sailorday- said: I also enjoyed the whole movie, it was great, got emotional at the end.Watching the demon slayer movieee way late cause I want to watch season 2 but omg this movie was so good. I’m usually not a huge shounen fan either but it made me cry so much. If you didn’t like the movie let me know why Im curious no spoilers though plz. |
 |
sailorday- said: first of all the movie did not make sense. A lot of plot holes. In addition compared to heaven’s feel the fights and animation were lacklustre. In general this anime series is only popular and loved only because of the animation. The manga had a rating of 7.64 before the anime came out for fuck sakes. Truly overrated.Watching the demon slayer movieee way late cause I want to watch season 2 but omg this movie was so good. I’m usually not a huge shounen fan either but it made me cry so much. If you didn’t like the movie let me know why Im curious no spoilers though plz. |
sailorday- said: well the manga is finished and was close to finishing when the show first aired (the ending of the manga was bad so i heard). As of plot holes and things I think are wrong with the movie:elderonn said: You can criticize the show without hating on it but ok. What kind of plot holes did you think they missed I’m just curious. Also I think it just needs time to develop once since it’s only 1 season like we really know is characters, what fighting style they use, as well as their purpose of fighting for a few of them. That’s enough for me to keep watching but I understand how people say this show is just a basic shounen but I also hate it since there’s only 26 episodes.first of all the movie did not make sense. A lot of plot holes. In addition compared to heaven’s feel the fights and animation were lacklustre. In general this anime series is only popular and loved only because of the animation. The manga had a rating of 7.64 before the anime came out for fuck sakes. Truly overrated. 1. Why did they cry for a guy that they met 4 hours ago ? 2. How did the train demon know that the team are not gonna be late and not meet the fire hashira before they get on the train? 3. They said that if there is a demon near them they are gonna wake up from there dream but the whole train was a part demon in the first place. 4. If the power that the dream demon used in the fight with tanjiro is the same power he has used before, how can tanjiro go to sleep if near him is a demon? 5.and why all of them did not wake up when tanjiro’s sister is a demon and is right near them? I watched the movie quite some time ago so I maybe forgetting something but this is what I remember that is wrong with the movie. |
| Glad to see that you enjoyed it that much. I personally didn't like first half cuz it was mostly just Tanjiro doing everything with plot convenience and a lot of time had me uninterested and even when Akaza was introduced, I still had problems because I thought the dialogues were boring and poorly written but the 20 minutes around the end was amazingly executed and that was the only part I liked about the movie |
elderonn said: Those aren’t plot holes, it’s simply just you not understanding what was said. Much like how I could barely understand anything you just said. There was nothing wrong with the movie plot-wise. Also, empathy is one of the major, overarching themes of this show, so if you can’t understand why they would cry over something like that, you might need to pay a bit more attention; or maybe just have some empathy lmao.sailorday- said: well the manga is finished and was close to finishing when the show first aired (the ending of the manga was bad so i heard). As of plot holes and things I think are wrong with the movie:You can criticize the show without hating on it but ok. What kind of plot holes did you think they missed I’m just curious. Also I think it just needs time to develop once since it’s only 1 season like we really know is characters, what fighting style they use, as well as their purpose of fighting for a few of them. That’s enough for me to keep watching but I understand how people say this show is just a basic shounen but I also hate it since there’s only 26 episodes. 1. Why did they cry for a guy that they met 4 hours ago ? 2. How did the train demon know that the team are not gonna be late and not meet the fire hashira before they get on the train? 3. They said that if there is a demon near them they are gonna wake up from there dream but the whole train was a part demon in the first place. 4. If the power that the dream demon used in the fight with tanjiro is the same power he has used before, how can tanjiro go to sleep if near him is a demon? 5.and why all of them did not wake up when tanjiro’s sister is a demon and is right near them? I watched the movie quite some time ago so I maybe forgetting something but this is what I remember that is wrong with the movie. |
My Candies:       Bonus:   |
| Good for you man, you actually appreciated a good movie and a made a humble thread about it. I loved the movie from beginning to the end and never once thought it was boring. It was a great experience and truly the people hating on this are a very very small minority so I dont take their opinion into consideration (I dont mean anything bad by it, but its just that I have never heard a genuine or reasonable argument) |
If you enjoyed the time you wasted, then its not a waste of time.  |
