Jackrito said: For the record, I believe Karote's claim. I believe people have 2 roles like Rosie have (Deputy - Cop) unless they are vanillas/goons. I think Karote might have a Hider as a modifier.logic340 said: Where is everyone? We need to discuss Karote's final claim. Who believes it's possible and why? I really don't know how to feel about it as I don't know much about balance in a setup. If it's scum aligned (and I believe it could be) then it's dangerous and needs to be dealt with. If it's true (the bus driver claim) then if anyone targeted Karote or Jack N1 they might want to reconsider their results. I don't buy it at all tbh they are some flaws in his thought pattern as well like him claiming he never compared it to hider which I have evidence of from the night. We also need him to explain his actions and why they picked the people they did. I see no reason to see them as town atm. @Karote care to verify? Now to question, is there a need for a transporter for this setup? Looking at peoples claim and flips makes it possible due to the setup is highly interactive. My only gripe about Karote's claims are the glaring mistakes about his claim and also the convenient timing of his claims. I find it suspicious. Other than that, his claim should be legit. It is a matter of knowing whether hes a town transporter or mafia transporter. |
DenjaX said: Ok, thank you for making that distinction for me. logic340 said: transporter = bus driver.Where is everyone? We need to discuss Karote's final claim. Who believes it's possible and why? I really don't know how to feel about it as I don't know much about balance in a setup. If it's scum aligned (and I believe it could be) then it's dangerous and needs to be dealt with. If it's true (the bus driver claim) then if anyone targeted Karote or Jack N1 they might want to reconsider their results. Its like calling doctor = protector or cop = sherrif/seer/investigator Your thoughts on his claim, his choices, and the change from hider to transporter? Jackrito said: I whole heartedly agree with you. I am waiting on an explanation as well. logic340 said: Where is everyone? We need to discuss Karote's final claim. Who believes it's possible and why? I really don't know how to feel about it as I don't know much about balance in a setup. If it's scum aligned (and I believe it could be) then it's dangerous and needs to be dealt with. If it's true (the bus driver claim) then if anyone targeted Karote or Jack N1 they might want to reconsider their results. I don't buy it at all tbh they are some flaws in his thought pattern as well like him claiming he never compared it to hider which I have evidence of from the night. We also need him to explain his actions and why they picked the people they did. I see no reason to see them as town atm. I just want to get people's feeling on the table so we can focus on other topics today as well. Back to reading D2. |
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC  |
DenjaX said: I was typing my post up when you posted this. Thanks for sharing your thoughts. Jackrito said: For the record, I believe Karote's claim. I believe people have 2 roles like Rosie have (Deputy - Cop) unless they are vanillas/goons. I think Karote might have a Hider as a modifier.I don't buy it at all tbh they are some flaws in his thought pattern as well like him claiming he never compared it to hider which I have evidence of from the night. We also need him to explain his actions and why they picked the people they did. I see no reason to see them as town atm. @Karote care to verify? Now to question, is there a need for a transporter for this setup? Looking at peoples claim and flips makes it possible due to the setup is highly interactive. My only gripe about Karote's claims are the glaring mistakes about his claim and also the convenient timing of his claims. I find it suspicious. Other than that, his claim should be legit. It is a matter of knowing whether hes a town transporter or mafia transporter. |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
