Jul 10, 2017
Okay, so I have a little bit of a contradiction in my review's rating, and I'll explain later why I rated this one a 6.
Story- 8
Okay so the story is basically about a fat girl who is trying to become attractive with the help of a tsundere prince and busty maid. All is well and good in this story, no stupid shoujo actions, nothing bad, and in fact it's quite a good read.
Art- 7
I personally enjoyed the art, but it felt like the backgrounds were almost non-existent, which doesn't usually bother me, but in this one it did and I can't explain why.
Characters- 9
I
...
honestly really loved the tubby girl's personality, and even the tsundere prince's personality, and the only character I didn't like was the b*tch best friend (which you'll see in the first, and last chapters) but even she was well done and while I didn't like her she wasn't a sh*tty character.
Enjoyment- 1
Now here is where my rating takes a nose dive. This series could have easily been a 30+ chapter manga (or if the author wanted to compact it they could've done it in 12) but instead, like most great manga, it was axed after 9 chapters, and they LITERALLY LEAVE IT ON A CLIFF HANGER, and this cliff hanger will never climb that hill as he's been dead for a while now. I loved reading it up to chapter 9, but the ending of it ruined this manga for me. Normally, axed or rushed endings aren't terribly, like you can see it coming but it's okay because they get 2-3 chapters to quickly wrap things up (like Beezlebub), but not with this one, as it ends sharply at 9 chapters.
Overall- 6
So, I've rated this one a 6, even though I really liked it. But because of an axed ending, it was ruined for me, and it truly breaks my heart to give it such a love score when it could have easily been in my top 10 all time favorite mangas, but it ended before it got a chance to take off, which is like shooting a firework into a campfire, sure the resulting explosion could be cool, but you mostly miss the actual firework explosion and you just wasted a firework doing your stupid stunt. In summary, I loved this manga, but hated the ending it had as it couldn't even be considered an ending in the slightest. So read it if you want, but just stop maybe by chapter 7 to avoid the heart break.
Reviewer’s Rating: 6
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
.png)
.png)
