New
Apr 28, 2017 4:12 AM
#3251
aa-dono said: Actually scratch that list.I think all my previous reads are lost at sea. Welcoming Dono's new list: *drumrolls* 1. The Sneaky Scum: Penta, DenjaX 2. Scum in Training: logic340 3. The Lost at Sea: Jack, Grape/Sleipnirr, Qoco 4. Maid in Training: grrr 5. The Always Right Mistresses: Coelestin, Shinichi-Kun Here's a newer new list. 1. The Sneaky Scum: Penta, DenjaX 2. Scum in Training: Qoco or probably one of those that are lost at sea 3. The Lost at Sea: Jack, Grape/Sleipnirr 4. Maid in Training: grrr, logic340 5. The Always Right Mistresses: Coelestin, Shinichi-Kun Reason for the change: logic340 makes sense if both grrr and Rosie makes sense. I don't see Carrot and Qoco possibly the same alignment. |
Apr 28, 2017 4:15 AM
#3252
Suzune-chan said: The Moon Rises The full moon was beginning to rise as night was upon the ability users. Everyone was fighting. It was becoming apparent that the darkness they were looking for was lurking in those closest to them. Friends turning on friends. "Stop fighting. We need to think this through. We need to relax a little. I am not your enemy." Atsushi announces. Coelestin has been revealed as Atsushi Nakajima (Beast Beneath the Moonlight) the innocent child. b] @Logic340, @Sleipnirr, @Shinichi-Kun, @Kit, @Aa-dono, @DenjaX, @Jackrito, @Grrr,, @Pentaflare, @LucianRoy, @Coelestin, @Qoco Well that is that cleared would rather that be revealed later tbh to catch a bad scum push on her. |
Apr 28, 2017 4:17 AM
#3253
DenjaX said: He was the one to suggest who should use what ability. Sure, at the end of the day, it's up to the person to use it or not. But being suggestive is another form of manipulation of words.aa-dono said: nvm. I saw you vote for Penta.DenjaX said: where do you wanna go with that list? How is Penta more scummy than me? Second, it's easy for someone to agree with an idea or go along with it. Town could do it too. So that puts you second to list (of who to vote first). On top of I'm giving you the benefit of doubt from your respond to me after Carrot's claim. However, I stated nowhere that Penta is scummier than you. What gave you that idea? |
Apr 28, 2017 4:19 AM
#3254
| Why is no one asking how Shinichi knew Chione's role? |
Apr 28, 2017 4:21 AM
#3255
Jackrito said: If they're both town, isn't it fine?Why is no one asking how Shinichi knew Chione's role? |
Apr 28, 2017 4:21 AM
#3256
aa-dono said: You put me in the same scum pile with him but you voted him instead. Is it not your read list? DenjaX said: He was the one to suggest who should use what ability. Sure, at the end of the day, it's up to the person to use it or not. But being suggestive is another form of manipulation of words.aa-dono said: DenjaX said: What do you mean?where do you wanna go with that list? How is Penta more scummy than me? Second, it's easy for someone to agree with an idea or go along with it. Town could do it too. So that puts you second to list (of who to vote first). On top of I'm giving you the benefit of doubt from your respond to me after Carrot's claim. However, I stated nowhere that Penta is scummier than you. What gave you that idea? Also what idea did I agree on? Off topic: you changed your sig! |
Apr 28, 2017 4:22 AM
#3257
Apr 28, 2017 4:22 AM
#3258
aa-dono said: Jackrito said: If they're both town, isn't it fine?Why is no one asking how Shinichi knew Chione's role? Not really he should not know that off his role, it bothers me the disintrest in that. |
Apr 28, 2017 4:25 AM
#3259
Jackrito said: This happens Day 4 or during the night? Could it be someone checks Coel and Shinichi got the result?aa-dono said: Jackrito said: Why is no one asking how Shinichi knew Chione's role? Not really he should not know that off his role, it bothers me the disintrest in that. But that's not how it works, right? Everything redirect to him means whatever result people get is all based off Shinichi.. |
Apr 28, 2017 4:30 AM
#3260
aa-dono said: thats not how it works.Jackrito said: This happens Day 4 or during the night? Could it be someone checks Coel and Shinichi got the result?aa-dono said: Jackrito said: If they're both town, isn't it fine?Why is no one asking how Shinichi knew Chione's role? Not really he should not know that off his role, it bothers me the disintrest in that. But that's not how it works, right? Everything redirect to him means whatever result people get is all based off Shinichi.. But lets say lightning rod also takes night results. Even if we have another cop, he would learn his own alignment only. But it would have been greatly utilised if there was a watcher and he learned who visited him. But I dont think lightning rod works that way. Would have been cool tho. @Shinichi-Kun |
Apr 28, 2017 4:34 AM
#3261
DenjaX said: The idea that he's scummier.aa-dono said: You put me in the same scum pile with him but you voted him instead. Is it not your read list? DenjaX said: aa-dono said: nvm. I saw you vote for Penta.DenjaX said: What do you mean?where do you wanna go with that list? How is Penta more scummy than me? Second, it's easy for someone to agree with an idea or go along with it. Town could do it too. So that puts you second to list (of who to vote first). On top of I'm giving you the benefit of doubt from your respond to me after Carrot's claim. However, I stated nowhere that Penta is scummier than you. What gave you that idea? Also what idea did I agree on? Off topic: you changed your sig! Oh yep, my read list. Well, mainly because I can get reads from you by this kind of conversation alone~ Chione wasn't exactly off about people not going after Jack, her and Penta. I had to force myself to check every word to get read their post without feeling like I'm being dragged in a comfortable flow. DenjaX said: He suggested it somewhere and Coel responded to it with "why did you have to reveal it" something.Jackrito said: I cant even find the post about him talking her role.Why is no one asking how Shinichi knew Chione's role? Off topic: Yeah, I reused my old sig since while thinking of a new one. Don't change yours just yet. I'm thinking of making triplets or similar. Matching sig with you was fun but *cough cough*, worried if someone gets sulky later x) |