DenjaX said: Jackrito said: For the record, I believe Karote's claim. I believe people have 2 roles like Rosie have (Deputy - Cop) unless they are vanillas/goons. I think Karote might have a Hider as a modifier.I don't buy it at all tbh they are some flaws in his thought pattern as well like him claiming he never compared it to hider which I have evidence of from the night. We also need him to explain his actions and why they picked the people they did. I see no reason to see them as town atm. @Karote care to verify? Now to question, is there a need for a transporter for this setup? Looking at peoples claim and flips makes it possible due to the setup is highly interactive. My only gripe about Karote's claims are the glaring mistakes about his claim and also the convenient timing of his claims. I find it suspicious. Other than that, his claim should be legit. It is a matter of knowing whether hes a town transporter or mafia transporter. How would Hider work as a mod it is a separate role and in the case of deputy it is a backup role not a mod they were not two separate roles at once. I will also say my role does not have 2 sides to it and based off what Shinichi got from Lucians neither did he. I'm not saying I don't think he is a transporter I'm saying he is a scum one who has tried to cover it up with multi fake claims and fell into a trap. I would suspect if he is also scum he has been getting help with it. This is all speculation however based off how vague they are in replies at times it does not seem like they understand what they are doing |
 |
| Should i town read Logic? Of course not. Logic and penta are mafia. aa-domo and grapfruit are next. Grapefruit can take a bullet as well : D. He kind-a agrees that he is mafia. |
 |
| @Kit Welcome! I will never understand grrr's play I think. logic's I understand even less right now though. And not a ton changed despite a lot happening. Let's try something new: Vote: Kit I know it's hard immeadiately upon replacing in, but give me reads on Qoco, dono, and Karote. |
grrr said: Should i town read Logic? Of course not. Logic and penta are mafia. aa-domo and grapfruit are next. Grapefruit can take a bullet as well : D. He kind-a agrees that he is mafia. What on earth are you talking about? You have never explained this read on me past not wanting to claim weird/not weird to you. |
logic340 said: Where is everyone? We need to discuss Karote's final claim. Who believes it's possible and why? I really don't know how to feel about it as I don't know much about balance in a setup. If it's scum aligned (and I believe it could be) then it's dangerous and needs to be dealt with. If it's true (the bus driver claim) then if anyone targeted Karote or Jack N1 they might want to reconsider their results. I dont see why we shouldnt believe it, he didnt claim a different role. Transporter is the less common name for a bus driver which is the more common role name so its not like he claimed a 3rd new role. |
  |
Jackrito said: logic340 said: Where is everyone? We need to discuss Karote's final claim. Who believes it's possible and why? I really don't know how to feel about it as I don't know much about balance in a setup. If it's scum aligned (and I believe it could be) then it's dangerous and needs to be dealt with. If it's true (the bus driver claim) then if anyone targeted Karote or Jack N1 they might want to reconsider their results. I don't buy it at all tbh they are some flaws in his thought pattern as well like him claiming he never compared it to hider which I have evidence of from the night. We also need him to explain his actions and why they picked the people they did. I see no reason to see them as town atm. This is true i may believe the claim but i dont trust karote, not gonna just lynch him tho. |
|
DenjaX said: Jackrito said: For the record, I believe Karote's claim. I believe people have 2 roles like Rosie have (Deputy - Cop) unless they are vanillas/goons. I think Karote might have a Hider as a modifier.I don't buy it at all tbh they are some flaws in his thought pattern as well like him claiming he never compared it to hider which I have evidence of from the night. We also need him to explain his actions and why they picked the people they did. I see no reason to see them as town atm. @Karote care to verify? Now to question, is there a need for a transporter for this setup? Looking at peoples claim and flips makes it possible due to the setup is highly interactive. My only gripe about Karote's claims are the glaring mistakes about his claim and also the convenient timing of his claims. I find it suspicious. Other than that, his claim should be legit. It is a matter of knowing whether hes a town transporter or mafia transporter. What about the timing? The 1st claim was 15 mins before phase change and the other claim was right after phase change i think. So the 1st claim wasnt really that odd it was just pressured out of him. If hes a scum bus driver he absolutely needs to be lynched today but if hes town we honesty lose a powerful asset. |
