Forum Settings
Forums

Minigame v11: Bungou Stray Dogs | Game Over Mafia Wins!

New
Reply Disabled for Non-Club Members
Pages (85) « First ... « 21 22 [23] 24 25 » ... Last »
Apr 20, 2017 3:31 PM

Offline
Aug 2013
1703
@Logic340

It has the best characters so far. Persona 5

Apr 20, 2017 3:51 PM

Offline
Jan 2010
15856

Thank you for your response it's been so long since someone had actual thoughts about one of my ISO's

1. I honestly think gut feeling, which is hard to explain, is sometime more right than the over thinking we do. I mean at that point the only think Karote had done was vote and leave so I am not sure that move would be so justified as you make it sound. Also I don't think she ever outright said he was scum for it
2. I understand the way the roll is supposed to be played. I know there are two outcomes from this claim.
a. What you believe she is scum who wanted an out when she was checked. Death Sentence
b. What I think she's actually a Miller and played it horribly
The timing of her claim doesn't change the fact that if a cop checks her they have to decide whether she is lying or not
3. The thing is we're allowed to feel differently about posts. We have different experiences in mafia and different experiences with Ruu. I know meta is an "iffy" subject because I don't just take everyone's meta at face value either. you don't know if you can trust me this game so you feel like I could be skewing results to fit my narrative I get that. I will work on articulating things better.
4. Lucian didn't think Ruu was scum before he died and right now she's going to open the phase with a lot of votes on her.
5. I really don't think it is unfair. He asked grrr one question. Ruu asked the same question then asked other question relating to the game. Which behavior do you find scummy? Asking someone how they feel about being lynched then voting them for not answering said question or asking someone if they are trying to get themselves killed and asks him why he is role fishing (a question related to getting himself killed and the game).
6. grrr wasn't the traitor in Kitty Mafia though so how do you equate that to traitor role? I am not seeing the correlation but I guess anything is possible. Also the traitor role was Judas who didn't know they were traitor to my knowledge.
7. Scum hunting puts you in the spotlight? Scum hunting is a way to shake suspicion, not scum hunting is what got suspicion on her no?
8. The thing is we're allowed to feel differently about posts. I guess we'll see when she flips.
9. While you may have treated Ruu the same would everyone else have? You know Grapefruit wont let that shit go until she's dead. I struggle to see the scum motivation in claiming Miller there knowing it's a death sentence.

my responses are numbered obviously
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC


Apr 20, 2017 4:01 PM

Offline
Jun 2009
15934
Day 2



"Elise-chan!"

"Elise-chan! Where are you?"

Mori ran though the streets arms laden with bags from the story. "Wait until she sees this simply beautiful dress with the ruffles. I will have to get her some cake so she will try it on."

But suddenly he stops. He senses a strong malice. Mori activates his ability Vita Sexualis. This summons Elise to him.

"If you limit your field of vision, the enemies moves become obvious" says a voice." Mori's heart falls. Then the car near him blows up. Elise turning into ribbons and Mori crumbles to the ground.

Corrupted Purity dies:
They were Mori Ougai


Time until night 2

@Logic340, @Grapefruit21, @Shinichi-Kun, @Ruu, @Aa-dono, @CorruptedPurity, @Lam-B, @Jackrito, @Grrr, @Oyasumi_Rosie, @Karote, @Pentaflare, @LucianRoy, @Coelestin, @Qoco

Where there is no imagination there is no horror. || Arthur Conan Doyle || Happy Halloween!
Apr 20, 2017 4:08 PM

Offline
Feb 2014
4455
vote: grapefruit
Apr 20, 2017 4:09 PM

Offline
Jun 2009
15934
All night actions have been sent at this point.

