Who is the best musician in Kessoku Band ?

Best musician in Kessoku Band

Aug 26, 2:11 PM

Offline

Dec 2021

I think the competition is mainly between Bocchi and Ryou. Bocchi is an extremely talented elite guitarist and without her social anxiety she is literally on God mode with her Guitar ( as we have seen in the iconic “Bocchi the Rokku” episode), and plus she writes the lyrics for Kessoku Band songs and if she ever tries she can sing pretty good too. Ryou on the other hand is also extremely good on bass, her technical skills with her instrument may not be on the same level as Bocchi and Kikkuri but she makes up for this disadvantage with her brilliant music composition and arrangement skills, and from the anime we know that she can play othe instruments too like Guitar,Piano and can also sing too.

Aug 26, 3:06 PM

Mr_Sai

Offline

Sep 2022

347

heisenberg is the best musician in the kessoku band

Aug 26, 3:52 PM

AntonioSilva

Offline

Apr 2019

ARE YOU KIDDING ME ?!nijika w 2% ,shes like an octopus on those drums

Aug 26, 4:42 PM

rinnmakesmusic

Offline

Oct 2023

133

It’s Bocchi without a doubt, but Nijika is also crazy talented

Aug 26, 6:06 PM

Bolona07

Offline

Jul 2023

264

Ryou used to write the songs and she has enough experience to calmly handle the band and even teach guitar even though her main instrument is the bass. She’s also really good as a bassist for somebody who’s just in high school.
Maybe this is just bias because I also play bass but still, I think it’s just between Bocchi and Ryou

Aug 26, 7:57 PM

flymango

Offline

Jun 2024

Did blud just turn a music anime into a shonen debate...

Aug 26, 10:29 PM

middle_pickup

Offline

Aug 2022

106

Bocchi clears the rest of the band easy, and if you even try to debate this you're showing your lack of musical competence.

Aug 26, 11:10 PM

ReXiRa

Offline

Nov 2022

230

Not sure you can compare proficiency between different musical instruments but go off

Ikuyo is probably the least proficient, given she started last. Not to discredit her or anything since she's good enough to ad-lib while Hitori was coming up with a way to save her broken string, but given the timeline she's good enough, but not a standout

Nijika likely comes next, again she's a good drummer but in ch56~57 of the manga

but yea, she mostly just needed a pointer to flesh out her drumming

Honestly, I think it's hard to break the tie between, solo-in-the-closet Hitori and Ryou whenever she doesn't have to study for a test.

It's a bit easier to analyze Ryou's performance and her composing, since we got a direct comparison of her riffs and Kikuri's accompaniment during the roadside performance of あのバンド/that band. Ryou clearly likes to flaunt her Bass skill with the riffs she wrote while Kikuri's accompaniment showed proficiency, even without knowing the actual complex riffs Ryou wrote.

Hitori's case is a bit tricker since we don't get to see (hear) a full performance of her when she's alone in the closet, so we can only really go off what she's done during a live performance

Aug 27, 12:48 AM

TommyTheWeeb139

Offline

Dec 2023

110

Bocchi practiced nonstop for like 4 years, I don’t think it’s really a contest

Aug 27, 1:05 AM

#10

Oriorii

Offline

Jan 2023

Guitar Hero is the best one

Aug 27, 2:50 AM

#11

jamieac42

Offline

Oct 2020

180

Nijika is easily the best, ryo and bocchi’s parts are too mental and distasteful sometimes to work with the rest of the bands playing whereas nijika is brilliant at coordinating with the other instruments rhymically, kita is obviously not that good but gets credit as she sings and plays at the same time so her guitar parts are never that interesting and the vocals are good but not anything too special, ryo is probably better than bocchi mostly although seishun complex is a masterpiece on guitar

jamieac42Aug 27, 2:54 AM

Aug 27, 4:56 PM

#12

playitagain

Offline

Sep 2023

They’re all amazing in their own areas but the overall best would probably be ryo. She’s experienced, she plays a variety of instruments and she’s good at them and understands them, and because she understands those instruments she’s a fantastic composer. She knows the strengths and weaknesses of each member so she’s not scared to give Bocchi technically difficult parts or even Kita because she knows she’s a fast learner when dedicated. Nijika’s drumming goes hand in hand with the bass, and honestly she’s super underrated. She kills it on the drums every single song. Ryo knows how to set the foundation of the songs so each member can shine in their own way.