|
Jackrito said: DenjaX said: For the record, I believe Karote's claim. I believe people have 2 roles like Rosie have (Deputy - Cop) unless they are vanillas/goons. I think Karote might have a Hider as a modifier. @Karote care to verify? Now to question, is there a need for a transporter for this setup? Looking at peoples claim and flips makes it possible due to the setup is highly interactive. My only gripe about Karote's claims are the glaring mistakes about his claim and also the convenient timing of his claims. I find it suspicious. Other than that, his claim should be legit. It is a matter of knowing whether hes a town transporter or mafia transporter. How would Hider work as a mod it is a separate role and in the case of deputy it is a backup role not a mod they were not two separate roles at once. I will also say my role does not have 2 sides to it and based off what Shinichi got from Lucians neither did he. I'm not saying I don't think he is a transporter I'm saying he is a scum one who has tried to cover it up with multi fake claims and fell into a trap. I would suspect if he is also scum he has been getting help with it. This is all speculation however based off how vague they are in replies at times it does not seem like they understand what they are doing Well lamb has an ascetic doesnt that mean its possible hider is karote? Maybe with like a "50% to hide behind one of the eople you are transporting" Kind of thing? Doubtful but its def an asectic that could work. |
|
grrr said: Should i town read Logic? Of course not. Logic and penta are mafia. aa-domo and grapfruit are next. Grapefruit can take a bullet as well : D. He kind-a agrees that he is mafia. Most likely only 3 mafia, one of those other names could be a 2nd tpr tho. |
|
Shinichi-Kun said: He explained about him being a hider as well after we saw Rosie's flip.DenjaX said: For the record, I believe Karote's claim. I believe people have 2 roles like Rosie have (Deputy - Cop) unless they are vanillas/goons. I think Karote might have a Hider as a modifier. @Karote care to verify? Now to question, is there a need for a transporter for this setup? Looking at peoples claim and flips makes it possible due to the setup is highly interactive. My only gripe about Karote's claims are the glaring mistakes about his claim and also the convenient timing of his claims. I find it suspicious. Other than that, his claim should be legit. It is a matter of knowing whether hes a town transporter or mafia transporter. What about the timing? The 1st claim was 15 mins before phase change and the other claim was right after phase change i think. So the 1st claim wasnt really that odd it was just pressured out of him. If hes a scum bus driver he absolutely needs to be lynched today but if hes town we honesty lose a powerful asset. |
| So I've just been night killed in one of my other games which frees up more of my time for this one. Glad there is still almost a full day until lynch. |
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal. ~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~ |
PentaFlare said: So I've just been night killed in one of my other games which frees up more of my time for this one. Glad there is still almost a full day until lynch. welp rip penta 2nd life |
|
Coelestin said: @Qoco OK, let's start with something simple. Please give me a read list, just a simple one's fine where you list people from towniest to scummiest. From top to bottom. Pick a name, any name. Kit Logic Jackrito Karote Grrr Shinichi-Kun aa-dono DenjaX Grapefruit21 Penta Chione |
 |
PentaFlare said: So I've just been night killed in one of my other games which frees up more of my time for this one. Glad there is still almost a full day until lynch. If only :/ My other is in lylo... |
DenjaX said: Here is Karote's first post of D3 I guess what you are looking for would be somewhere after this?Huh. This is weird. I cannot find Karotes post anywhere. Demmet. Being on mobile is hard |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Jackrito said: @Qoco & @Shinichi-Kun funny little question. But a serious one. Did you read the roles in the rules/setup post? There are no roles. Just rules regarding roles, but no roles. This game is a closed setup. Meaning that anyone can go willy-nilly with claims, which is why I don't trust. |
|
