| Marin is cute, excited to see s2 for sure. Swagernator said: LostSpectre said: I think the ratings speak for themselves. I think the reviews speaks for themselves. You see, Cardi B ratings are always off the charts, but that does not make her music good. Thats because salty people like you and the OP upvote each other's equally lousy opinions. 453,000+ people have this in their list and it's an 8.3. Plenty of people think this s2 was well deserved. If you don't like it, don't watch it. L + gg + ratio |
ScootboiSep 18, 2022 4:27 AM
 |
Scootboi said: Thats because salty people like you and the OP upvote each other's equally lousy opinions. 453,000+ people have this in their list and it's an 8.3. Plenty of people think this s2 was well deserved. If you don't like it, don't watch it. L + gg + ratio Amount of people does not equal quality show or manga. Popularity does not mean something is good. Instead of calling out OP and me, you should provide actual positive traits of this work, instead of "she cute, dont care" opinion. |
 |
Swagernator said: Popularity does not mean something is good. Instead of calling out OP and me, you should provide actual positive traits of this work, instead of "she cute, dont care" opinion. Animation is good, the couple is cute, Gojo's development from a doll creator to a cosplay designer is relaxing to watch alongside their relationship slowly making progress, Marin has some personality traits that differ from many other romcom MCs. But none of that matters. You'd rather come here and voice your distaste for a series instead of just ignoring it and moving on with your life. It's like you cropdusted the thread for no reason. |
|
Scootboi said: Animation is good, the couple is cute, Gojo's development from a doll creator to a cosplay designer is relaxing to watch alongside their relationship slowly making progress, Marin has some personality traits that differ from many other romcom MCs. But none of that matters. You'd rather come here and voice your distaste for a series instead of just ignoring it and moving on with your life. It's like you cropdusted the thread for no reason. The animation indeed is very good. But what couple are we even talking about ? The only thing we've seen in the first season is a hot looking girl commanding a gloomy guy to make cosplay for her, which he obviously accepts, because he's too shy to say no to people. Gojo isn't even a doll creator at this point, he only cares about the cosplay making because it make the only girl that ever talked to him in school, to talk to him more, his state of mind is literally on the level of "if i stop making cosplay costumes for her, she will leave me all alone again". How many dolls did he made since he met Marin ? There is no relationship progress at all amongst the two characters, it's a season full of self righteous girl taking advantage of a kid that does not know better. And that is cute for people for some reason ? You say Marin has some personality traits that differ from many other romcom MCs ? I strongly disagree, her design is cute looking, stylish blonde girl with cheerful personality that you cant say NO to. That is like every girl in every harem show, but this time shes into cosplay so we unique, somehow. I'm not trying to convince you or anyone else, i'm just saying how much wrong is there with this show/manga. And how much people let to ignore just cuz the visuals are attractive. |
SwagernatorSep 18, 2022 5:00 AM
|
| Glad this got a Season 2. I wonder if we will see Gojo being even more outspoken this time around. |
 |
| Quoting IGN and ANN as a standard for reviews quality. Dude, you lost all possible credibility before you even got one. |
|
Bear_from_cave said: Swagernator said: I wrote a near 2000 word review on the series so I probably put more thought into it than most fans did. As for the thread speed, I saw it was in the DB queue about to be approved so I naturally had a fast post lead time. If you wrote big-ass review elsewhere it doesn't somehow make this starting post not pathetic, besides I already wrote what I think about average MAL reviewer. Why where you in such a hurry to start this topic if you don't even care for this series? If you really needed to know why people like the series, you could easily find a well-written positive review and find your answer there instead of trying to start ASAP a thread to criticize the previous season, while most people would rather discuss what will be in the upcoming one. If I want to post a thread that follows site guidelines, I am free to do so, I already explained me being first was happenstance and a byproduct of me knowing when the DB entry was going live. Someone is going to be first on the forum, it just so happened to be me. Not sure why it bothers you so much, you can make your own thread praising the series. Also here's a video you may benefit from. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LnJwH_PZXnM&t |