Apr 28, 2017 4:39 AM
#3262
Apr 28, 2017 4:42 AM
#3263
DenjaX said: Good. I've been meaning to ask: What's segregation duties?@aa-dono keep it up. I liked your segregation duties. If you have questions for me, I am here. Off topic: I meant you updated it. Mine is still February xDD Other than that, I'm assuming it means you think I'm town. Why? Seems like general consensus is "I don't know where to place you" and "scum" when it comes to me. So what post or posts made you think I'm town? Off topic: Astros urged me to. He's the only fan of my bookclub. |
Apr 28, 2017 4:49 AM
#3264
aa-dono said: DenjaX said: Good. I've been meaning to ask: What's segregation duties?@aa-dono keep it up. I liked your segregation duties. If you have questions for me, I am here. Off topic: I meant you updated it. Mine is still February xDD Other than that, I'm assuming it means you think I'm town. Why? Seems like general consensus is "I don't know where to place you" and "scum" when it comes to me. So what post or posts made you think I'm town? Off topic: Astros urged me to. He's the only fan of my bookclub. I want answer to that as well. |
Apr 28, 2017 4:58 AM
#3265
aa-dono said: Segregation duties is my way of doing to sort out alignments from players.DenjaX said: Good. I've been meaning to ask: What's segregation duties?@aa-dono keep it up. I liked your segregation duties. If you have questions for me, I am here. Off topic: I meant you updated it. Mine is still February xDD Other than that, I'm assuming it means you think I'm town. Why? Seems like general consensus is "I don't know where to place you" and "scum" when it comes to me. So what post or posts made you think I'm town? Off topic: Astros urged me to. He's the only fan of my bookclub. And oof, unfortunately, I cannot provide you the posts you made because I am on mobile atm and I will be on mobile for the rest of the phase. But your posts helped me when I was catching up. Your posts were easy to read and I was able to see the current state of the game much faster. |
Apr 28, 2017 5:01 AM
#3266
| Fekk i pressed post message by accident. Also, I town read you but I dont consider you confirmed town yet. Because scum usually know the overview of the current game state due to their inside information. That is why I am wary about you. But since there are more bad people out there, I consider you my ally for now. |
Apr 28, 2017 5:03 AM
#3267
aa-dono said: I've only skimmed through things. Anyway, I hate that lighting rod thing and I have no idea why you guys suggested that. Probably explained, but I can't remember it. 1. All it does is confirm Shin's ability. If he wasn't up for a lynch why does he need to do it? 2. It doesn't help check Qoco who was also a lynch candidate. 3. Unless I get the ability wrong, then everything gets redirected to Shinichi which means that it's a wasted night for informative roles to get info. If you there's a manipulation role like Carrot, I don't think only informative role is Cop. Also, to town. Do you really believe all those claims? Look at your role pm, and look at the flips and tell me that you think all of them are right. @PentaFlare What did you achieve from the Shin's ability? @Coelestin I thought Innocent Child is revealed at the start of game? To this I think it was a good night it confimed Shinichi and that we do have a healer, not sure the issue. No one died either On claims no I don\t believe them town has too much imo to stop kills. Also with no death on Shinichi likely no strongman to balance that as well. |
Apr 28, 2017 5:03 AM
#3268
Apr 28, 2017 5:05 AM
#3269
DenjaX said: Fekk i pressed post message by accident. Also, I town read you but I dont consider you confirmed town yet. Because scum usually know the overview of the current game state due to their inside information. That is why I am wary about you. But since there are more bad people out there, I consider you my ally for now. That last bit makes no sense if they are a doubt dont trust them that much or you get led to mislynches. |
Apr 28, 2017 5:08 AM
#3270
DenjaX said: when did I give an overview? I don't think my posts summarize anything. Except my thoughts.Fekk i pressed post message by accident. Also, I town read you but I dont consider you confirmed town yet. Because scum usually know the overview of the current game state due to their inside information. That is why I am wary about you. But since there are more bad people out there, I consider you my ally for now. Who's bad? |
Apr 28, 2017 5:09 AM
#3271
Jackrito said: If you let mistrust/doubts get over you all the time, you wont able to find progress. I proceeded with caution because that is the best thing to do. Well that is the only thing I can do. It is true that there are scum in the midst but it is also true that there are town among us as well.DenjaX said: Fekk i pressed post message by accident. Also, I town read you but I dont consider you confirmed town yet. Because scum usually know the overview of the current game state due to their inside information. That is why I am wary about you. But since there are more bad people out there, I consider you my ally for now. That last bit makes no sense if they are a doubt dont trust them that much or you get led to mislynches. |
Apr 28, 2017 5:12 AM
#3272
aa-dono said: did I use a wrong term? When I was catching up, I keep founding myself nodding in agreement when I was reading your posts. This was my experience.DenjaX said: when did I give an overview? I don't think my posts summarize anything. Except my thoughts.Fekk i pressed post message by accident. Also, I town read you but I dont consider you confirmed town yet. Because scum usually know the overview of the current game state due to their inside information. That is why I am wary about you. But since there are more bad people out there, I consider you my ally for now. Who's bad? |
