Forum Settings
Forums

Mini Game v4: Higurashi no Naku Koro Night Mafia | Game End

New
Reply Disabled for Non-Club Members
Pages (28) « First ... « 8 9 [10] 11 12 » ... Last »
Nov 19, 2016 10:59 PM

Offline
Aug 2013
8706
Holo what's your read on mishu?
Nov 19, 2016 11:04 PM

Offline
May 2013
2803
A post was deleted?
Nov 19, 2016 11:16 PM

Offline
Aug 2013
8706
@Mishukax
Why did togs vote look like a bus?

I wouldn't feel the need to kill logic as scum. I'd probably kill someone less obvious and more experienced at the game. Or maybe I'd predict town to predict that and do it anyway. Wifom is a scary and beautiful thing.

You're using very assured words here like "nobody else would kill him but you" and "nobody else but you had reason to" but that's
1) Patently false
2) wifom logic



Yea I'm not asking you why you didn't ask them about why they were being defeated. I'm asking why you didn't ask them -anything at all- despite having a reason to scumread them.

And no I'm not making anything "deeper than it actually is" I'm trying to understand your thoughts. That means we need to go deep. It's shallow of you to approach your read on yurkin in it's entirety based on you not agreeing with a fair reason to call them town. It begs the question more if you don't have an opinion there why you felt the need to comment about how that reasoning doesn't mean anything to you.

And then not bring any thoughts of your own to the table.

I don't think you misunderstood I think that you're just backtracking now.
-You specifically said that you thought tenshi was "hiding a buddy in his townreads"
-But you also understand "who they were about"
-But trouble understand why they came so early

What does how early they came have to do with why you did or didn't understand them?
Nov 20, 2016 12:23 AM

Offline
Aug 2016
1754
This is a doozy, but pretty much analyzation on Fo's interactions with others and responses from pages 1-8. @@



All in all, my read on Fo right now is Neutral/maybe slightly leaning towards third party? I found it odd that he kept deflecting Sukiya and Phraze's questions and failed to answer them. Why is that?

Also keep in mind everyone that just because Logic loosley suspected Fo, does not make him automatic scum :T read into it yourselves and base your reads on Fo's actions, not others.

Sidenotes:

I'd like to point out that here Logic got a neutral read on Sithis and here he says he's willing to vote for Sithis "due to inactivity". :|

Though I will say that people on this Sithis lynch are most definitely either town or third party.

Tenshii_ said:

@Fo, Why is Holocauster town?


Also can I say lol at this name spelling here?
Nov 20, 2016 12:24 AM

Offline
Aug 2016
1754
Fo said:
Holo what's your read on mishu?


I'll be analyzing Mimi's posts as well, but tomorrow a good few hours before phaze change. Your analysis took a lot out of me lol
Nov 20, 2016 12:24 AM

Offline
Aug 2016
1754
Two hours to be exact o-o
Nov 20, 2016 12:32 AM

Offline
Aug 2013
8706
You should analyze my posts from when I was actually invested in the game! :D

Also, bit less of an analysis and more of rundown on things pertaining to fo if anything but I'll answer your questions here in a minute regardless.
Nov 20, 2016 12:38 AM

Offline
Aug 2013
8706
Holocaster said:
Asks Fo's thoughts on the flip. For some reason I cannot find the post that Logic quoted. Deleted, perhaps? For some reason? @Fo ?
No I just never responded to that post; my thoughts on the flip were given later on.

