before I like the way she interacts with me out of that it is nto grear. They are of course on POE for me but a couple come first also I want to see what they claim |
|
logic340 said: i said aa dono is good peopleDenjaX said: Are you going to be able to make it to a computer? Do you want to claim before you phone dies if not? I haven't seen enough "Best Town" from you to offer my unyielding protection like I normally would. How do you feel about aa-dono? I haven't been able to make a definitive read either way. I can't even say she is scummy of meta because I think I would have found it hard to read her until she claimed in the sailor moon game that just ended. Rip 6% battery |
| Are you saying Penta is town? |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
logic340 said: Are you saying Penta is town? no im saying his role is actually in that list lol where did i say he was town |
|
DenjaX said: aa-dono said: oh you finally saw my mini segregation duty. Good jobActually, I changed my mind again. Denja could be not scum. When Carrot claimed, he asked Carrot if Carrot was roleblocked. Since he lied about his role, he knew that Carrot wasn't roleblocked. But he asked anyway, wanting to check Carrot's reaction. If he's scum, checking this reaction is unnecessary. Then he was against Carrot's train. Which could be due to him knowing that Carrot's town. (Since well, if Carrot was scum, he would have said he got roleblocked.) So back to Vote: PentaFlare Hmm am i missing something here im pretty sure he was just confirming stuff, karote would have had no reason to lie or say he was roleblocked nor give any weird reaction all he had to do was just say he wants roleblocked. |
|
| @Shinichi-kun, @PentaFlare, @Kit, @aa-dono, @Jackrito, @Coelestin, @DenjaX, @Sleipnirr, @Grrr, @Qoco Are we letting Qoco prove his ability tonight? |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Shinichi-Kun said: You didn't which is why I asked for clarification instead of implying or outright saying "Shinichi said Penta is town". So you know for a fact that Penta's role is in the list? You don't have to tell me what you think it is be what do you think it means for his alignment?logic340 said: Are you saying Penta is town? no im saying his role is actually in that list lol where did i say he was town |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
logic340 said: @Shinichi-kun, @PentaFlare, @Kit, @aa-dono, @Jackrito, @Coelestin, @DenjaX, @Sleipnirr, @Grrr, @Qoco Are we letting Qoco prove his ability tonight? This is the last shot. After this I'm vanilla. |
 |
| @Qoco I told you I would work with you today. I have asked multiple times. If someone doesn't prove your ability I cannot and will not hold it against you. |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
| @Qoco how do you feel about the three current lynch options? Penta/Denja/Jack? |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
| unvote Until I've finally caught up. Still stuck somewhere on page 64. |
 |
Coelestin said: @Jackrito You said you are naturally wary of Denja because he hasn't claimed yet but you aren't wary of dono? I'm of course wary of them and want them to claim, but I'm just not getting a strong scum feel from them this game.not q strong one town one either though. I don't feel confident in that lynch like I would one on Penta or Denjax and a lesser degree Quco. I know you disagree but it is not happening for me a gut thing I guess but I have been wrong s lot already so maybe wrong again |
|
logic340 said: How do these questions about Denja's role help you discern his alignment? Not behavioural, but still a read. |
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal. ~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~ |
Kit said: Sleipnirr said: I think the way logic claimed makes him almost confirmed anyway, unless scum team has someone that makes very convincing convoluted fake claims.. (just IMO)Sadly I know that shinichi is inheritor and confirmed lightning Rod. This put me in a really bad spot because in order to catch up as efficient as possible I tend to skip some long posts like jacks and logic's. Not in the way that I did not read them but read them too quickly that only some minor details left impression on me. So in the players I paid attention to shinichi is a no go and all of logic's post seemed townie. I am not gonna lie logic town read might be biased as I never saw a scum logic anway so there is only penta and jack left in my possible to be scum list and honestly I am still trying to figure out whoch one might be the scum penta seem more likely but most of jacks posts seemed to repeat itself. I'm still concerned about jack myself and that is not a good sign for me since last game I was in with him it seemed so easy to read him. Either it's just a simple matter of different game different behavior or he's scum. Though I'm more convinced on Penta though I am started to wonder if I'm having confirmation bias as every time he responds to me it seems scummy as he just disregards my point it seems, though at the same time he has defended me iirc. What do you think of Chione? She is apparently part of her self-declared "trinity" (chione, jack, and penta) Dunno if you've reached the part yet, but if you have, can you tell me what you think about Penta's actions at the end of D2? And I think it has turned into a quaternity xD |
|
Coelestin said: Kit said: I think the way logic claimed makes him almost confirmed anyway, unless scum team has someone that makes very convincing convoluted fake claims.. (just IMO) I'm still concerned about jack myself and that is not a good sign for me since last game I was in with him it seemed so easy to read him. Either it's just a simple matter of different game different behavior or he's scum. Though I'm more convinced on Penta though I am started to wonder if I'm having confirmation bias as every time he responds to me it seems scummy as he just disregards my point it seems, though at the same time he has defended me iirc. What do you think of Chione? She is apparently part of her self-declared "trinity" (chione, jack, and penta) Dunno if you've reached the part yet, but if you have, can you tell me what you think about Penta's actions at the end of D2? And I think it has turned into a quaternity xD Oh, and his explanation post after that as well. |
|
