10: Masterpiece, god-tier, and covers and delivers extremely well on ALL aspects a show is expected of in its genre, and MULTIPLE aspects outside of its genre*
(Eg. an action show which has many thought-provoking messages or
a SOL show with extremely good world-building would be said to deliver extremely well on ONE aspect OUTSIDE its genre.)
ALSO stands out in some way in writing. (Eg. Beautiful scenes that combine art and music to provide a surreal experience)
9: Masterpiece, with minor flaws that can be easily overlooked. Stands out in some way in writing, OR covers and delivers extremely on at least ONE aspect a show is expected of OUTSIDE of its genre, and most, if not all** aspects WITHIN its genre.
8: Very Good: Enjoyed the anime, with minor flaws that can be easily overlooked. As a viewer, I keep looking forward to the next episode, if any. It must deliver extremely well on most, if not all, aspects the show is expected of WITHIN its genre.
7: Good: A good show, which has some flaws. To emphasise, still a good show. Most likely would look forward to the next episode.
6: Fine: A show which may have some glaring flaws or is somewhat insipid. Overall, it is a show which does have some enjoyable moments. Unfortunately, these moments do not occur too often.
5: Average: A show which has few enjoyable moments, and is mostly bland. It delivers a subpar plot and has uninteresting characters. Kind of meh.
4: Bad: A show whose plot downright does not make sense. While plot holes may have been present in shows with a higher rating, plot holes that exist here are too large for the show to make basic sense, and the story falls apart.
3: Very Bad: 4, except that its worse. Actually feelsbad watching the show
2: Horrible: 3, except that its worse.
1: Appalling: .
* I use the word "genre" very loosely. What I mean is what you expect the show to contain. For example, you can expect fights from action anime, but you can also expect camaraderie/friendships, or rivalrous relationships from action anime as well (depending on the anime).
** This will depend on whether it is a movie, whereby less will be expected from certain aspects such as character development
All Comments (0) Comments