Fofo-man said: elderonn said: well the manga is finished and was close to finishing when the show first aired (the ending of the manga was bad so i heard). As of plot holes and things I think are wrong with the movie: 1. Why did they cry for a guy that they met 4 hours ago ? 2. How did the train demon know that the team are not gonna be late and not meet the fire hashira before they get on the train? 3. They said that if there is a demon near them they are gonna wake up from there dream but the whole train was a part demon in the first place. 4. If the power that the dream demon used in the fight with tanjiro is the same power he has used before, how can tanjiro go to sleep if near him is a demon? 5.and why all of them did not wake up when tanjiro’s sister is a demon and is right near them? I watched the movie quite some time ago so I maybe forgetting something but this is what I remember that is wrong with the movie. 1. Because they have a heart??? Rengoku was such a genuinely good person that gave up his life to save 200 people without even thinking twice. Seeing people die in a terrible way in front of you is sad and Tanjiro, Inosuke and Zenitsu are 15 year old kids. 2. What do you even mean by that? The kids were used to put any potential demon slayer in a crippling state whilst Enmu was transforming so that he didn't need to take any risks fighting hashiras. 3. No the train was not part of Enmu's body from the start, that's why he put them to sleep so that he could stall for time. 4. He clearly mentioned that strong or experienced demon slayers could sense nearby demons in their sleep. Tanjiro is a Misunoto, it's not weird that he didn't wake up whilst being asleep the first time even though he has his special sense of smell. The power Enmu has puts people to SLEEP and even if it's a hashira they would still be put to sleep but wake up immediately 'cause they sense Enmu, Tanjiro did also wake up immediately but only because he was aware during his sleep and knew how to get out. 5. Probably because they're so used to her being near and don't see her as a threat. Rengoku also said that all the Hashira had memorized her presence and won't harm her. Maybe pay attention whilst watching instead of just looking at the pretty colors? I've never heard anyone complain about plot holes in KnY before lol. I was going to say these same things to him but thanks for clarifying it to him. |
If you enjoyed the time you wasted, then its not a waste of time. |
Fofo-man said: okay, first of all I do not know anybody that would cry for a guy that he got to know 4 hours ago like he was his only son. Second of all almost every point that you presented was an excuse or a speculation. You can not debunk my points by stating speculation, when you say “ they “probably” did that or that “ to debunk what I am saying it has no basis at all. As long as the anime did not state the things you said as facts your arguments are not valid at all.elderonn said: well the manga is finished and was close to finishing when the show first aired (the ending of the manga was bad so i heard). As of plot holes and things I think are wrong with the movie: 1. Why did they cry for a guy that they met 4 hours ago ? 2. How did the train demon know that the team are not gonna be late and not meet the fire hashira before they get on the train? 3. They said that if there is a demon near them they are gonna wake up from there dream but the whole train was a part demon in the first place. 4. If the power that the dream demon used in the fight with tanjiro is the same power he has used before, how can tanjiro go to sleep if near him is a demon? 5.and why all of them did not wake up when tanjiro’s sister is a demon and is right near them? I watched the movie quite some time ago so I maybe forgetting something but this is what I remember that is wrong with the movie. 1. Because they have a heart??? Rengoku was such a genuinely good person that gave up his life to save 200 people without even thinking twice. Seeing people die in a terrible way in front of you is sad and Tanjiro, Inosuke and Zenitsu are 15 year old kids. 2. What do you even mean by that? The kids were used to put any potential demon slayer in a crippling state whilst Enmu was transforming so that he didn't need to take any risks fighting hashiras. 3. No the train was not part of Enmu's body from the start, that's why he put them to sleep so that he could stall for time. 4. He clearly mentioned that strong or experienced demon slayers could sense nearby demons in their sleep. Tanjiro is a Misunoto, it's not weird that he didn't wake up whilst being asleep the first time even though he has his special sense of smell. The power Enmu has puts people to SLEEP and even if it's a hashira they would still be put to sleep but wake up immediately 'cause they sense Enmu, Tanjiro did also wake up immediately but only because he was aware during his sleep and knew how to get out. 5. Probably because they're so used to her being near and don't see her as a threat. Rengoku also said that all the Hashira had memorized her presence and won't harm her. Maybe pay attention whilst watching instead of just looking at the pretty colors? I've never heard anyone complain about plot holes in KnY before lol. |
