You'd think after being traumatized by how bad the first two series were, I wouldn't think twice of going anywhere near this franchise again but no, apparently I'm a masochist so I decided to torture myself further by watching this. Actually I’m kidding, it's really not that bad. It has its shortcomings which I will mention in the review but I found myself genuinely curious and enjoying this. Maybe because there's no annoying Chizuru? I couldn’t stand her in the first two series so I guess without her I managed to enjoy the bishies more.
My apologies for the weird ordering, this is a slight revision
...
to the original I wrote on my blog and on there I the character review first before the story.
Review contains my crazy ramblings and also spoilers, so if you are easily affected by those then I don’t recommend reading.
Characters: 8/10
As someone who has seen the first two series, I already had prior knowledge of the characters and this series remains fairly true to their personality. Though with that being said, it didn't always start off this way. Hijikata, Okita, Heisuke and Ryunosuke are the few who undergo a major change in this series and the 12 episodes cover quite a bit of their back story to before they joined the Roshigumi and then later becoming the Shinsengumi we know. Mind you I was pretty shocked at how naive Okita used to be, so totally unlike him.
Yes Okita. The guy who talks about killing or cutting someone down literally every single time trouble arises USED TO BE A CUTE NAIVE LITTLE BOY. OMG. LIKE WHAT. HE WAS SO ADORABLE IT'S UNBELIEVABLE. Anyway his back story was his sister left him at Kondo's dojo and he wants to repay Kondo by serving him as a useful samurai because he was apparently the only one who didn't "pity" him. So yeah lonely kid meets a kind person. The end. JK, the first half of the series was mainly dedicated to developing Okita's character. He starts off pretty content with himself since he was the top student at the dojo, until his spar with Saito and he loses. Nevermind all's cool beans. Then later when giving Serizawa the epic glare of death because he insulted Kondo, Serizawa scoffs at how lacking his stare is in intimidating his opponents and mentions how it can't possibly compare to Hijikata's glare of death which literally was a glare of death that gave him the chills. Of course, Okita manages to hold his temper in fairly well until Serizawa casually mentions how even Saito was more intimidating since he's clearly giving off vibes of someone who's killed before. Aaaand that was the last straw, Okita is now jealous of how Saito has killed people before and he hasn't. YEAH. THANKS FOR CREATING BLOODTHIRSTY OKITA, SERIZAWA. I think from here on, we know exactly where Okita's story is going.
Heisuke. Adorable little boy who's always upbeat and bubbly, blurts out the wrong things all the time but is the type that'll befriend anyone and is liked by most because of his cheerful personality. He was the first friend Ryunosuke made when he came to Edo with Serizawa. He is fairly strong in terms of skill and strength but lacks resolve to kill as he mentions to Kodo that he would be delighted if he never had to kill. His story was fairly short and mostly consisted of him strengthening his resolve for the Roshigumi by killing a runaway Fury (Rasetsu) after letting it escape the first time. Aside from that, nothing interesting happens.
Hijikata the Demon vice-commander. Would you believe this guy used to be so nice? They even called him "soft" in the anime. And dafuq I never knew he had a sister either. LOL. Well in this series he's mostly laughed at by Serizawa for lacking the resolve to become a demon to achieve his dreams despite the fact Serizawa acknowledges his ability and strength. So for most of the episodes he's usually being all angry and death-glarey at Serizawa who just smirks back.
Ryunosuke the useless, weak protagonist of this series. You know, I've been wondering since the start, WHY EXACTLY IS HE IN THIS STORY??! He grows a lot as a character but he's more like a side character who appears all the time without any real purpose. You could cut him out the story and nothing would change, that's how much he lacks in making a difference. The others will still change regardless of whether he existed or not and he doesn't even appear after the Shinsengumi is formed in S1, DA POINT IN THAT?
So yep good character development for those 4. Shinpachi, Harada, Saito and Kondou don't really change or deviate much from their personalities in S1 so there's nothing worth mentioning about them.
