 If you liked
Shuffle!
|
 ...then you might like
Mashiro-iro Symphony: The Color of Lovers
|
More then one girl is in love with the male guy.
Male ends up with the unexpected girl.
Very similar,
Tells each side of the girls stories.
Harem anime that, unlike most harem shows, don't immediately make it obvious who the guy will end up with. Both have five girls and one guy (though not all of those girls have romantic feelings for the guy) and they each have bright, unique hair colors and archetypes.
Both are school-age harem romantic comedies that are a bit less focused on slapstick comedy and the "accidental pervert" trope than most in the genre. Moreover, both anime reach a satisfying conclusion, in which the boy makes a choice about who to love--and in neither case, does he make the "obvious" choice.