Apr 28, 2017 5:15 AM
#3273
Apr 28, 2017 5:16 AM
#3274
Jackrito said: Actually now that I thought of it...aa-dono said: I've only skimmed through things. Anyway, I hate that lighting rod thing and I have no idea why you guys suggested that. Probably explained, but I can't remember it. 1. All it does is confirm Shin's ability. If he wasn't up for a lynch why does he need to do it? 2. It doesn't help check Qoco who was also a lynch candidate. 3. Unless I get the ability wrong, then everything gets redirected to Shinichi which means that it's a wasted night for informative roles to get info. If you there's a manipulation role like Carrot, I don't think only informative role is Cop. Also, to town. Do you really believe all those claims? Look at your role pm, and look at the flips and tell me that you think all of them are right. @PentaFlare What did you achieve from the Shin's ability? @Coelestin I thought Innocent Child is revealed at the start of game? To this I think it was a good night it confimed Shinichi and that we do have a healer, not sure the issue. No one died either On claims no I don\t believe them town has too much imo to stop kills. Also with no death on Shinichi likely no strongman to balance that as well. grrr is moved back to town for me. The roles are flavoured according to anime. So a healer with a condition makes sense. Question. Hypothetically, if a roleblocker exist, what alignment do you think they'll be in? |
Apr 28, 2017 5:21 AM
#3275
DenjaX said: ... I can't help you with terms :Daa-dono said: did I use a wrong term? When I was catching up, I keep founding myself nodding in agreement when I was reading your posts. This was my experience.DenjaX said: Fekk i pressed post message by accident. Also, I town read you but I dont consider you confirmed town yet. Because scum usually know the overview of the current game state due to their inside information. That is why I am wary about you. But since there are more bad people out there, I consider you my ally for now. Who's bad? But alright. Haha, now I don't want to scumread you because it's rare to find people agreeing to me~ Anyway, don't dodge the question. Who's bad? (I'm sorry if it's in the previous posts but I don't want to dig it up right now, and asking you is faster.) |
Apr 28, 2017 5:30 AM
#3276
aa-dono said: Jackrito said: Actually now that I thought of it...aa-dono said: I've only skimmed through things. Anyway, I hate that lighting rod thing and I have no idea why you guys suggested that. Probably explained, but I can't remember it. 1. All it does is confirm Shin's ability. If he wasn't up for a lynch why does he need to do it? 2. It doesn't help check Qoco who was also a lynch candidate. 3. Unless I get the ability wrong, then everything gets redirected to Shinichi which means that it's a wasted night for informative roles to get info. If you there's a manipulation role like Carrot, I don't think only informative role is Cop. Also, to town. Do you really believe all those claims? Look at your role pm, and look at the flips and tell me that you think all of them are right. @PentaFlare What did you achieve from the Shin's ability? @Coelestin I thought Innocent Child is revealed at the start of game? To this I think it was a good night it confimed Shinichi and that we do have a healer, not sure the issue. No one died either On claims no I don\t believe them town has too much imo to stop kills. Also with no death on Shinichi likely no strongman to balance that as well. grrr is moved back to town for me. The roles are flavoured according to anime. So a healer with a condition makes sense. Question. Hypothetically, if a roleblocker exist, what alignment do you think they'll be in? Scum would have to be since town has so much. but he fact no one claimed to be RB makes it doubtful unless they are playing it safe. Actually the 3rd party could RB so it would make sense for scum to as well but as said no sign yet |
Apr 28, 2017 5:31 AM
#3277
DenjaX said: aa-dono said: did I use a wrong term? When I was catching up, I keep founding myself nodding in agreement when I was reading your posts. This was my experience.DenjaX said: Fekk i pressed post message by accident. Also, I town read you but I dont consider you confirmed town yet. Because scum usually know the overview of the current game state due to their inside information. That is why I am wary about you. But since there are more bad people out there, I consider you my ally for now. Who's bad? If the person themself disagrees you will need to show examples if this when able |
Apr 28, 2017 5:35 AM
#3278
DenjaX said: Jackrito said: If you let mistrust/doubts get over you all the time, you wont able to find progress. I proceeded with caution because that is the best thing to do. Well that is the only thing I can do. It is true that there are scum in the midst but it is also true that there are town among us as well.DenjaX said: Fekk i pressed post message by accident. Also, I town read you but I dont consider you confirmed town yet. Because scum usually know the overview of the current game state due to their inside information. That is why I am wary about you. But since there are more bad people out there, I consider you my ally for now. That last bit makes no sense if they are a doubt dont trust them that much or you get led to mislynches. Yes they is we have a couple confirmed so are past giving benefit of doubt if we think someone is bad. Early game I agree but those not confirmed should not he trusted. Yes that includes me before you say they is no reason for anyone to trust me at this point |
Apr 28, 2017 5:41 AM
#3279
