New
Jan 17, 2017 10:33 AM
#1
Welcome to the world of Disgaea: A Darker Darkness presented by your hosts Doughkey and Cody. The creators of the unique games Fate/stay Night Mafia, Fire Emblem Mafia, Hyrule Hysteria, UAS and UAS2 are here to bring you another gimmicky spin-off of the traditional forum mafia formula. The premise of this game spawned from the idea of a game that kept all players involved from start to finish, regardless of silly concepts like 'death'. With so many new elements thrown into this game it will truly test the ability of the participants. I would like to thank @Cody, @Jackrito and @SoulEaterQueen for their help in balancing and managing this game, this would be impossible without their continued support~ Rules Section I: General Game Guidelines 1. External communications (PM/IRC/etc.) are prohibited. Mafia is allowed to communicate with their fellow members in the designated club created by the host. Mafia is allowed to discuss in both day and night phases freely. 2. ]You may PM the host with questions/concerns regarding the rules. PM's will likely receive replies within 12 hours. 3. The Site & Forum Guidelines should be taken into consideration. Section II: Game Overview 1. This game is no-reveal. Any player who is killed will not have their role or alignment revealed. 2. Every role in the game is effectively 'stump' role. Upon death, whether via Lynch or ability, the player will remain in the game with the ability to speak freely in thread. This player will lose the ability to vote and use their abilities and do not count towards their factions number. See passive: 'Heroes Never Die'. 3. There are two phases; day phase and night phase. Day phase will last 48 hours, night phase will be 24 hours. Day is where you discuss who to lynch and vote. Communication is NOT allowed during the Night phase. Mafia may talk in their club and will choose who to kill during the night phase. 4. There will be no spoilers, but I may make references when I have the chance. 5. Abilities are processed according to this priority system. Role Blocking>Protection>Night kill. 6. If you want to use your skills, contact the host via your role PM. Alternatively for mafia post your action(s) in your club by comment or thread, make sure it's in bold. The mafia kill will be decided by Xenolith. Upon Xenoliths death a new mafia godfather will be chosen through RNG. This players abilities will remain as they were, they will only decide who to be killed. 7. No copy/pasting PMs. You can share the contents of a PM, but you can only paraphrase what I said. 8. No posting a screenshot of a PM or a modified screenshot of a PM 9. No communication is allowed during the night phase. 10. Play to your win condition. 11. If a third party meets their win condition, the host will make an announcement stating the role has won the game. The players identity will not be revealed and they will remain in the game. 12. Disgaea is an open setup game with no bastard elements, 14 players, kills WILL NOT be revealed, factions consist of town, mafia and 3rd party. Section III: Lynching 1. During the day phase, players can vote who they want to lynch. Who ever gets the most votes at the end of the day phase will be lynched. 2. Any player can change and/or remove their vote. 3. Vote like this: Vote: Cody bold so that I wont miss it. If a vote is not bolded it will not be considered under any circumstances. 4. Tied votes will result in no lynch for day 1 only, from day 2 onwards tied votes will equal a randomized lynch between the players who are tied. 5. No Lynch' is a valid vote option. If this option receives the most votes, no lynch will occur on that phase. If No Lynch ties with another lynch option, no lynch will occur regardless of what day it is. Section IV: Inactivity 1. Inactivity is frowned upon and makes the game boring. So please be as active as you can. It is especially important to remain active in this game given the unique setup. 2. If you are unable to post for a phase please PM the host and I will excuse you for a single phase. If you need to be replaced give the host as much time as possible to find a replacement. I understand things arise and you may not be able to play. 3. To be deemed active you must make 4 posts per phase. If you do not meet this requirement you will be given a strike and will be sent a PM containing a warning. If you go another phase without posting the requirement, you will be immediately banned upon that phases end. Roles Town Laharl Passive - Heroes Never Die If you are killed - If this player is killed they will remain in the game. They will be able to post in the thread freely. However, they lose their ability to lynch and no longer count towards their factions number of players. Passive 2 - I'm Da King, Baby! Laharl will be revealed as town on Day 1. Flonne Ability - Divine Intervention Fionne may choose 1 player every night to protect. This ability blocks both the mafia night kill and Xenoliths Exorcism ability. Passive - Heroes Never Die If this player is killed they will remain in the game. They will