JosephSaber40 said:
movies and fictional stories should try to reflect our real world history, and Zero Requiem isn't realistic and can't be applied to our real world, what's more realistic is Schenizel's ideology of peace backed by force, but of course you need to minimize the damage and not kill 1 or 2 billions through nuke bombs, Schenizel's right in his ideas but he's extremists at the same time, while Lelouch seems some kind of a delusional man. it's easy to call a character delusional when you actually don't understand the depth of his actions, lelouch didn't create eternal peace nor he solved humanity's problems, he destroyed the world as it was and gave people an opportunity to move to a better future, because he believed in the nature of humanity to desire and long for what's better, what lelouch did is to show the world the bad in being ruled by a tyran, he literally possessed the whole world and did all kind of atrocities to unite every one against him, even those who never experienced tyranny before now they know and feel what the others suffered from, of course this wasn't showed explicitly and they didn't need to do so because the idea is so obvious and the finale should finish with a higher note.
So lelouch needed to die for the world to continue its evolution towards a better tomorrow, and this is why people were gathering around tables to discuss instead of making wars, but this does not mean things will stay like this forever, peace can broken again but lelouch accomplished his goal to create a new world where people can live together in a better way than it was.
And about fiction having to be a mirror of our history, i agree with you to an extent, but writing a story isn't copying history, it's using history in order to convey a message, ideas and to give solutions of potential problems that exist and still hasn't been solved. So fiction in my opinion is most importantly about giving solutions no matter if they are idealistic or not as far as the problem persists in the real life, just give me a meaningful solution that has been explored and well developed through the series and that will be good. If the world hasn't yet a "realistic" solution to war and peace why do you expect a fictional story to do so, this is ridiculous.
Fiction is about giving ideas that can be applied in some circumstances even if it's hard to make them. The zero requiem can be applied in the real world if you have a system that can subjugate every single one in this world to a tyrannical authority, if everyone knows the pain of having no right to talk or to discuss things then people will try not make the same mistakes in the future if this entity disappears . This is of course theoretical and have very low chances to become a reality, but the idea is here, and this is what fiction should be about, this is what great fictional stories do, they have something new to add even though it's not yet possible to apply the idea, but at least there was a try to approach the matter in a way.
What will fiction add to you if it just reflects what reality is? We all know that and it will have no added value because you can learn about history in the books. Fiction is about treating reality and most importantly surpassing it, people want what's beyond reality even if it's just an illusion or a faraway dream that may not become true, but history has also shown that what people was making jokes about and saw as utopic and unrealistic became one day a reality. |