Where there is no imagination there is no horror. || Arthur Conan Doyle || Happy Halloween!
Apr 20, 2017 4:10 PM

Offline
Jan 2010
15856
Great job Mafia Team!! XD Thank you so much for sparing a townie while helping us get rid of that menace! You deserve a round of applause.
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC


Apr 20, 2017 4:11 PM

Offline
Jun 2009
15934
Vote Count 2.0

Grapefruit21: Grrr

Those not voting
Logic340, Grapefruit21, Shinichi-Kun, Ruu, Aa-dono, Lam-B, Jackrito, Oyasumi_Rosie, Karote, Pentaflare, Coelestin, Qoco

What has already transpired
Phase Day one! || Vote count 1.1 || 1.2 || 1.3 || 1.4 || 1.5 || 1.6 || 1.7 || 1.8 || 1.9 || 1.10 || 1.11 || 1.12 || 1.13 || 1.14 || 1.15
Night one
Day 2 || Vote Count 2.0


Where there is no imagination there is no horror. || Arthur Conan Doyle || Happy Halloween!
Apr 20, 2017 4:13 PM

Offline
Aug 2014
6565
Vote: grapefruit
BAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal.
~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~
Apr 20, 2017 4:19 PM

Offline
Dec 2013
17265
woah that night kill lol thanska bunch mafia


Apr 20, 2017 4:22 PM

Offline
Dec 2013
17265
whats with the grapefruit votes am i missing something?


Apr 20, 2017 4:24 PM

Offline
Dec 2014
3945
You made me the saltiest man alive now. I was so hyped to play that role out... Sooo frustrated

CP out... (in an extremely angry and salty manner)
Apr 20, 2017 4:25 PM

Offline
Dec 2013
17265
CorruptedPurity said:
You made me the saltiest man alive now. I was so hyped to play that role out... Sooo frustrated

CP out... (in an extremely angry and salty manner)


\o <3


Apr 20, 2017 4:29 PM

Offline
Jan 2010
15856
Shinichi-Kun said:
whats with the grapefruit votes am i missing something?
I was wondering the same thing thought the first few votes of this phase would go directly to Ruu.
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC


Apr 20, 2017 4:39 PM

Offline
Jan 2010
15856
Grapefruit hasn't been overly active lets see if I can get a third ISO done today and see if I am seeing what they are seeing?

Edit: My company just arrived this one will be on hold until the morning. I will be keeping up on mobile so don't expect any wall post from me.
Maybe I should take Purity's advice and go Rinto mode for a little while?
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC


Apr 20, 2017 4:57 PM

Offline
Aug 2014
6565
Shinichi-Kun said:
whats with the grapefruit votes am i missing something?

Good question. I don't really have an answer
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal.
~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~
Apr 20, 2017 5:00 PM

Offline
May 2015
6406
what happened? I'm lost... let me reread D:

so the tpr died?
Apr 20, 2017 5:01 PM

Offline
May 2015
6406
PentaFlare said:
Shinichi-Kun said:
whats with the grapefruit votes am i missing something?

Good question. I don't really have an answer


+1
Apr 20, 2017 5:02 PM

Offline
Aug 2014
6565
Ruu said:
what happened? I'm lost... let me reread D:

so the tpr died?

This is your chance to prove yourself. Once you have a chance to sort yourself out, it would be nice if you could give us a top 3 scumreads/top 3 townreads
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal.
~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~
Apr 20, 2017 5:04 PM

Offline
May 2015
6406
How sad it sound that I'm happy that the first two votes are not for me? xD
Apr 20, 2017 5:04 PM

Offline
May 2015
6406
PentaFlare said:
Ruu said:
what happened? I'm lost... let me reread D:

so the tpr died?

This is your chance to prove yourself. Once you have a chance to sort yourself out, it would be nice if you could give us a top 3 scumreads/top 3 townreads


Working on it!
Apr 20, 2017 5:13 PM

Offline
Aug 2013
1703
Ruu said:
what happened? I'm lost... let me reread D:

so the tpr died?
No he is just a cop right? a role blocker

Apr 20, 2017 5:24 PM

Offline
May 2015
6406
Oyasumi_Rosie said:
Ruu said:
what happened? I'm lost... let me reread D:

so the tpr died?
No he is just a cop right? a role blocker


Since they are "blue" I thought that meant a different alignment :/

Also I'm rereading and my strongest townread atm is Penta. I can only see town motives behind his posts. I like how he is trying to get everyone to scumhunt and making relevant questions and not just fluffy posts (I'm still on p5 so please be patient)
Apr 20, 2017 5:49 PM

Offline
May 2015
6406
Okkay, no quotes because I'm on mobile atm.

