Was Annie forgiven to easily?

dark_knight107 said:

Yeah I agree with you but all those people who are blindly supporting Eren's actions just because he is the mc have clearly misinterpreted the author's message of why genocide is evil. I absolutely love Eren but I don't support his actions. He is basically doing it to achieve the false image of freedom which he created in his mind and the world which he had imagined outside the walls after taking a look at Armin's book. The author himself has said on multiple occasions through many characters about Eren's unjust and selfish actions and most fail to understand this. But, tbh they were necessary to the plot since that involves the theme and message of his character.

Neo2425 said:

Rlly. Tell me some animes u consider masterpiece and I’ll tell u bunch of flaws.

Razrop said:

this ain't masterpiece nor even close to it.....go check out other anime.....
She killed most of the people inside the wall and our anti-Eren squad just forgives her.......

MunkeeMan said:

I was joking. I think S4 Part 2 was a huge disappointment.

ichikasolos said:

This is difficult but i’ll list some shows but this may be biased, Owarimonogatari S2, Mob Psycho S2, Steins Gate and the Classroom of the Elite light novel Y1 and Y2, also Attack on Titan S3 P2.

The_Grandmaster said:

Bro it was obviously a joke.

Neo2425 said:

Rlly. Tell me some animes u consider masterpiece and I’ll tell u bunch of flaws.

ichikasolos said:

This is difficult but i’ll list some shows but this may be biased, Owarimonogatari S2, Mob Psycho S2, Steins Gate and the Classroom of the Elite light novel Y1 and Y2, also Attack on Titan S3 P2.

Neo2425 said:
I have such a problem with how Annie was forgiven. She basically killed a bunch of scouts, killed Levi squad, and not only she killed them, she played around with them like fidget spinners. Also she not only was to easily forgiven by the scouts, she was too easily forgiven by Reiner. So Annie doesn’t kill Armin who then ends up devouring Berthodlt and Reiner has no problem with her not going with the mission?

The_Grandmaster said:

Damn. And i defended you as well..

Gaddammitkyle said:
it's a case of "bigger things to worry about". What Eren is about to do is far more worrisome than what Annie has done, plus most of the main cast didnt witness Levi Squad dying first hand, just Levi and Eren.

ichikasolos said:

This is difficult but i’ll list some shows but this may be biased, Owarimonogatari S2, Mob Psycho S2, Steins Gate and the Classroom of the Elite light novel Y1 and Y2, also Attack on Titan S3 P2.

SystemEight said:
Eren and the gang didn't really hate Annie for her betrayal did they? They just felt really sad (because she is their friend and classmate) and Eren became pissed later on. Even when Annie was frozen Armin still visited her whereas Reiner and Bertholdt got hate because they are the ones who killed Eren's mom and caused the whole ruckus.
So, it makes sense that they forgave her sooner and they already overcame the deaths of their comrades so they didn't really feel that angry for killing the scouts and the Levi squad. She was seen more like someone forced in Reiner's scheme.

MysticGekkougaZ said:
Shouldn't you discuss this in the later season forums?

INSANELYWP said:
time heals all wounds. probably didn’t affect them as much years after it happened. also they had a common enemy so they sorted out their differences

INSANELYWP said:
time heals all wounds. probably didn’t affect them as much years after it happened. also they had a common enemy so they sorted out their differences

kxlel02 said:
i don’t know that she was forgiven. i think the whole point of attack on titan is that no one is necessarily the bad guy and no one is necessarily the hero. the people who are painted as heroes are indeed not heroes (Ex.eren). and the people painted as villains are indeed not villains (Ex. Reiner). So when it comes the the alliance formed against eren during the rumbling, i think annie was more accepted for her power and what she could contribute rather than them forgiving her for everything that she’s done. the campfire episode went over this all very clearly.

so i can see how you may say she was forgiven too easily but if you look at it from that perspective, i don’t think they forgave her at all (except maybe armin) but rather they realized they’re all people who have made mistakes and killed others and in that moment they needed her help to fight the big problem and that was more important than personal feelings.

Gaddammitkyle said:
it's a case of "bigger things to worry about". What Eren is about to do is far more worrisome than what Annie has done, plus most of the main cast didnt witness Levi Squad dying first hand, just Levi and Eren.

Razrop said:

yes .....and that's the reason SNK is not a masterpiece nor near to being masterpiece

dark_knight107 said:

Literally every Marleyan individual in the alliance had their reasons to stop Eren aside from their crimes. Most overlook the fact that Annie and Reiner were literally kids when they broke the wall on that day and they were brainwashed into believing that every island devil is evil by Marley. Same applies for Gabi. Falco and Pieck seemed like the only smart ones who got the jist of the situation around them. And, I seriously don't get how people hate this.

itsrj20 said:

Fmab exist, the best flawless show, "almost" to none.
Then there's monster, too.

And redo of ... Jk :⁠-⁠!

dylpickles said:

You don’t have to think it’s a masterpiece that’s fine we can disagree, but you’re saying because she had reasons from her perspective to justify her actions, that takes away from the story? just like most characters in the story on both sides, there were reasons why they act the way they did. They learned the truth of the world way before Annie unhardened, and were in completely different circumstances. It would make less sense if they didn’t forgive after being buddy buddy with the rest of their enemies

Razrop said:

that's why not close to being masterpiece......

dylpickles said:

no that’s why you’re not a masterpiece

Razrop said:

i didn't even mentioned myself being masterpiece in any quote......
that's why you need to watch other anime instead of thinking SNK being best.....

elderonn said:

Owari 2 amazing , there are (very very minor) problems with the first 2 arcs but Ougi dark is flawless. Steins gate the first half was boring and poorly done. Could have been shorter or structured differently. COT I heard amazing things about it but Y2 was underwhelming to my understanding.

LIVI___ said:

your opinion mattered untill you classified cote as a masterpiece.

Footed7 said:

Cmon man classroom of the elite is not a masterpiece

ichikasolos said:

Talking about the light novel.

dylpickles said:

Lol I perceived you as a troll so I responded as such. I gave actual logic as to why it DOESN’T take away from the show, and you haven’t given me any logical response as to how it does. you just saying and that’s exactly why it’s not a masterpiece makes literally no sense . I’ve seen plenty of great anime and aot is absolutely amongst the very best I’ve seen

ichikasolos said:

This is difficult but i’ll list some shows but this may be biased, Owarimonogatari S2, Mob Psycho S2, Steins Gate and the Classroom of the Elite light novel Y1 and Y2, also Attack on Titan S3 P2.

LIVI___ said:

Even the light novel isn't any kind of masterpiece. The protagonist is edgy asf