A reply above said Bocchi clears everyone and that that much is obvious, but I have to argue that that completely disregards other aspects of being a musician besides playing.

That said, Bocchi does give ryo a good run for her money cuz in the manga she’s been trying out composing herself and is growing to be a very well rounded, standout musician. I guess you could say she’s “naturally” talented, but she still has yet to really hone in on her strengths and hit her peak.

Aug 27, 8:03 PM

#13

ilusatus

Offline

Nov 2017

211

AntonioSilva said:
ARE YOU KIDDING ME ?!nijika w 2% ,shes like an octopus on those drums

I love our angel so much, but lets be honest in term of musicality shes the most average among Kessoku member.

Aug 27, 10:12 PM

#14

NickGrim

Online

Dec 2022

Wild question. They’re all goated

Aug 28, 3:45 AM

#15

oniisan_kenobi

Offline

Oct 2022

Bocchi is insanely talented for someone who's only played guitar for 3-4 years. Not to mention that she is self-taught. That sweep-picking solo in Never Forget is frankly way out of reach for anyone in real life with only 3 years of experience. Most people can't even play in tune during their 1st year of self-taught guitar.

Ryo might be the best musician in the sense that she is the band's main composer and has access to many different instruments, so she probably has more experience than Bocchi. But in terms of pure natural talent, Bocchi wins by far. The fact that Bocchi had already become a very popular Youtuber before she even joined Kessoku Band shouldn't be discounted either.

Aug 28, 9:32 PM

#16

Solacity

Offline

Mar 2024

middle_pickup said:
Bocchi clears the rest of the band easy, and if you even try to debate this you're showing your lack of musical competence.

Dawg, what. In terms of raw instrumental, you can give it to Bocchi. Ryo has an argument because she’s more consistent, but “best” could be referred to their current peak, which Bocchi wins.
However, music production exists. Yes, Bocchi does write the lyrics, but Ryo has to grasp an understanding of said lyrics, combining both intellectual and musical intelligence. Mixing, recording, mastering, creating the composition are talents with a high ceiling, and Ryo’s production is quite high, considering they’re only teenagers.
You also have to consider that a bass player supports the drummers, guitarists, pianist (kessoku band doesn’t have), and other roles.
Bocchi’s guitar sets the pace of the band, and Ryo and the others have to adjust accordingly.
Also, Bocchi’s current peak isn’t far off of Ryo’s playing. The guitar has a rich sound that is more attractive than the bass, garnering more attention both in the audience of fans and the anime.

Aug 29, 12:20 PM

#17

middle_pickup

Offline

Aug 2022

106

Reply to Solacity

middle_pickup said:
Bocchi clears the rest of the band easy, and if you even try to debate this you're showing your lack of musical competence.

@Solacity Ryo is talented, but she isn't as gifted as Bocchi is. She also lacks Bocchi's work ethic. Real musicians know that natural talent only gets someone so far. Consistently showing up for the effort every day is what makes someone great-not the ability to throw an arrangement together in a pinch.

Aug 29, 12:28 PM

#18

Zarutaku

Offline

Sep 2016

7301

The one who looks like Eris Greyrat

This dance is the pinnacle of human achievement.

Yesterday, 12:06 PM

#19

inko4126

Offline

Mar 2024

It's literally Kita

See All Discussions

Poll: » Bocchi the Rock! Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ) KANLen09 - Dec 10, 2022	240	by dagmartoons »» 6 hours ago
Poll: » Bocchi the Rock! Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page ) KANLen09 - Dec 24, 2022	761	by Kindhearted_C »» 11 hours ago
Poll: » Bocchi the Rock! Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page ) KANLen09 - Oct 15, 2022	312	by Hatsuyuki »» Aug 26, 6:28 PM
» Is this show ever getting an English dub? FrierenSimpKing - Dec 15, 2023	47	by FrierenSimpKing »» Aug 23, 2:47 PM
Poll: » Bocchi the Rock! Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ) KANLen09 - Dec 3, 2022	235	by jilebi_james23 »» Aug 16, 1:26 PM

Who is the best musician in Kessoku Band ?

More topics from this board

Poll: » Bocchi the Rock! Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )

Poll: » Bocchi the Rock! Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Poll: » Bocchi the Rock! Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

» Is this show ever getting an English dub?

Poll: » Bocchi the Rock! Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters