I was here trying to make effort not to reveal the winner, to everyone see the video, I guess that was down the drain hehe.
Zymf said:
Bluffing and surprise attacks
First of all, I think the bluffing and the surprise attacks were a bit confusing and I think there should be some very clear rules as to when and how you bluff/surprise attack.
I think it would be better if all movements and actions is posted in the thread. If you want to attack someone, you should use the command "Execute attack" and then send the attack in a PM.
The bluff was actually simple, since the PM's took priority, and during the day you were only allowed to send if it was in a fight, though towards the special phase I allowed it anyway.
My last movement was: "Move next to Niida, so that I'm standing 1 square away from him" - I don't think this sort of movement should be allowed. I should have calculated his movements instead and then moved like normal.
Yes I agree, but I couldn't say no when I allowed similar movements to other players, unless they were too much.
Weapons
I had 10 shurikens and, even though I used them all the time, I don't think I even used half of them. I think weapons with limited ammo should either be:
- Limited even further to like 1, 2 or 3 shots total
- Or the shots should be less effective. In return the players should then be able to use several at once.
Weapons without ammo, such as the Katana or the whip, should have a much shorter range (max 2), but in return they should be very effective (like 5-6 damage)!
I also agree, they were mostly arbitrary numbers, so my bad on this one.
PM's
In the later half of the game, I started sending PM's to both mycoolboo and Jackrito. This wasn't against the rules, and I think this should be made clear so that more people could take advantage of it.. Or maybe you should just forbid it? I'm not really sure what would be better in this game :/
I did not know of that, otherwise I would not have allowed, I said when you made an alliance that I would intermediate any conversations, though, I never stated it clear because I thought it was a basic role to any game, should have thought of this.
Voting
I don't think voting was used very often in this game, which I think was a shame.. I think you should change the rules, so that not 50% of the players would have to agree on 1 option. As long as one option has more votes than the other, it should be enough..
I changed to that it didn't really worked, it's improbable that I would do another free for all game soon, but I'll keep this on mind.
Half of the rules was explained in the OP and the other half was explained on page 6 just before the "Day phase 1"-post. This was also because of the tutorial of course..
Yeah, I didn't had time to put everything explained, and there were things that was properly explains only half way through the game, because the game 9 was near it's end I was pressured to start this one, not that anyone did it(on the contrary), it was just me.
Anyways, thanks for hosting Verumir and Crowlage! I hope this helps ^^
Yes, this helps a lot thank you very much for the feedback. |