be able to post in the thread freely. However, they lose their ability to lynch and no longer count towards their factions number of players.Passive - Heroes Never Die - If you are killed - If this player is killed they will remain in the game. They will be able to post in the thread freely. However, they lose their ability to lynch and no longer count towards their factions number of players. Etna Passive - Heroes Never Die If you are killed - If this player is killed they will remain in the game. They will be able to post in the thread freely. However, they lose their ability to lynch and no longer count towards their factions number of players. Passive 2 - Polished Shit Not a Prinny. Prinny x6 Passive - Heroes Never Die If you are killed - If this player is killed they will remain in the game. They will be able to post in the thread freely. However, they lose their ability to lynch and no longer count towards their factions number of players. Mafia Xenolith Ability - Dark Phenomenon For every one of your Prinnies that die you may choose to exorcise another player. If you select a player who has already been killed, you may target them to remove them from the game once and for all. This ability has no effect on players who are alive. The mafia may use their night kill ability and Dark Phenomenon on the same target on the same night. You may use this ability during any phase and it will go into effect at the next phase change. When a player is exorcised the host will announce the victim at phase change. Laharl is immune to this ability. Fionne's 'Divine Intervention' will negate the effects of Exorcism and you will lose the chance to use this ability on someone for that Prinny's death. Passive - Heroes Never Die If this player is killed they will remain in the game. They will be able to post in the thread freely. However, they lose their ability to lynch and no longer count towards their factions number of players. Prinny x2 Passive - Heroes Never Die If this player is killed they will remain in the game. They will be able to post in the thread freely. However, they lose their ability to lynch and no longer count towards their factions number of players. 3rd Party Metallia Win Condition If Metallia is lynched she will win the game. Passive - Heroes Never Die If this player is killed they will remain in the game. They will be able to post in the thread freely. However, they lose their ability to lynch and no longer count towards their factions number of players. Rozalin Win Condition Rozalin will be given a townie target along with her role PM. Rozalin will be tasked to lynch the target. If that target is killed by the mafia she will be given only one more target, if that one is also killed, she will lose the game. The target will be chosen through RNG among the town, Laharl, mafia and Metallia cannot be the target. Passive - Heroes Never Die If this player is killed they will remain in the game. They will be able to post in the thread freely. However, they lose their ability to lynch and no longer count towards their factions number of players. Player List 1. Phraze - Laharl 2. Wen294 3. Ruu 4. ZXDarkBlade 5. Logic340 6. Sleipnirr - Metallia Won D2 7. Suzune-chan 8. Shinichi-Chad 9. Grapefruit21 10. AlbertinoDias 11. aa-dono 12. Blonde 13. Omnisword Togs Rinto-kun 14. Karote Wait-list 1. Togs 2. leunammi 3. Rinto-kun |
SorenApr 25, 2017 10:43 AM
Jan 18, 2017 12:50 PM
#2
All roles have been sent. If you have not received your role please send me a PM. Game will begin in 3 hours~ 1. @Phraze 2. @Wen294 3. @Ruu 4. @ZXDarkBlade 5. @Logic340 6. @Sleipnirr 7. @Suzune-chan 8. @Shinichi-kun (Chad) 9. @Grapefruit21 10. @AlbertinoDias 11. @aa-dono 12. @Blonde 13. @Omnisword 14. @Karote |
Jan 18, 2017 3:52 PM
#3
Day 1 starts now! Phraze has been revealed as Laharl! Time until Phase Change |
Jan 18, 2017 4:09 PM
#4
Alright game start!!! I'm playing two games at once so bear with me. vote: AlbertinoDias It's been a while. Did you get a scum PM this game? |
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Jan 18, 2017 4:23 PM
#5
@Phraze @Wen294 @Ruu @ZXDarkBlade @Logic340 @Sleipnirr @Suzune-chan @Shinichi-kun (Chad) @Grapefruit21 @AlbertinoDias @aa-dono @Blonde @Omnisword @Karote Game start lets get it in!!! |
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Jan 18, 2017 4:31 PM
#6
Vote Phraze for OMGUS reasons. Also as a general thought I'm a bit perplexed about how to approach this game. Lack of flips is going to make me really agonize over reads and interactions. |
Jan 18, 2017 4:45 PM
#7
Grapefruit21 said: you do know Phraze is confirmed town right?Vote Phraze for OMGUS reasons. Also as a general thought I'm a bit perplexed about how to approach this game. Lack of flips is going to make me really agonize over reads and interactions. |
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Jan 18, 2017 4:47 PM
#8
vote: Grapefruit21 come on man Edit: corrected spelling |
logic340Jan 18, 2017 5:24 PM
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Jan 18, 2017 5:01 PM
#9