Holocaster said:
Responds to Sukiya's next question on why he changed his vote without an actual response, just says "Fair question". @Fo why didn't you answer her?
Because that question wasn't directed at me.
Nov 20, 2016 12:44 AM

Offline
Aug 2013
8706
I'm kinda confused why someone would take the time to IIoA that hard and then only come away with a third party read based on ... not really sure what.
Nov 20, 2016 12:47 AM

Offline
Oct 2011
20890
Fo said:
I'm kinda confused why someone would take the time to IIoA that hard and then only come away with a third party read based on ... not really sure what.

that might be due to ur claims of SK in the game. if so then it makes no sense to lynch u xD
Nov 20, 2016 12:48 AM

Offline
Aug 2013
8706
Phraze said:
Fo said:
I'm kinda confused why someone would take the time to IIoA that hard and then only come away with a third party read based on ... not really sure what.

that might be due to ur claims of SK in the game. if so then it makes no sense to lynch u xD
phraze what do you think of my thoughts on mishu brah?
Nov 20, 2016 12:50 AM

Offline
Aug 2016
1754
Fo said:
I'm kinda confused why someone would take the time to IIoA that hard and then only come away with a third party read based on ... not really sure what.


I didn't write the post to incriminate/defend you, I wrote it to gather my own thoughts and base a conclusion on everything once I was done lol

Why would I not do that? Do you not want me looking into your posts? I wanted to determine for myself what I believe you are instead of reading a page and a half and base a claim on what others are saying.
Nov 20, 2016 12:53 AM

Offline
Aug 2013
8706
Holocaster said:
Fo said:
I'm kinda confused why someone would take the time to IIoA that hard and then only come away with a third party read based on ... not really sure what.


I didn't write the post to incriminate/defend you, I wrote it to gather my own thoughts and base a conclusion on everything once I was done lol

Why would I not do that? Do you not want me looking into your posts? I wanted to determine for myself what I believe you are instead of reading a page and a half and base a claim on what others are saying.
I wasn't claiming that your motivation to make that post was to defend/incriminate me; I was just saying that there wasn't very many opinions on the things I've done but more just you talking about things that I've done.
Nov 20, 2016 12:57 AM

Offline
Aug 2016
1754
Fo said:
I wasn't claiming that your motivation to make that post was to defend/incriminate me; I was just saying that there wasn't very many opinions on the things I've done but more just you talking about things that I've done.


Yes, I didn't want to base opinions until I was done. It would have taken too long to base an opinion on every single post, so I just wrote down a short summary of what happened and gave my conclusion at the end. It's easier for me to gather cohesive thoughts this way instead of making points on every single thing.
Nov 20, 2016 12:58 AM

Offline
Aug 2013
8706
@Suzune-chan @Crossbell @Togs
If you all let these punks mislynch me I'll lose respect for the lot of you; and shake the hand of whichever one of you is scum.
Nov 20, 2016 1:02 AM

Offline
Aug 2013
8706
Holocaster said:
Fo said:
I wasn't claiming that your motivation to make that post was to defend/incriminate me; I was just saying that there wasn't very many opinions on the things I've done but more just you talking about things that I've done.


Yes, I didn't want to base opinions until I was done. It would have taken too long to base an opinion on every single post, so I just wrote down a short summary of what happened and gave my conclusion at the end. It's easier for me to gather cohesive thoughts this way instead of making points on every single thing.
Okay. I'm still confused why after all the posts I've posted your only opinion was meh/maaaaybe 3p.

Nobody has posted more content than me. This is Fo's thread at this point.
Nov 20, 2016 1:05 AM

Offline
Aug 2016
1754
Fo said:
Okay. I'm still confused why after all the posts I've posted your only opinion was meh/maaaaybe 3p.

Nobody has posted more content than me. This is Fo's thread at this point.


I don't think your scum, but I'm not sure if you're town either. That's why I went with third party.

Either way I think most of these posts and people wanting to hop on another wagon are slightly baseless. The only reason I did a post on Fo was because right now he's on the burner.
Nov 20, 2016 1:10 AM

Offline
Aug 2013
8706
Holocaster said:
Fo said:
Okay. I'm still confused why after all the posts I've posted your only opinion was meh/maaaaybe 3p.

Nobody has posted more content than me. This is Fo's thread at this point.


I don't think your scum, but I'm not sure if you're town either. That's why I went with third party.

Either way I think most of these posts and people wanting to hop on another wagon are slightly baseless. The only reason I did a post on Fo was because right now he's on the burner.
Well that's a start at least. I'm town.