Qoco said: Did you not look at the "sample role"?Jackrito said: @Qoco & @Shinichi-Kun funny little question. But a serious one. Did you read the roles in the rules/setup post? There are no roles. Just rules regarding roles, but no roles. This game is a closed setup. Meaning that anyone can go willy-nilly with claims, which is why I don't trust. |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
DenjaX said: because I said this. I must have made a mistake then. I thought I saw Karote posting after Rosies flip.I agree. It looked pretty convenient for Karote to claim those 2 roles after Rosie's flip came up. Though, I am preparing some strategies for this game because people are playing well and I will take on a different approach by solving this mechanically. |
DenjaX said: Huh. This is weird. I cannot find Karotes post anywhere. Demmet. Being on mobile is hard Tell me about it. |
|
Vote Count 3.4 Qoco: DenjaX, Logic340, Shinichi-Kun Karote: Jackrito Logic340:Qoco AA-Dono: Pentaflare, Coelestin Coelestin: aa-dono Pentaflare: Grrr Kit:Grapefruit21 Not Voting: Kit, Karote What has already transpired Phase Day one! || Vote count 1.1 || 1.2 || 1.3 || 1.4 || 1.5 || 1.6 || 1.7 || 1.8 || 1.9 || 1.10 || 1.11 || 1.12 || 1.13 || 1.14 || 1.15 Night one Day 2 || Vote Count 2.0 || 2.1 || 2.2 || 2.3 || 2.4 || 2.5 || 2.6 || 2.7 || 2.8 || 2.9 || 2.10 || 2.11 Night 2 Day 3 || Vote Count 3.0 || 3.1 || 3.2 || 3.3 |
 Where there is no imagination there is no horror. || Arthur Conan Doyle || Happy Halloween! |
Qoco said: Coelestin said: @Qoco OK, let's start with something simple. Please give me a read list, just a simple one's fine where you list people from towniest to scummiest. From top to bottom. Pick a name, any name. Kit Logic Jackrito Karote Grrr Shinichi-Kun aa-dono DenjaX Grapefruit21 Penta Chione chione |
|
logic340 said: Qoco said: Did you not look at the "sample role"?There are no roles. Just rules regarding roles, but no roles. This game is a closed setup. Meaning that anyone can go willy-nilly with claims, which is why I don't trust. what about it? |
|
| Why so defensive? It clearly shows us how to read our PM's that's what about it. He says there are no roles there but there is clearly a sample role there. This guy trolls all day accuses me of trolling and you run to his rescue? Aren't you voting him? Take a chill and let thing happen. |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
| This is going to seem weird, but I'm trying something new. One of the following claims are true. You could spend some time trying to decipher this if you want, but I'm mostly just trying to mess with the mafia's heads. 1. I'm town vengeful. If you lynch me I've got my brutal aimed at Karote. 2. I'm virgin. Lynch me and there is no night kill. 3. I'm a 1-Shot Vigilante who can not shoot day 1 and was roleblocked last night. 4. I'm a tracker who has been tracking grrr every phase to see whether the nurse claim is justified and have not seen them perform an action. 5. I'm a mason with a top secret mason buddy. 6. I'm a mayor that hasn't revealed because I haven't been under significant pressure. Once I reveal I will be unable to be protected from death, implying there is a doctor but no strongman. 7. I am a town roleblocker who has blocked grrr every phase to see what will happen. 8. I'm a spy and have gotten snippets of the mafia conversation about who they think they can mislynch, which clears grrr, but was roleblocked night 2 and heard nothing. 9. I'm a 1-Shot lie detector and verified grrr's Nurse claim. 10. I'm a type of vanilla cop that can determine whether someone attempted to perform an action last night and have determined that neither grrr nor Ruu attempted actions. 11. I'm the real transporter, but it is a 2-shot ability I haven't used yet. 12. I'm an odd day doublevoter. 13. I'm a special type of doctor that can only stop attempted suicides instead of night kills but do not know what kind of ability would cause that. 14. I'm a martyr that will die in place of my target and has a 50% chance of revealing the killer. 15. I'm a vanilla town. |
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal. ~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~ |
| I'm here alone again it seems.... |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Qoco said: Coelestin said: @Qoco OK, let's start with something simple. Please give me a read list, just a simple one's fine where you list people from towniest to scummiest. From top to bottom. Pick a name, any name. Kit Logic Jackrito Karote Grrr Shinichi-Kun aa-dono DenjaX Grapefruit21 Penta Chione Do you think it is a contradiction to have both me and Grape so close to the bottom of the list after the way I pushed them last day phase? |