Well that was a fail of reading... Going to blame that one on playing at work >_> Vote Ruu |
Jan 18, 2017 5:50 PM
#10
Jump in to Disgaea thread hello everyone i see two familiar user above me. sasuga of Laharl he even bribed the GM to revealed himself that is overlord Laharl for you my starter post i will Vote : Suzune-chan |
Jan 18, 2017 7:22 PM
#11
Ahahah sorry guys I wasn't available until now (actually I shouldn't even be on now because my friend is in the room sleeping lol) @grapefruit21 why me? Just to start a conversation since we don't know each other? Also I know the feeling man, Astros' game used the same set up and the not knowing is horrible xD I'll do the same and vote:Blonde Still I hope logic rolled scum this time. I'll probably change my vote later after I talk to Blonde and everyone else. I hate that @Phraze is confirmed town I always enjoy trying to lynch her xD I'm ready for my Romeo to show up, where are you? :-; |
Jan 18, 2017 7:34 PM
#12
Ruu said: That's a negative Ghost Rider. Have you played with many of the people in this game before?Ahahah sorry guys I wasn't available until now (actually I shouldn't even be on now because my friend is in the room sleeping lol) @grapefruit21 why me? Just to start a conversation since we don't know each other? Also I know the feeling man, Astros' game used the same set up and the not knowing is horrible xD I'll do the same and vote:Blonde Still I hope logic rolled scum this time. I'll probably change my vote later after I talk to Blonde and everyone else. I hate that @Phraze is confirmed town I always enjoy trying to lynch her xD I'm ready for my Romeo to show up, where are you? :-; |
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Jan 18, 2017 7:44 PM
#13
Yay, game start. Vote:Sleip Did we play together recently or long ago? Could you remind me. |
Where there is no imagination there is no horror. || Arthur Conan Doyle || Happy Halloween! |
Jan 18, 2017 8:11 PM
#14
logic340 said: Ruu said: That's a negative Ghost Rider. Have you played with many of the people in this game before?Ahahah sorry guys I wasn't available until now (actually I shouldn't even be on now because my friend is in the room sleeping lol) @grapefruit21 why me? Just to start a conversation since we don't know each other? Also I know the feeling man, Astros' game used the same set up and the not knowing is horrible xD I'll do the same and vote:Blonde Still I hope logic rolled scum this time. I'll probably change my vote later after I talk to Blonde and everyone else. I hate that @Phraze is confirmed town I always enjoy trying to lynch her xD I'm ready for my Romeo to show up, where are you? :-; What's that? O_o I see a lot of new people at least for me. But the classics are still here xD like you, Phraze, Suzu, Chad, Karote, aa-dono. |
Jan 18, 2017 8:14 PM
#15
Ruu said: I'm interested in seeing how Phraze approaches things with her being townfirmed. I see a lot of familiar faces as well.logic340 said: Ruu said: Ahahah sorry guys I wasn't available until now (actually I shouldn't even be on now because my friend is in the room sleeping lol) @grapefruit21 why me? Just to start a conversation since we don't know each other? Also I know the feeling man, Astros' game used the same set up and the not knowing is horrible xD I'll do the same and vote:Blonde Still I hope logic rolled scum this time. I'll probably change my vote later after I talk to Blonde and everyone else. I hate that @Phraze is confirmed town I always enjoy trying to lynch her xD I'm ready for my Romeo to show up, where are you? :-; What's that? O_o I see a lot of new people at least for me. But the classics are still here xD like you, Phraze, Suzu, Chad, Karote, aa-dono. |
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Jan 18, 2017 8:28 PM
#16
@Ruu well I wasn't going to leave my vote on Phraze.... Your name happened to be the easiest to spell so you won RVS lottery take two! |
Jan 18, 2017 8:54 PM
#17
Grapefruit21 said: @Ruu well I wasn't going to leave my vote on Phraze.... Your name happened to be the easiest to spell so you won RVS lottery take two! Becareful Laharl with catch you because he is the most badass and number 1 overlord. |
Jan 18, 2017 10:24 PM
#19
Soooo.... @Shinichi-kun did you get scum again? Grapefruit21 said: Why did you skip wen?Well that was a fail of reading... Going to blame that one on playing at work >_> Vote Ruu |
Jan 18, 2017 10:26 PM
#20
Omnisword said: Aiyaaa seems like there's someone else who's seeking Suzune's attention. Jump in to Disgaea thread hello everyone i see two familiar user above me. sasuga of Laharl he even bribed the GM to revealed himself that is overlord Laharl for you my starter post i will Vote : Suzune-chan Hello btw o/ |
Jan 18, 2017 10:53 PM
#21
aa-dono said: Omnisword said: Aiyaaa seems like there's someone else who's seeking Suzune's attention. Jump in to Disgaea thread hello everyone i see two familiar user above me. sasuga of Laharl he even bribed the GM to revealed himself that is overlord Laharl for you my starter post i will Vote : Suzune-chan Hello btw o/ Hello, i see you are innocent girl listen there is abandoned house over there let's come with me Don't worry i am not suspicious man you can tell from my profile user page "smile" |
Jan 18, 2017 10:53 PM
#22
aa-dono said: Soooo.... @Shinichi-kun did you get scum again? Grapefruit21 said: Why did you skip wen?Well that was a fail of reading... Going to blame that one on playing at work >_> Vote Ruu Good question! Why did you? >_> Still I'll let you use the newbie card for this one but I hope it doesn't became a habit >_> I will keep and eye on your interactions >_> Omnisword said: Grapefruit21 said: @Ruu well I wasn't going to leave my vote on Phraze.... Your name happened to be the easiest to spell so you won RVS lottery take two! Becareful Laharl with catch you because he is the most badass and number 1 overlord. ^ I don't trust fluff posts sorry. You are on my watchlist. People are suspecting Suzu from the start is just because she usually rolls scum? I thought Shinichi was going to get the first train xD Congrats Chad :p |
Jan 18, 2017 11:58 PM
#23
Ruu said: aa-dono said: Soooo.... @Shinichi-kun did you get scum again? Grapefruit21 said: Well that was a fail of reading... Going to blame that one on playing at work >_> Vote Ruu Good question! Why did you? >_> Still I'll let you use the newbie card for this one but I hope it doesn't became a habit >_> I will keep and eye on your interactions >_> Omnisword said: Grapefruit21 said: @Ruu well I wasn't going to leave my vote on Phraze.... Your name happened to be the easiest to spell so you won RVS lottery take two! Becareful Laharl with catch you because he is the most badass and number 1 overlord. ^ I don't trust fluff posts sorry. You are on my watchlist. People are suspecting Suzu from the start is just because she usually rolls scum? I thought Shinichi was going to get the first train xD Congrats Chad :p When did grape use the newbie card? o.O People as in me and Omni? I voted her because I like her. Not sure if she always rolls scum :/ You don't wanna join us? Why? You don't like her? D: Also, Shin-chan is too mainstream. Though I believe in jinx. So he might be scum here. Since Penta's not here x) |
Jan 19, 2017 12:17 AM
#24
logic340 said: it will be my pleasure to play with you and you are wrong, sorry about that, (just got up... Sorry)Alright game start!!! I'm playing two games at once so bear with me. vote: AlbertinoDias It's been a while. Did you get a scum PM this game? |
Jan 19, 2017 12:19 AM
#25
And I am so salty here why aa-dono didn't responded to my genuine offer to come with me to that abandoned house "sulk in corner" vote aa-dono |
Jan 19, 2017 12:36 AM
#26
Omnisword said: My momma told me not to follow strangers~And I am so salty here why aa-dono didn't responded to my genuine offer to come with me to that abandoned house "sulk in corner" vote aa-dono |
Jan 19, 2017 1:40 AM
#27
gratz me~ what's my power-zero streak now? @Ruu I hate that @Phraze is confirmed town I always enjoy trying to lynch her xD I'm ready for my Romeo to show up, where are you? :-; my golden opportunity has arrived! I can lynch my Julietto anytime >w>@logic340 I'm interested in seeing how Phraze approaches things with her being townfirmed. I see a lot of familiar faces as well. I'd say town is lucky it's me who's townfirmed, esp in a no-reveal. I can easily run multiple scenarios/possibilities as the only town stump lol. it would be a waste of scum to NK me too, since I'm just as useful dead or alive....as a stump :Psooooo who wants to buddy up with me~? noww errr we gotta find the jester and watch out for him.. |
Jan 19, 2017 1:43 AM
#28
Chad doing what chad does best. AKA rolling scum. aa-dono said: Omnisword said: My momma told me not to follow strangers~And I am so salty here why aa-dono didn't responded to my genuine offer to come with me to that abandoned house "sulk in corner" vote aa-dono Guess he should've offered a bar of chocolate. aa-dono said: When did grape use the newbie card? o.O Also, Shin-chan is too mainstream. Though I believe in jinx. So he might be scum here. Since Penta's not here x) Hm so grape isn't a newbie then? I don't know him so thanks for telling i guess. Also, when you're in a game with penta and you rolled vig, first thing you do is shoot penta. True story. As for my vote: vote: Phraze because reasons I cry about the fact that i can't do this. Vote: Togs because togs I still cry. Vote: omnisword I mean obviously nobody would seriously praise Laharl, it's obviously fake to try and get close to Laharl. Except maybe for prinnies that were forced into praising Laharl by Laharl himself but his messages don't end with DOOD so we can assume that isn't the case. |
Jan 19, 2017 1:45 AM
#29
Phraze said: noww errr we gotta find the jester and watch out for him.. Okey guys i have a masterplan, Phraze is confirmed to be Laharl so if we lynch her we know for sure that we're not lynching the jester. |
Jan 19, 2017 3:35 AM
#30
@wen294 I'm semi noob. Finished one game of forum mafia, many in person, and a decent chunk of theory and game reading in addition to my one finished game. |
