Do You think there should be sections for 18+ material not appropriate for 13-17 yr olds.
| I like the idea of having a warning page prior to pages with questionable content, or making those pages hidden by default. I would also prefer no crude content on the site. Yet in practice, there will be the issues of how to decide what is "obscene" or not, as well as how to verify one's age, as many people have pointed out. When it comes down to it, the owner of the site is the one legally responsible, so I would completely understand him making regulations that best protect him, regardless of differing opinions or members who are not content with the decisions. |
 |
boursk said: Can't we just ban stuff from MAL that have ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to do with anime? You'd still have things like the hentai club, but at least you'll get rid of the cum club. Because even anime fans have other interests... and it's always fun to find your MAL friends that may have something else in common with you. Getting rid of ALL anime clubs (which I honestly don't think Xinil would do)... would force A LOT of good CLEAN clubs to close (off the top of my head... the Kanashimi Fan Club, the Music Club, the Poetry Club, the Pangya Players Club, the Xinil Fan Club, and the Harry Potter Fanclub)... in my opinion, there is nothing wrong with these clubs... and it gives a chance for people with like-interests to discuss and enjoy. |
| Personally I find the warning page, quiet agreeable. I just want something, some kind of protection on the stie that would let me feel comfortable letting my brother and sister join the site. I don't live with them and I would love to share this site with them. But I will not even tell them about the site tell Im 100% sure it will be safe for them. Its not even that I think my brother isnt mature enough to handle the content its just if he visits the site at school or at home and a teacher or my mom passes by with one of those images pops up on the screen. He would be screwed. And my last thing, I do want MAL to be a safe place for my sister to visit, I dont want to have to worry about some "Cum Club" *edited for content* saying inappropreate things to my lil sister or worse. I know that, and both trust my siblings, that if a warning page comes up they will back away from it. I like the idea and approve of it. :EDIT: I also think Xinil should of course have final say on a club. I mean the Cum Club is obviously nothing but an thread for sexually active adults talkign about sex with a bunch of (for my country anyway) underage children (no offence to any 13-17 yr olds out there). I mean the site has got to have some measure of standards doesnt it? At some point isnt there a line or something that takes it too far? In any event this is my opinion and I can't really explain it more that I have tried as I suck with these kinds of things. |
SandgolemJun 28, 2007 7:11 AM
 |
| well its hard to say yes or no on an adult section bit because of the fact that a lot of anime has some form of sexual content or anything.. i think anything as blatantly obvious like the cum club obviously belong somewhere else or better yet in the club creation have an 18 or older restriction on just that club..not on everything that goes on in mal |
  |
More topics from this board
» Watched history pagesnotathrowaway75 - 2 hours ago |
0 |
by notathrowaway75
»»
2 hours ago |
|
» Please add a filter to the Adapted to Anime to only show 1st SeasonsSAMOAK - 11 hours ago |
0 |
by SAMOAK
»»
11 hours ago |
|
» Remove the new "Adapted to manga" tabKietaTeenRomance - Dec 13, 2024 |
15 |
by retroy
»»
Yesterday, 10:27 PM |
|
Poll: » Add list setting to make notes private (on public lists)Shark93 - Nov 12, 2022 |
34 |
by Daviljoe193
»»
Yesterday, 9:24 PM |
|
» Magazines into "Companies Faves"MisutaaPurinsu - Jan 2 |
0 |
by MisutaaPurinsu
»»
Jan 2, 4:05 PM |