Look into mishu please when you can; his posts are almost all commentary, not a lot of opinions. And his thoughts are inconsistent in places and he has backtracked on things pertaining to reads on players when questioned on it.

His response is "you're digging too deep"

Ha.
Nov 20, 2016 2:12 AM

Offline
Jan 2016
3816
Notes I took on the plane ride:

Post #69 might be a very, very weak unaligned pair between Astros and Sithis? I don't really see Sithis coaching Astros in the thread.

wen294 said:

Don't you think this is a bit rediculously early to start giving out town reads?
I really dislike this question. It screams of doubtcasting the townreads already present in the game and trying to widen the PoE pool.

yurkin said:
And among us how much are suppossed to be mafia, like 5 or less...
Should I accept this derp clear?

Gonna trust Tenshii as it was pretty apparent that he was competent.

I dislike Fo pointing out there is a SK; his posts feel differently to me in general than Halloween Night.

I like how Phraze changed her vote quickly to Sithis.

Phraze feels a little town here?

yurkin does indeed feel town.

Holo also feels kind of town with 205? It's like. "I am confused as to why you are voting this person who is then flipping scum".

wen294 said:
So far Lord_Sithis has been a lurky ass, in that regard i don't overly mind voting for him if it's to assure a lynch. That said there are people out there that are lurking more and aside from this i haven't seen all that much scum indicative from him i guess. I'd rather vote for him on D2 if he's still as lurky as he is now, but i'd still rather vote for Tenshii_ or untill he properly explains/defends himself.
This is gross.

Why is Mishukax voting Togs?

God I hate Fo's fixation on a serial killer. It reads to me that he has too much inside information. His posts also read very much like when I am scum; long quote-stripes and questions, rather than being in the game and trying to figure the gamestate out.

I also like how logic pointed out that Fo is "asking questions that have already been answered". It reminds me of my pressuring of Shinichi in Camp Crystal Lake Mafia.

"I thought their leader could have been lynched as scapegoat/sacrifice but ...oh forget it, I'll go back at the beginning of the game and this time I'll take notes on paper not just read.
Guys, why do it feel like you all have good observation skills and mine can be compared to the skills of a dead horse T-T" - town.

Holo once again feels town.

logic has had a decent view when townreading Mishukax, I'll think about it.

Hm. Fo actually kind of feels town with the "It's difficult to have a conversation with you. And that's scummy because if you're town I'd expect you to realize I've been doing nothing but trying to figure you out and also maybe see you trying to figure me out."

I'll need to question Fo heavily myself in order to figure out his alignment.

Kiiiiiind of coming around to Fo being a little more town? His vote on Phraze is ????, but he has some tonally town markers that make me think he might be town.

Since I bet I will be sleeping in tomorrow:

Vote wen294

I will actually get caught up and be engaged in the thread then.
Nov 20, 2016 2:43 AM

Offline
Oct 2013
5719
Shoot! Missed alot, backreading now!
<3
Nov 20, 2016 3:35 AM

Offline
Oct 2013
5719
@Fo
Fo said:
GTMH Atros is serial killer but wouldn't put any money on it.


What does GTMH mean? What makes you think Astros is a SK? Wouldnt they want to have as many dead people as possible? I know I'm talking about the SK so much, but thats just because I played one before and I can relate xD

To answer your question about who I think was indecisive on D1(in a strange way) would be: Astros, wen and Holo, I stated that before because wen and Holo were saying that Sithis could be scum but didnt want to vote for them. In the end it was wen that voted for him. And with Astros and his "too many new faces"-excuse, yea ...he plays pretty risky, which makes me think he's somewhat confident with his role. Welp havent caught up yet so I'll see what they all have to say.
<3
Nov 20, 2016 3:57 AM

Offline
Dec 2013
11900
okey this game kinda lost me at D1.

I still can't see why people think that Fo is scum.