Jan 19, 2017 3:58 AM
#31
So if we are worried about lynching the jester I will ask everyone who is voting Omni why they have their votes their? I don't know much about third party roles but out of everyone Omni's behavior would be most indicative of this role from my PoV. Basically Jester wants to get lynched to achieve wincon so they will be doing some lynch worthy stuff. I do feel this will give scum a little more latitude in what they are able to do as many players can fake 3rd party but hopefully if scum do that it will make Metallia side with the town. I wont be voting up Omni right now. Grapefruit21 is a RVS but also due to not reading things and voting Phraze @Phraze I wont buddy up to you but it's almost like having my mason lodge without the chat. I know that I can trust what you say is coming from town and I can use what I know about our roles to PoE later on. AlbertinoDias said: While I hope that is the case we will have to prove it to one another. logic340 said: it will be my pleasure to play with you and you are wrong, sorry about that, (just got up... Sorry)Alright game start!!! I'm playing two games at once so bear with me. vote: AlbertinoDias It's been a while. Did you get a scum PM this game? aa-dono said: Shinichii has been scum in both games I played with him. I hope to see what his town game is like for a change. I wont hold the fact that he roles scum a lot against him since the opposite is true of me. Ruu said: aa-dono said: Soooo.... @Shinichi-kun did you get scum again? Grapefruit21 said: Why did you skip wen?Well that was a fail of reading... Going to blame that one on playing at work >_> Vote Ruu Good question! Why did you? >_> Still I'll let you use the newbie card for this one but I hope it doesn't became a habit >_> I will keep and eye on your interactions >_> Omnisword said: Grapefruit21 said: @Ruu well I wasn't going to leave my vote on Phraze.... Your name happened to be the easiest to spell so you won RVS lottery take two! Becareful Laharl with catch you because he is the most badass and number 1 overlord. ^ I don't trust fluff posts sorry. You are on my watchlist. People are suspecting Suzu from the start is just because she usually rolls scum? I thought Shinichi was going to get the first train xD Congrats Chad :p When did grape use the newbie card? o.O People as in me and Omni? I voted her because I like her. Not sure if she always rolls scum :/ You don't wanna join us? Why? You don't like her? D: Also, Shin-chan is too mainstream. Though I believe in jinx. So he might be scum here. Since Penta's not here x) wen294 said: I don't like it lets just lynch scum instead.Phraze said: noww errr we gotta find the jester and watch out for him.. Okey guys i have a masterplan, Phraze is confirmed to be Laharl so if we lynch her we know for sure that we're not lynching the jester. |
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Jan 19, 2017 5:03 AM
#32
aa-dono said: Ruu said: aa-dono said: Soooo.... @Shinichi-kun did you get scum again? Grapefruit21 said: Why did you skip wen?Well that was a fail of reading... Going to blame that one on playing at work >_> Vote Ruu Good question! Why did you? >_> Still I'll let you use the newbie card for this one but I hope it doesn't became a habit >_> I will keep and eye on your interactions >_> Omnisword said: Grapefruit21 said: @Ruu well I wasn't going to leave my vote on Phraze.... Your name happened to be the easiest to spell so you won RVS lottery take two! Becareful Laharl with catch you because he is the most badass and number 1 overlord. ^ I don't trust fluff posts sorry. You are on my watchlist. People are suspecting Suzu from the start is just because she usually rolls scum? I thought Shinichi was going to get the first train xD Congrats Chad :p When did grape use the newbie card? o.O People as in me and Omni? I voted her because I like her. Not sure if she always rolls scum :/ You don't wanna join us? Why? You don't like her? D: Also, Shin-chan is too mainstream. Though I believe in jinx. So he might be scum here. Since Penta's not here x) Because of the mistakes he made I assume he was a newbie so I was saying I'll let him have this one because newbie. Is he not? If so trying to get lynch to achieve wincon? I can also see mafia trying to look guilty so everybody think they are 3rd party but Idk. Without Denja or grrr playing we don't have confirmed mafia from the start xD I wish more people were talking so we could move pass rvs :/ |
Jan 19, 2017 5:48 AM
#33
wen294 said: I don't mean he's not new. What I meant is that Ruu was saying he used the newbie card something but I don't see that in grape's posts.aa-dono said: When did grape use the newbie card? o.O Also, Shin-chan is too mainstream. Though I believe in jinx. So he might be scum here. Since Penta's not here x) Hm so grape isn't a newbie then? I don't know him so thanks for telling i guess. |
Jan 19, 2017 5:51 AM
#34
