Game v8: Between The Rock and the Sea | Game End - MAFIA WINS

Shinichi-Kun said:


if logic flips town the game ends ppretty much lol

Shinichi-Kun said:


honestly this just a bad attempt of trying to get eyes offf of you.

Rinto-kun said:
So guys do you think Rosie lied and her double-voter ability was actually a mafia's regular skill?
I doubt many towns have double-voting so.

Anyone wondering where aa-dono disappeared? She sent some accusations to my address yet she hasn't appeared to back me up.

Rinto-kun said:
So guys do you think Rosie lied and her double-voter ability was actually a mafia's regular skill?
I doubt many towns have double-voting so.

Anyone wondering where aa-dono disappeared? She sent some accusations to my address yet she hasn't appeared to back me up.

logic340 said:
EoD2 Rosie was trying to see a Vote Count in an attempt to see if her ability worked. Some though it was scummy I though it pointed to her being a Double Voter. Anyway when she revealed her ability she said she was an even day double vote and would be able to use her ability today D4.
At the EoD3Rinto leads the lynch with 4 (Grrr, JustKrista, CorruptedPurity, Rinto) grrr is second with 3 (Rosie, Me, Shinichi). Somehow grrr ended up dying which we are still trying to figure out why/how?

Oyasumi_Rosie said:
They were a replace me for togs since D3 so they couldn't have protected anyone lol

Oyasumi_Rosie said:
I think he means that if I was scum I would have lied about thinking I was an even day voter (it might turn out that I am an odd day double voter)but if I am town I would just be as surprised as everyone else is to figure out my power (which I am lol)

TheConquerer said:

I guess if there's 4 scum left by process of most scummy I'd say.
Grape
Shin
Rinto (even if they're trolling I'd put them over log and rosie)
aa-dono (just if there are 4)

logic340 said:
@TheConquerer do you think aa is scummy for her vote on you? Is it her behavior or are you looking at her and Kaitou as a whole. I have plenty of suspicions about that slot as well so I'd like to hear what you are thinking about aa so far?

Grapefruit21 said:
Reread Krista because for numbers it seems like one of my town reads must be scum. Trying to figure out who. After reading Krista feel good there. Followed through as promised.

Shinichi-Kun said:


ok fair enough

problem is now we need to find the roleblocker

Rinto-kun said:
Anyone wondering where aa-dono disappeared? She sent some accusations to my address yet she hasn't appeared to back me up.

aa-dono said:
"plenty of suspicion" here refers to Kaitou, right?
I thought he was inactive. What earned him suspicion besides inactivity?

Grapefruit21 said:
@logic340 of course I'm implying you'd know each others abilities if you in every scum chats I've seen they have mod confirmed roles of each other. You I don't know why you think I'd imply cheating with that. Scum know each others roles.

aa-dono said:
I can see the points that Grape brought up against logic. And this: makes me feel even more suspicious. I didn't think logic would be scumreading an inactive slot. That's just odd.

However, Grape also brought up another point that makes scum!logic unlikely:

logic has never rolled scum before this so it's not odd that he didn't know or thought of the basic of scum club, that scumbuddies are likely to know each other roles, either they share it or host share it in the secret club.
If he overlook this, I think it simply means that he didn't know that roles between scum members are shared which implies that he's not scum this time too.

Grapefruit21 said:
I've been assuming 5-4 but if it's 6 3 we have another mislynch. (feels like too many mislynches though)

On Rosie I would never lynch her without a scum lgoic flip. But I started wondering with the double vote stuff that logic seemed to know too much. Then they started defending each other pretty strongly. Rosies Shini vote was really strange and kind of looked like scum not knowing where they can vote safely. She had expressed 0 scum read on Shinichi before this that I recall, and didn't really explain ot all. Never voting today but I don't know where scum is besides logic and I need to start figuring it out as I'm probably not going to get NKd with scum trying their darndest to mislynch me today.

BorrowedFromCorruptedPurity said:
Confirmed:
Kit - Cop
Gwendolly - Doctor
Claire - Vanilla
Suzune - Neighbor
Sonata - Vanilla
grrr - Vanilla
Lam-B - Roleblocker

Claims
Krista - Vig
Shinichi - Vanilla
Grapefruit - Vanilla
Oyssumi_Rosie - Double Voter
Rinto - Vanilla
TheConquerer - 75% Doc
Logic - Vanilla
CorruptedPurity - Vengeful
aa-dono - unknown

Oyasumi_Rosie said:
My only defensense agiantst this is that I have. Though not in a way I am sure you would have read it as such. I am pretty sure that I mentioned my thoughts during day two, because it was back when Suzu was alive. I will find the post for you

Grapefruit21 said:
@aa-dono wait you were in that game wouldn't you have know logic was finally scum? I'm confused now. Do you just not count that the game as one of these longer games?

aa-dono said:
You mean the 1 week werewolf? Wasn't logic scum that did not join the scum chat? He swap roles with CP right?

aa-dono said:

Correct me if I'm wrong here:
So @Rinto-kun voted himself in an effort to save grrr?