Townreads ( based on the ratio between fluff/helpful posts, the content of them and the interaction with other players trying to scumhunt/get reads)

Penta / grrr

Scummy (based on fluff/helpful posts, reasons behind votes)

Lamb / Jack / Chione

vote: Lamb

Okay let me explain. I'm voting for lamb because he was a complete ghost (even more than me) at first and then when he appeared his posts had more fluff than actual useful information. His vote on grrr was weak imo. And his later input didn't give me town vibes.

Chione is different, her posts are good but I don't see a townie behind them. She also defends lamb a lot from logic in the beginning which seemed odd to me. And I can see a lamb/Chione team.

Jack is a similar case to Chione, his posts are not full of fluff but I get a scum!jack vibe from them.

I have to go now but I'll try to come back later!
Apr 20, 2017 5:54 PM

Offline
Apr 2014
10943
Oyasumi_Rosie said:
Ruu said:
what happened? I'm lost... let me reread D:

so the tpr died?
No he is just a cop right? a role blocker


It is pretty clear they are a 3rd party converter not sure where you got the cop part from,
Apr 20, 2017 6:04 PM

Offline
Apr 2014
10943
Ruu said:
Okkay, no quotes because I'm on mobile atm.

Townreads ( based on the ratio between fluff/helpful posts, the content of them and the interaction with other players trying to scumhunt/get reads)

Penta / grrr

Scummy (based on fluff/helpful posts, reasons behind votes)

Lamb / Jack / Chione

vote: Lamb

Okay let me explain. I'm voting for lamb because he was a complete ghost (even more than me) at first and then when he appeared his posts had more fluff than actual useful information. His vote on grrr was weak imo. And his later input didn't give me town vibes.

Chione is different, her posts are good but I don't see a townie behind them. She also defends lamb a lot from logic in the beginning which seemed odd to me. And I can see a lamb/Chione team.

Jack is a similar case to Chione, his posts are not full of fluff but I get a scum!jack vibe from them.

I have to go now but I'll try to come back later!


I want to understand the town read on grr here, since you seem to base it off value of posts and how much they scum hunted, Penta I can agree with off that but not grr so explain this one.


Onto the other side what about about lamb posts made you get a scum vibe.

On the bits about me and Chione why do they not appear as town to you, it is easy to do vague statements like this but if you want people to follow your reads it needs more. Also you say a Chione Lamb team is that not a bit obv why would they be that open about it, and just because someone defends someone it fdoes not mean they are on same team.

Also out of everyone in this game, why did you only pick us five. I would expect you to have thoughts on Shinichi, Logic who were both pretty active and also to a lesser degree on Grape. I can understand less reads on others though.
Apr 20, 2017 6:05 PM

Offline
Aug 2014
6565
Ruu said:
Okkay, no quotes because I'm on mobile atm.

Townreads ( based on the ratio between fluff/helpful posts, the content of them and the interaction with other players trying to scumhunt/get reads)

Penta / grrr

Scummy (based on fluff/helpful posts, reasons behind votes)

Lamb / Jack / Chione

vote: Lamb

Okay let me explain. I'm voting for lamb because he was a complete ghost (even more than me) at first and then when he appeared his posts had more fluff than actual useful information. His vote on grrr was weak imo. And his later input didn't give me town vibes.

Chione is different, her posts are good but I don't see a townie behind them. She also defends lamb a lot from logic in the beginning which seemed odd to me. And I can see a lamb/Chione team.

Jack is a similar case to Chione, his posts are not full of fluff but I get a scum!jack vibe from them.

I have to go now but I'll try to come back later!