Fofo-man said: I was talking also about your 4th point, You are assuming that he could not wake up in the first time.. because he is week, although, The show did clearly state that they would have woken up if they could smell him... that is why he sent the kids. "The power Enmu has puts people to SLEEP and even if it's a hashira they would still be put to sleep but wake up immediately 'cause they sense Enmu, Tanjiro did also wake up immediately but only because he was aware during his sleep and knew how to get out." - Yet again this is you assuming and making up excuses as to why he did not immediately wake up, the fact is, the train demon sent the kids to the demon slayers because they would wake up if they smelled him... and then they did not wake up when they smelled him. As for the whole crying thing, I groupwatched the movie and me and another dude starting laughing our assess off when Tanjiro started crying more for the hashira's death than his frailly dying. As I said, I don't know anybody who will cry so hard (or at all) for a stranger. elderonn said: okay, first of all I do not know anybody that would cry for a guy that he got to know 4 hours ago like he was his only son. Second of all almost every point that you presented was an excuse or a speculation. You can not debunk my points by stating speculation, when you say “ they “probably” did that or that “ to debunk what I am saying it has no basis at all. As long as the anime did not state the things you said as facts your arguments are not valid at all. Do you possibly not know how to read? All the statements except the last one were facts the show tells you through dialog and they never tell you straight out and leave it up for speculation which is why I said "probably". Though my speculation is most likely the answer. If you saw someone die like that and didn't at least feel like crying, there's really something wrong with you. As I said they're children and seeing people die terribly is traumatic and horrible it's only natural that they'd cry. I mean I my self cried and I'm a grown. I don't know why you have so much trouble taking in what you read but that's probably why you think KnY has plot holes. |
sailorday- said: Watching the demon slayer movieee way late cause I want to watch season 2 but omg this movie was so good. I’m usually not a huge shounen fan either but it made me cry so much. If you didn’t like the movie let me know why Im curious no spoilers though plz. I just loved the movie too....as people say first half isnt as good as second but that doesnt makes the first half bad..........first half was a 8/10 and second one was a 10/10...........I cant think of any reason to not like it...... |
 "No one can rewrite the stars How can you say you'll be mine? Everything keeps us apart And I'm not the one you were meant to find It's not up to you you It's not up to me When everyone tells us what we can be How can we rewrite the stars?" |
sailorday- said: I watched it late also and I thought it was a masterpiece through and through.Watching the demon slayer movieee way late cause I want to watch season 2 but omg this movie was so good. I’m usually not a huge shounen fan either but it made me cry so much. If you didn’t like the movie let me know why Im curious no spoilers though plz. |
Mansibuddin101 said: finally a proper answer. Why people can’t give proper arguments like you? Every other answer I got was, “ because he has a heart!” Or something like that. Still it was funny as hell to see him breakdown.elderonn said: okay, first of all I do not know anybody that would cry for a guy that he got to know 4 hours ago like he was his only son. Second of all almost every point that you presented was an excuse or a speculation. You can not debunk my points by stating speculation, when you say “ they “probably” did that or that “ to debunk what I am saying it has no basis at all. As long as the anime did not state the things you said as facts your arguments are not valid at all. He cried because he looked up to rengoku and he saw him get brutally killed by a 'demon'. I mean he is still a kid. He also cried because he was frustrated. Think of this, he trained all those months mastering total concentration constant and even after those hard work, he couldn't save rengoku. He cried out of frustration because every time he masters one thing another thick wall appears before him. He has an unwavering resolve to turn nezuko to human, but after seeing even a very strong person like rengoku get defeated like that just shatters him. He says "Can I ever be like rengoku?" He believes he should've died instead, at least rengoku could've defeated muzan for him that's what he thinks. Also not to mention just a while ago he had to make the choice to leave his family again. He was already heartbroken. And loosing a good person like rengoku who risked his Life to save 200 people doesn't do good either. So after all this if you don't understand why he would cry, then you're living a far too unrealistic life |
| same here watched it just now cause of work, damn its amazing and here i thought i wouldnt cry since i already finished the manga.... boy i was wrong |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Kimetsu no Yaiba Movie: Mugen Ressha-hen Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )-Stray - Oct 19, 2020 |
407 |
by subahokke
»»
Oct 13, 2:13 PM |
|
» Is it true that this movie set a box office record?AcbSnakeDemon - Mar 6 |
14 |
by Just-For_Fun
»»
Sep 19, 1:26 PM |
|
» Movie OST Album is out worldwide.dazedcowcow62 - Jul 6 |
0 |
by dazedcowcow62
»»
Jul 6, 6:50 AM |
|
Poll: » Would you recommend I watch the Mugen Train movie or TV arc?KitsuneZoro - Apr 4 |
29 |
by Tristanteken
»»
Apr 18, 12:03 PM |
|
» So the movie was pointless? ( 1 2 )ibm30rpg - Sep 26, 2021 |
61 |
by IDontWishToBe
»»
Jun 1, 2024 7:09 AM |