Sleipnirr said: @kit well from the single page I paid attention to co-something (cant spell the new name sorry) (also not like I can ignor it the whole page is about her fighting with aa) anyway she seemed pretty confident about her reads on dono and carrot and considering that carrot was lynched dp 2 and dono is still alive a pretty weird situation. She strongly pushed her targets and was almost sure that her targets were scum and her attack on dono seemed weak like there was no substance to it. This could mean that there is a possuble wifom situation since we always assume that scum would not be confident and always leave a backroom when their target appears town she might use this. Though this is not likely. Sounds like you're not confident enough to actually scum read me despite me acting scummy. |
|
aa-dono said: I've only skimmed through things. Anyway, I hate that lighting rod thing and I have no idea why you guys suggested that. Probably explained, but I can't remember it. 1. All it does is confirm Shin's ability. If he wasn't up for a lynch why does he need to do it? 2. It doesn't help check Qoco who was also a lynch candidate. 3. Unless I get the ability wrong, then everything gets redirected to Shinichi which means that it's a wasted night for informative roles to get info. If you there's a manipulation role like Carrot, I don't think only informative role is Cop. Also, to town. Do you really believe all those claims? Look at your role pm, and look at the flips and tell me that you think all of them are right. @PentaFlare What did you achieve from the Shin's ability? @Coelestin I thought Innocent Child is revealed at the start of game? I was doubting Shinichi's townies because his day 3 was really weak. It has been better again this phase though. Having him as very likely town and seeing better behavioural reads allows me to take him out of PoE. I'm really close to having a PoE pool of only a few players. |
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal. ~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~ |
DenjaX said: Also Sleip is bad for not taking the modkill. ... No? |
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal. ~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~ |
Kit said: logic340 said: I like sleip's updates so far, though I suppose even scum could do that so maybe NAI@sleipnirr and @Kit can I get your feeling on each or the claims players have made? Also can I get read lists or just townies to scummiest? I believe grrr, shinichi, and logic. (tho technically i didn't see grrr claim, but no counter claims and there should be a protective bc of the no kill) Penta's list is BS and pointless. Qoco can easily be claiming that without needing to prove it. I find it funny that despite there being a lot of discussion on the lightning rod being use, he decided to "waste" a shot last night anyway. Is someone supposed to visit him when he says he's going to use it, then? That sounds like a waste of someone else's role. prob town: logic, shinichi, grr maybe town: sleip, denja, jack who are you: aa-dono maybe scum: chione, qoco prob scum: penta the "maybe"s subject to frequent change/close to neutral (actually my entire maybe town list are people i've said could be scum...) Can't remember your read on dono, how did they end up at neutral? |
|
I haven't read much from yesterday/today. I skimmed earlier and saw that Chione showed up as Innocent Child, so that's good. iirc from those three, DenjaX claimed Ascetic or some shit, and idk wtf that is. PentaFlare claimed 15 roles, and Jackrito has not claimed yet. I'm down to lynch either one, though my options are not limited to just that. |
|
Coelestin said: Kit said: I like sleip's updates so far, though I suppose even scum could do that so maybe NAI I believe grrr, shinichi, and logic. (tho technically i didn't see grrr claim, but no counter claims and there should be a protective bc of the no kill) Penta's list is BS and pointless. Qoco can easily be claiming that without needing to prove it. I find it funny that despite there being a lot of discussion on the lightning rod being use, he decided to "waste" a shot last night anyway. Is someone supposed to visit him when he says he's going to use it, then? That sounds like a waste of someone else's role. prob town: logic, shinichi, grr maybe town: sleip, denja, jack who are you: aa-dono maybe scum: chione, qoco prob scum: penta the "maybe"s subject to frequent change/close to neutral (actually my entire maybe town list are people i've said could be scum...) Can't remember your read on dono, how did they end up at neutral? I can't even remember that she's playing lmfao. Sneaky sneaky. |
|
DenjaX said: Coelestin said: wot?There's nothing better than being alive. The Private Detective Agency showed me that. It is my home, my save heaven. And when it's under attack, I will fight. For this, I ask for your help. Beast Beneath the Moonlight, reveal yourself! Reveal: Innocent Child @Suzune-chan @SoulEaterQUEEN @Shinichi-kun Thank you for revealing my role for absolutely NO reason -_____________________- @logic340 Sorry that you had to make that ISO read despite me claiming now anyways. Will be back in a few hours. I thought this was a host write up post. Suzu-chan isn't the only one who has a soft spot for stories :') |
|
More topics from this board
» [GAME] Give something to the user above you ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Soren - Oct 9, 2015 |
1395 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 13, 9:10 PM |
|
» [GAME] Last Letter Game ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )grave_robber - Sep 9, 2014 |
8755 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 11, 7:29 PM |
|
» [GAME] (*￣･￣)ﾉ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated MEMBER Posts! v1 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )SoulEaterQUEEN - Mar 26, 2016 |
1996 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 7, 10:20 PM |
|
» [GAME] (*￣･￣)ﾉ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated Staff Member Posts! v4 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Togs - Jul 2, 2017 |
2877 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 7, 10:20 PM |
|
» Count To 7777 V3 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Lambtron - May 15, 2018 |
1170 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 7, 10:20 PM |