When you come back can you try and give a specific example of something in one of Jack's posts that make you see scum!Jack? I'm not getting a strong read off the way he is saying things and I would love to hear a read one way or another.
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal.
~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~
Apr 20, 2017 6:08 PM

Offline
Aug 2013
1703
Jackrito said:
Oyasumi_Rosie said:
No he is just a cop right? a role blocker


It is pretty clear they are a 3rd party converter not sure where you got the cop part from,
"Targeting someone once Will Roleblock them"

Hence cop.

Apr 20, 2017 6:09 PM

Offline
Apr 2014
10943
Ruu said:
Okkay, no quotes because I'm on mobile atm.

Townreads ( based on the ratio between fluff/helpful posts, the content of them and the interaction with other players trying to scumhunt/get reads)

Penta / grrr

Scummy (based on fluff/helpful posts, reasons behind votes)

Lamb / Jack / Chione

vote: Lamb

Okay let me explain. I'm voting for lamb because he was a complete ghost (even more than me) at first and then when he appeared his posts had more fluff than actual useful information. His vote on grrr was weak imo. And his later input didn't give me town vibes.

Chione is different, her posts are good but I don't see a townie behind them. She also defends lamb a lot from logic in the beginning which seemed odd to me. And I can see a lamb/Chione team.

Jack is a similar case to Chione, his posts are not full of fluff but I get a scum!jack vibe from them.

I have to go now but I'll try to come back later!


Another point on this is this a up to date read because 30 mins before you were only on page 5, I would be impressed if you read whole game in that time and were able to get solid reads. I just see these reads as a bit of a rush job to look busy and more town like not to sound too harsh.
Apr 20, 2017 6:11 PM

Offline
Apr 2014
10943
Oyasumi_Rosie said:
Jackrito said:


It is pretty clear they are a 3rd party converter not sure where you got the cop part from,
"Targeting someone once Will Roleblock them"

Hence cop.


A cop does not roleblock, they check to see if someone is town or scum. Also it says on the rolecard what their role is.
Apr 20, 2017 7:06 PM

Offline
Dec 2016
577
Dang. How many more parties could there be?
Apr 20, 2017 7:08 PM

Offline
Dec 2016
1608
Vote: Ruu

Miller's have to be sorted out sooner or later. And with the NK being the best possible for us this seems like a good time.

And @logic340 I read everything and you keep denying that you're sure or that you are biased about Ruu, but you made 948. That is not the post you make when you're just trying to play devil's advocate and make people think through a lynch before they rush it through. That is aggressively trying to make someone feel bad about a stance you don't agree with In the words of our lord and savior Kendrick: "Sit down. Be humble."

You also said Ruu claimed under no pressure, which is very far from true. No immediate pressure because it was a night phase but there had been pressure. My biggest takeaway from your Iso was that you didn't have any issue with soft claiming Miller. I'll say it again, if you are town and claim or hint at it in any way other than full claiming in your first 3 posts you're doing it wrong.
Apr 20, 2017 7:09 PM

Offline
Dec 2016
577
I wonder if any connection can be traced from that death.
Apr 20, 2017 7:12 PM

Offline
Dec 2016
577
Ruu said:
Okkay, no quotes because I'm on mobile atm.

Townreads ( based on the ratio between fluff/helpful posts, the content of them and the interaction with other players trying to scumhunt/get reads)

Penta / grrr

Scummy (based on fluff/helpful posts, reasons behind votes)

Lamb / Jack / Chione

vote: Lamb

Okay let me explain. I'm voting for lamb because he was a complete ghost (even more than me) at first and then when he appeared his posts had more fluff than actual useful information. His vote on grrr was weak imo. And his later input didn't give me town vibes.

Chione is different, her posts are good but I don't see a townie behind them. She also defends lamb a lot from logic in the beginning which seemed odd to me. And I can see a lamb/Chione team.

Jack is a similar case to Chione, his posts are not full of fluff but I get a scum!jack vibe from them.

I have to go now but I'll try to come back later!