Story: 7/10
I know I should have done this the other way BUT WHO CARES. The story is set before the events of Hakuouki S1 and as mentioned earlier talks about how the Shinsengumi was formed since they were originally called the Roshigumi at the time they left Edo for Kyoto. And heck, it sure wasn't easy. Getting your name out there and becoming well known takes time and a lot of money. They have no sponsors to back their funding so how are they supposed to get by while trying to build a name for themselves? Serizawa comes to the rescue and decides the best way to get money is of course....grab them off the people. How nice. And their motto was to PROTECT THE PEOPLE, so of course the Roshigumi's name ends up being dragged through the mud and hated by the people. Tough life guys. And while I do agree with the guys how Serizawa was a bit extreme in his methods, they all know somewhere that if it wasn't for him, they wouldn't have even survived to form the Shinsengumi. He was merely playing the villain they all refused to except he acts like such a bamf, that you can't help but hate him at the start. So yeah story was pretty much how they got the Roshigumi/Shinsengumi name out, found Aizu as a sponsor and how the Fury were made and yada yada yada. You get the jist. Oh the interesting thing was we actually did get to see Kodo Yukimura, Chizuru's "father" who I found pretty emotionless (actually he sorted looked a bit like a sadist) when he didn't even flinch during the first Fury experiment and they also added small bits here and there about how he wrote letters to Chizuru and this ties in with the start of Hakuouki S1 where Chizuru leaves to find him because she was no longer receiving his letters. SEE IT ALL LINKS UP SOMEHOW. WE EVEN GET A CAMEO APPEARANCE OF KAZAMA TO GIVE US A SAMPLE OF THE NEXT SERIES. Though his only lines were to tell Serizawa how he was dying. Ah well, he wasn't really meant to be significant in this story anyway.
Um..as to why I gave 7, well personally I thought the series could have been longer. I mean for a start I would have loved more back stories on the other guys, namely Harada and Saito since they're two of my favourites. And not knowing how they met with the others in the first place left me sorta gutted, especially Harada who REALLY DID feel like a side character. //le sobs. Well at least they didn't try to squash all their stories into a 12 episode series, that would be disastrous. And also, THEY NEVER SHOWED WHAT HAPPENED WITH THE MAIKO RYUNOSUKE LIKED! WHERE THE HECK DID SHE GO HUH??? Okay I lied, she left the Shimbara (or w/e the red light district was called) but that was it. No "I'MMA FIND RYUNOSUKE" OR "I'MMA MAKE A NEW LIVING DOING BLAH BLAH." Nope. Just a "thank you for looking after me" to her sisters and off she goes somewhere. Charming. So yeah story was decent but not outstanding or anything.
Art: 9/10
Adapted from the awesome art by Kazuki Yone (omg have you seen the CGs for the games she designs? they're so *&F*&$*%H gorgeous and beautiful it has me going kyaaaaaa at how good the bishies look. *__* ohmygawd, I could literally stare all day at some of the CGs *cough*) so of course it'll look good. I used to be pretty sketchy on Studio DEEN's animations since they're renowned for being bad but this was done decently. Well I guess it is a 2012 anime so the quality standard MUST have improved somehow. And bishies. Can never get enough of pretty bishies. WHAT. DON'T LOOK AT ME LIKE THAT, I CAN'T HELP IT IF I'M A FANGIRL. XD But yeah pretty art was one of the reasons I liked this show.
Sound: 7/10
Eh, was pretty decent for the most part. Kinda average though. Especially during some of the scenes where it just sorta fades out along with the moon fading out to black LOL. Soundtrack didn't really stick with me that much. The OP/ED was nice though. I'll give some points for that.
Overall: 8/10
I wanted to watch this for 3 reasons.
1) Didn't have Chizuru
2) Since I saw the first two series and,
3) Because I'm currently playing the psp game. (LOL)
The main off putting factor from the previous series was just how annoying and useless Chizuru was so without her, I found the series much more enjoyable even if there's no romance. Honestly speaking, despite hating the first two series I did enjoy watching this show. It didn't "WOW" or amaze me much but it's a series that I felt was worth the time. Not something I'd recommend instantly if someone asked for a good anime but it's good enough to pass time and I've always been a sucker for Jap history animes so I couldn't help but watch it out of curiosity for the setting. If you hated the first two series but love this kinda setting I’d definitely recommend trying this series out. It’s much better and actually feels more realistic.
All (71)FriendsAlso Available atRSS Feeds |
Mar 7, 2013
Hakuouki: Reimeiroku
(Anime)
add
You'd think after being traumatized by how bad the first two series were, I wouldn't think twice of going anywhere near this franchise again but no, apparently I'm a masochist so I decided to torture myself further by watching this. Actually I’m kidding, it's really not that bad. It has its shortcomings which I will mention in the review but I found myself genuinely curious and enjoying this. Maybe because there's no annoying Chizuru? I couldn’t stand her in the first two series so I guess without her I managed to enjoy the bishies more.
My apologies for the weird ordering, this is a slight revision ... 
Oct 2, 2011
(I'm shit at writing reviews so read this at your own risk XD)
Okay, my first thought about this show: SO CHEESY. I first heard about this from Youtube, off an AMV actually. Basically I saw the bishies and thought “OHHHH LOOKS GOOD!” and then looked it up MAL. And you know what MAL put in it’s description? You don't? Look at the top of this page and see for yourself. //me reads and cringes in horror. That description totally put me off the show however I still went and got myself a copy of the episodes out so far and figured I could trudge through it slowly when I ... |