Jackrito said: Yeah I thought so too. Not the 2nd part, since I don't think there's another 3rd party besides CP.aa-dono said: Jackrito said: aa-dono said: I've only skimmed through things. Anyway, I hate that lighting rod thing and I have no idea why you guys suggested that. Probably explained, but I can't remember it. 1. All it does is confirm Shin's ability. If he wasn't up for a lynch why does he need to do it? 2. It doesn't help check Qoco who was also a lynch candidate. 3. Unless I get the ability wrong, then everything gets redirected to Shinichi which means that it's a wasted night for informative roles to get info. If you there's a manipulation role like Carrot, I don't think only informative role is Cop. Also, to town. Do you really believe all those claims? Look at your role pm, and look at the flips and tell me that you think all of them are right. @PentaFlare What did you achieve from the Shin's ability? @Coelestin I thought Innocent Child is revealed at the start of game? To this I think it was a good night it confimed Shinichi and that we do have a healer, not sure the issue. No one died either On claims no I don\t believe them town has too much imo to stop kills. Also with no death on Shinichi likely no strongman to balance that as well. grrr is moved back to town for me. The roles are flavoured according to anime. So a healer with a condition makes sense. Question. Hypothetically, if a roleblocker exist, what alignment do you think they'll be in? Scum would have to be since town has so much. but he fact no one claimed to be RB makes it doubtful unless they are playing it safe. Actually the 3rd party could RB so it would make sense for scum to as well but as said no sign yet Since if it flavors around the anime, I think roleblocker and JoAT fits. Initially, I doubt JoAt could be town, but then again it doesn't match for a scumrole to give benefits to town. Hence, logic is town for now. I didn't think of rber before because of the ascetic claim. Anime spoiler - not if you watched at least 2 episodes. Since well, Dazai. But I honestly doubt it could be lifted. Seems like the role pm tells exactly on point what will happen or what is hidden. So @DenjaX saying he's unsure feels weird. He could be unsure about why Carrot's not roleblocked. But if he's not sure why his old role is gone just doesn't feel right. |
Apr 28, 2017 5:44 AM
#3280
Jackrito said: Everytime I play with you, you give me more lesson on why I should doubt people than trust. o.oDenjaX said: aa-dono said: DenjaX said: when did I give an overview? I don't think my posts summarize anything. Except my thoughts.Fekk i pressed post message by accident. Also, I town read you but I dont consider you confirmed town yet. Because scum usually know the overview of the current game state due to their inside information. That is why I am wary about you. But since there are more bad people out there, I consider you my ally for now. Who's bad? If the person themself disagrees you will need to show examples if this when able So uhm,, @DenjaX when you get to PC, could you tell me which post you're in agreement with? |
Apr 28, 2017 5:51 AM
#3281
aa-dono said: Jackrito said: Yeah I thought so too. Not the 2nd part, since I don't think there's another 3rd party besides CP.aa-dono said: Jackrito said: Actually now that I thought of it...aa-dono said: I've only skimmed through things. Anyway, I hate that lighting rod thing and I have no idea why you guys suggested that. Probably explained, but I can't remember it. 1. All it does is confirm Shin's ability. If he wasn't up for a lynch why does he need to do it? 2. It doesn't help check Qoco who was also a lynch candidate. 3. Unless I get the ability wrong, then everything gets redirected to Shinichi which means that it's a wasted night for informative roles to get info. If you there's a manipulation role like Carrot, I don't think only informative role is Cop. Also, to town. Do you really believe all those claims? Look at your role pm, and look at the flips and tell me that you think all of them are right. @PentaFlare What did you achieve from the Shin's ability? @Coelestin I thought Innocent Child is revealed at the start of game? To this I think it was a good night it confimed Shinichi and that we do have a healer, not sure the issue. No one died either On claims no I don\t believe them town has too much imo to stop kills. Also with no death on Shinichi likely no strongman to balance that as well. grrr is moved back to town for me. The roles are flavoured according to anime. So a healer with a condition makes sense. Question. Hypothetically, if a roleblocker exist, what alignment do you think they'll be in? Scum would have to be since town has so much. but he fact no one claimed to be RB makes it doubtful unless they are playing it safe. Actually the 3rd party could RB so it would make sense for scum to as well but as said no sign yet Since if it flavors around the anime, I think roleblocker and JoAT fits. Initially, I doubt JoAt could be town, but then again it doesn't match for a scumrole to give benefits to town. Hence, logic is town for now. I didn't think of rber before because of the ascetic claim. Anime spoiler - not if you watched at least 2 episodes. Since well, Dazai. But I honestly doubt it could be lifted. Seems like the role pm tells exactly on point what will happen or what is hidden. So @DenjaX saying he's unsure feels weird. He could be unsure about why Carrot's not roleblocked. But if he's not sure why his old role is gone just doesn't feel right. Sorry my bad I meant since a 3rd party could RB as part of their role that been CP,better chance another RB and imo it been mafia, I agree they is not another 3rd party. They have been examples of a JOAT been scum and we have no proof of his ablities actually working but I agree they are likely town still based off play and how they explained role, it was too complex and detailed to be fake On the ascetic claim Lamb and Denjax both lied on that and now claims he has a OP 1 shot ablity. I sort of see that as a don't lynch me I can save you and win game claim though. |