And I still can't see where people are pulling those Yurkin townreads from, i mean like all the posts that people say 'oh look, totally town' about are posts that ping me for scum. Right now it feels like she's just ignoring everything that isn't beneficial to her, how is that a town-tell? Where she got all negative from 2 votes D1 she just 100% ignored a vote cast on her in D2. Her play is inconsistent.

Also it might be nice if this time around we could get a roleclaim before the lynch happens.


Crossbell said:

wen294 said:

Don't you think this is a bit rediculously early to start giving out town reads?
I really dislike this question. It screams of doubtcasting the townreads already present in the game and trying to widen the PoE pool.

No shit. I didn't agree with the townreads, and they came way too early as well. Give me a reason that i wouldn't 'doubtcast' (whatever the hell that means) those townreads. Given i didn't agree with neither the substance nor the timing.


Phraze feels a little town here?

yurkin does indeed feel town.

How? What? When? Where? Why?
We can't do much with this if we don't even know what post you're talking about. And this goes for most of the points you mentioned.

wen294 said:
So far Lord_Sithis has been a lurky ass, in that regard i don't overly mind voting for him if it's to assure a lynch. That said there are people out there that are lurking more and aside from this i haven't seen all that much scum indicative from him i guess. I'd rather vote for him on D2 if he's still as lurky as he is now, but i'd still rather vote for Tenshii_ or untill he properly explains/defends himself.
This is gross.

Well very nice to know that you're willing and able to throw insults around but once again this isn't much use if you don't say why.

God I hate Fo's fixation on a serial killer. It reads to me that he has too much inside information. His posts also read very much like when I am scum; long quote-stripes and questions, rather than being in the game and trying to figure the gamestate out.

I also like how logic pointed out that Fo is "asking questions that have already been answered". It reminds me of my pressuring of Shinichi in Camp Crystal Lake Mafia.

So let me get this straight, Fo's scumgame is similar to your scumgame or not? Because if not then these points kinda lose meaning. Would be nice to mention this or else we can't do anything with this, again.

"I thought their leader could have been lynched as scapegoat/sacrifice but ...oh forget it, I'll go back at the beginning of the game and this time I'll take notes on paper not just read.
Guys, why do it feel like you all have good observation skills and mine can be compared to the skills of a dead horse T-T" - town.

Offering an opinion, then dismissing it in the same post and then downtalk yourself is a townread nowadays? Why?

Holo once again feels town.

And once again, what is this based on?

I mean it's nice to know that you're reading the thread and all that but we can't do much with most of this post.
Nov 20, 2016 4:14 AM

Offline
Dec 2013
11900
Fo said:
This is Fo's thread at this point.

Fo no Naku Koro Ni.

(especially if you get lynched, the translation would be fairly suitable xD)

Phraze said:
Fo said:
I'm kinda confused why someone would take the time to IIoA that hard and then only come away with a third party read based on ... not really sure what.

that might be due to ur claims of SK in the game. if so then it makes no sense to lynch u xD

I don't get what you mean with this post. At all.
Nov 20, 2016 4:20 AM

Offline
Jul 2009
8549
@wen294 Its not like i'm ignoring you or anything.
Ok, so why do you vote for me wen?
Nov 20, 2016 4:27 AM

Offline
Oct 2013
5719
wen294 said:
Gwendolly said:

Of course its pretty vital for EVERYONE to know, not just town. We shouldnt exclude that idea that there is none, especially in a Higurashi-based game. I dont like how you bought up how a SK would normally act during a nightphase to sidetrack us from the thought that there is one. Havent you forgot our last game? There was no sign of a SK during the whole game and yet there was one ;)

Did you forget i died hella early and didn't follow the rest? ;)


Your death was a doublekill (mafia+SK)
<3
Nov 20, 2016 4:34 AM

Offline
Jul 2009
8549
And to be honest - I was wrong. After reading the wiki page with something like manual for newbies I came to the obvious conclusion - everything I did or attempted to do with no success at all, was wrong.
"PbPA are quite possible the most pointless way you can waste time in Mafia"
"Skilled players are probably not going to post directly scummy things. To a degree, what they post doesn't really matter. It's more helpful to look at their responses to various pressures and judje their motives accordingly."