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal. ~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~ |
PentaFlare said: lol i counterclaim on one of them!!!This is going to seem weird, but I'm trying something new. One of the following claims are true. You could spend some time trying to decipher this if you want, but I'm mostly just trying to mess with the mafia's heads. 1. I'm town vengeful. If you lynch me I've got my brutal aimed at Karote. 2. I'm virgin. Lynch me and there is no night kill. 3. I'm a 1-Shot Vigilante who can not shoot day 1 and was roleblocked last night. 4. I'm a tracker who has been tracking grrr every phase to see whether the nurse claim is justified and have not seen them perform an action. 5. I'm a mason with a top secret mason buddy. 6. I'm a mayor that hasn't revealed because I haven't been under significant pressure. Once I reveal I will be unable to be protected from death, implying there is a doctor but no strongman. 7. I am a town roleblocker who has blocked grrr every phase to see what will happen. 8. I'm a spy and have gotten snippets of the mafia conversation about who they think they can mislynch, which clears grrr, but was roleblocked night 2 and heard nothing. 9. I'm a 1-Shot lie detector and verified grrr's Nurse claim. 10. I'm a type of vanilla cop that can determine whether someone attempted to perform an action last night and have determined that neither grrr nor Ruu attempted actions. 11. I'm the real transporter, but it is a 2-shot ability I haven't used yet. 12. I'm an odd day doublevoter. 13. I'm a special type of doctor that can only stop attempted suicides instead of night kills but do not know what kind of ability would cause that. 14. I'm a martyr that will die in place of my target and has a 50% chance of revealing the killer. 15. I'm a vanilla town. |
PentaFlare said: This is quite interesting. I don't know how I feel about it though. It's great WIFOM especially if you're town but if you're mafia you have plenty to choose from if you get into a claim situation. I have a few ideas comparing against my own role and ability but that's only if your town and being honest. From this I take you town read grrr and trust his claim? This is going to seem weird, but I'm trying something new. One of the following claims are true. You could spend some time trying to decipher this if you want, but I'm mostly just trying to mess with the mafia's heads. 1. I'm town vengeful. If you lynch me I've got my brutal aimed at Karote. 2. I'm virgin. Lynch me and there is no night kill. 3. I'm a 1-Shot Vigilante who can not shoot day 1 and was roleblocked last night. 4. I'm a tracker who has been tracking grrr every phase to see whether the nurse claim is justified and have not seen them perform an action. 5. I'm a mason with a top secret mason buddy. 6. I'm a mayor that hasn't revealed because I haven't been under significant pressure. Once I reveal I will be unable to be protected from death, implying there is a doctor but no strongman. 7. I am a town roleblocker who has blocked grrr every phase to see what will happen. 8. I'm a spy and have gotten snippets of the mafia conversation about who they think they can mislynch, which clears grrr, but was roleblocked night 2 and heard nothing. 9. I'm a 1-Shot lie detector and verified grrr's Nurse claim. 10. I'm a type of vanilla cop that can determine whether someone attempted to perform an action last night and have determined that neither grrr nor Ruu attempted actions. 11. I'm the real transporter, but it is a 2-shot ability I haven't used yet. 12. I'm an odd day doublevoter. 13. I'm a special type of doctor that can only stop attempted suicides instead of night kills but do not know what kind of ability would cause that. 14. I'm a martyr that will die in place of my target and has a 50% chance of revealing the killer. 15. I'm a vanilla town. |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
logic340 said: Why so defensive? It clearly shows us how to read our PM's that's what about it. He says there are no roles there but there is clearly a sample role there. This guy trolls all day accuses me of trolling and you run to his rescue? Aren't you voting him? Take a chill and let thing happen. Lol i was just honestly asking a question sorry if i sounded hostile. |
|