Apr 28, 2017 5:52 AM
#3282
aa-dono said: DenjaX said: ... I can't help you with terms :Daa-dono said: DenjaX said: when did I give an overview? I don't think my posts summarize anything. Except my thoughts.Fekk i pressed post message by accident. Also, I town read you but I dont consider you confirmed town yet. Because scum usually know the overview of the current game state due to their inside information. That is why I am wary about you. But since there are more bad people out there, I consider you my ally for now. Who's bad? But alright. Haha, now I don't want to scumread you because it's rare to find people agreeing to me~ Anyway, don't dodge the question. Who's bad? (I'm sorry if it's in the previous posts but I don't want to dig it up right now, and asking you is faster.) He is currently voting me I believe even though his most scummy read is Grape slot cant remember his other reads I will find them. |
Apr 28, 2017 5:55 AM
#3283
Jackrito said: DenjaX said: Jackrito said: DenjaX said: Jackrito said: At least state your reasons for your scumreads.i'm def in a slump a lot of people seem to think Penta still not sure how I feel on it, My top scum reads at the moment is Grape/slepnirr, Denjax and Dono. Wont get much from Dono today so would feel scummy voting them and still not sure. I also think Slepnirr is not up to date so would be hard to question them. Still not sure on Kit and Quco either. You give me your scumreads and why then if it is so easy, https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1607887&show=2800#msg50502298 Where are yours? I just told you my scum reads and why in the last post, I don't see the point in ranking my towns reads. @aa-Dono there you go, I would say read that page since me and Denjax had a bit of back and forth as well. |
Apr 28, 2017 5:57 AM
#3284
aa-dono said: aa-dono said: Actually scratch that list.I think all my previous reads are lost at sea. Welcoming Dono's new list: *drumrolls* 1. The Sneaky Scum: Penta, DenjaX 2. Scum in Training: logic340 3. The Lost at Sea: Jack, Grape/Sleipnirr, Qoco 4. Maid in Training: grrr 5. The Always Right Mistresses: Coelestin, Shinichi-Kun Here's a newer new list. 1. The Sneaky Scum: Penta, DenjaX 2. Scum in Training: Qoco or probably one of those that are lost at sea 3. The Lost at Sea: Jack, Grape/Sleipnirr 4. Maid in Training: grrr, logic340 5. The Always Right Mistresses: Coelestin, Shinichi-Kun Reason for the change: logic340 makes sense if both grrr and Rosie makes sense. I don't see Carrot and Qoco possibly the same alignment. Since Quco is a top scum read what do you think on his commuter claim, sorry if already said |
Apr 28, 2017 5:58 AM
#3285
Jackrito said: Oh, I missed this. (I would ask if you could link me to it, but it's alright.... when my energy comes back, I'll re-read everything properly.)On the ascetic claim Lamb and Denjax both lied on that and now claims he has a OP 1 shot ablity. I sort of see that as a don't lynch me I can save you and win game claim though. OP 1 shot ability is too much. That would render Shin's ability useless. Since that was pretty OP. I don't distrust he have an OP role though. If town have Shin's role, then mafia should have one too. Vote: DenjaX Sorry Shishou. Thank you for trusting me. I can't return you the favour ;-; |
Apr 28, 2017 6:00 AM
#3286
aa-dono said: i said Sleip in next post but I will let him play for now. I respect replacers.DenjaX said: ... I can't help you with terms :Daa-dono said: DenjaX said: when did I give an overview? I don't think my posts summarize anything. Except my thoughts.Fekk i pressed post message by accident. Also, I town read you but I dont consider you confirmed town yet. Because scum usually know the overview of the current game state due to their inside information. That is why I am wary about you. But since there are more bad people out there, I consider you my ally for now. Who's bad? But alright. Haha, now I don't want to scumread you because it's rare to find people agreeing to me~ Anyway, don't dodge the question. Who's bad? (I'm sorry if it's in the previous posts but I don't want to dig it up right now, and asking you is faster.) Jack next. But he is getting better. I will move to logic next. |
Apr 28, 2017 6:01 AM
#3287
aa-dono said: Jackrito said: Oh, I missed this. (I would ask if you could link me to it, but it's alright.... when my energy comes back, I'll re-read everything properly.)On the ascetic claim Lamb and Denjax both lied on that and now claims he has a OP 1 shot ablity. I sort of see that as a don't lynch me I can save you and win game claim though. OP 1 shot ability is too much. That would render Shin's ability useless. Since that was pretty OP. I don't distrust he have an OP role though. If town have Shin's role, then mafia should have one too. Vote: DenjaX Sorry Shishou. Thank you for trusting me. I can't return you the favour ;-; Since people will blame me for this later, will clarify he never used OP that was my view of it he just said it was strong. I agree with you on that more likely scum has a strong1 shot move. I have a idea what it may be and if so I could be in trouble. |
Apr 28, 2017 6:03 AM
#3288
DenjaX said: aa-dono said: i said Sleip in next post but I will let him play for now. I respect replacers.DenjaX said: aa-dono said: did I use a wrong term? When I was catching up, I keep founding myself nodding in agreement when I was reading your posts. This was my experience.DenjaX said: when did I give an overview? I don't think my posts summarize anything. Except my thoughts.Fekk i pressed post message by accident. Also, I town read you but I dont consider you confirmed town yet. Because scum usually know the overview of the current game state due to their inside information. That is why I am wary about you. But since there are more bad people out there, I consider you my ally for now. Who's bad? But alright. Haha, now I don't want to scumread you because it's rare to find people agreeing to me~ Anyway, don't dodge the question. Who's bad? (I'm sorry if it's in the previous posts but I don't want to dig it up right now, and asking you is faster.) Jack next. But he is getting better. I will move to logic next. You wanted him modkilled how does that respect replacers. Why logic next |