Umm....I kind of wonder if I am not suited for mafia game, since I got it all wrong and all.

Edit: when I see Jackrito is online I'll ask for replacement.
yurkinNov 20, 2016 4:39 AM
Nov 20, 2016 4:38 AM

Offline
Aug 2013
8706
@Gwendolly
GTMH (gun to my head) means that if there was a gun in my face and somebody told me to guess who I thought the sk was or eat lead, then at this point I'd say it's astros. Based on nothing besides a hunch.

I don't think that it was strange for astros specifically to be indecisive there; he pushed nolynch. That takes someone who doesn't appreciate what good old scumhunting can actually accomplish, I bet tenshii and sithis were the same people with different avatars to him.

I didn't mind wen's vote on sithis in hindsight. It's what basically killed him more or less. And I really liked his response to my light pressure earlier in the game.

I agree that holo didn't seem to have much of an opinion on sithis.

Do you agree with her read on me?
How do you feel about mishu's last couple of posts? Read there in general?
Nov 20, 2016 5:13 AM

Offline
Dec 2013
11900
yurkin said:
@wen294 Its not like i'm ignoring you or anything.
Ok, so why do you vote for me wen?

Partially, because i think you're scum.
Other reason was because i was really interested in your response. Not getting any was kinda pretty dissapointing. Well i guess that's a response in itself as well.

Also not really sure where you got it from that PbPA is a bad thing, as far as i'm aware of it's not that bad?
Or maybe i just don't know what i'm saying. One of both i guess.
Nov 20, 2016 6:04 AM

Offline
Oct 2013
5719
What I've read until now I'm content with wens arguments (his reasons for voting Sithis), so I dont see him as scummy as I have seen him before.

I'm gonna leave this vote here for now.
vote: Astros
Because I was planning to anyway due to my previous posts.
And he's not even present!

I have to prepare another event in 20+ club today, so bare with me in being slow in replies today x)
and welcome Suzune and Cross. So Tenshii and Sukiya are gone, hmm its a shame I wanted to see what Tenshii had to say more, his playstyle was very different and interesting.

@Togs They dont call me a "sassy black woman" for nothing ;D

Yes, yes filler comment blablabla. BRB!
<3
Nov 20, 2016 6:11 AM

Offline
Oct 2013
5719
yurkin said:
And to be honest - I was wrong. After reading the wiki page with something like manual for newbies I came to the obvious conclusion - everything I did or attempted to do with no success at all, was wrong.
"PbPA are quite possible the most pointless way you can waste time in Mafia"
"Skilled players are probably not going to post directly scummy things. To a degree, what they post doesn't really matter. It's more helpful to look at their responses to various pressures and judje their motives accordingly."

Umm....I kind of wonder if I am not suited for mafia game, since I got it all wrong and all.

Edit: when I see Jackrito is online I'll ask for replacement.

Try to stay and get a grasp of this game, once you understand it, it can be alot of fun! :D My first game was catastrophal and I swore myself to never play one again lol but then I gave it another chance and now look at me^^ If you lose, you lose! But atleast you learned from it then. It's not the end of the world, so please no replacement, I hate replacements xD (sorry suzune and cross, I love you both)
<3
Nov 20, 2016 6:44 AM

Offline
Dec 2013
11900
Gwendolly said:

vote: Astros
And he's not even present!

Wouldn't be suprised if he's up next for replacements if he keeps it like this.