PentaFlare said: I think his list is from scummiest to towniest? Not sure but pretty certain he isn't town reading me?Qoco said: From top to bottom. Pick a name, any name. Kit Logic Jackrito Karote Grrr Shinichi-Kun aa-dono DenjaX Grapefruit21 Penta Chione Do you think it is a contradiction to have both me and Grape so close to the bottom of the list after the way I pushed them last day phase? |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
PentaFlare said: This is going to seem weird, but I'm trying something new. One of the following claims are true. You could spend some time trying to decipher this if you want, but I'm mostly just trying to mess with the mafia's heads. 1. I'm town vengeful. If you lynch me I've got my brutal aimed at Karote. 2. I'm virgin. Lynch me and there is no night kill. 3. I'm a 1-Shot Vigilante who can not shoot day 1 and was roleblocked last night. 4. I'm a tracker who has been tracking grrr every phase to see whether the nurse claim is justified and have not seen them perform an action. 5. I'm a mason with a top secret mason buddy. 6. I'm a mayor that hasn't revealed because I haven't been under significant pressure. Once I reveal I will be unable to be protected from death, implying there is a doctor but no strongman. 7. I am a town roleblocker who has blocked grrr every phase to see what will happen. 8. I'm a spy and have gotten snippets of the mafia conversation about who they think they can mislynch, which clears grrr, but was roleblocked night 2 and heard nothing. 9. I'm a 1-Shot lie detector and verified grrr's Nurse claim. 10. I'm a type of vanilla cop that can determine whether someone attempted to perform an action last night and have determined that neither grrr nor Ruu attempted actions. 11. I'm the real transporter, but it is a 2-shot ability I haven't used yet. 12. I'm an odd day doublevoter. 13. I'm a special type of doctor that can only stop attempted suicides instead of night kills but do not know what kind of ability would cause that. 14. I'm a martyr that will die in place of my target and has a 50% chance of revealing the killer. 15. I'm a vanilla town. i got about 5 that i think aare possible but i cant possibly narrow it down. |
|
| I'm going to call it a night. Hope we hear from @Qoco, @Karote, @aa-dono, @Kit, @Coelestin while I am away. |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
PentaFlare said: This is going to seem weird, but I'm trying something new. One of the following claims are true. You could spend some time trying to decipher this if you want, but I'm mostly just trying to mess with the mafia's heads. 1. I'm town vengeful. If you lynch me I've got my brutal aimed at Karote. 2. I'm virgin. Lynch me and there is no night kill. 3. I'm a 1-Shot Vigilante who can not shoot day 1 and was roleblocked last night. 4. I'm a tracker who has been tracking grrr every phase to see whether the nurse claim is justified and have not seen them perform an action. 5. I'm a mason with a top secret mason buddy. 6. I'm a mayor that hasn't revealed because I haven't been under significant pressure. Once I reveal I will be unable to be protected from death, implying there is a doctor but no strongman. 7. I am a town roleblocker who has blocked grrr every phase to see what will happen. 8. I'm a spy and have gotten snippets of the mafia conversation about who they think they can mislynch, which clears grrr, but was roleblocked night 2 and heard nothing. 9. I'm a 1-Shot lie detector and verified grrr's Nurse claim. 10. I'm a type of vanilla cop that can determine whether someone attempted to perform an action last night and have determined that neither grrr nor Ruu attempted actions. 11. I'm the real transporter, but it is a 2-shot ability I haven't used yet. 12. I'm an odd day doublevoter. 13. I'm a special type of doctor that can only stop attempted suicides instead of night kills but do not know what kind of ability would cause that. 14. I'm a martyr that will die in place of my target and has a 50% chance of revealing the killer. 15. I'm a vanilla town. Well at least I can rule out 15 lol |
Kit said: Do what you can I'm not really rushing you. If you could share some thoughts as you progress it would be appreciated.logic340 said: I'm on page 8 out of 47... CriesI'm going to call it a night. Hope we hear from @Qoco, @Karote, @aa-dono, @Kit, @Coelestin while I am away. |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Shinichi-Kun said: Qoco said: From top to bottom. Pick a name, any name. Kit Logic Jackrito Karote Grrr Shinichi-Kun aa-dono DenjaX Grapefruit21 Penta Chione chione I like Chione. I feel that we share a lot of thoughts, as evident by how she can understand me and interpret how I feel in regards to something. I don't feel like there is any ill-intention behind what they say and do. I can somewhat tell when someone does something seemingly "townie", with the intention to fling shit around. Chione isn't like that. She is good people imo. |