Apr 28, 2017 6:12 AM
#3289
Vote Count 4.3 PentaFlare: Kit Jackrito: Coelestin, DenjaX DenjaX: Shinichi-Kun, Jackrito, AA-dono Sleipnirr: Grrr One vote is missing let me check for it. Added!! Not Voting:, Pentaflare, Qoco, Sleipnirr, Logic340, What has already transpired Phase Day one! || Vote count 1.1 || 1.2 || 1.3 || 1.4 || 1.5 || 1.6 || 1.7 || 1.8 || 1.9 || 1.10 || 1.11 || 1.12 || 1.13 || 1.14 || 1.15 Night one Day 2 || Vote Count 2.0 || 2.1 || 2.2 || 2.3 || 2.4 || 2.5 || 2.6 || 2.7 || 2.8 || 2.9 || 2.10 || 2.11 Night 2 Day 3 || Vote Count 3.0 || 3.1 || 3.2 || 3.3 || 3.4 || 3.5 || 3.6 || 3.7 || 3.8 || 3.9 || 3.10 || 3.11 Night 3 Day 4 || 4.1 || 4.2 |
Where there is no imagination there is no horror. || Arthur Conan Doyle || Happy Halloween! |
Apr 28, 2017 6:16 AM
#3290
DenjaX said: Just for you~@Suzune-chwan can we have VC please? Sorry it is not lovely, I'm on my phone. |
Where there is no imagination there is no horror. || Arthur Conan Doyle || Happy Halloween! |
Apr 28, 2017 6:20 AM
#3291
Jackrito said: Thank you :)@aa-Dono there you go, I would say read that page since me and Denjax had a bit of back and forth as well. Jackrito said: I don't believe it to be a town role.aa-dono said: aa-dono said: I think all my previous reads are lost at sea. Welcoming Dono's new list: *drumrolls* 1. The Sneaky Scum: Penta, DenjaX 2. Scum in Training: logic340 3. The Lost at Sea: Jack, Grape/Sleipnirr, Qoco 4. Maid in Training: grrr 5. The Always Right Mistresses: Coelestin, Shinichi-Kun Here's a newer new list. 1. The Sneaky Scum: Penta, DenjaX 2. Scum in Training: Qoco or probably one of those that are lost at sea 3. The Lost at Sea: Jack, Grape/Sleipnirr 4. Maid in Training: grrr, logic340 5. The Always Right Mistresses: Coelestin, Shinichi-Kun Reason for the change: logic340 makes sense if both grrr and Rosie makes sense. I don't see Carrot and Qoco possibly the same alignment. Since Quco is a top scum read what do you think on his commuter claim, sorry if already said Carrot's role and Qoco's claim both mess with other roles. I call them mischief roles. I don't see why both of them would be town. Would it be more balanced if one is town and the other is scum? Unless scum has more rule-set in their role. I wouldn't use "Qoco saw the night discussion but wasted his shot anyway" because I don't pay attention to night discussions too. It's the time I take a break from mafia, so that I go back in Day phase without any bias or frustration from the previous Day phase. Not saying he did the same, but it's possible that he did not pay much attention to the Shin-chan's discussion. Even if he did use his shot, it doesn't prove his alignment. This just gives him another day to say, "give me a chance to prove my role". Which is why I suspected Penta. The delay feels scummy. Jackrito said: I think this town takes the bait of proving themselves town too much. What the action does is reveal to mafia what town roles are present. To this I think it was a good night it confimed Shinichi and that we do have a healer, not sure the issue. No one died either On claims no I don\t believe them town has too much imo to stop kills. Also with no death on Shinichi likely no strongman to balance that as well. Whereas we can only speculate that mafia "likely has no strongman". |
Apr 28, 2017 6:21 AM
#3292
DenjaX said: Why logic?I will move to logic next. |
Apr 28, 2017 6:22 AM
#3293
| Urgh. I want to delete the above post since Jack already asked >,> I feel redundant. |
Apr 28, 2017 6:35 AM
#3294
Shinichi-Kun said: still hate you for turning me into a pawn lol This makes me wanna write a chess fanfic~ "Move! You are in the way! It doesn't matter if we sacrifice you out there anyways!" The tyrannic queen Penta shouted at the little pawn. "HAH??!" As if the queen had any right to tell him how to behave! She didn't even care about him in the first place! That old hag should just shut up! "Fine, don't listen to me. I always need to do everything by myself anyways." The queen rolled her eyes and continued to play with her algorithms. "Tch. As if she could achieve anything just by shouting like that." Shinichi whispered quietly. He was always so underestimated and not recognized at all except when people ask him to sacrifice himself. Actually, he already had figured out the best move, he just needed confirmation if he hasn't miscalculated. But if that hag just keeps shouting then how is he supposed to confirm that it's the best move and that he actually hasn't missed something that could hinder his plan from working? Three other voices made themselves known when they saw that there was a fight between the two of them. It was rook Jack. "You know, at some point you'll have to use your power anyways." he inquired. "Why not now?" A small voice came from behind. It was the queen's bishop, Coele. "Well, you will not necessarily die if you move there, don't you?" The other rook Denja however, just came crashing in with the optimal strategy Shinichi had already thought of. "Look, knight grrr is there. Even if you move there, he will be there to protect you." And it was true. There was grrr on b3, almost unnoticed by everyone. The queen however, looked like she was about to face palm. "Just do it already, I don't care about what happens anymore. Fine, fine. Plan looks good. Now do it." There was another voice that wanted to be heard. It was the king's bishop, logic. "Wouldn't it be better if we rather use it as a surprise move though? There might be a chance that the enemy has a move to counter Shin's movements which we haven't thought of." Rook Jack nodded in agreement. "That's true." "Do it anyways. It looks safe enough." rook Denja and queen Penta nudged him. "Uhh..." bishop logic looks into the the distance. There was knight Qoco at the edge. "Shouldn't we help him as well?" Everyone shrugs. And thus, the little pawn Shinichi got convinced to move forward and subsequently saved the kingdom from another attack. |