Bastard element is hidden right? What is Rosie is actually a Double Voter on odd days?
That would make more sense if grrr's lynch was RNGed.

Either that or Rinto has some kind of manipulation ability. Though I doubt this. Since usually when someone has a manipulation ability, they would make it so that they don't come into spotlight. That self vote, if it wasn't Rinto giving up, then he miggght be town.

aa-dono said:
"plenty of suspicion" here refers to Kaitou, right?
I thought he was inactive. What earned him suspicion besides inactivity?

Grapefruit21 said:

He has rolled scum now. The ultimate werewolf game which he won. Unsure if it had a scum chat though. I also assume he would have read scum chats because he's thorough and obsessive like I am.

Well and this one too, but I haven't been proven right yet.

Grapefruit21 said:
@aa-dono can you explain your logic town read a bit more for me? Is it just the knowing Rosie's role thing? Couldn't that just mean they aren't scum together?

CorruptedPurity said:


I've only played with logic like twice before, both times I was scum and he was town. Tbh, I tend to be emotional at times so he being emotional isn't a scum marker for me.

You argue that he has been pushing onto grape for last 3 phases but at the same time, grape has been pushing into logic for last 3 phases. Also, logic had other suspects like Krista,Suzu and Grrr. He did a long post and ISO on each of them, so no, I don't see him tunneling on grape in the same way grape tunneled onto him.



Wrong, logic and grape are top tier on the lynch list. Rinto comes a close third. You come a close fourth after evaluation, maybe even higher. Your only defense for your EoD3 behavior is "i fucked up by voting grrr, but nonetheless im still town and i still want us to win the game."?

Idk why you have a town-lean on grape, or even if you claim to not have, you do not seem to be suspecting him as much as logic. I can honestly see a scum team with you and grape. Only reason why I (don't think) I'm voting you today is because I see better a better target in Grape and (potentially logic) but mostly grape. If he flips scum, you're next to be lynched.

Shinichi-Kun said:

you can all bicker about me all you want in the end i admi i fucked up by voting grrr, but nonetheless im stl
ill town and i still want us to win the game.

logic340 said:
@Grapefruit21 and @Shinichi-kun. You guys say there wasn't another option when you saw Rinto-kun vote for himself right? What about aa-dono (2) grrr, Krista? Couldn't you have saved both Rinto and grrr both?

Grapefruit21 said:
@aa-dono wait you were in that game wouldn't you have know logic was finally scum? I'm confused now. Do you just not count that the game as one of these longer games?

logic340 said:
Maybe you should familiarized yourself with that game before you use that as reasoning for I am scum you are flawed here. It was not a traditional mafia game here is the link.

CorruptedPurity said:
This coupled with the fact that Shinichi's best defense to my post on #1640 is that
makes my view on him turn 180.

Also, he and Grape always have a nice one-pocket-the-other interaction. Shini votes logic, grape votes logic. Shini decides to last minute jump onto grrr train, grape decides to last minute jump onto grrr train.

Vote:Shinichi

Oyasumi_Rosie said:
Unrelated to this game, I wish I signed up. I love RL One Night Werewolf. Its so much fun. One day we should all play a live version : D

CorruptedPurity said:


Meh, it was pretty inactive and to this day, I can never forgive logic for robbing my role and my win.

aa-dono said:
I scumread Shinichi based on these before. And he ended up town so idk... Effort and explanation seems to depends on external factors with him :/

Grapefruit21 said:
Unvote

Dono your case is convincing. I just assumed logic would know that from reading scum chats and knowing how scum coordinate their abilities, but for now benefit of the doubt. Because you're right even if he did know him making that post makes no sense as scum at least that I can think of right now.

@Oyasumi_Rosie thanks for that. Looking at it and back at D2 now.

@logic340 you considered me conf town because of being role locked edit blocked. If I'm town who is scum. I feel lost and naked outside my tunnel.

Also I don't have work tomorrow so I will be up for a while but hopefully not till 4.