logic340 said: So if we are worried about lynching the jester I will ask everyone who is voting Omni why they have their votes their? I don't know much about third party roles but out of everyone Omni's behavior would be most indicative of this role from my PoV. Basically Jester wants to get lynched to achieve wincon so they will be doing some lynch worthy stuff. I do feel this will give scum a little more latitude in what they are able to do as many players can fake 3rd party but hopefully if scum do that it will make Metallia side with the town. Few roles are as likely to slip as the jester. So long as we don't try to rush a decision it's fine to pressurize whoever. |
Jan 19, 2017 5:55 AM
#35
This feels so scummy. Why do you feel the need to declare not-gonna-buddy-up? Vote Change: logic340 Also, what's wrong with that Omni vote? If he's a jester from acting scummy, then he deserves all the pressure. But how would you know that it's not scum being scummy? E-eh. Because you're scum and he's not your team? Good. |
Jan 19, 2017 5:57 AM
#36
Ruu said: Because of the mistakes he made I assume he was a newbie so I was saying I'll let him have this one because newbie. Is he not? If so trying to get lynch to achieve wincon? I can also see mafia trying to look guilty so everybody think they are 3rd party but Idk. Without Denja or grrr playing we don't have confirmed mafia from the start xD I wish more people were talking so we could move pass rvs :/ From my experience Denja and Grrr just go full jest while playing as town. I've never seen either as scum, but whenever i played with them i always just felt like something was up. aa-dono said: wen294 said: I don't mean he's not new. What I meant is that Ruu was saying he used the newbie card something but I don't see that in grape's posts.aa-dono said: When did grape use the newbie card? o.O Also, Shin-chan is too mainstream. Though I believe in jinx. So he might be scum here. Since Penta's not here x) Hm so grape isn't a newbie then? I don't know him so thanks for telling i guess. Saying he doesn't know how to approach the game, failed to read something everyone should've read. I mean why would you not pay attention to the confirmed town message when you know in advance that there will be one, irregardless of role. For scum it's someone to keep on your to-kill list, as town it's someone you can trust, what that leaves is third party because they don't care who is town and who isn't. |
Jan 19, 2017 6:07 AM
#37
@Ruu and @aa-dono Grapefruit is currently playing his second and third forum mafia games. He has RL experience playing and has done study before joining the MS club here on MAL. He is new here but has a good understanding of game. We were mason's together in his first game (Haruhi). aa-dono said: Phraze asked a question I answered that is how I work I don't shy away from things that people may or may not find scummy I do me and handle things as they come. I will be suspicious of the people who openly try to buddy up to Phraze knowing she is town firmed. I never said that Omni isn't scum being scummy I was laying out my thoughts for you all. If we don't want to lynch the jester and he is most jester like why is everyone voting for him? Sure it could be scum and the fact that they know there is a jester gives them a little latitude but if we are really trying to prevent the jester from winning why vote for the person who seems to fit that role perfectly? It's a question not a defense?This feels so scummy. Why do you feel the need to declare not-gonna-buddy-up? Vote Change: logic340 Also, what's wrong with that Omni vote? If he's a jester from acting scummy, then he deserves all the pressure. But how would you know that it's not scum being scummy? E-eh. Because you're scum and he's not your team? Good. |
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Jan 19, 2017 6:21 AM
#38
"has done study before joining the MS club" sorry what? I can't help imagine people sitting behind some thick theory book and then taking some entrance exam to get into the club. Last i checked it was just a "if you are interested join and play, you'll learn it eventually" |
Jan 19, 2017 6:26 AM
#39
wen294 said: Ah~ I didn't check who the innocent child was either :PRuu said: Because of the mistakes he made I assume he was a newbie so I was saying I'll let him have this one because newbie. Is he not? If so trying to get lynch to achieve wincon? I can also see mafia trying to look guilty so everybody think they are 3rd party but Idk. Without Denja or grrr playing we don't have confirmed mafia from the start xD I wish more people were talking so we could move pass rvs :/ From my experience Denja and Grrr just go full jest while playing as town. I've never seen either as scum, but whenever i played with them i always just felt like something was up. aa-dono said: wen294 said: aa-dono said: When did grape use the newbie card? o.O Also, Shin-chan is too mainstream. Though I believe in jinx. So he might be scum here. Since Penta's not here x) Hm so grape isn't a newbie then? I don't know him so thanks for telling i guess. Saying he doesn't know how to approach the game, failed to read something everyone should've read. I mean why would you not pay attention to the confirmed town message when you know in advance that there will be one, irregardless of role. For scum it's someone to keep on your to-kill list, as town it's someone you can trust, what that leaves is third party because they don't care who is town and who isn't. I only knew it's Phraze because I read that grape - logic interaction. |