ACasualViewerSep 19, 2022 3:42 PM
 |
Swagernator said: its not true nise has 8 score and positive reviews on MAL and this is not credible? Like MAL reviews and score are unreliable and they are not credible tooQuoting IGN and ANN as a standard for reviews quality. Dude, you lost all possible credibility before you even got one. |
chriskor022Sep 19, 2022 5:16 PM
 |
| It is big hit because it is good series. And the appeal of FeMC is not the only reason why it is popular even the MC is a good character and the appeal of the cosplay technicalities which is somehow unique spin in the romance genre. The ecchi scenes are in line with the story about cosplay so it is not bad. And comedy even its subjective is good |
|
| Can't wait to see more oversexualized high schoolers and people being creepy about Marin |
 |
| >says Marin is generic >refuses to elaborate further >leaves qǝǝʍ ǝɓɐɹǝʌ∀ u∀ |
 |
ACasualViewer said: Guess I can't be surprised, it was a pretty big hit, though I still don't understand the appeal besides Marin being generic waifu bait. ACasualViewer said: FrostXC3 said: "I don't get the appeal of this anime but I'm going to make a post about it even before the people who love it" Attention seekers will never not be a pathetic joke. Lol! I wrote a near 2000 word review on the series so I probably put more thought into it than most fans did. As for the thread speed, I saw it was in the DB queue about to be approved so I naturally had a fast post lead time. The botted up top reviews showing up first in a decently scored anime make sense now. Swagernator said: LostSpectre said: I think the ratings speak for themselves. I think the reviews speaks for themselves. You see, Cardi B ratings are always off the charts, but that does not make her music good. A Type/Moon fan shouldn't be throwing around this much shade when the thing only exists due to a badly written power wanking eroge vn and is alive today because of a gacha. |
I may make you feel but I can't make you think.  |
LoveScope said: A Type/Moon fan shouldn't be throwing around this much shade when the thing only exists due to a badly written power wanking eroge vn and is alive today because of a gacha. Go fund hasans new mansion or something, and dont bother people around. |
|
Swagernator said: LoveScope said: A Type/Moon fan shouldn't be throwing around this much shade when the thing only exists due to a badly written power wanking eroge vn and is alive today because of a gacha. Go fund hasans new mansion or something, and dont bother people around. Who? A non reply, as expected of the waifu IP lover. Glass houses. |
I may make you feel but I can't make you think. |
Bear_from_cave said: Swagernator said: Quoting IGN and ANN as a standard for reviews quality. Dude, you lost all possible credibility before you even got one. They are pillars of credibility compared to MAL reviews, with for example Dr Stone still having 1/10 review on the very top because some "popular" MAL reviewer got salty with the series, and with Yofukashi no Uta having only incoherent babbling about pedos in top reviews. There are some good MAL reviews, but they are buried deep beneath the upvoted ones, because people writing them watch the series properly instead of racing to get the review ASAP on page to rack in the votes. So yes, quoting some bad MAL reviews as a proof taht this series sucks despite high user score is just LOL-worthy. Bad MAL reviews can be sometimes useful because if series is popular but there are critical reviews in top section, you can check them and see if reviewers' issues are likely to be similar to yours, though recent change in voting system broke even that, but they're not really significant considering anybody can write them. Are you trying to say "top reviews are bad" which is heavily dependent on timing and haters, or "total number of negative reviews is high" which is dumb because a) everybody can write few words and add their negative review to the pile, and b) if you google around on other websites, vast majority of reviews are positives, and MAL is hardly only the oracle for general otaku population. That just sound like a you problem. |
