Basic Game V6: Kitty Mafia | Game End - Mafia Win!

logic340 said:
He was vanilla!!!!# Lmmfao!!!!

logic340 said:
Vote Lynch: Shinichi-kun
Let's not draw this out any longer than it needs to be

Shinichi-Kun said:


shouldnt be voting to hastily ik ive been contradicting myself lately but that was cause i was truly confused on who could be scum, if it wasnt for my vote on crossbell who even knows if grrr would have swapped scum.

grrr said:
Well my bets are:

logic + shinichi: 45%
shinichi + crossbell: 35%
shinichi + denja: 10%
denja + crossbell: 10%

others: less than <5%

logic340 said:
Denja Night Kill Analysis:
1. Shinichi is scum thinking Denja would check him he had no choice but to kill him.
2. grrr is scum and killed Denja to frame Shinichi

grrr said:
I think the best I can do in this case is to throw a coin.

35% logic, 65% shinichi. I will let the coin decide. Though I am not sure if these percentages are okay.

grrr said:
Denja basically forced the night kill on himself. So I can't see the night kill as logic trying to frame shinichi.

logic340 said:
Had your vote not been on Crossbell who knows if I move my vote to grrr like I did?
It's not really hasty though I had all night to think about it. I'll make my case more thoroughly now that I am home.

Rosie train scum on the train was Crossbell are you suggesting that grrr or I are a second scum on that train?

logic340 said:
Denja Night Kill Analysis:
1. Shinichi is scum thinking Denja would check him he had no choice but to kill him.
2. grrr is scum and killed Denja to frame Shinichi

grrr said:
Denja basically forced the night kill on himself. So I can't see the night kill as logic trying to frame shinichi.

logic340 said:
So from what I know and understand about mafia is:
They don't vote together
They don't bus unless they need to

Day 1:
Rosie: Crosbell, Logic grrr
Crossbell was the scum on the train using the above reasoning grrr and I should be town
grrr on me all day moved his vote at the last second but as RE and I discussed there was no reason for scum grrr to do that (especially now that we know Crossbell was the scum on the train)
Sollux moves his vote to grrr at the last second though that wouldn't have helped Rosie anyway.
Conclusion: Sollux is the most likely scum in this situation

Day 2:
Based on what we know about mafia they both could be Crossbell's partner due to spreading out across the vote count
grrr starts off with a vote on me, then Claire then back to me, moves off me to RE when it appears i wont be getting lynched day 2. You could make a case that this saved me but why would scum grrr save me? You could also make the case that he didn't want to vote with Crossbell but I believe he moved his vote before that and I provoked Crossbell into voting for me.
Shinichi took my side in the Grapefruit argument. Admittedly looking it back it feels like scum!Rinto in Fairy Tail game when I was facing the lynch D2 in that game. You could make the case his vote on Grapefruit
Conclusion: You could make a case for either being Crossbell's partner in this phase. The details don't help shed much light on who it could be.

Day 3:
Based on what we know about mafia they both could be Crossbell's partner due to spreading out across the vote count
Shinichi is the only player who's vote didn't land on scum D3
grrr continues his crusade against me. This time he leaves his vote on me for the final vote count. grrr did vote Crossbell on this day as well not sure if scum grrr buses his partner at this point when scum is doing so well.
Shinichi was the only one truly opposed to Denja's plan though I don't remember grrr weighing in on it either. Shinichi lead the charge against Penta and his reasoning wasn't necessarily the best at the time. Shinichi also says this was probably demotivated town Crossbell when RE and I are trying to get support for a Crossbell lynch (iirc).

Conclusion: They could both be Crossbell's partner due to spreading out but I feel like Shinichi took the path of least resistance in regards to Crossbell and don't think grrr would be bussing in that situation. Shinichi also opposed killing Lam which could be protecting a teammate.


Day 4:
Throw everything we know about mafia not bussing out the window as it certainly happened this phase,
grrr voted Crossbell early
Shinich seemed more hesitant to go that way being the last to vote Crossbell.

Conclusion: Either could be scum but more likely Shinichi at this point imo. Even more so when you look at that slot over the course of the entire game, but especially in regards to D1. If Shinichi isn't scum here gg grrr.

Lam-B and Crossbell's interactions with Sollux feel the same and they are the team based on D1 vote count. I'm sure that there is more on Shinichi than this but this is what I could do based off memory.

grrr said:
Both of you voted penta. So I guess I should ignore that.

Shinichi claimed his cat last.
VCA shows that there is no way logic is mafia.
Logic made weird as fuck last second vote change in the last phase.

grrr said:
@logic explain me your vote change. Did you try to save crossbell?

Shinichi-Kun said:


Was no reason for me to claim my cat cause it had nothing to say about my alignment lol.

If u look at just from Final vote count on day 1 logic is more likely to be scum than me

logic340 said:
Explain why you were the last one willing to move on Crossbell? Also you think that Crossbell and I have been bussing one another since D2? Crossbell tried to sacrifice me D2?

grrr said:
@logic explain me your vote change. Did you try to save crossbell?

logic340 said:
I respect that
unvote
Vote: Rosie
She's either having a really off game or she's scum
I'm feeling the latter

Shinichi-Kun said:


its totally possible, and i didnt believe crossbell was scum only reason i voted him at the end was because i trusted everyone elses judgement.

Also how were u bussing him? U voted him once on day 3 and u never voted him again till day 4. He bussed you way more.

logic340 said:
I knew there wasn't time for Crossbell to be saved. From my PoV there was scum bussing Crossbell I needed one more reaction because I wasn't sure about our N3. Your reaction to it is what I needed to solidify my read.
Night 4 show's my thinking on why you and Crossbell aren't a scum team. Vote count show's Shinichi since mafia spreads out, the evidence says Shinichi as he was the most hesitant to vote Cross D4 and wouldn't D3.