| Personally I prefer the manga since I think they did the story alot better (by that I mean they actually had a good romance going between Karin and Kenta instead of them just being friends that secretly have a crush on each other).But I was curious to what other people thought so vote and post away. P.S. If you do post please put the reason why you picked what you did |
BlazingDevilMar 28, 2009 1:03 PM
 ~Signature made by Dea37s~ Night Academy I.D. |
| Personally, I preferred the manga because the romance was far more developed. Seriously, there were plenty of opportunites to develop the romance, and most of them were skimped out for MORE FUCKING WINNER SCREENTIME. The pool episode made me rage the most because it should have gone: Karin, Kenta, Maki, and Winner go to the water park. Hilarity ensues. Including Kenta into that episode would have improved it SO much more. However, one thing the anime did better was give Elda more personality and more screentime. Other than that, the manga surpasses the anime in every other way. The manga was a lot more realistic and the jokes were A LOT better. Oh god, I can't stress this enough. The anime had jokes that were either a hit or a miss, and most of them involved Winner or Karin's breasts in some way. The manga had much more clever and creative humor. For example, in volume 5 where Karin gets her words twisted around by the manager concerning the extra work for Christmas. I LOL'D. Geniunely funny sex joke, unlike in the anime. (DURR HURR BOOBS NOSEBLEED LOL SO RANDOM XD) |
zonnikkuMar 15, 2009 9:38 PM
zonnikku said: Actually I wouldnt know about the pool episode cause I skipped over most of it... I just can't stand that DAMN BASTARD WINNER!!! He just pisses me off, I mean he knows that Karin and Kenta have a thing for each other and he still tries to get in the way. God he is almost as bad as Seista from Zero no Tsukaima. ( yes I like ZnT dont beat me over the head about it.)Though he still isn't quite as bad as her because no one can be as bad as Seista. Oh well I think I have ranted enough but basically I agree Winner is an idiot and Kenta should have been added into the pool episode.Personally, I preferred the manga because the romance was far more developed. Seriously, there were plenty of opportunites to develop the romance, and most of them were skimped out for MORE FUCKING WINNER SCREENTIME. The pool episode made me rage the most because it should have gone: Karin, Kenta, Maki, and Winner go to the water park. Hilarity ensues. Including Kenta into that episode would have improved it SO much more. |
ZinnKidMar 18, 2009 8:11 AM
| ~Signature made by Dea37s~ Night Academy I.D. |
zonnikku said: Quoted from the effing truth!Personally, I preferred the manga because the romance was far more developed. Seriously, there were plenty of opportunites to develop the romance, and most of them were skimped out for MORE FUCKING WINNER SCREENTIME. The manga was a lot more realistic and the jokes were A LOT better. Oh god, I can't stress this enough. The anime had jokes that were either a hit or a miss, and most of them involved Winner or Karin's breasts in some way. It's depressing how often anime adaptations fail to stand on the same level of humor as the original material. Doujin Work was enough to destroy my hope in anime companies for a looooong while. All that brilliant 4-panel humor down the drain -.-" I also prefer the manga, for many good reasons but mostly because of Winner. Oh, that little brat stuck out in that big group of likable character like a sore thumb with frostbites. After following the colorful events of the Marker family you expect me to accept that? Not ****ing likely. The romance in the anime was okay I guess, but that's a bad thing when it's so addicting to follow in the manga. |
| oh i just got done watching this anime it was so cute and delightful I really need to read the manga still I've yet to read it So i'll leave my feelings on that when i read it hehe. |
| manga because it had more of a plot and a real ending. however, I like the anime a lot too. I feel like I'm the only one who doesn't hate Winner. His voice is so annoying that I like it. I know I'm crazy xD |
| I prefer the manga because the plot was more elaborate and it answered more questions. But the anime was good too.... |