|
PentaFlare said: Qoco said: From top to bottom. Pick a name, any name. Kit Logic Jackrito Karote Grrr Shinichi-Kun aa-dono DenjaX Grapefruit21 Penta Chione Do you think it is a contradiction to have both me and Grape so close to the bottom of the list after the way I pushed them last day phase? I have said it before, and I will say it once again. I don't understand what people see about Grape. Everyone keeps mentioning this supposed case against him, but to this point in time, I have yet to see this case myself. From my perspective, people only parrot and vote. It's why I feel that Grape is Lucian 2.0. |
|
Qoco said: Coelestin said: @Qoco OK, let's start with something simple. Please give me a read list, just a simple one's fine where you list people from towniest to scummiest. From top to bottom. Pick a name, any name. Kit Logic Jackrito Karote Grrr Shinichi-Kun aa-dono DenjaX Grapefruit21 Penta Chione karote |
|
PentaFlare said: 1. I'm town. Here you go, Mr. LD. Have fun with this. |
|
Shinichi-Kun said: Qoco said: From top to bottom. Pick a name, any name. Kit Logic Jackrito Karote Grrr Shinichi-Kun aa-dono DenjaX Grapefruit21 Penta Chione karote Karote is shady. This could be both good and bad, depending on what their role is. Sometimes you need to do things, like lie about your role, for the greater good. However, their role is something that I don't know, and so I treat him with special care. I suspect him, but I don't want to lynch him just yet. So he's kind of up there, but not really. He's more like an "I'm watching you" type of guy, I guess. |
|
| @Qoco talk to me about dono and Denja. |
Grapefruit21 said: @Coelestin I'm mostly town reading Penta, but the jumping around and long explanation of what they were doing reminds me of their scum game in Harhui Mafia. That said nothing Penta has done has struck me as overly scummy. I can squint and see the tying vote as a scum move, but I have a hard time believing that was intentional. As for dono I can see the case for scum dono, but I'd rather lynch Abu, qoco or Karote. Dono is going to keep talking and they will make themselves clearer over time, unless unexpected things happen that first group pretty much just are what they are. Even good scum have a hard time when the pool narrows and I'd rather sort out the larger question marks now. Ask logic and Shinichi how much fun dealing with a blank box in lylo is. Alright. I can totally see what you mean by blank boxes. That's what some tried to fight against yesterday. I think the three way tie we have right now between aa, Carrot and Qoco is nice tho, we can always switch to lynching Carrot or Qoco if necessary. And almost everyone's voting now, in comparison to yesterday it's much better today. Shinichi-Kun said: Coelestin said: Vote: aa-dono This scummy behavior lasting for two days isn't coincidence anymore. I've waited too long to place this vote, should've done it sooner. Your talk seems all nice but I still haven't seen noteworthy scum hunting actions that would make me wanna town read you. The pool of people you actually suspect is unnaturally narrow. I've had enough, you're too scummy. You may have been able to talk yourself out of stuff but actions speak louder than words. It's already unbelievable that you've gotten away without having a train on you yesterday but Penta and I are onto you today. As much as i understand where your coming from i dont see how someones scumminess can be judged by lack of scum hunting. If thats the case then we already have 5 scum: Me,Dono,Qoco,Karote,Abu. If u remove the claimers it leaves just qoco and dono. The pool of people i suspect changes every phase and through the littlest of actions its why i never have a solid read. Like i said dont i understand this from a town POV so i won't try to stop it because that just be silly. Well, the thing is too, she's kind of active and is there, but... rhetorical question: what actually is she doing here if she's town and not scum hunting? I can see your point but arrrgh. Not scum hunting normally shouldn't be associated with town. Shinichi-Kun said: aa-dono said: No. I said I don't need to know why she (Coel) townread Jack and Penta. Because she explained. And she doesn't need to