Gwendolly said:
My first game was catastrophal and I swore myself to never play one again lol but then I gave it another chance and now look at me^^

I dominated my first game, and i did really well on my second game as well. But lately i've been struggling.
The more games i seem to play the harder they become :|

Or maybe my games just had unintended but profitable learning curves in terms of other players. Who knows.
Nov 20, 2016 7:16 AM

Offline
Jul 2009
8549
#480 @Gwendolly
Yeah, mine's catastrophal too lol. Who knows which one is worse.
But if I'm not too much of a bother I still want to play.
Thanks Gwen.
Nov 20, 2016 8:00 AM

Offline
Dec 2013
11900
yurkin said:
#480 @Gwendolly
Yeah, mine's catastrophal too lol. Who knows which one is worse.
But if I'm not too much of a bother I still want to play.
Thanks Gwen.

I can't say you've played a good game so far here, but i'd never say that you're a bother to have in a game. Nor would i say that to anyone, for that matter.
If you still want to play then i don't think anyone would mind having you around.
Nov 20, 2016 8:20 AM

Offline
Apr 2014
10943
🏯🎆 Vote Count 2.4 🏯🎆

💣 Fo 💣 (2) // 🔪Phraze, Mishukax🔪
yurkin (1) // 🔪wen294🔪
Holocaster (1) // 🔪Togs🔪
Mishukax (1) // 🔪Fo🔪
wen294 (1) // 🔪Crossbell🔪
Astros (1) // 🔪Gwendolly🔪

🚩Not Voting🚩: ⚔ Astros, Gwendolly, Holocaster, Suzune-chan, yurkin ⚔


👑 Mod Notes: It takes 6 votes on a player to achieve lynch lock. 👑
☼ Day 2 Timer ☼



JackritoNov 20, 2016 11:13 AM
Nov 20, 2016 9:42 AM

Offline
Aug 2013
8706
Looks like there's about 7 hours until deadline. heh

Anybody online? @jackrito @souleaterqueen any news on an astros replacement?

Any thoughts at all on my stuff on mishu in posts #443, #444 and the stuff on his cogdis I mentioned in #453?

Just his general lack of defending his vote at all and then disappearing after I try and have a conversation with him should be scumclaimy enough if you want my opinion but eh.
Nov 20, 2016 9:52 AM

Offline
Nov 2013
9439
I really just want to put in my two cents out here as a host. I understand that mafia can be a bit difficult, and stressful at times - this is normal. It can also be an emotional rollercoaster ride experience, and sometimes you are left feeling in the dark because you are unsure of what to do. But I want to emphasize that each game you play is a learning experience amongst everyone - hosts included. You are not expected to be perfect, you can fumble and fall, but you just have to keep on working at it to get back up.

Anyway, what I am trying to say that since Jackrito, and I have put a lot of time into this game, please don't just ask to be replaced out so lightly. We have been chewing through our waitlist, and once we cannot find any more players, we will have to start modkilling slots, and that would just ruin the experience for everyone and us included. Mafia will not always bring good moments, but I do expect everyone to be mature with handling situations that come your way.
Nov 20, 2016 9:53 AM

Offline
Nov 2013
9439
Fo said:
Looks like there's about 7 hours until deadline. heh

Anybody online? @jackrito @souleaterqueen any news on an astros replacement?

Any thoughts at all on my stuff on mishu in posts #443, #444 and the stuff on his cogdis I mentioned in #453?

Just his general lack of defending his vote at all and then disappearing after I try and have a conversation with him should be scumclaimy enough if you want my opinion but eh.

They have until the end of the phase to reach the posting quota still.
Nov 20, 2016 10:03 AM

Offline
Aug 2013
8706
Oh okay that's how it works. Thank you.

And yea also just wanna say it's also okay if you don't think the game's for you and you're not having fun to replace out; nobody can force you to play. But a lot of effort goes into the setups, running and playing on a lot of people's part the classy thing to do is play it out if you can and let somebody know if you can't.

I mean like. When I in for games is approach it with a mindset that "I'm gonna make this game better than it was if I hadn't played it" and tbh; I feel bad that I wasn't around to crush scum with you guys day 1; so give me a chance to make up for it and help me crush scum right now. :D


Vote mishu!
Nov 20, 2016 10:39 AM

Offline
Nov 2015
4744
Sorry for the shortness of this pop in, I will be out and kind of busy today. I will definitely be back before the EoD though.