Cool Jester play. Vigshot please.
Apr 20, 2017 7:15 PM

Offline
Dec 2016
577
logic340 said:
Shinichi-Kun said:
whats with the grapefruit votes am i missing something?
I was wondering the same thing thought the first few votes of this phase would go directly to Ruu.


I don't trust. Ruu is baiting.
Apr 20, 2017 7:20 PM

Offline
Dec 2016
577
Vote: Karote

I'm calling you out. Show yourself!
Apr 20, 2017 8:07 PM

Offline
Dec 2016
1608
Time for a worldview post.

I'm town and dead townies are town:

Grapefruit21
LucianRoy

Dead third parties are TPR
CorruptedPurity

logic being difficult and his stance on Ruu is making me doubt everything, but his interactions with Qoco felt strongly town as I can't imagine scum making up a reason to scum read someone like that. I have my doubts given his position on the the lucian train, but I really struggle to see scum logic going at Qoco over that interaction.

I agree with the idea that Penta hammering Lucian the way they did is most likely town motivated. Also generally strong posts, such as taking the correct stance on grrr's fishing, 413, and the progression on Lucian in 618.

And I've done a 180 on Shinichi and have a decent town lean on him. I liked his posting overnight especially his back and forth with logic and his bolded responses to the Ruu ISO.

logic
Penta
Shinichi


Then we come to the people with a few town + things going for them, but not enough that I'm comfortable putting them in with the above group.

Lam-B: 554 and the quoted exchange in 601 are good, but I need more.

I like just about every post Jackrito has made, but none of them really stick with me. I don't have any huge +++ in my notes, but a lot of yup that sounds good. Which scares me because last time that was the case Jack won the game as scum... Still I'm not going to look consistent town behavior in the mouth and turn it away. Jack's spot on the wagon also worries me.

Lam-b
Jackrito


Then we have the nulls, of which there are way too many. Some of that is on my reading, some of that is on people.

Rosie
Qoco
Karote

I tried to Iso Karote last night and quit when there were like three pages of nothing.

Ruu I've discussed enough elsewhere, but claimed miller can never be outside the PoE because of that, needs to be sorted sooner rather than later.


Ruu


And then there were 3. Coelestin, grrr, and aa-dono.

Colestin has posted most so her first. After skimming/reading Chione in the Just a Normal Game Penta linked Chione is pretty confident as scum. And I can't really rule them out based on activity/confidence as I was sort of doing D1. Most of their posts are reasonable and they fall into a similar camp to Jack and Penta, but their spot on the wagon is more suspect. Coelestin was organizing it and driving the votes. Before seeing that game I was willing to write them off as town for taking that prominent role, but I'm not comfortable doing so anymore.

grrr my stance is the same, they will not be outside the PoE ever and the rolefishing they were doing (and continued to do after they admitted it was to find the doc!!!!) was anti-town. The whole nurse claim seemed reasonable at the time and is enough that grrr isn't at the top of my list, but he's not far behind.

aa-dono this one is quick and easy I feel like there is a pretty decent chance they are scum who voted Lucian early and kind of just got stuck with their vote there. It was never a very supported vote and everyone else on the Lucian train has some good evidence pointing towards them being town.

Coelestin
grrr
aa-dono


Which gives us a world view that looks like so:

Grapefruit21
LucianRoy

CorruptedPurity
logic
Penta
Shinichi

Lam-b
Jackrito

Rosie
Qoco
Karote
Coelestin
grrr
aa-dono


Ruu


I'm happy lynching anyone below Jackrito right now.
Apr 20, 2017 8:22 PM

Offline
Dec 2016
1608
1097
Was the post that really jumped out at me for Shinichi.

@aa-dono I know you were unwell part of yesterDay and I hope you're feeling better, but I'm going to need more from you today. What are your thoughts on Ruu? How about your wagon mates on Lucian? Who do you feel is most likely scum outside that pool?

@Coelestin same questions minus the imploring for more.

