What Is A Killer? - Forums - MyAnimeList.net

01-26-11, 12:46 AM

Offline
Joined: Mar 2010
Posts: 234

Well the title speaks for itself. Basicly what do you think the PMK could concidered to be a Killer?

Case 1: Killing The dead?
Do you think that 'Killing' the dead makes you a killer? Should we accept the act of stopping the dead from moving be concidered Killing?

Case 2: Manslaughter!
Ok this does not apply to our club but I just want to know. Do you think that accidental killing would make you a Killer? Even if it has a name which is even more horrible then willingly killing.

UserBars

#2 01-29-11, 6:31 PM
Invalidated Offline Joined: Jan 2011 Posts: 585	Case 1: Killing The dead? No, you're just destroying a vessel. It depends on the context also. How are the dead walking? Are they lifeless vessels being used as puppets? Are they possessed by demons? etc. Case 2: Manslaughter! Yes, you're a killer, someones life was lost due to your negligence.

#3 01-30-11, 1:32 AM
Winged_Phantom Offline Joined: Mar 2010 Posts: 234	CaritasAvaritia said: Case 1: Killing The dead? How are the dead walking? Are they lifeless vessels being used as puppets? Are they possessed by demons? etc. No they are revived. They still have their memories and their souls I guess... UserBars

#4 01-30-11, 2:08 AM
yujipouyg Offline Joined: Aug 2010 Posts: 9	1. Killing the dead? Nope,you are not a killer. You are just having fun >:D HOTD <3

#5 01-30-11, 2:09 AM
yujipouyg Offline Joined: Aug 2010 Posts: 9	1. Killing the dead? Nope,you are not a killer. You are just having fun >:D HOTD <3

#6

01-30-11, 5:59 AM

Nekro-Nin

Offline
Joined: Mar 2009
Posts: 1287

1. Killing the dead
No, you're not a killer/murder, because the dead is already dead and you don't take life by destroying them. If you "kil"l a zombie, you don't "kill" a living human being.
You can be denounce as necrophile (= desecrator of corpses).

2. Manslaughter
No you're not a killer/murder, because you don't have the intent to kill.

You count as a killer/murder, if you've an intent to kill and if you take someone's life.
If you don't belive me, you can read the article from Wikipedia yourself.

#7 01-30-11, 6:36 AM
Winged_Phantom Offline Joined: Mar 2010 Posts: 234	Well yes but I wanted to know if WE could accept them or not. But if you think you like it better like that then I'm fine with it ^^ UserBars

#8 01-30-11, 7:59 AM
Invalidated Offline Joined: Jan 2011 Posts: 585	@Nekro-Nin What do you mean if we don't believe you? What's YOUR definition of a killer, not some editor on Wikipedia.

#9 01-30-11, 1:36 PM
TheMcShan Offline Joined: Sep 2010 Posts: 231	Ive heard that people die if they are killed It boggles my mind >_<

#10 01-30-11, 7:42 PM
Nasuversepro Offline Joined: Dec 2009 Posts: 672	1) Mystic Eyes of Death Perception can. they kill existance so... no revival for zombies...never 2) in the end you get used to it. so yes. maybe discuss "Murder vs Slaughter" "Got it?this is what it means to kill things"

#11 01-30-11, 9:54 PM
Invalidated Offline Joined: Jan 2011 Posts: 585	TheMcShan said: Ive heard that people die if they are killed Studied this phenomenon for years, I've come to similar conclusions.

#12

01-31-11, 4:39 AM

Shima_XIX

Offline
Joined: May 2010
Posts: 1355

Killing the dead, in my opinion, would count as killing if they'd been fully revived (with their original memories and personalities, that is), but it wouldn't count as killing if they're just reanimated corpses (more in line with zombies)...

Accidental killing is still killing. Though I wouldn't go so far as calling the one who committed it a heartless murderer, it would still count as a killing, nonetheless...

#13 01-31-11, 6:47 AM
Nekro-Nin Offline Joined: Mar 2009 Posts: 1287	CaritasAvaritia said: @Nekro-Nin What do you mean if we don't believe you? What's YOUR definition of a killer, not some editor on Wikipedia. It's judgement ~ You judge me as a murder => I'm a murder.

#14 01-31-11, 7:43 PM
karezuzusan Offline Joined: Nov 2010 Posts: 414	Since the dead are not merely corpses, you would be considered a killer since they have their souls so its like u are killing a human.... Even tho its accidental or for self defense, you still are a killer, but not a cold blooded one.....

#15 02-02-11, 3:54 AM
Nekro-Nin Offline Joined: Mar 2009 Posts: 1287	If accidental killing count as killing (with intent to kill), consuming drug is killing: People die, because you consume drugs (for example cannabis). Drug business has ever doing with killing. Drug consuming is killing at your point of view? We discuss about killing humans. But if you kill animals, you take their life, too. Are you a killer, if you kill animals?

#16 02-02-11, 8:28 AM
Invalidated Offline Joined: Jan 2011 Posts: 585	@Nekro-Nin Yes drug dealers are killers, they knowingly distribute substances that are known to cause harm, only caring about a profit, maybe not Cannabis, but for Meth, or Cocaine. Well you're KILLING animals, I guess that makes you (wait for it!) a killer.

#17 02-04-11, 3:29 PM
animefreak13 Offline Joined: Sep 2009 Posts: 18	killing the dead? no,it'sw just cleaning a mess. killing people? no,if they deserve to die or in self defence. other thanb that yes. killing animals?no,if it's for food. no,if it's for fur or game.

#18

02-16-11, 8:52 AM

Kammenos19

Offline
Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 436

1)in my opinion if you are hunted by sth dead and you have to kill in order to survive then
....No you are NOT a killer

2)if you are addicted to horror films and try repeat what you have seen on humans,or you wake up one day and you hate the hole world( and you want to be for ever alone)and start killing people then.....YES Congratulations you ARE A MANIAC A PHYSHOPATH and most important A KIRA ( you know who i am talking about)