I'll just say right here, I strongly strongly oppose Fo being toDay's lynch. I have strong reasons for thinking this and I'll fight against his wagon all I can toDay.

I think, there is likely to be at least one scum between Holo and Mishu. I see Fo raising some points on Mishu, looks kind of reasonable to me and would like to see others weigh in.

@Holocaster @Mishukax

I see you both posted a lot of thoughts on Fo, but I want to see full T/S from you guys ! Please and thank you.
Nov 20, 2016 10:41 AM

Offline
Jun 2009
15934
@Fo

Your yurkin read doesn't make a lot of sense to me; could you possibly go over that one and give some examples of where you thought they were very certain of themselves? And why you thought that was scummy?
What I mean is in the beginning I thought that certain behaviours were scummy for this person, but as time went by they seemed to ping pong from high on both sides of the spectrum, leaving me with a more townie feel.

Why do you think playing passively lends itself to be a 3p tell and not a scumtell or even just a playstyle tell?
This is irrelevant because that was the slot I subbed in as. So it was kind of silly. But I had meant that always looking to compromise and make friends everwhere while not being locking into any particular viewpoint made them possibly 3rd.

Where there is no imagination there is no horror. || Arthur Conan Doyle || Happy Halloween!
Nov 20, 2016 10:43 AM

Offline
Jun 2009
15934
Fo said:
I'm kinda confused why someone would take the time to IIoA that hard and then only come away with a third party read based on ... not really sure what.
I find it interesting that you criticize people for third party reads. What is wrong with thinking certain behaviours might fall more to third party.

Where there is no imagination there is no horror. || Arthur Conan Doyle || Happy Halloween!
Nov 20, 2016 10:48 AM

Offline
Dec 2013
11900
I'm still around for another 2 hours or so.

@Jackrito, Crossbell voted me, not Fo. Fo has kept his vote on mishu.

I agree with Togs on the fact that i have no intentions of letting Fo get lynched, if i had to choose between lynching Fo and Mishu i'll vote mishu. If the vote count when i need to leave is still similar to this i'll vote for misha.
Nov 20, 2016 10:50 AM

Offline
Jun 2009
15934
If we are going to discuss possible lynch targets. I could really do Astros or Mushi. While I was back and forth on Fo I do not think they are my priority to lynch today.

Where there is no imagination there is no horror. || Arthur Conan Doyle || Happy Halloween!
Nov 20, 2016 11:22 AM

Offline
Dec 2013
11900
Yeah i'm no fan of Astros either, that said i do think it's more likely for him to be 3th party than scum. Either way i highly doubt that he's town so he makes for a pretty decent lynch candidate as well.

His D1 was nothing that moved the game forward in anyway and i don't think he said anything D2... So yeah, imo he clearly shows a disinterest in the game.
Nov 20, 2016 11:45 AM

Offline
May 2013
2803
Fo said:
I wouldn't feel the need to kill logic as scum. I'd probably kill someone less obvious and more experienced at the game. Or maybe I'd predict town to predict that and do it anyway. Wifom is a scary and beautiful thing.

You're using very assured words here like "nobody else would kill him but you" and "nobody else but you had reason to" but that's
1) Patently false
2) wifom logic

I understand your point about the wifom situation that logic kill put us into. However, I would assume that since the mafia killed logic, that would be for either of the following reasons:
1) Logic was too much on the right track
2) Logic was too good and they feared that (I don't think logic is a bad player, but if mafia was going that way, they probably would have killed someone like you instead. It's pretty obvious that you're knowledgable about the game and can handle leading lynches pretty well)
3) Random kill (definitely doubt that)

When I'm mafia and someone scumreads me day 1, I usually kill them off without being scared of being suspected for it. I believe it applies to a lot of people in general who are mafia. There's always a way to turn an argument around with the concept of wifom, after all, so killing off the one who suspects you the most isn't dangerous by any means. In the scenario that anyone other than you was scum, they would keep logic alive for the simple reason that he was misreading many townies, including you. It's better to keep people who are mislead alive, than to kill them off to make the people they were misreading suspicious.
This is anyway my train of thought. Maybe there really isn't something to think about logic's death. But I don't think so.
Fo said:
What does how early they came have to do with why you did or didn't understand them?