@Oyasumi_Rosie enjoy Persona, but save some time for us or replace out. I'm tired of dead weight slots. You're great, but activity is better.

@Qoco do you have any thoughts on anything?

@Karote Hi, what do you make of logic this game?
Apr 20, 2017 8:24 PM

Offline
Dec 2016
1608
Okay I missed @Qoco posting while working on my posts. Also they apparenlty took like 45 minutes.... Uggh I'm slow

Qoco: do you really think there is a jester in a game with a TPR converter?
Apr 20, 2017 9:30 PM

Offline
Aug 2012
11444
Grapefruit21 said:
@aa-dono I know you were unwell part of yesterDay and I hope you're feeling better, but I'm going to need more from you today. What are your thoughts on Ruu? How about your wagon mates on Lucian? Who do you feel is most likely scum outside that pool?
Yeah, sorry I can't seem to be be up lately T_T

Personally, I don't think she's scum. It's more a feel than anything. Though I don't really care if she gets lynched now. If she's scum, that she gets off easy with people like me and logic thinking that she just plays badly as town. On the chance that I'm wrong, it's on her to prove to everyone if she's town.
There's another part of me who finds her scummy. Minus her timings and reasonings, she seems to appeal emotionally. I don't trust that.
Overall, unless it's to secure a lynch, I don't see myself voting for her at the moment.

I'll get back on the wagon later. Need to do things o/

Apr 20, 2017 9:33 PM

Offline
Jan 2010
15856
Ruu said:
Okkay, no quotes because I'm on mobile atm.

Townreads ( based on the ratio between fluff/helpful posts, the content of them and the interaction with other players trying to scumhunt/get reads)

Penta / grrr

Scummy (based on fluff/helpful posts, reasons behind votes)

Lamb / Jack / Chione

vote: Lamb

Okay let me explain. I'm voting for lamb because he was a complete ghost (even more than me) at first and then when he appeared his posts had more fluff than actual useful information. His vote on grrr was weak imo. And his later input didn't give me town vibes.

Chione is different, her posts are good but I don't see a townie behind them. She also defends lamb a lot from logic in the beginning which seemed odd to me. And I can see a lamb/Chione team.

Jack is a similar case to Chione, his posts are not full of fluff but I get a scum!jack vibe from them.

I have to go now but I'll try to come back later!
and after I just defended you during the night phase....smh.
Though I tend to agree with you on Penta I would still like you to cite the posts you feel are helpful. Even more so in regards to grrr.
What is this pre-flip association you have going on between Lam-B and Chione? I don't even see a team there and I was the one who was in the middle of that situation? What scum vibes is jack giving off? Is this "paranoia" talking or do you have something credible to back this with? You're making my question my judgment with my ISO Ruu. I know you said you would be scum hunting at your pace but it's time to pick ir up a little bit for real.
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC


Apr 20, 2017 9:41 PM

Offline
Dec 2016
1608
@logic340 grrr is your top town read in the game? Or am I reading the above wrong. Because I can't wrap my head around not having a stronger town read than grrr at this stage.

Edit:
@aa-dono life comes first, but I'm eager for you to give your take on who is actually scum here.
Apr 20, 2017 9:48 PM

Offline
Jan 2010
15856
Grapefruit21 said:
@logic340 grrr is your top town read in the game? Or am I reading the above wrong. Because I can't wrap my head around not having a stronger town read than grrr at this stage.

Edit:
@aa-dono life comes first, but I'm eager for you to give your take on who is actually scum here.
IDK how you get Penta or grrr as my top town read out of this. I agree that penta has content and what appear to be generally helpful posts but I would like her to cite some of them for us. Even more so in regards to grrr in citing helpful, fluffless posts, with content. I want to see how her mind is working here. I never know what to make of grrr. The more I try the more I feel like I am wrong only ever read him right in NnT. Neutral there. Strongest town read? Probably Jack off tone and a few mindmelds.
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC


Apr 20, 2017 10:08 PM

Offline
Dec 2016
1608
Ahhh gotcha, I totally misread that even more so.
Apr 20, 2017 10:46 PM

Offline
Aug 2013
1703
Grapefruit21 said:


@Oyasumi_Rosie enjoy Persona, but save some time for us or replace out. I'm tired of dead weight slots. You're great, but activity is better.