Jan 19, 2017 6:33 AM
#40
logic340 said: Ah, sorry about that. I missed Phraze's question. Or perhaps I thought it was rhetorical :/@Ruu and @aa-dono Grapefruit is currently playing his second and third forum mafia games. He has RL experience playing and has done study before joining the MS club here on MAL. He is new here but has a good understanding of game. We were mason's together in his first game (Haruhi). aa-dono said: Phraze asked a question I answered that is how I work I don't shy away from things that people may or may not find scummy I do me and handle things as they come. I will be suspicious of the people who openly try to buddy up to Phraze knowing she is town firmed. I never said that Omni isn't scum being scummy I was laying out my thoughts for you all. If we don't want to lynch the jester and he is most jester like why is everyone voting for him? Sure it could be scum and the fact that they know there is a jester gives them a little latitude but if we are really trying to prevent the jester from winning why vote for the person who seems to fit that role perfectly? It's a question not a defense?This feels so scummy. Why do you feel the need to declare not-gonna-buddy-up? Vote Change: logic340 Also, what's wrong with that Omni vote? If he's a jester from acting scummy, then he deserves all the pressure. But how would you know that it's not scum being scummy? E-eh. Because you're scum and he's not your team? Good. So do you think Ruu and wen is going after a jester? How does omni fits the jester role perfectly in your opinion? Also, what do you mean by "It's a question not a defense?" o.O |
Jan 19, 2017 6:36 AM
#41
aa-dono said: it may have been rhetorical though admittedly I didn't put much thought into it before responding to it.logic340 said: Ah, sorry about that. I missed Phraze's question. Or perhaps I thought it was rhetorical :/@Ruu and @aa-dono Grapefruit is currently playing his second and third forum mafia games. He has RL experience playing and has done study before joining the MS club here on MAL. He is new here but has a good understanding of game. We were mason's together in his first game (Haruhi). aa-dono said: This feels so scummy. Why do you feel the need to declare not-gonna-buddy-up? Vote Change: logic340 Also, what's wrong with that Omni vote? If he's a jester from acting scummy, then he deserves all the pressure. But how would you know that it's not scum being scummy? E-eh. Because you're scum and he's not your team? Good. So do you think Ruu and wen is going after a jester? How does omni fits the jester role perfectly in your opinion? Also, what do you mean by "It's a question not a defense?" o.O Based on what the Jesters wincon is I think that if I drew that roll I would be making myself visibly scummy. I would probably do things to attract attention of any kind to myself so that in the end I could attract the needed votes to hit my wincon. I only have town experience to go on so maybe I am thinking about this incorrectly. |
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Jan 19, 2017 6:38 AM
#42
aa-dono said: "So if we are worried about lynching the jester I will ask everyone who is voting Omni why they have their votes their?" this is my question everything that comes after is framing my thoughts not defending Omni. I just wanted to clarify that before someone tries to say I was defending him later on.Also, what do you mean by "It's a question not a defense?" o.O |
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Jan 19, 2017 6:40 AM
#43
Omnisword said: Hello stranger.And I am so salty here why aa-dono didn't responded to my genuine offer to come with me to that abandoned house "sulk in corner" vote aa-dono What do you think of the votes on you? And logic's reluctance to vote due to it? |
Jan 19, 2017 6:40 AM
#44
wen294 said: Look I am telling you what I know if you want a link to haruhi and our mason club I will be happy to provide them. Before starting in on Forum Mafia Grapefruit did research on mafia theory and other aspects of the game if you want more detail ask him directly I was just trying to help answer you questions since I had it available."has done study before joining the MS club" sorry what? I can't help imagine people sitting behind some thick theory book and then taking some entrance exam to get into the club. Last i checked it was just a "if you are interested join and play, you'll learn it eventually" Grapefruit explains it here #30 |
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Jan 19, 2017 6:41 AM
#45