Apr 28, 2017 6:41 AM
#3295
Coelestin said: A simply fun fanfic.Shinichi-Kun said: still hate you for turning me into a pawn lol This makes me wanna write a chess fanfic~ "Move! You are in the way! It doesn't matter if we sacrifice you out there anyways!" The tyrannic queen Penta shouted at the little pawn. "HAH??!" As if the queen had any right to tell him how to behave! She didn't even care about him in the first place! That old hag should just shut up! "Fine, don't listen to me. I always need to do everything by myself anyways." The queen rolled her eyes and continued to play with her algorithms. "Tch. As if she could achieve anything just by shouting like that." Shinichi whispered quietly. He was always so underestimated and not recognized at all except when people ask him to sacrifice himself. Actually, he already had figured out the best move, he just needed confirmation if he hasn't miscalculated. But if that hag just keeps shouting then how is he supposed to confirm that it's the best move and that he actually hasn't missed something that could hinder his plan from working? Three other voices made themselves known when they saw that there was a fight between the two of them. It was rook Jack. "You know, at some point you'll have to use your power anyways." he inquired. "Why not now?" A small voice came from behind. It was the queen's bishop, Coele. "Well, you will not necessarily die if you move there, don't you?" The other rook Denja however, just came crashing in with the optimal strategy Shinichi had already thought of. "Look, knight grrr is there. Even if you move there, he will be there to protect you." And it was true. There was grrr on b3, almost unnoticed by everyone. The queen however, looked like she was about to face palm. "Just do it already, I don't care about what happens anymore. Fine, fine. Plan looks good. Now do it." There was another voice that wanted to be heard. It was the king's bishop, logic. "Wouldn't it be better if we rather use it as a surprise move though? There might be a chance that the enemy has a move to counter Shin's movements which we haven't thought of." Rook Jack nodded in agreement. "That's true." "Do it anyways. It looks safe enough." rook Denja and queen Penta nudged him. "Uhh..." bishop logic looks into the the distance. There was knight Qoco at the edge. "Shouldn't we help him as well?" Everyone shrugs. And thus, the little pawn Shinichi got convinced to move forward and subsequently saved the kingdom from another attack. |
Where there is no imagination there is no horror. || Arthur Conan Doyle || Happy Halloween! |
Apr 28, 2017 6:47 AM
#3296
| Actually, I changed my mind again. Denja could be not scum. When Carrot claimed, he asked Carrot if Carrot was roleblocked. Since he lied about his role, he knew that Carrot wasn't roleblocked. But he asked anyway, wanting to check Carrot's reaction. If he's scum, checking this reaction is unnecessary. Then he was against Carrot's train. Which could be due to him knowing that Carrot's town. (Since well, if Carrot was scum, he would have said he got roleblocked.) So back to Vote: PentaFlare |
Apr 28, 2017 6:50 AM
#3297
| ........... I have about 12 minutes~ *spin* *dance* *twirl* Sigh |
Apr 28, 2017 6:52 AM
#3298
Jackrito said: Coelestin said: Jackrito said: Coelestin said: @Jackrito What exactly do you expect to get from Sleipnirr when they haven't even caught up? Well I can't wait for them to catch up fully so need to get sone early thoughts. They are my main scum lead so at least want something. I would pressure dono more but I know they won't be here. Had interactions with Denjax which worry me since i yhink their reasons and criticsm are unreasonable and tried one with Quco but they left straight away. Jackrito said: Coelestin said: @Jackrito Would be nice if we get a full read on Denja from you. Well based off their interactions with me today I find a lot of it easy shaming and perhaps trying to take adv off any potential mistrust in me. The stuff from last night a key example I also want more expansion on their scum reads. Since I find them lacking more then my own. I'm nowhere near as comfortable with this slot as you. I really don't see what you see that I don't. Why not vote Denja then? I want to try to work them out more first. To see if they is town motives there While wasting your time on Sleipnirr? |
Apr 28, 2017 6:52 AM
#3299
Shinichi-Kun said: @Coelestin If your really are the innocent child reveal now, if u dont reveal then no reason for me or any of the other people that know ur role to trust you. The Moon Rises The full moon was beginning to rise as night was upon the ability users. Everyone was fighting. It was becoming apparent that the darkness they were looking for was lurking in those closest to them. Friends turning on friends. "Stop fighting. We need to think this through. We need to relax a little. I am not your enemy." Atsushi announces. Coelestin has been revealed as Atsushi Nakajima (Beast Beneath the Moonlight) the innocent child. b] @Logic340, @Sleipnirr, @Shinichi-Kun, @Kit, @Aa-dono, @DenjaX, @Jackrito, @Grrr,, @Pentaflare, @LucianRoy, @Coelestin, @Qoco @Shinichi-Kun how did you figure out that Coelestin was the innocent child role? @Coelestin no worries though it took a very long time it's good to see that my conclusion was correct. XD Too bad no scum wanted to fight on my conclusion before you revealed yourself. |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Apr 28, 2017 6:53 AM