|
| Looking forward to more premium waifu bait |
 |
| Generic? Funny. One of the most positive girls in anime, a true friend and a joy to hang out with, without a single tsundere crap in her and you call her generic. |
 |
| Yay really excited about this sequel. I don't know about y'all, but I'm not watching for Marin, I'm watching for Gojo AND Marin. I love to see their interactions, but especially the development of Gojo. I cannot wait for this sequel and hope we won't have to wait for too long. |
| I sometimes forget to finish my sentences. |
SentiOnikawa said: your post makes sense but it got to have something extra which made it this popular, i've understood that this isn't a new concept, while writing my original post i'm not sure if i knew about this but i still think my dress up has something that others didn't hence the popularity. and yes i've watched bunny girl senpai, it's a 10/10 anime.TsutanaiFuun said: Your description of Marin is every romcom female lead ever. As someone who has ventured into Shojo Ai, it's not a rarity. Gojo also isn't all that original. A male love interest with a "weird" hobby who catches the eye of a popular female lead who also shares a similar interest? It's not like Bottom-tier Character Tomazaki-kun, High Score Girl, Loving Yamada at Level 999, and Accel World exist. There was also one from years ago where the male lead is in an anime club and the female lead joins because of him, only to find herself getting immersed in otaku culture. It even has cosplay moments, so y'know...Waifu isn't the only thing going on for this anime. You can say Marin is the selling point of this anime but once you get into this anime you can see that it's an actual good romcom with a great female MC, she's not shy, has realised she likes the male MC, is NOT GENERIC. The anime has loads of wholesome moments, though the comedic moments can be a hit or miss for some people. This anime perfectly shpws what it's about, we get lots of cosplays. The male MC is better than many other romcom MCs. He has many other qualities other than just being dense like many other romcom MCs. He's the most normal teenage MC I've ever seen, everything is natural about him. Marin being present just makes everything 10 times better. There's great character development too, our lonely MC by the end of Season 1 becomes a chad who's casually hanging out with pretty women and has gotten the cutest girl in his class to have a crush on him. Can't wait to see how Marin acts around Gojo after the last scene of ep12. Sono Bisque Doll isn't even that original with its writing or characters. It's derivative to the point of actively depreciating with everyone who possesses an IQ above the temperature of lukewarm water. If you want a series with highly-competent writing and is a romcom, go watch Bunnygirl-senpai. Not only is the writing solid, but the characters interactions are a lot more engaging. |
 The end of an era. Thank you Wit, Mappa and Isayama. Feeling half happy, half sad. Kawaii waifus and precious best girls <3333 |
adfrula said: didn't realise i wrote something funny but all good if it made someone happy.TsutanaiFuun said: Mod edit.your post makes sense but it got to have something extra which made it this popular, i've understood that this isn't a new concept, while writing my original post i'm not sure if i knew about this but i still think my dress up has something that others didn't hence the popularity. and yes i've watched bunny girl senpai, it's a 10/10 anime. |
cyruzJul 14, 2023 8:21 AM
The end of an era. Thank you Wit, Mappa and Isayama. Feeling half happy, half sad. Kawaii waifus and precious best girls <3333 |
More topics from this board
» Any updates on this season 2?Brucasco - Jan 17 |
17 |
by wallsg
»»
May 7, 12:06 AM |
|
» It won't be as good as the first season ( 1 2 )rickotaviano - Sep 18, 2022 |
63 |
by H4trax
»»
Feb 1, 7:09 AM |
|
» This is tagged as slice of life, not a romance anymoreAnimeIs4Kidz - Feb 2, 2023 |
26 |
by Otakodo_kumo
»»
Jan 16, 2:21 AM |
|
» Will Himeno appear?AsHoul - Oct 16, 2023 |
14 |
by Swagernator
»»
Nov 17, 2023 6:15 AM |
|
» Season 2 confirmation from extra pages in Volume 10 that was just released today.wangson - Sep 23, 2022 |
6 |
by Tajihiro
»»
Mar 5, 2023 9:10 PM |