Forum Settings
Forums
New
Jul 31, 2023 9:32 AM
#1
Offline
May 2022
162
Had a gander and this current topic is trending all over Japan. This outrage was in response to the official Barbie Movie twitter account responding to memes making light of the atomic bomb incident and not the Oppenheimer movie itself. It was then that I was directed to a clip of this movie where the incident occurred and it's mortifying to say the least. 

It's ironic how political correctness is pushed by America and then they do this? I mean at the end of the day it shouldn't be hard not to make light of such events of mass genocide.
JSeanaYJul 31, 2023 2:28 PM
Jul 31, 2023 8:46 PM
#2
Offline
May 2020
198
__potato__ said:
Imagine if an official Japanese account started posting 9/11 memes. Kinda sad how that Barbie account started posting memes about an event that literally killed around 200,000 people (not even to mention the people who suffered even though they weren't born at that time because the radiation was passed down from mother to child) but it's okay because it didn't happen in America so it's okay to make jokes about🙄.

Americans joke about 9/11 all the time.

If a Japanese account made a joke about 9/11 relating to a movie depicting it, I doubt we’d even hear about it. It’s possible a conservative site or two would write outraged headlines, but it wouldn’t go beyond that.

Whether a joke about a tragedy works is entirely audience dependent. New Yorkers that watched 9/11 happen have different standards for jokes about it than Americans who watched it on TV, and they have different standards than non-Americans and Americans born after it.

Jokes about tragedies do not inherently downplay the seriousness of those tragedies. Often they rely on that seriousness to work, that’s the entire comedic crux of the Barbenheimer memes.

Obviously Japan is going to relate differently to the Barbenheimer jokes than the US, that doesn’t give us any obligation to feign offense to them.
onespankmanJul 31, 2023 8:51 PM
Aug 1, 2023 3:40 AM
#3
Offline
May 2022
162
onespankman said:
__potato__ said:
Imagine if an official Japanese account started posting 9/11 memes. Kinda sad how that Barbie account started posting memes about an event that literally killed around 200,000 people (not even to mention the people who suffered even though they weren't born at that time because the radiation was passed down from mother to child) but it's okay because it didn't happen in America so it's okay to make jokes about🙄.

Americans joke about 9/11 all the time.

If a Japanese account made a joke about 9/11 relating to a movie depicting it, I doubt we’d even hear about it. It’s possible a conservative site or two would write outraged headlines, but it wouldn’t go beyond that.

Whether a joke about a tragedy works is entirely audience dependent. New Yorkers that watched 9/11 happen have different standards for jokes about it than Americans who watched it on TV, and they have different standards than non-Americans and Americans born after it.

Jokes about tragedies do not inherently downplay the seriousness of those tragedies. Often they rely on that seriousness to work, that’s the entire comedic crux of the Barbenheimer memes.

Obviously Japan is going to relate differently to the Barbenheimer jokes than the US, that doesn’t give us any obligation to feign offense to them.

I agree with this, it is widely different to America and 9/11. At the end of the day it is not about feigning offence on the behalf of Japan but realising the fact that they are going to react a bit differently.

Overall, it is audience dependent and while this anime graphically highlights the effect of the atomic bomb, it does not hide the atrocities carried out by imperial Japan during that time too.
JSeanaYAug 1, 2023 9:29 AM

More topics from this board

Poll: » Barefoot Gen Episode 1 Discussion

saxophone15 - Apr 18, 2010

40 by Biisoo »»
May 14, 4:01 PM

Poll: » Barefoot Gen + Nuclear Bombs General Discussion

arimakenshin - Jan 9, 2009

13 by milktaster2 »»
Nov 25, 2023 8:53 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login