It doesn't have anything to do with it. I understood those reads, if I assumed Tenshii was town. I didn't understand why they came so early in the game, compared to the fact that no one else had reached a clear conclusion, and didn't before a good deal of time.
Holocaster said:
I found it odd that he kept deflecting Sukiya and Phraze's questions and failed to answer them. Why is that?

I'm starting to think he has enough confidence to display that his questions matter more than others'.
wen294 said:
The more games i seem to play the harder they become :|

Right? I think that might only be a misconception, but I still feel like I'm playing wrong. I'd say this comes from the fact that when you lack experience and knowledge of the game, you are blind to how strong good you could be, and thus see your play as pretty good, but then when you play more games, it becomes clearer that you have so many things to improve, and you feel oppressed, trying to always play better. People are good thinkers by default, and great thinkers with enough practice - it's when they think that they could be bad thinkers that their thinking gets unhinged.
Nov 20, 2016 12:35 PM

Offline
Dec 2013
9884
@SoulEaterQUEEN Despite what others have said, I'm still quite interested in the game and will be active so do not worry about finding a replacement or your Wait-List emptying.

Togs said:
Looking forward to it : )


@Astros I didn’t forget about you. You said earlier that you supported no lynching Day 1 but not no lynching through the game, which means I’m expect you to push on someone toDay. The game is definitely out of it’s early stages at this point, so I’d like to know your outlook of it.
I'll get to this soon. Taking a break to post at the moment.
Nov 20, 2016 12:47 PM

Offline
Dec 2013
11900
Oh okey in that case:

Vote Change: Astros

And i'll be gone for the rest of the day in a minute or 10, just to inform you.
Nov 20, 2016 2:40 PM

Offline
Aug 2016
1754
Togs said:
I see you both posted a lot of thoughts on Fo, but I want to see full T/S from you guys ! Please and thank you.


T/S?
Nov 20, 2016 2:44 PM

Offline
Dec 2013
9884
I assume he means Town/Scum. Could be wrong.
Nov 20, 2016 2:54 PM

Offline
Aug 2016
1754
Okay I'll write a quick mock-up. Keep in mind none of these are solid, because I don't like making concrete assumptions unless I have good proof.

Confirmed Town
Logic

Leaning Town
Togs
Suzune (prev. Sukiya)
Yurkin

Leaning Third Party/Neutral
Fo
Gwendolly
Mimi
Wen
Astros

Everyone but Fo on this list I need to look more into, which is what I'll be doing after I look into my leaning scum reads.

Leaning Scum
Tenshii (Now Crossbell)
Phraze

Confirmed Scum
Lord_Sithis
Reply Disabled for Non-Club Members
Pages (28) « First ... « 8 9 [10] 11 12 » ... Last »

More topics from this board

» Chat Thread ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Fo - Jul 10, 2014

3745 by Mishukax »»
Oct 21, 11:34 AM

» Count To 7777 V3 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Lambtron - May 15, 2018

1163 by Kit »»
Oct 17, 6:57 AM

» [GAME] Last Letter Game ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

grave_robber - Sep 9, 2014

8752 by Aswin_Ash »»
Jan 23, 11:52 AM

» [GAME] (* ̄・ ̄)ノ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated Staff Member Posts! v4 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Togs - Jul 2, 2017

2870 by Jackrito »»
Jan 8, 11:22 AM

» [GAME] (* ̄・ ̄)ノ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated MEMBER Posts! v1 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

SoulEaterQUEEN - Mar 26, 2016

1990 by Serafos »»
Aug 17, 2024 9:42 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login