So last night means nothing?

Apr 20, 2017 10:56 PM

Offline
Dec 2013
17265
logic340 said:

Thank you for your response it's been so long since someone had actual thoughts about one of my ISO's

1. I honestly think gut feeling, which is hard to explain, is sometime more right than the over thinking we do. I mean at that point the only think Karote had done was vote and leave so I am not sure that move would be so justified as you make it sound. Also I don't think she ever outright said he was scum for it
2. I understand the way the roll is supposed to be played. I know there are two outcomes from this claim.
a. What you believe she is scum who wanted an out when she was checked. Death Sentence
b. What I think she's actually a Miller and played it horribly
The timing of her claim doesn't change the fact that if a cop checks her they have to decide whether she is lying or not
3. The thing is we're allowed to feel differently about posts. We have different experiences in mafia and different experiences with Ruu. I know meta is an "iffy" subject because I don't just take everyone's meta at face value either. you don't know if you can trust me this game so you feel like I could be skewing results to fit my narrative I get that. I will work on articulating things better.
4. Lucian didn't think Ruu was scum before he died and right now she's going to open the phase with a lot of votes on her.
5. I really don't think it is unfair. He asked grrr one question. Ruu asked the same question then asked other question relating to the game. Which behavior do you find scummy? Asking someone how they feel about being lynched then voting them for not answering said question or asking someone if they are trying to get themselves killed and asks him why he is role fishing (a question related to getting himself killed and the game).
6. grrr wasn't the traitor in Kitty Mafia though so how do you equate that to traitor role? I am not seeing the correlation but I guess anything is possible. Also the traitor role was Judas who didn't know they were traitor to my knowledge.
7. Scum hunting puts you in the spotlight? Scum hunting is a way to shake suspicion, not scum hunting is what got suspicion on her no?
8. The thing is we're allowed to feel differently about posts. I guess we'll see when she flips.
9. While you may have treated Ruu the same would everyone else have? You know Grapefruit wont let that shit go until she's dead. I struggle to see the scum motivation in claiming Miller there knowing it's a death sentence.

my responses are numbered obviously


1.gut feeling is prob the best path, either way karote one of the people im gonna pressure and ill also want to hear more from ruu's gut feeling.
2.I believe A is more possible because if she really was worried about B then why not claim at the start of the game.
3.Yep exactly, its why people try to avoid meta in the first place becaucse others intepret it differently.
4.Apparently not lol grape took that role
5.I think both are wrong tbf
6.I equate it cause traitor role is the same as miller its just scum aligned that the mafia dont know about. Thats one of the issue town have with that role.
7.Idk i most supicious of her posts and that iso.
8.true
9.Well if she claimed miller after she was check then she def be lynched lol.


Apr 20, 2017 11:00 PM

Offline
Dec 2013
17265
PentaFlare said:
Shinichi-Kun said:
whats with the grapefruit votes am i missing something?

Good question. I don't really have an answer


There goes any town cred i had on you lol, why wont someone for no reason on day 2


Apr 20, 2017 11:08 PM

Offline
Dec 2016
1608
Mini ISO on dono

Properly enters the thread at 260 with a big reads and catchup post.

And there are few odd inconsistencies. The first is the progression on me.

"#70 - Grapefruit starts pressuring grrr for the vote on Coel (#56)
#78 - Suspicious of grrr and Qoco [have to check about Qoco]. The suspicion on grr based on his fluff vote is suspicious. Feels like he picks what may seem scummy, disregarding intentions in other posts.
#81 - Explained susp on Qoco: due to absence of vote. No comment. Used to do that as well since standard is to vote. Views grrr vote-statement as fear mongering.
#194 - If CP wasn't an emotional player, I would have seen this as town. But ok, for now.. maybe not scum. (Or maybe a TPR who wants scum dead so much he's emotional?)" that is not a particularly townie progression, and they say as much in liking Coelestin's vote on me. When asked about it later they cited 194, which isn't given a ringing endorsement here, as the post that swung their opinion. The kicker, 194 had nothing to do with CPurity...