hirahira said: Yes... Yes you are...lolmanga because it had more of a plot and a real ending. however, I like the anime a lot too. I feel like I'm the only one who doesn't hate Winner. His voice is so annoying that I like it. I know I'm crazy xD |
| ~Signature made by Dea37s~ Night Academy I.D. |
| Manga, absolutely. The story is better developed ^_^ |
  |
| I prefer manga cos there was no vampire hunter Winner lol An of course plot was more interesting ^^ |
 |
| I thought the anime was boring |
| I have to say the anime cuz I haven't gotten past 1st chapter in the manga. ^O^ But I'm fairly certain I'll change my mind once I read on. That always happens. ^^ |
| "I became insane, with long intervals of horrible sanity." -Edgar Allan Poe |
| I'm going what most people have said is with the manga since I also feel that the story and romance is more developed than the anime. |
I see the world how it is... in shades of gray. Nothing is totally clean... or totally dirty! - Majeh     |
| I've only read two volumes of the manga so far (watched anime around 2 months ago) so can't really compare them yet, but judging from all the comments here the manga should be better, I'll just have to see for it myself. Though it'll take a while since there are only 4 volumes of it published in my country so far :( |
 |
| The Anime |
| Sig deleted for being too large. |
| Manga is better IMO!! Not just the story;even the art was cooler!! D:< |
| For me manga is better. |
 |
| I think manga might be better than anime, but for now i only watched anime, so I prefer anime:) But in near future I will read manga:) |
 |
| Manga, obviously because the story goes way further than in the anime, to the point that there's even a time skip. |
 Ku ku ku~  |
| I haven't watched the anime, and I have no desire to do so because of how amazing the manga was. |
 |
| The anime was kinda.. bad actually xD |
| The manga is better |
 |
| just got invited so i thought! i better go reread the Manga series! its been almost 6 months since i finished so im forgetful. And i have to buy the rest of the volumes i only have 1-3 <_< but yes Manga is so much better! i almost dropped the anime series because of the english dub, god bless the japanese dub! |
| I must agree with everyone that in manga Karin&Kenta's romance was more... "mature", but I think that anime was better. Sorry, the end of manga just made me stay up in tears for over half of hour:( |
| Denerwować się to mścić się na własnym zdrowiu za głupotę innych. |
| I haven't watched the anime so I can't tell which is better, but the manga looks pretty well to me^^ |
  |
| Another plus for the manga: Hekikai no Aion has officially joined Karin's "universe". We may still get some post-ending Karin dose since the just-conceived Kanon is related to the Akuma twins (Karin's epilogue chapter is years after Aion, though). |
| Ku ku ku~ |
xShiroSakura said: The anime was kinda.. bad actually xD You said it! The manga is very good, the anime is full of flaws. Holes in the plot, annoying new characters and the end is really lame. |
| Wanna join these clubs and have a nice talk: We Hate Censorship and Luna & Survive Fan Club |
| I liked the anime, cause who doesn't like seeing their favorite chars animated. However, as typical with many anime, I like the manga better. Fuller story, less "what the" moments. They did the changes to the story well in the anime, but it still wasn't as good. |
 |
| Manga was better in so many ways!! First, as someone already said, the romance was far more developed, and second, there was no Winner-kun! Who the hell created all that hunter stuff? Anyway, Loser-kun is really no good, and he took so much time of the show.. :( manga ftw |
 IF YOU WON'T CLICK IT, IT WON'T GROW *udontsay* |
| I prefer the anime over the manga, the ending just makes me feel much better about life compared to the manga. xD |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Did You Read The Manga, Watched The Anime, Or Both?ZinnKid - Jan 23, 2010 |
31 |
by Ascendence
»»
Sep 25, 2015 9:25 PM |
|
Poll: » Who is your favorite Karin character.... ( 1 2 )Maora - Aug 16, 2007 |
92 |
by Ascendence
»»
Sep 25, 2015 9:16 PM |
|
Poll: » Club ColorShadowed_Flames - Oct 27, 2008 |
14 |
by Mangaman13
»»
Jul 18, 2015 7:13 PM |
|
Poll: » Which Karin vampire would enjoy your blood the most?ZinnKid - Mar 8, 2009 |
30 |
by WarEasley
»»
Mar 9, 2015 3:15 AM |
|
Poll: » Are you male or female? ( 1 2 )removed-user - Dec 17, 2008 |
72 |
by HELLSATAN
»»
Jan 21, 2014 3:15 AM |