logic340 said: So you are already worried of association. Noted.aa-dono said: "So if we are worried about lynching the jester I will ask everyone who is voting Omni why they have their votes their?" this is my question everything that comes after is framing my thoughts not defending Omni. I just wanted to clarify that before someone tries to say I was defending him later on.Also, what do you mean by "It's a question not a defense?" o.O |
Jan 19, 2017 6:42 AM
#46
aa-dono said: Who said I was reluctant to vote? "I wont be voting up Omni right now" means that until I see something scummy I wont be voting that way. I've placed two RVS so my next vote should have some substance. If he does something I find decidedly scummy and not possibly attributed to town or TPR then my vote will be placed right there.Omnisword said: Hello stranger.And I am so salty here why aa-dono didn't responded to my genuine offer to come with me to that abandoned house "sulk in corner" vote aa-dono What do you think of the votes on you? And logic's reluctance to vote due to it? |
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Jan 19, 2017 6:42 AM
#47
wen294 said: "has done study before joining the MS club" sorry what? I can't help imagine people sitting behind some thick theory book and then taking some entrance exam to get into the club. Last i checked it was just a "if you are interested join and play, you'll learn it eventually" aahah it means he read mafia wiki at least xDD Like Kit did before her first game (if I'm not mistaken) Also I get the feeling, from his posts, that wen is jester. For example after talking about "his masterplan" he got a reaction from logic who probably now see him as an anti-town player (like we all see grrr in every game xDD) so he would be in favor of lynching wen. If he can get enough reactions like that he will get lynch ---> if jester wincon. |
Jan 19, 2017 6:50 AM
#48
logic340 said: I said you were reluctant.aa-dono said: Who said I was reluctant to vote? "I wont be voting up Omni right now" means that until I see something scummy I wont be voting that way. I've placed two RVS so my next vote should have some substance. If he does something I find decidedly scummy and not possibly attributed to town or TPR then my vote will be placed right there.Omnisword said: And I am so salty here why aa-dono didn't responded to my genuine offer to come with me to that abandoned house "sulk in corner" vote aa-dono What do you think of the votes on you? And logic's reluctance to vote due to it? You declared not wanting to vote for omni after you read the votes on him by Ruu and wen. And they noted something scummy. Do you know for certain that they are wrong? Do you not see that as scummy? If you don't see it as scummy, then you contradict where you said he fits the jester role. So if you are not reluctant to vote, then what was that declaration for? |
Jan 19, 2017 6:56 AM
#49
I've only played a game with a jester once. At least from memory, only once. I was jester, and I lost so you can take this with a grain of salt. Anyway, don't bother jester. Look for scum. If you see jester in every scummy behavior, scum can hide easily. Just see scum in scummy behavior, you'll know later (maybe few hours before lynch) whether that's scum or jester. Plus, if you did catch jester, you're only making it easy for scum to decide night kills - they avoid jester and we being paranoid over jesters. Whereas if you let scum find jesters on their own, they might kill jester for us, and we could be rid of that jester worry. |
Jan 19, 2017 7:03 AM
#50
aa-dono said: I've only played a game with a jester once. At least from memory, only once. I was jester, and I lost so you can take this with a grain of salt. Anyway, don't bother jester. Look for scum. If you see jester in every scummy behavior, scum can hide easily. Just see scum in scummy behavior, you'll know later (maybe few hours before lynch) whether that's scum or jester. Plus, if you did catch jester, you're only making it easy for scum to decide night kills - they avoid jester and we being paranoid over jesters. Whereas if you let scum find jesters on their own, they might kill jester for us, and we could be rid of that jester worry. my thoughts exactly xD I think scum will go after jester so we don't need to worry about that. WHERE ARE ALL THE PLAYERS BTW???? COME PLAY DAMMIT! xD |
More topics from this board
» [GAME] (* ̄・ ̄)ノ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated MEMBER Posts! v1 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )SoulEaterQUEEN - Mar 26, 2016 |
1990 |
by Serafos
»»
Aug 17, 9:42 PM |
|
» [GAME] Say something about the person above you ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Haine - Jul 19, 2014 |
3811 |
by Serafos
»»
Aug 17, 9:42 PM |
|
» [GAME] Last Letter Game ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )grave_robber - Sep 9, 2014 |
8751 |
by Serafos
»»
Aug 17, 9:41 PM |
|
» [GAME] (* ̄・ ̄)ノ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated Staff Member Posts! v4 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Togs - Jul 2, 2017 |
2867 |
by Serafos
»»
Aug 17, 9:41 PM |
|
» Count To 7777 V3 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Lambtron - May 15, 2018 |
1160 |
by Serafos
»»
Aug 17, 9:41 PM |