Then they vote lucian but give this progression in their reads:

"#79] - LucianRoy - actually liking this question. Shows Lucian picking up on actual suspicion > moving from RVS
#95 - Baiting grrr with meta.
#183 - One more grrr. Seems set on grrr rather than actually believing Grapefruit."

Again they clarified that it was more points two and 3 outweighing 1 which was a positive.

And that was enough for them to hop on the Lucian train as the fourth vote. 3 lines of posts, two of which were a joke/taunt. That is an incredibly flimsy reasoning.

So aa-dono cited roughly 2 posts of mine they didn't like, 1 they liked for reasons that make no sense and then voted Lucian based off two posts, one of which was town read by others (I think it was Penta who liked that calling attention to his vote being worse than mine post which was 183), they then left there vote there as the wagon disintegrated and reformed without really giving too much more to the case.

Next major post is 509 where they engage with Penta to discuss the Lucian read. My major takeaway from it is the unwillingness to take a stand. Which I understand can happen when you're disengaged from the game because real life is in the way, but in that case you probably shouldn't leave your vote if you're unsure.

Next big post is another major catch up post with lot's of links 536 and this one gives me a bit of pause because all the questions are solid. Still not really campaigning for the Lucian lynch or unvoting though.

This is the last meaningful post before the phase change, they still aren't pushing Lucian in a big way or unvoting. In fact this and shortly before it they spent a lot of effort trying to unknot Ruu, but like logic seeming to come at it from the idea that Ruu is town. Which just confuses me. Like I want to say easy game scum team is Ruu, logic, dono for protecting each other, but that makes no sense at all on any level except the confidence I just can't understand on Ruu being town.

Anyway my major takeaway from this is dono hopped onto a hot wagon. Did not leave when it went cold, but never pushed for it in a big way. Even their convo with Penta that is the closest they came to pushing it feels half hearted. If I didn't have such a good feeling about Ruu being scum I'd be happy to vote dono at this point.

-------------------

Reading while posting @Oyasumi_Rosie it's not that last night meant nothing it's more that doesn't give you a pass to have another day like D1. Though I'd have to reread to see how much you actually did last night. The only part that left an impression on me was your on point meme'ing. I don't pay as much attention to nights tbh.

Apr 20, 2017 11:14 PM

Offline
Dec 2016
1608
Ughh that dono case is horribly messy. I need to remember to put all the links at the beginning and not disperse them around like I want to for readability. Legibility is more important...
Apr 20, 2017 11:21 PM

Offline
Dec 2013
17265
gonna finish replying in the morning


Apr 20, 2017 11:38 PM

Offline
Jan 2010
15856
Going to take a nap. I have laundry to do in a little while hopefully I can be on with @Lam-B tonight?
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC


Reply Disabled for Non-Club Members
Pages (85) « First ... « 21 22 [23] 24 25 » ... Last »

More topics from this board

» [GAME] Give something to the user above you ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Soren - Oct 9, 2015

1395 by Serafos »»
Dec 13, 9:10 PM

» [GAME] Last Letter Game ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

grave_robber - Sep 9, 2014

8755 by Serafos »»
Dec 11, 7:29 PM

» [GAME] (* ̄・ ̄)ノ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated MEMBER Posts! v1 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

SoulEaterQUEEN - Mar 26, 2016

1996 by Serafos »»
Dec 7, 10:20 PM

» [GAME] (* ̄・ ̄)ノ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated Staff Member Posts! v4 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Togs - Jul 2, 2017

2877 by Serafos »»
Dec 7, 10:20 PM

» Count To 7777 V3 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Lambtron - May 15, 2018

1170 by Serafos »»
Dec 7, 10:20 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login