#3300
Shinichi-Kun said: Coelestin said: Shinichi-Kun said: Coelestin said: Jackrito said: Coelestin said: Great, we can clear off Shin and grrr for now. logic340 said: When I got my role I was very excited as it's a role I have been very interested in. I am Jack-of-All-Trades. It comes with some really neat abilities but I will only tell you about two of them. I was going to play a little more passive Day 1 regardless due to my last few games but due to my role I knew i wanted to stay in the PoE zone so I could make full use of my role. I didn't really think about my role at all Day 1, my focus was survival and finding scum. Surviving wasn't the issue finding scum was. Night 1 I spent a lot of time thinking about how best to use my ability. Which ability would make sense which night and what not. After careful consideration I decided to investigate Jackrito. I received an town check, but I thought there was a potential for him to be God Father. I want back over Jack's post and felt comfortable with my town read, so to further my read on him I decided to lay it on a little heavy in order to get a reaction. I still liked what I saw which is why I was so defensive of my read E0D2 because a lot of time has actually gone into it due to the information I had. Night 2 Karote claimed Bus Driver after the No Lynch and that is where my I'm sick post comes from. I have put so much time into this Jack read based off possibly bad information (well worth it though). Time to revisit my Jack read incase Karote is telling the truth (still felt good) After careful deliberation I decided who to use my second ability to protect Shinichi-kun. I have a fairly decent record when it comes to protecting people from NK's. Which is why the Rosie kill was so surprising to me. D3 after Rosie's flip I thought about what Shinichi said about Rosie soft claim and possibly being promoted D2 since I used an investigation N1. Then grrr claimed he was now Full doctor after I just used a protection on Shinichi it clicked with Rosie's promotion. I know I may be wrong but this is why I feel like I am connected to them becoming full doctor and cop (I might be wrong). I tried to work with Karote to to help me believe his claim because if his claim was true then it mean I got results on him. All Day D3 I kept my vote on Qoco hoping to get that lynch through. The vote was so close and I still couldn't solidly believe Karote's claim so I decided to make the gap insurmountable. I have two more abilities that I will keep quiet about for now. TL:DR I am a JoAT N1 I checked Jack but still evaluated my read due to possible GF. Karote skewed my results anyway so that was a good decision. Rosie Full cop D2?? N2 I protected Shinichi-kun. grrr Full Doctor D3 The reason I believe I am the reason for promotion is because it seems the night after I use investigation and protection those roles were promoted accordingly. So this is my story kept myself in PoE so that I could make the best use of my role. If you have any questions please feel free to ask. This whole thing sounds so very much reasonable and far fetched at the same time o__o Your choices make sense though. Ok, looking at the vote count... I suppose you guys are all in a slump right now? Cause so am I. i'm def in a slump a lot of people seem to think Penta still not sure how I feel on it, My top scum reads at the moment is Grape/slepnirr, Denjax and Dono. Wont get much from Dono today so would feel scummy voting them and still not sure. I also think Slepnirr is not up to date so would be hard to question them. Still not sure on Kit and Quco either. Hmmm... what bothers me is that you, me and Penta have barely been under pressure and haven't been questioned the whole game, which is probably part of why we're hard to judge and we're definitely going in circles at the moment, which makes it for scum easier to hide. Vote: Jackrito Now this will look weird since I've been defending Jack and Penta so much but town needs a change of pace once in a while. And I've seen too many people being too hesitant on the two of them now, people are barely trying to talk about them. Since we're in a slump anyways and still need to wait for people to catch up, I'll use this move to encourage discussion. I think Jack's been doing good behavior wise which is what my town read is based on but is starting to get horrific action wise. Anyone agreeing? I agree on this which is why ill be doing this Vote: Coel Honestly idk what to think about you right now i feel like u just stepped back way too much and now that 2 people u thought could be scum got cleared ur jumping right back in. Which i do find supicious. I'll admit I lost my fire for a while. I have no clue which 2 people you are talking about though which is why I cannot comprehend this scum read. *pats there there everything will be fine sweet sweet chi chi Don't pat me when you haven't even told me what you meant |
More topics from this board
» [GAME] Last Letter Game ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )grave_robber - Sep 9, 2014 |
8755 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 11, 7:29 PM |
|
» [GAME] (* ̄・ ̄)ノ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated MEMBER Posts! v1 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )SoulEaterQUEEN - Mar 26, 2016 |
1996 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 7, 10:20 PM |
|
» [GAME] (* ̄・ ̄)ノ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated Staff Member Posts! v4 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Togs - Jul 2, 2017 |
2877 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 7, 10:20 PM |
|
» Count To 7777 V3 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Lambtron - May 15, 2018 |
1170 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 7, 10:20 PM |
|
» [GAME] Truth or dare (ToD) 2.0 [Round 5] ( 1 2 )Lambtron - Mar 12, 2019 |
93 |
by ExoTrillionic
»»
Dec 6, 9:55 PM |