explain things twice. I don't disagree on that read. And her next scumread besides me is Karote, which similar to above, I don't disagree. tbf it honestly just seems like shes scum reading all the anti town players and town reading all the players with the towniest play styles lol Lol. I've actually gotten doubts on my reads on logic and grape again yesterday especially since I actually had been suspecting both of them at some point in day 1 and because even with PoE it's unlikely to have all 3-4 scum in the pool of five peeps that are under suspicion right now, but yeah, nothing can shake my read on Penta and Jack now. Doesn't matter right now though, we've got scummier people to deal with first unless something unexpected happens. |
 |
Qoco said: Coelestin said: @Qoco OK, let's start with something simple. Please give me a read list, just a simple one's fine where you list people from towniest to scummiest. From top to bottom. Pick a name, any name. Kit Logic Jackrito Karote Grrr Shinichi-Kun aa-dono DenjaX Grapefruit21 Penta Chione Thank you. Grrr and Shinichi please. |
|
Coelestin said: Grapefruit21 said: @Coelestin I'm mostly town reading Penta, but the jumping around and long explanation of what they were doing reminds me of their scum game in Harhui Mafia. That said nothing Penta has done has struck me as overly scummy. I can squint and see the tying vote as a scum move, but I have a hard time believing that was intentional. As for dono I can see the case for scum dono, but I'd rather lynch Abu, qoco or Karote. Dono is going to keep talking and they will make themselves clearer over time, unless unexpected things happen that first group pretty much just are what they are. Even good scum have a hard time when the pool narrows and I'd rather sort out the larger question marks now. Ask logic and Shinichi how much fun dealing with a blank box in lylo is. Alright. I can totally see what you mean by blank boxes. That's what some tried to fight against yesterday. I think the three way tie we have right now between aa, Carrot and Qoco is nice tho, we can always switch to lynching Carrot or Qoco if necessary. And almost everyone's voting now, in comparison to yesterday it's much better today. Welp ignore the thing about the tie. I began writing the post yesterday when there still was one but then had something else to do -.- |
|
Qoco said: This was actually my question but oh well.Jackrito said: @Qoco & @Shinichi-Kun funny little question. But a serious one. Did you read the roles in the rules/setup post? There are no roles. Just rules regarding roles, but no roles. This game is a closed setup. Meaning that anyone can go willy-nilly with claims, which is why I don't trust. True, anyone could claim anything, but if you did read the roles or the rules, you would know that TPR can't be jester since the win con is clearly stated. @Shinichi-Kun So why would you speculate Ruu/Abu/Kit jester? |
 |
PentaFlare said: Well then sorry that you think that way but what points would you want me say anyway?Not at the time, but this made me think you were trying to hear my position first again. I don't want that because I believe this behaviour of yours is scummy so I won't encourage it You're townreading someone I find scummy. I pointed why she could be town back when I didn't scumread her but my read changed. My question is more to why do you still find her town? If you think I'm gonna echo your reads, then fine don't tell me. |
|
More topics from this board
» [GAME] Give something to the user above you ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Soren - Oct 9, 2015 |
1395 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 13, 9:10 PM |
|
» [GAME] Last Letter Game ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )grave_robber - Sep 9, 2014 |
8755 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 11, 7:29 PM |
|
» [GAME] (*￣･￣)ﾉ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated MEMBER Posts! v1 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )SoulEaterQUEEN - Mar 26, 2016 |
1996 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 7, 10:20 PM |
|
» [GAME] (*￣･￣)ﾉ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated Staff Member Posts! v4 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Togs - Jul 2, 2017 |
2877 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 7, 10:20 PM |
|
» Count To 7777 V3 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Lambtron - May 15, 2018 |
1170 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 7, 10:20 PM |